News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by local_issues on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:51AM (#36847991)
No no no no no.

Design your product to be understandable at first pass. Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone, while Sony forces you to do it on every new device.

Let the onboarding be a forcing function for usability. This isn't a crutch, it's something worse and damaging.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by twen_ty on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36848286)
> Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone

Maybe that's why 50% of iPhone users still don't know that they can use long press on they keyboard (or space bar) to gain cursor control - and this is just one example.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by logical_proof on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:18AM (#36848398)
iPhone user since switching from a Droid X. You just taught me something that I have been dying for… thank you and way to make your point.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by seanthemon on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:24AM (#36848488)
Apple features famously taught in hacker news comments.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by pests on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:40PM (#36853214)
If you press with a second finger anywhere on the keyboard after activating it will switch to selection mode.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by ericmcer on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:17AM (#36849385)
You just changed my text messaging efficiency
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by ibdf on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:19AM (#36849421)
What’s this black magic! Never knew it either.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by StockHuman on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:28AM (#36849569)
This is featured the first time you ever bring up the software keyboard and then never again. You can see the behaviour by booting up a simulator. They do have an explainer, but it’s very easy to dismiss if you expected to just start typing.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by jallen_dot_dev on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:35AM (#36849680)
> This is featured the first time you ever bring up the software keyboard and then never again.

In other words, a behavior that something like Driver.js can help you achieve.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by smt88 on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36848277)
> Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone

You're arguing in favor of a product tour. iOS usability is garbage. There are no affordances. Nothing is discoverable. There are a million inputs (mostly gestures) that no one ever finds out about unless someone tells them or they Google it, and they're not consistent across apps, even first-party apps. Sometimes "swipe the row left" means "remove," sometimes it means "more actions". It's just a jumble of inconsistent nonsense.

Watch a non-tech person use their iPhone. They have no idea that they can do 50% of the things that they can do. Ever see anyone use "shake to undo" for example?

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by MrBodangles on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:40AM (#36848792)
“Shake to undo” also doesn’t work more often than it does. You’d assume an OS-specific keyboard interaction would work anywhere there’s text input, but no!
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by pests on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:39PM (#36853204)
The only time I use that gesture is when I drop my phone.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by smt88 on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:31PM (#36855659)
You can disable it in Accessibility settings
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by enraged_camel on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:16PM (#36850347)
>> iOS usability is garbage

Yes, that must be why my technologically illiterate 90-year-old grandpa was able to figure out how to use an iPhone after being shown a single swipe gesture.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by tekchip on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:12PM (#36851203)
My 65, at the time, year old father figured out Android just fine. What point was your n of 1 example trying to make?

