News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by apienx on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:26AM (#36982117)
Please use secure channels for authentication. SMS is antiquatedly insecure (Any way it's sent: SS7, SMPP, etc.).

More traffic benefits the industry (since some sucker pays for it). There's no incentive for any of the entities that profit from this to stop it (unless it's too sell you a premium protection service).

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by jnwatson on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:56AM (#36982296)
NIST recommended getting off SMS in 2016.

I’d say 7 years is plenty of time that folks really shouldn’t be using it.

https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/08/nist_is_no_lo...

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ComodoHacker on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:09AM (#36982386)
Meanwhile, there are countries whose entire banking, tax filing, CC processing and various public service systems rely on SMS as the only second factor.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by vladvasiliu on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:20AM (#36982465)
I don't know about those countries, but I know of one who says it's trying to compete with the US on tech, and one of their biggest banks moved away from hardware TOTP tokens to some kind of "secure app" and now to... SMS!

To name and shame: BNP in France. My personal account stayed on the app, but for my company account, it I only get SMS now.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by KronisLV on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:40AM (#36982579)
> To name and shame: BNP in France. My personal account stayed on the app, but for my company account, it I only get SMS now.

I remember a story about a university in Lithuania also opting for either SMS or a proprietary 2FA app, but not allowing TOTP either: https://fsfe.org/news/2023/news-20230418-01.html

What's worse, all they had to do was enable a checkbox in the settings somewhere but they went on an embarrassingly long e-mail thread back and forth, not even willing to help the users.

So I think that in cases like that, it's definitely a good idea to call attention to the issue and tell more people about open technologies like that! Unfortunately, most people just won't care.

That said, TOTP is actually decent and I'm surprised that it's not supported everywhere, especially given how much shouting about SMS not being secure enough goes around.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:14AM (#36984759)
TOTP unfortunately does not satisfy the “transaction binding” requirement of PSD2, since the token does not tell you what you’re confirming at the time you share it with a (potentially MITMing) website.

SMS-OTP, despite its many other flaws, at least offers a trusted path to say “by sharing this code, you are paying x€ to y corp”.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by vladvasiliu on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:12AM (#36986230)
I think that since the issue at hand is that SMS can be intercepted, the protection afforded by this information is minimal.

Anecdotally, in the case of my bank, if I try to make a transfer, the SMS is something along the lines of "Are you trying to transfer 1234 €? If yes, enter the code 12345, or else call your representative asap".

One terrible point being that once you've entered the confirmation code, they consider the transaction as "strongly verified", so it's not that easy to roll it back. Fortunately, I've never had this happen to me so I don't know what that entails, but contesting a random unverified charge is as easy as clicking on the transaction list and then "dispute".

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:51AM (#36986761)
Yes, all in all I'm not happy with SMS-OTP still being considered just as secure as e.g. WebAuthN, and much more secure than Email-OTP (which is explicitly prohibited for PSD2/SCA purposes).

The problem isn't really interception in my view (even though SIM-jacking and porting attacks are scary enough!), but rather the high likelihood of phishing/UI confusion: With modern mobile OSes auto-filling transaction details, I'm not too sure if everybody is still reading the text accompanying the confirmation code.

It's quite possible for a fraud victim to be directed to amaz0n.com and tricked into entering an SMS-OTP confirmation code to confirm a purchase of €5.00, without noticing that the accompanying text actually says "only enter this code on BuyCryptoNoKycOrBacksies.com to confirm your purchase of €500".

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by Cthulhu_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:42AM (#36982601)
That's also because these systems are large, complicated, and slow moving. Not only that, but the users are resistant to change; the older you get, the faster time moves, and a decade between one system (SMS) and the next (e.g. a two factor auth app) feels short and unnecessary.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ComodoHacker on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:15AM (#36982844)
That's primarily because a significant portion of population there don't have smartphones.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @12:04PM (#36987723)
Last I checked, even the US federal government required SMS 2FA to get into your Social Security account.

But the problem is also only allowing SMS 2FA. Why not allow both and let people choose TOTP?

