Re:SMS Pumping Attack
by lxgr on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:51AM
(#36986761)
Yes, all in all I'm not happy with SMS-OTP still being considered just as secure as e.g. WebAuthN, and much more secure than Email-OTP (which is explicitly prohibited for PSD2/SCA purposes).
The problem isn't really interception in my view (even though SIM-jacking and porting attacks are scary enough!), but rather the high likelihood of phishing/UI confusion: With modern mobile OSes auto-filling transaction details, I'm not too sure if everybody is still reading the text accompanying the confirmation code.
It's quite possible for a fraud victim to be directed to amaz0n.com and tricked into entering an SMS-OTP confirmation code to confirm a purchase of €5.00, without noticing that the accompanying text actually says "only enter this code on BuyCryptoNoKycOrBacksies.com to confirm your purchase of €500".
The problem isn't really interception in my view (even though SIM-jacking and porting attacks are scary enough!), but rather the high likelihood of phishing/UI confusion: With modern mobile OSes auto-filling transaction details, I'm not too sure if everybody is still reading the text accompanying the confirmation code.
It's quite possible for a fraud victim to be directed to amaz0n.com and tricked into entering an SMS-OTP confirmation code to confirm a purchase of €5.00, without noticing that the accompanying text actually says "only enter this code on BuyCryptoNoKycOrBacksies.com to confirm your purchase of €500".