News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by oldjim69 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:06AM (#37049155)
Nothing shows the power of unions more than the lengths companies go to fight them.

In a Union there is Strength.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by epivosism on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:25AM (#37049437)
This sounds like just the opposite of a capitalist monopoly from the other side. Why would I want any party to control the way a market works? You'll get stagnation both ways. see many historical examples where both monopolies and unions refused change and were overturned, leading to failures. i.e. Detroit

I want a functioning competitive market where workers and firms compete and have to adjust and innovate to fit what people want. Neither side should be able to lock down and define the way things must work.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by wpietri on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:36AM (#37049615)
> Nothing shows the power of capitalist monopolies more than the lengths unions go to fight them. Oh wait

You say this as if it's some clever proof, but I'd say it's literally correct. It's why all sorts of people in all sorts of countries fight capitalist monopolies.

And, I should add, for all sorts of reasons. I believe strongly in the power of markets. They're incredible optimization machines. Which is why I'm also for strong markets. Monopolies are just as anti-market as the most ardent communist. People who believe in free enterprise should all fight monopolistic behavior.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by epivosism on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:42AM (#37049715)
Yeah I was saying that the original claim was self-contradictory since if you use "resistance exists" as a proof that something is good, then you've already admitted that anti-unionism is good too, since it's also strongly resisted.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by wpietri on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#37049966)
Rewriting a comment after somebody has already responded is very rude. Now your comment is differently wrong, but I'm sure not going to bother with it or you given that you may just keep rewriting the thing I'm responding to.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by epivosism on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:43AM (#37050749)
Apologies, I was adding detail and don't realize you were already responding. I don't think we disagree though - do you? I still agree with what you responded to, I just removed that phrase because it seemed inflammatory
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by venv on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:57AM (#37049930)
GP said it was proof of power. Power can be used for good or ill.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by tech_ken on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:30AM (#37050497)
But the problem is that the labor "market" has many weird inefficiencies not found in the usual "buyer X selling widget Y" model of the free market. For example, the poorer you are the less elasticity you have in your labor "product"; by the mere necessity of paying rent and buying food you have to accept virtually any offer that comes your way. On the other hand, employers often negotiate from a position of substantial strength because of their deep capital reserves. I'd consider this a market distortion, and a harmful one at that. Labor laws and unions provide counterbalance which is important to ensuring a healthy labor market.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by epivosism on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:58AM (#37051046)
I agree that this is a theoretical weakness. In the US currently, though, it seems that this rarely ever comes into play. i.e. in SF the city gives anyone money to survive for food/etc. w/out working. I think truly not having options is very rare in the 1st world in general. If you think this is an active issue here, I'm open to looking further into it.

So I agree that while exploitation by monopolies is possible (in the extreme, just via slavery or indentured servitude/debt peonage), I think we have mostly taken care of it via social support mechanisms. If that's true, then further intervention in markets doesn't seem necessary. Of course, I still would support health inspections, etc to root out local corruption since it's too hard for the public to monitor that themselves. In a sense, the fact that voters approve the FDA and other inspection-style measures is just them commissioning someone to do that for them, and that's okay.

But when it comes to California coming in and saying that Uber drivers shouldn't be allowed to voluntarily work as contractors, it seems really strange. Drivers like it and the company likes it, so what's the problem? Yet the state still wants to intervene in the relationship.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by tech_ken on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @12:27PM (#37051557)
I'm not sure where things stand now, but just prior to the pandemic I remember reading that the labor market was historically inelastic for workers of all stripes. Between non-computes, implicit collusion, and the emergence of gig work people who sold their labor for wages were the least able to change jobs or negotiate for better wages since like the 70s.

Your characterization of SF's social safety net seems (charitably) hyperbolic, I think you need to diversify your news diet.

> I think we have mostly taken care of it via social support mechanisms

As with labor elasticity, these are again at historical lows. Basically since Reagan we have gutted our social safety net and replaced it with tax cuts for the employers who then take their extra capital overseas.

> Drivers like it and the company likes it, so what's the problem?

I don't know who you're talking to, but drivers definitely don't "like it". They need it, yes, but the ones I've spoken to seem to have major problems with Uber who has stonewalled them for years.

Overall it sounds like we are starting from very different assumptions about the state of play in the labor market right now, not sure if we're going to bridge this in a comment thread debate. Have a good one!

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by saagarjha on Thursday August 10, 2023 @02:02PM (#37079580)
The free market has options and then showing something that was designed in SF precisely because the free market fails people is not a very good argument for the free market.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by adfskghnmionio on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:49AM (#37050851)
A capitalist monopoly is a conspiracy in favor of the firm. Unions are a conspiracy in favor of the people.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by Draiken on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @12:16PM (#37051347)
Exactly. And somehow people fail to see a difference between human needs and the needs of a profit seeking machine.