I have a feeling SMS 2FA is used as a cheap way to implement a rough social credit score. If you have a stable life and follow the rules, then you have continuous access to the same phone number. And only allowing SMS 2FA allows you to only deal with this population, and ignore populations that might have higher proportions of “costly” customers.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:13AM (#36984739)
Very true, unfortunately.

My country’s administration lets people e-sign PDFs that are accepted throughout the EU as legally binding/equivalent to a paper signature using only a static password and SMS-OTP.

(The system used to be based on PCKS#11-compatible smart cards, but nobody managed to use the software, so they switched to SMS…)

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ghusbands on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:06AM (#36983709)
Sure, but it seems a bit short-sighted to assume that SMS brings no benefit. If a customer somehow loses access, SMS is far cheaper and more available for all involved than any other alternative. Most people don't want to carry any dongles (especially not institution-specific ones) and many don't really want to install apps or have phones that will wipe app data for infrequently-used apps.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by bigDinosaur on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:44AM (#36983954)
SMS as a backup is very different to SMS as your only option. For one it can be made much more inconvenient to use SMS so as to reduce the surface area for scams. Plenty of places still have it as the primary and only 2FA mechanism. Of course SMS itself is awful which is the key problem here. What you mean is that having your phone tied to an identity is useful (what if you lose your phone? SMS is no longer at all useful) and we could do much better than SMS for that.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by berkes on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:36AM (#36984349)
> SMS as a backup

Indeed. I once worked on a system where we had SMS as one of the "last resorts". When someone used SMS as recovery, we'd disable withdrawals and fundings (it was some sort of wallet) as well as severely limit their daily limits. Until the account was fully restored again using normal, secure methods (Mail, KYC, etc).

We were hit by a similar "attack" where our "let us call you to start recovery" was abused by putting a toll-number there, and our system would then call this toll-number and we'd get rediculous bills. But putting in limitations helped a lot, so we did this for SMS too.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ta1243 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @12:19PM (#36987921)
If I lose my phone I get a replacement simcard from my provider in a day or two, and SMS continues to work

If I lose my phone I've lost all my various OTP authenticator apps - I don't think they are backed up to icloud

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by bigDinosaur on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:53PM (#37007397)
You should be able to back up your OTP generator codes, I have mine in KeepassXC and on my phone.

Note as well that you really don't want to rely on SMS if travelling internationally, which is a use case I hit reasonably frequently.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by Phurist on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:08AM (#36982379)
Why would I want to buy a smartphone, just to log in to some service? Why would I want to install some crappy auth app on my computer (That most likely does not have a Flatpak for it even)?

Most places do not support Yubikey... so getting SMS on my Nokia 3310 is the best option for me.

SMS is the way to go.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by vladvasiliu on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:16AM (#36982441)
You don't need a crappy app. Just write down the seed someplace and compute the TOTP yourself. It's not rocket science.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-based_one-time_password

edit: here's a cli tool for doing this: https://www.nongnu.org/oath-toolkit/oathtool.1.html

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by friendly_wizard on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:28AM (#36982517)
This is a pretty good one

https://github.com/arcanericky/totp

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by circularfoyers on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:58AM (#36983197)
Furthermore, Flatpaks do exist since, like you've stated, it is easy to implement https://flathub.org/apps/search?q=totp
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by orangepurple on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:47AM (#36987478)
KeepassXC and KeepassDroid support TOTP tokens in the same record as your username and password for more convenience too
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by loxdalen on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:13AM (#36982417)
It's the way to go for you since it is convenient for you? Doesn't really help against the security problems with SMS. Someone can for example socially engineer a phone company operator to steal your phone number.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ThePowerOfFuet on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:12AM (#36982406)
SMS is the way to go until your operator swaps the SIM on your line without your approval.

SMS is the way to go until you need to sign in from somewhere you don't have cellular coverage.

TOTP is superior in almost every way. Failing that, sending a login link (or code) to the user's email address is more secure than SMS.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by pjmlp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:12AM (#36984159)
Which feature phones usually used by aging population support TOTP?
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by notpushkin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @12:08PM (#36987797)
Any phone that supports J2ME should do, there's several apps:

https://github.com/kwart/totp-me

https://github.com/baumschubser/hotpants

(Couldn't find one that supports QR codes, though I don't see why that would be hard to implement)

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by pjmlp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:26PM (#36989728)
I guess there is a business figuring out how to compile out of github into phones for non-techies, specially in the aging population.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by notpushkin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:05PM (#36991892)
Hopefully their relatives can remember how to install JAR/JAD apps: https://github.com/baumschubser/hotpants/releases

(Yeah, the UX could be better probably, but hey.)