Please try to keep in mind there is a wide breadth of technical prowess, thought patterns, and comprehension out there. What works great for some people doesn't for others. Also something to keep it mind being able to "figure something out" or "use it" doesn't necessarily make it a good experience, or an ideal one.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by superdug on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:39PM (#36852475)
Please excuse the last remnants of the technology debate of “Are Apple products worth the higher price tag of their very capable competitors?” It’s been happening since Apple came into existence with people defending or arguing against Macintosh computers to where it is now with cell phones and the higher cost of entry priced iPhones. The ecosystem Apple created is the great divider. It’s a closed garden in every sense of the word, but still a great garden where if you’re okay with the HOA, you can live right on top of.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by Etheryte on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:53PM (#36850940)
People not knowing some of the features is not really a problem, because it doesn't matter. Every single one of my elderly relatives can use an iPhone after a quick intro and they don't need help afterwards. The device is essentially self-serve once you understand one or two core ideas. Them not knowing about some features is not a problem, they can do all the important things without someone helping them out. No other smartphone platform has delivered that.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by sgc on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:08PM (#36851150)
Come on, iOS is not so special. Grandmas all over the world get by just fine on an Android as well. If you don't do much with your device, you don't need much. At the same time, it is obvious that gestures should be consistent, and the documentation should be clear, on device, and easy to find.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by Etheryte on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:02PM (#36851922)
I think this is a point where we'll fundamentally disagree, for all practical intents and purposes, no regular user ever has or ever will read the manual for their smartphone. Your phone comes with one, have you read it? Documentation is a crutch for complexity and it's only acceptable for hard topics and advanced users. Most people don't even touch the manuals for all the appliances they own, never mind your elderly relatives. If they run into a problem, they'll ask someone to help, not look for the manual.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by superdug on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:34PM (#36852401)
I think you’re missing a key fact about who cell phone users _can_ _be_. The dumbest people on this planet can still pick up any iPhone anywhere and be able to use it even if they’ve never used the device itself once. It’s muscle memory to people who wouldn’t know what to do with a manual in the first place. You have to accept that there is no barrier to advanced communication technology to anyone with the means to procure said devices. While I appreciate a finely tuned platform for my technology uses, I still carry an iPhone in particular so that I don’t need to do all of that advanced tweaking and personalization by sacrificing maybe 5% of my overall performance by using an unmodified iPhone running iOS in particular. Sacrificing that 5% of performance means the device has no barrier of entry for 99.9% of humans old enough and cognizant enough to procure a similar technology and be able to fully interact with me on a digital medium. Bringing it back to the topic at hand, those 99.9% of people includes family members who didn’t grow up with electricity let alone technology.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by not_your_vase on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:42PM (#36852512)
Haha, every few weeks I do some magic gesture, and my iPad duplicates the current application in a separate window. I never did it intentionally, and to this day I have no idea how to do it back. Also, I can't fathom who and why would want to do it.

But the good, old Apple troubleshooting works: nuke it, and start again. If I close the app and restart it, then it's back to its single window form.

Oh, well.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by karaterobot on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:29PM (#36853105)
> Every single one of my elderly relatives can use an iPhone after a quick intro

So, after an onboarding workflow, in other words. What's the difference between giving them a quick intro, and their being some form of onboarding built into the application? Consider people who don't have someone on hand to introduce them to the product: how should they gain that same level of competence?

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by capableweb on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:32PM (#36853146)
> People not knowing some of the features is not really a problem, because it doesn't matter

It does matter. I started using a iPhone maybe a couple of years back, after using an Android phone for many many years, and I still find out stuff randomly by chance that they could have just told me about.

Biggest example when I just got the phone, took me maybe a couple of days before I understood that swiping from the top of the screen and down depends on if you're on the left side or right side of the phone, which decides if you see the notifications vs the "control panel" thing. Initially it felt random which one it showed.

And I'm a technical user, probably in the top 1% when it comes to technical knowledge compared to the rest of the userbase of iPhones. And how do you think things like that works out for the rest of the people who don't work with technology for a living?

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by alaskamiller on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:48PM (#36853294)
My non-English-speaking first-gen immigrant grandma that assembled rice cookers in factories back in her day figured slide down for notifications, right slide down for control panel, and slide up on day 4.

My mom didn’t ask about it until after the first year.

So to answer your question… maybe it doesn’t take to be the top 1% of something.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by brazzledazzle on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:16PM (#36852960)
> They have no idea that they can do 50% of the things that they can do

Maybe even more than that. I know people that have used iOS for years and don't know they can copy/paste text or drag down to search in messages, mail and settings.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by jahewson on Monday July 24, 2023 @06:20PM (#36855041)
These are basically power user features. You don’t need them to get by on everyday tasks. They just help. Just like right-click on the desktop.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by chadash on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:16AM (#36848383)
Sorry, this isn't practical for everything. Sure, a phone should be intuitive. And more importantly, you don't have to know how everything works at first pass. You can build it over time.

But, for example, I recently signed up for HubSpot as a CRM and while I think that overall, the product is well organized and intuitive, it's just difficult if not impossible to make it as intuitive as a smartphone. The product tours really help.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by dooraven on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36848284)
I think this is broadly accurate for consumer apps.

