News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by Invictus0 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:58AM (#36864287)
cannot get work... at the price they want. Plenty of low-paying remote jobs out there
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by shmatt on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:11PM (#36864556)
Im not sure why this is even getting downvoted. Top pay of market has significantly shifted to hybrid. Even once a week in office means you can't live anywhere in the country you'd like. Though i'm not sure if the original article counts hybrid as remote in this case

There are plenty of fully remote openings for senior software engineers looking for $100k TC right now. Every person can make their own calculation

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by zer8k on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:21PM (#36864757)
Honestly, I'd take 100k TC for a position to keep remote. One caveat, I will be working at 20% of my actual mental capacity. Frequent vacations, using sick time as often as possible, etc. I would not take on anything resembling pagerduty and I wouldn't try to lead anything. Then I'll leave for any job with higher TC. Malicious compliance is the best kind of compliance and is the only way to respond to a lop-sided negotiation.

Companies are exploiting the rift in labor due to inflation, COVID, etc right now. For 2 years the power was in the hands of employees. This left a very bad taste in the mouths of management. What companies want is top-tier labor for bottom-tier pricing. It won't happen. If it does, you'll have a bunch of people with 1.5 feet out the door coasting at work.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by addisonl on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:28PM (#36866003)
And people wonder why companies don’t like remote work…
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by no_wizard on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:18PM (#36866926)
you can do this in office / hybrid too. It wasn't uncommon when FAANG hiring was ebbing and flowing or people would leave to come back at those places (some FAANGs have weird policies on promoting internally vs externally. It was sometimes easier to leave and comeback)

I worked somewhere where we always had a dozen boomerang FAANG engineers, the practice stopped when everyone realized they were coasting often and getting way to close to deadlines, had poorer than expected engineering output etc.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by horns4lyfe on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @05:48PM (#36870044)
Because they can’t pay low prices for great work? Is this bad?
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by CoastalCoder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:17PM (#36864687)
I agree with the parent and grandparent comments.

For me personally, the question is how long I hold out for a job that will pay the bills. E.g., without my kids needing to take out big college loans.

For one thing, I don't want to screw over an employer by taking a job that I know I'll leave as soon as something better-paying becomes available. Hopefully I'll find a decent job before I get that desparate.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by pcthrowaway on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:46PM (#36867398)
> Top pay of market has significantly shifted to hybrid

* In the U.S.

In Canada, top pay is mostly full remote.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by RestlessMind on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:53PM (#36868392)
Are those all US based companies?
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by pcthrowaway on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @06:23PM (#36870475)
Exactly.

Salaries with Canadian companies pale in comparison to U.S. salaries, with perhaps a few exceptions.

When the market was piping hot in early 2022 I was fielding a few offers and the highest a Canadian company got me (as someone with 8-9 YoE at the time) was 95K (USD). U.S. companies were offering in the range of 120K-150K.

Although I made a huge mistake and took a counteroffer at a lower salary from the company I already worked with, which came with a significant retention bonus (and verbal promise of stock + additional bonuses which never materialized). Now I'm making about 70K USD as a lead.

Which is probably more than I'd get from a Canada-based company right now to be fair.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by bamfly on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:15PM (#36864650)
> low-paying

For high values of "low paying".

$150-250k TC, instead of $300-500k.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by baristaGeek on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:58PM (#36865492)
Exactly! It just makes the job market much more perfect. $500k at scale is an economic squander.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by bamfly on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:36PM (#36866153)
To be clear, I'm not complaining about FAANG/finance comp rates. Anyone taking a bigger paycheck instead of that money going to capital is doing god's work (plus, building a foundation for future capital innovation, if you want the pro-capitalism slant on it—more people with investable capital and more people with cushion to try to build a business is very good). You should absolutely take every dollar you can wring out. They wanna spend stupid-money, see if they'll give you "stupid + $1". All day long.

Just putting things in perspective. "Bad" developer pay is still really good.

(of course, there's a worse tier of pay for developers and sysadmins under that one, but I don't think there's a lot of remote work in that tier that isn't also offshored work—in-person, though, yes)

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by coryrc on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:04PM (#36866690)
This useless administrator[0] who failed King County completely is hired by Seattle for $250/hr.

Paying SWEs $150k-250k is low.

[0] https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/regional-homelessn...

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by tayo42 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:09PM (#36864518)
Companies are being cheap. Software engineers are only providing 200k dollars worth of value? I find that hard to believe.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by HDThoreaun on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:21PM (#36864754)
Salary has never been about the value you provide. It's about the cost to replace you. Companies will never pay you more than you cost to replace.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by nonethewiser on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:38PM (#36865107)
> Salary has never been about the value you provide. It's about the cost to replace you. Companies will never pay you more than you cost to replace.