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by pjmlp on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:57AM (#36996384)
Sure, because everyone has a relative that knows technical stuff, why there is a hiring problem in IT at all.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by notpushkin on Friday August 04, 2023 @06:53AM (#36998132)
To be honest, you probably don't need to have a CS degree just to remember how you downloaded pirate Java games in early 2000s.

What's your proposed solution again?

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by Knee_Pain on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:09AM (#36982782)
SMS is not the way to go and you are conflating capabilities with poor engineering.

You cannot install a barebones TOTP app on your Nokia 3310 because it is closed source.

Most services don't offer third party TOTP because they are pressured into pushing their shitty proprietary apps.

But TOTP not only is more secure but it's completely offline. It's close to the best solution and totally exists right now

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by nottorp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:43AM (#36983526)
Well I have a smartphone but I still don't want a shitty app for each service.

What's all this about SMS being insecure? I never heard of phone numbers being hijacked in my country (except in the case of physically stolen phones ofc). Is this another consequence of US making it so easy to steal an identity?

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by Knee_Pain on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:48AM (#36983567)
TOTP does not require one app for each service, plus phone scams and sim cloning is rampant. Seems you have limited experience un both subjects
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by nottorp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:07AM (#36983714)
> TOTP does not require one app for each service

That is, if your vendors all agree on something.

> Seems you have limited experience un both subjects

Yes, also limited experience on identity theft. Care to comment on my suspicion?

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by _flux on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:52AM (#36985198)
I have a bunch of vendors (e.g. Microsoft, Google, Gitlab, VPN, others) in the same OTP app in my phone, so my belief is that they seem to agree just fine.

There are of course examples of vendors that don't. I think Steam is one of them. And my bank.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by mcronce on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:23AM (#36986371)
TOTP is a standard; if your vendor supports it, that _is_ them agreeing on something.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by yomlica8 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:21AM (#36984836)
This is the problem though. SMS was pushed early on since it was great way to identify and track users in addition to being easy for most of them to use. It was never as good of a choice as TOTP, but it was easier to get users to use. But now there is of momentum behind SMS and sporadic support of things like TOTP.

Most of the new alternatives seem focused on pushing lock-in traps and are complicated for users to understand or use. If they're going to lose user tracking of the phone number they want something even worse to replace it, not something open like TOTP.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by timwis on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:05AM (#36982758)
Just want to flag that Twilio’s 2FA service, Authy, is tightly tied to SMS. For example, if you want to login to iwantmyname.com, it asks you for your Authy totp, but if you don’t remember it, they’ll settle for an SMS code instead. And that’s a ‘feature’ of the Authy integration.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by Dachande663 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:11AM (#36982806)
Additionally, other services in their family won't let you use other TOTP apps. Looking at you sendgrid. Utter travesty of a company.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by glogla on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:35AM (#36983472)
SMS is the only second factor that works for people without smartphones. Having a smartphone means signing your life (your location 24/7, your messages, your contacts, your everything) over to either Google or Apple.

I understand the security aspect and realistically most people will have smartphones anyway, but forcing everyone into this surveillance duopoly, especially as Apple is overpriced and Google is ad company with stated mission of removing privacy, makes me pretty salty.

There should be a better way.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by scrollaway on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:53AM (#36983609)
There is a better way. There are plenty of non-phone-based totp authenticators, and many of the password managers provide one. I’m using 1Password for example and I do not use phones for second factor.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by harg on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:56AM (#36983637)
> SMS is the only second factor that works for people without smartphones.

That's not correct. Many password managers have TOTP authentication features built in.

There's also increasing support for security keys (e.g. yubikey) with many websites.