However, a B2B app ,which is where most product demo tutorials are used, isn't like this. Good product tutorials are great for salespeople to walk the customer through the app and sell properly to prospective clients.

When the contract sizes are in the 10,000s or 100,000s and the product is pretty complex then this is a good solution vs having your sales and support staff having to firefight issues.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by bryanrasmussen on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:34AM (#36848668)
>Design your product to be understandable at first pass

implies never deliver any product complex enough that a design cannot be made that is understandable at first pass.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by sebastianconcpt on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:02AM (#36848169)
Yes to the pretend you can't have this as forcing force for usability but I'm good for adding it if the user answers "Yes" to have a tour.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by kristiandupont on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36848293)
Hm.. I find that Apple products have tons of hidden features that I discover after years of usage. I appreciate the clean lines, I really do, but it does have a tradeoff when it comes to discoverability, so this policy is debatable IMO.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by WhatWorkingOn on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:14AM (#36848341)
The difference is it's intuitive to discover. Once you discover this does something here, you start wondering where else could this happen? You might wonder if you can adjust the iPhone flashlight brightness. For me it was intuitive to long-press the icon in control center to find more options and I was delighted to discover that's exactly how it works.

Those little moments of delight and synergy are why I choose the apple ecosystem.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by discussDev on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:20AM (#36848423)
Half the time it does something, I don't know what I did, and I'm in a rush and so instead of sitting down and having a happy little moment I'm annoyed at having it do some unexpected, unrepeatable thing.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by WhatWorkingOn on Monday July 24, 2023 @04:36PM (#36853846)
I have never found that the case in iOS. Anything I click / do unexpectedly I can reliably repeat the steps 99% of the time, it's why I prefer iOS over Android with apps that can modify the OS.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by ebiester on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:14PM (#36851246)
They have the "Tips" application that has all of the features. It's on the front of a new app. What is stopping you from discovering it?
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by onion2k on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:47AM (#36848920)
If you're on a Mac, open a Finder window, then click Help -> "New to the Mac? Take a tour". There's your OSX tour. It opens a web browser pointing to https://help.apple.com/macos/big-sur/mac-basics/ (or whatever version you're on).
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by mindcrime on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:11AM (#36849294)
Let the onboarding be a forcing function for usability.

Sure, you always want usability and discoverability. But to suggest that everything can always just be discovered seems a lot like discussion of the elusive "sufficiently smart compiler." Eg, an unattainable ideal that doesn't exist in the real world.

I am not convinced that the current state of UX is such that it's possible to make a UI where there is zero need for product tours, documentation, video tutorials, etc. At least not for moderately complex products and beyond.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by popcorncowboy on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:53PM (#36854756)
> I am not convinced that the current state of UX is such that it's possible to make a UI where there is zero need for product tours, documentation, video tutorials, etc.

Agreed. All software, like much modern design, is starting to look the same, which is heading to about as close as we can get here: that _conventions_ are baked into apps to such an extent that "everyone" "knows" what to do. But even these huge sacrifices to homogeneity won't ever sufficiently cover everything, or even close. At best we get common patterns, like games, where you can relatively quickly get to grips. But games are model worth considering. They don't smack you in the face like Driver.js does but they propose a congruent concept (progressive complexity).

Anyway. I don't know. UI is hard. Abstractions are hard. "This button does this", "Click this to blah" is one approach. Driver.js has its place. And for apps I'm not sure the progressive complexity of games translates well (the app environment doesn't generally scale along the same progression vectors).

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by thyrox on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:21AM (#36849451)
Yes I agree 100%. These type of demos teach me nothing and are annoying as hell.