Those things aren’t mutually exclusive. To some extent, the value you bring is whats behind the cost to replace you.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by 1270018080 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:40PM (#36865158)
Which is why we need a union, despite what libertarian fetishist tech bros think they are above.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by w4termelon on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:58PM (#36865475)
> Which is why we need a union

Development is global as opposed to, say, cab driving. So, tech companies from other parts of the world will applaud your decision. Keep pushing new regulations, we'll reap the benefits.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by mostlysimilar on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:30PM (#36866045)
Cool, so you can be worked into the ground by abusive landlords who add no value. We'll pool our skills and create organizations of engineers who want better for themselves and the world.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dang on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:03PM (#36865578)
Please make your substantive points without snark or name-calling. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by Der_Einzige on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:17PM (#36867881)
Oh, well, dang, aren't we feeling extra sensitive today? I see you've appointed yourself the etiquette police of the HN comments section again.

I'm finding it hard to see how the original comment was either snarky or name-calling. The user simply put forward a perspective, but I suppose it's easier to quash dissenting opinions than engage with them. Typical for you

It's interesting how you've become the arbiter of free thought here on HN. Are we all meant to walk on eggshells, worried that we might offend the delicate sensibilities of the certain ideologies? Is this the legacy of Y Combinator? A haven for the sensitive, led by you, the self-appointed gatekeeper of acceptable thought? The answer seems to be yes

It feels like we're all playing a guessing game called "What will offend dang today?" You may be following some form of guidelines, but I reckon you could make them up as you go and no one would know the difference.

So here's a thought: instead of playing sheriff in every thread, how about you foster a culture of open debate and exchange of ideas? Unless, of course, your mission is to turn Hacker News into a placid pool of agreement. But then, wouldn't that be boring?

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dang on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @06:25PM (#36870502)
The comment was edited after I replied. I've quoted what it originally said in my reply now.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by mostlysimilar on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:32PM (#36866080)
This needs to happen as soon as possible. Not only to protect ourselves against the destructive race to the bottom and offshoring, but to put guard rails in place against these people who want to use technology to extract value at the expense of everything else. They're nothing without the engineers and product designers that actually create the value.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by yCombLinks on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:54PM (#36866506)
Lots of libertarians support unions, not sure where you get your info. The libertarian argument has the most subtlety about how and why to support or oppose certain unions. So yes, they do oppose some unions.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by tomtheelder on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:36PM (#36867223)
Anyone sane should oppose _some_ unions. They don’t all make sense/provide positive value. Looking at you, public sector unions.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by renewiltord on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:05PM (#36866723)
To any immigrants reading, remember that unions were instrumental in foreigners finding it hard to move to the US. Here are some opinions on you from HN users:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36511005

> Artifactually (sic) increasing the supply of workers suppresses wages.

Your existence will devalue their education

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36505802

> Given that it is much more expensive to gain skill when you are a native, the government somewhat pulled the rug from underneath the locals who spend a lot of money to go to uni etc and were hoping to have a decent return on their investment in education.

"Getting rid" of you will be considered a good idea

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36506071

> I think US will benefit in the long run getting rid of these h1bs.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by closeparen on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:33PM (#36866098)
Cost of labor bounded above by the value of the activity. Businesses that are not FAANG scale cannot afford FAANG-level talent even if it would be necessary for something they want to do. They just can't do the thing. Or try to do the closest analogue they can with the people they can afford. Maybe hire heavy-hitting consultants for a short time to put them on the right track.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by Aurornis on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:18PM (#36864701)
Compensation isn't proportional to the value you produce.

It never was.

The hiring market is a market. Prices in a market are set by supply and demand.

The value you produce only sets an upper limit on your compensation because companies don't want to lose money by employing people.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by mempko on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:36PM (#36865065)
It's a market but not that great of a market. No transparent price discovery. Huge market manipulation by the big guys making deals with each other to suppress wages (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2014/04/23...)

Yes, wages are high relative to other industries but the large tech companies are immensely profitable. Wages can be even higher without market manipulation.

So yes, it's a market but a really really bad one in ways we value markets to be good.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by tayo42 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:24PM (#36864809)
yeah sure its a market, the money is there though to get. that doesn't change companies are being cheap. nothing wrong trying to extract as much as you can. companies that pay low are signaling they don't value their workers.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by nonethewiser on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:49PM (#36865318)
> The hiring market is a market. Prices in a market are set by supply and demand.