Passkeys are also on the rise.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by pjmlp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:11AM (#36984146)
Which set of population without smartphones even know what a password manager is?
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:53AM (#36987563)
GP has also listed FIDO authenticators (Yubikey etc.), which are arguably a much better alternative for non-tech-savvy people than TOTP.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by notpushkin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:59AM (#36987672)
I think a pretty decent set of people who care about surveillance duopoly know about password managers too.
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by pjmlp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:27PM (#36989739)
Who said feature phone users among aging population care about it?
Re:SMS Pumping Attack by bux93 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:08AM (#36983719)
Before my bank supported smartphones, they used a smartcard reader that you'd put your debit card into (a vasco digipass). The earlier model required you to type in a numerical challenge, a later model used a digipass that can scan a QR like code (that uses colors for higher data density).

Another bank's employees used a physical RSA securid TOTP token (which was a bad idea since RSA hung onto the seeds and got hacked).

(TOTP can also be added to feature phones, it's fairly straightforward. There's open source java ME projects.)

Corporate clients with their competitor had been using MSDOS based banking software that came with a hardware token that ingested a challenge as flashes of light from the screen, which was pretty neat! It didn't read a debit card, the seed was just baked in.

Before banks started shipping physical tokens or card readers, they would send you a list of one time codes to approve transactions.

Note that Google also has the option to generate such codes (although you get 6, not 50 at a time), so you can get into your account even if your phone is stolen.

All of those worked in the age before smartphones.

Now, there's also passkey/U2F/FIDO2 based hardware keys you can provision yourself and buy from several vendors, like Yubikey or Token2.

There's plenty of reasons to be salty about the smartphone duopoly and surveillance economy, but for 2FA there's plenty of alternatives. And if you do use a smartphone, you could always use an open source authenticator app.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by saiya-jin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:16AM (#36984786)
Ha, in Swiss biggest bank by nr of clients (PostFinance), I log into ebanking with card reader (their yellow calculator-like thingie). Reader reads the payment card, asks for key from ebanking (after entering username & password), after entering it asks for card's pin, gives back resulting code which goes to ebanking.

If I count correctly its checking 1) username/password; 2) currently holding my payment card; 3) card's pin

Even if I don't count owning reader itself as another point of security (since it can be obtained ie via social engineering and its a simple generic device) its at least 3-factor auth and its still the most secured ebanking from all banks I have. Annoying a bit to log into but this is one place I don't mind it at all. And no phone involved in any step, for which I am very glad (not having yet another thing to manage, keep updated, worry and chase cancellation when lost/stolen).

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:51AM (#36987535)
> Having a smartphone means signing your life (your location 24/7, your messages, your contacts, your everything) over to either Google or Apple.

True – but using SMS-OTP signs over your life to your phone provider.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ta1243 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @12:23PM (#36987989)
Far more trustworthy than google or apple. I've never seen reports of Vodafone or whatever blocking a number because of some nebulous reason (unlike say through a court order), but it's so common for apple and google that someone tried setting up a startup to fix the problem [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36899787

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:10PM (#36988662)
Eh, depends. I wouldn’t trust Vodafone to give me the time of day, personally [1].

In any case, neither Big Tech nor Big Telco are my favorite candidates to be the guardian of my digital identity.

[1] Had them for years in an apartment where they have a local monopoly; speeds of 0.3 Mbit and latencies of 15 seconds – yes, 15000 milliseconds – during the pandemic were not unusual. The upgrade of the local node is scheduled for late 2024.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by ta1243 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:55PM (#36989325)
Did they block you as a customer?

Did they then block a SIM transfer request to another phone provider?

In my country there are significant consumer protections around mobile phones.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:30PM (#36992242)
> In my country there are significant consumer protections around mobile phones.

That's a good point – we urgently need those same protections for e.g. things like email addresses or Google accounts.

But, yes, I do know people that are unable to port out their phone number: Sometimes it's a line on a contract in somebody else's name (minors, spouses etc.), sometimes it's a prepaid card not properly registered (although that's getting less common with the EU mandate to verify everybody's identity before activation).

Neither a phone number nor a Gmail address/Google/Facebook/... account is a good anchor of trust for digital identities.

Re:SMS Pumping Attack by rz2k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @12:51PM (#36988360)
With e911 legally required on all phones, does a dumb phone provide you any actual location privacy?