The only button I'm looking for is the skip button. For the rare cases when the UI doesn't make sense, reading the docs or watching a demo video is far easier to follow as you can skip to the relevant part much easily.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by ericmcer on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:25AM (#36849516)
The one of these I don't hate was at Carrd. More of a toggleable full screen overlay with arrows and notes pointing to all relevant info. https://carrd.co/build/6881ccd20d634611
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by jabart on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:28AM (#36849583)
Have you setup an iPhone ever? Literally the first time you setup an iPhone it walks you through onboarding and a guided flow.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by runako on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:30AM (#36849615)
Casual reminder that many (most?) assignments are to improve existing products, not to build from scratch. Whether or not one agrees with the sentiment of this post, there are certainly places where quick wins are, in fact, still wins.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by brigadier132 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:44AM (#36849813)
Do you have data to back your assertion it's damaging? Because I briefly worked in growth and the stats show these things work and help people.

Apple gets a free pass because they have an army of unpaid bloggers willing to write articles on how to get around some of their terrible UX decisions (systems settings on iOS are impossible to navigate)

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by adolph on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:13PM (#36850309)
Apple does do product tours, example are animations here: https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-17-preview/
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by adrianparsons on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#36850383)
I laugh when I see these because I've witnessed the process that leads to them. It goes something like:

  1. Relatively confusing UX is designed and built.
  2. User testing or executive review concludes the UX is relatively confusing.
  3. Product Manager says "We'll build a slideshow/interactive tutorial!" to solve the problem.
The process and end result is completely understandable. It's hard to rehash a design when you've already built it and gotten buy-in.

I want to spend as little time as possible with most tools (especially enterprise tools), and so often these interrupt my work.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by wpietri on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:54PM (#36850948)
It's understandable in some sense. But wow, the arrogance of designing and building something and then only doing user testing at the point where it's too late to do anything about it. I could even forgive it the first time, but this just happens over and over.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by another-dave on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:55PM (#36852713)
While this can definitely be true, I think it's OK that some experiences are geared towards power users.

E.g. Photoshop is very powerful & you can be very productive but the controls aren't intuitive as a learner.

Aeroplane cockpits are geared towards being easy to do all the complicated things need to fly a plane, rather than being geared towards being easy to learn for non-pilots.

Feels like the "simple Vs easy" distinction.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by catapart on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:53PM (#36850935)
If your product is simple enough to not need a tour, you should design it like that; MOST products are definitely simple enough to not need a tour.

But if you're making Photoshop, or a deep-functionality video editor, or an enterprise accounting application, or a diagnostics utility or...

If you're building any of those things (or something complex like that), don't be afraid to keep it complex and use a tool for building user familiarity. That's good design, actually. No 'one-size-fits-all' solutions on UX, I'm afraid.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by c-hendricks on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:54PM (#36850946)
Guessing you're not familiar with the question mark icon in first party Apple apps like Garage Band?
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by willio58 on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:09PM (#36851154)
The "Hints" app is included with iOS, showing even Apple struggles with this. Most things should be obvious through using your product. For more complex things, it can be hard to rely on discovery.
Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by philvb on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:49PM (#36851717)
You really need both: solid, intuitive product design and good new user onboarding. Even with a great product, new uses will still need help discovering and understanding how to get value from your product.

Tooltips aren't always the answer though. Onboarding that's more seamlessly integrated into the experience are better, like Retool, Superhuman, or Intercom. You can see those experiences here: https://twitter.com/philvb/status/1617921908510699520?s=20&t...

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by joshmanders on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:37PM (#36852446)
> Apple famously doesn't do any of this with your iPhone

I just got a new iPhone and set it up from scratch yesterday... They do this, and it's everywhere.

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by lxe on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:04PM (#36852839)
Thank you. I came here to make a similar comment. Anytime I see a "tour" I know the interface is going to be annoying to get used to.

Don Norman's "Design on Everyday Things" is a must-read for anyone working with UX/UI. Also https://jnd.org/affordances-and-design/

(Of course, these affordances change over time, so some of the conventions/examples are a bit dated, but the spirit remains)

Re:Driver.js: Product tours, highlights, contextual help and... by Redsquare on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:37PM (#36854558)
I guarantee 99% of iphone users dont know 50% of iphone features. You have drunk far too many apple marketing paragraphs.