This doesn't sound like a good idea if your goal is to prevent these two companies (or divisions of the company) for co-conspiring.
Microsoft surely will continue to develope edge. That is my main issue with this thing, because they surely would like to be the one with the dominating browser again and if google has to drop chromium, Microsoft will just overtake it.
Antitrust and breakup is not a simple thing to do right.
What apple has done with browsers at least seems more egregious. Windows didn't stop you from installing a different browser, ios does. There was even a long running joke that the only good use for IE was to install a real browser.
It wouldn't be hard to find a reason to sure Microsoft though. Take a look someone at where the legal text states their software builds were made and ask what tax benefits one might get from running production builds on servers in the Caribbean.
If a bunch of websites suddenly required Edge on Windows to view, they'd lose a majority of their visitors.
But they do it any way they can. I never intented to open edge even once, but through various sketchy things, I had it open way too many times.
(when you click on the "learn more about this awesome landscape" - you land in edge, open a pdf, edge, saved a mhtml in chrome and open it, edge again. Search for chrome on edge? It almost tries to block you from downloading it.)
Meanwhile, all of us not using MS platforms (Linux, Android, MacOS, iOS) don't see any of this.
MS only has power over you because you choose to give them that power. They have no power at all over anyone not using an MS OS.
There are indeed the end times. I just saw cats lie down with dogs.
Where exactly did you get this idea?
It runs fine on both Chrome and Firefox on desktop, including voice, camera, screen sharing. They also have desktop apps, including a .deb for Linux (since it's ultimately just an Electron app).
Well, perhaps "runs fine" is not exactly the right word for what Teams does, but it's as awful on every platform at least.
Plainly wrong. I use MS Teams at work too. My machine is running Debian. No, I sure as hell don't have Edge installed on Debian; I use it in Chrome.
I suspect judges that just ordered an antitrust would not be kind to people to people who essentially ignore the order by recreating an informal structure.
It's important to keep things mentally separate here. There is nothing anti-competitive about remote attestation, no more than there is about TLS. It's just far too general a tool for that. Even much more restricted versions as used by the smartphones, games consoles, Windows managed network security etc have never been claimed to be anti-competitive. That would be a very novel legal theory that's unlikely to work on its own (you can use the tech in ways that are anti-competitive, but it needs someone to actually do so).
So if Google were to be broken up, it'd have to be for wider competition and market health concerns, it wouldn't be to do with any specific API getting added to Chrome. And then if they were split up, they'd need to formalize arrangements in contracts that are today informal, like how Chrome is funded exactly. At that point, do you think the newly born AdCorp will just accept paying lots of money for ad impressions to Chrome when the users aren't going to see them? Google tolerates it today for a mixture of reasons e.g. a lot of their own staff use ad blockers, they want to be able to recruit very widely for many different projects, etc. A company specialized only in advertising would have fewer such concerns and could easily demand more aggressive measures, indeed, their new shareholders might insist upon it. Whereas today Google isn't really susceptible to stockholder pressure and is willing to let a lot slide.
2. Your theory was basically proven broke by the fact that ATT which was broken up in anti-trust, became ATT, again.
And the result of a ruling is a court order to do something. Sure, "ordering an antitrust" is a bit less precise than "ordering a series of actions that result from a successful antitrust prosecution", but I was hoping it to be clear enough.
My point was that judge do issue orders, and they really don't like people finessing around the wording.
Browsers are complicated, but let's not pretend that that kind of money wouldn't be enough.
Theoretically this money should be enough to finance the continued investment in Chrome.
Rendering a website should not be a huge project. Websites are a medium for transmitting ideas; communication. A communication scheme that requires a massive engineering effort to interpret it is bad. A web browser should be something that a small community team can throw together in a couple months.
That figuring out the funding required to draw a website is seen as a big issue is a symptom of the problem.
Yeah, with tracking and ads from the browser enabled by default and by now allmost non existent marketshare. The money from ad companies does not come with no strings attached.
(But I still use Firefox btw.)
This isn't the 90s anymore. Smartphones exist, where Microsoft is irrelevant.
This is their business problem not ours.
Since Chrome, the browser, is in some way a new OS paradigm we can think that the open source community would take it seriously to build a new one and/or improve/fork Firefox in the same way we have Linux, OpenBSD, FreeBSD, NetBSD, etc, etc. I think the main issue is UX/UI where the open source community doesn't excel, yet.
And the money is coming from where? Chrome exists mostly, so the ad buisness gets more data and they can influence the direction of the web.
Seperate that and there will be no more chrome as there is no other source of income. (Except maybe a little bit from ChromeOS).
Otherwise I get it, it is mostly politics to threaten google to reach this.:
"It's quite likely to make Google dump this proposal, on the advice of their antitrust lawyers."
But a breakup of google(alphabet) is something very unrealistic and actually not something I want to see, unless we also break up Microsoft at the same time. Otherwise we end up with Microsoft dominating the web again. No thank you, I still remember those times.