Demand for software engineers is partially explained by the value software engineers generate.

The value a job creates is obviously a factor. Imagine a job that creates absolutely no value but has a limited supply of qualified people. It wont even exist let alone pay anything.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by dv_dt on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:52PM (#36865360)
> Compensation isn't proportional to the value you produce.

Contrast that with product/service pricing where the business advice is to capture as big a slice of the end value produced as possible.

Compensation is proportional to the value produced, and is also constrained by factors like, how close the position is to the income stream, if the dept you're working for is considered a cost or profit center. But basically different companies, industries, and situations have different typical proportional factors.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by the_only_law on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @04:34PM (#36868997)
What kills me is seeing ads for boot camps talking about “tech jobs are booming in [your area]”. Yet I’ve had the fewest number of recruiter contact in my career ever, including when I was trying to break into the industry.

Not that I don’t expect the industry to be full of liars at this point, but it still losses me off when I see them.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by cudgy on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:15PM (#36883332)
So, if a company has no profit, they would pay nothing for software engineers or ask them to pay to work there?
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by glimshe on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:34PM (#36866131)
~200K, inflation adjusted, is historically the salary of a competent senior software developer in the US. Give or take depending on location, so you can expect around this for remote (which doesn't suffer the same labor shortage pressure of some regions).

A friend of mine told me he joined Microsoft right out of college in 1998 for 35K/year + 10% bonus. This is around 70K-80K today. As a Senior II Software Engineer at Microsoft in 2014, I made around 180K total comp, which is around 230K today.

In the past 3-5 years we've seen incredibly distorted job markets. 500K is a salary you often see for CEOs and Directors of "normal companies". It's an incredible salary that puts you in the top 1% income in many states.

I'm not saying software engineers don't deserve a lot of money, and by all means, let's try to get as much as we can, but I'm just saying that the past few years have been abnormal and we're seeing the correction now.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by tayo42 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @02:05PM (#36866708)
i mean the low paying jobs he refers to only pay like 100k, if your paying sr engineers and leads 100-150k you are being cheap when you consider how much value we provide.

if you think engineers only provide maybe 200k dollars of value then sure pay 100k but i find that hard to believe

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by glimshe on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @05:10PM (#36869617)
Also have in mind that there are "Seniors" and "Seniors". 200K is a normal salary for a true Senior in a company that is either tech-focused or very reliant on tech.

Companies outside the tech hubs, or companies where custom tech only provides incremental value to their business, will certainly pay less, and salaries closer to 100K are actually not that uncommon. They often don't even have the ability to accurately evaluate the skill set of a Senior Software Engineer. So what you call Senior and what they call Senior isn't the same thing.

I'm not saying that you should accept 100K, simply that the market is very diverse and we are past the excesses of the past.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by yieldcrv on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:12PM (#36864574)
in my experience, the process is the same at any salary or compensation package

it isnt “easier” to get an offer at lower ranges, those companies think they are taking a risk with their comp ranges too

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by bamfly on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:20PM (#36864737)
> it isnt “easier” to get an offer at lower ranges, those companies think they are taking a risk with their comp ranges too

The trick is not to job-shop in bad markets. "Expensive" and "risky" to a startup in, I dunno, Billings, is "holy shit, what a bargain!" in a lot of cities—and not even the top markets, but tier two and three cities. Or to established, larger companies.

Be wary of small companies scraping by in cheap cities. If the pay's non-shit, they'll expect you to be a literal wizard, performing actual supernatural feats, for pay that's still probably on the low side.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by shmatt on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:14PM (#36864630)
It is significantly easier to get a $100k offer than a $600k one as a senior software engineer. Companies who offer lower pay fully understand they aren't poaching anyone from Meta or Netflix any time soon, and lower their bar in terms of how hard the interview is

In other words getting an offer for "tech in a non-tech company" is pretty easy. Getting the Meta offer in 1-shot of 6 back to back interviews, not so much

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by solarmist on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @04:32PM (#36868969)
The bar may be lower but their risk aversion is just as high, so they're also doing 7 round interviews where a single 'meh' ends the process.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by zer8k on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:24PM (#36864825)
The lowest end TC still requires you to do a 7 stage interview + colonoscopy.

They're doing this to age-out a large portion of the industry. No other reason.

Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by nonethewiser on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:51PM (#36865349)
What you say is true to an extent but its still easier because there are less or less qualified candidates.
Re:The remote work dominates on HN:Who is hiring? – 69% jobs... by nsxwolf on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:32PM (#36872084)
Anecdotal, I am not seeing any difference with the low paying jobs.