Without unions individuals basically NEVER have bargaining power. And of course it's not like you can choose to not work. At least not for the crushing majority of people, I guess.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by worrycue on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:32PM (#37058069)
Unions are often monopolies too - monopolies on labour. Monopolies often lead to inefficiency in the market and an inefficient market is bad for everyone.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by jenkstom on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @12:35PM (#37051663)
Unions are just another corporation. They balance the corporation that owns the assets. Nobody is locking anything down, they're just signing contracts. This is healthy for competition, not stifling.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by worrycue on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:29PM (#37058056)
Not quite “just another corporation”, they are often monopolies on labour.

Frankly, power imbalances in either direction isn’t good - because we all know it will be abused.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by barbariangrunge on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @12:40PM (#37051751)
The main way people compete, outside of vampire-FAANG, is by a willingness to work for lower wages, and then the only winners are the employers
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by Buttons840 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:56PM (#37052975)
There is some justice in that the young will get old and experience the same system they helped perpetuate. The young should be willing to hire the old, or else they themselves will become old and find that nobody is willing to hire them.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by jvmfjvfjvf on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:13AM (#37049255)
What strength do they have? Unions routinely cause jobs to be eliminated and offshored.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by tyree731 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:20AM (#37049358)
Would Amazon drivers unionizing cause Amazon to offshore drivers?

If Amazon drivers union would cause Amazon to eliminate drivers, does that suggest unions lack strength, or that unions have strength that Amazon fears?

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by jvmfjvfjvf on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:22AM (#37049389)
Amazon drivers unionizing would cause Amazon to hire FedEx or DHL. Unions don't have a monopoly on drivers.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by venv on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#37049958)
And would the drivers be paid more or less (and what of other conditions)?
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by somsak2 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:24AM (#37050379)
the whole reason Amazon has it's own drivers is because they can pay them way less. your example would actually represent a big success since ups/dhl/FedEx drivers have much better job security and benefits.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by otikik on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @10:27AM (#37049477)
Yes, it's the unions, not the execs.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by tech_ken on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @11:32AM (#37050530)
Well no, it's literally the employers who move their capital to regimes which allow more exploitative working arrangements to boost their profit margin. That they are so unwilling to accept a reduce share of the company's net income that they will pick up their toys and move to Bangladesh just indicates that we need to be more aggressive against capital mobility.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by akomtu on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:31PM (#37052645)
For unions, workers are the profit center. For corporations, workers are the expense.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by dimator on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @05:23PM (#37055658)
Blaming the unions for corporate greed (going offshore for cheaper labor) is utterly hilarious.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by say_it_as_it_is on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#37052421)
In a unionized amazon delivery, there is waiting. Are you going to wait 3 weeks for your deliveries to arrive? Let's see how important union strength is when you don't receive next-day deliveries.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by oldjim69 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:22PM (#37052497)
The post office offers amazing service and its workers have been a key part of the labour movement.

Also next day delivery is almost never an option where I live so I don't bother with it.

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by wnevets on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:32PM (#37052653)
> Let's see how important union strength is when you don't receive next-day deliveries.

That doesn't happen now

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by CJefferson on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:43PM (#37052796)
The Unionised Royal Mail seems to manage next day delivery fine. Does any country have a unionised mail service where you wait 3 weeks, or even 1 week, for packages?
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by digdugdirk on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:48PM (#37052858)
Following this logic, would you say that the only way to guarantee same day delivery be to legalize slavery for Amazon delivery drivers?
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by vkou on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @01:57PM (#37052980)
My life has been just fine without next-day deliveries. It has also been fine without being the master of a slave plantation, or having a live-in servant that works for pennies and sleeps in a closet, or a number of other things that would make it more comfortable and convenient at the expense of others.

---

(It does, unfortunately, depend on a large number of people growing my food, making my clothes, and soldering my electronics largely being treated like shit, but none of those are immutable facts of the world.)

Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by phailhaus on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @02:00PM (#37053036)
If next-day delivery requires unfair working conditions, then yes we should drop it. It's a false dichotomy to pretend as if the alternative to "next day" is "three weeks" though.
Re:Amazon Doesn't 'Employ' Drivers, but Hired Firms to Preve... by mikestew on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @05:16PM (#37055573)
Are you going to wait 3 weeks for your deliveries to arrive?

First, you know full well that it won't be three weeks. However, I'm willing to allow a bit of exaggeration to make a point. But let's make the argument reasonable: I have to wait five days for the equivalent of UPS Ground from the other coast (UPS, which I will point is unionized and offers next-day delivery). As a trade-off, drivers aren't pissing in bottles. Are you saying you'd rather drivers piss in bottles rather than wait a few more days for delivery?

But of course all of this is moot: many examples abound of delivery companies capable of delivering things the next day and having a unionized workforce.