News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by duxup on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:24PM (#36808597)
> A-bomb architect “was no Einstein,” historian says, but he did Nobel-level work on black holes

As a layman I find it hard to parse the difference from “no Einstein” but still doing “Nobel-level” work.

The interview didn’t really help explain it.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by krastanov on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:34PM (#36808644)
Take this as a biased personal opinion from a professional physicists, not necessarily representative of the field as a whole: Einstein's insights were on a scale quite a bit beyond what anyone else has done since then. That level insight happens very rarely in history, comparable to Euclid being a monumental figure for millennia. Nobel prize winners are smart, but there are two or three of them a year.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by umanwizard on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:54PM (#36808792)
How do you compare Einstein to Newton, in terms of how much each advanced physics?
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by krastanov on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:46PM (#36809120)
I would say Newton provided a similarly important discontinuous leap in our understanding of nature.

I want to be careful though. As some sibling comments mention, these discoveries of these great people were indeed "in the air" of their time. They will have happened. But it would have taken many more great scientists and more time.

For instance, I believe there are incredibly deep insights today derived from the mixture of quantum mechanics and information science. More deep insights are imminent and inevitable. But there is hardly one towering figure to do them all in one sweeping motion the way Einstein or Newton or Euclid did (to name a few easy examples).

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by rramadass on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:47PM (#36809450)
I believe Newton was much more important than Einstein in the history of Science. Essentially he laid the starting point for "Modern" Physics/Mathematics and everybody since then has been following on from there.

For me there are only three Scientists who could be called as truly "tectonic inducing" in the history of Modern Science. In order of ranking;

1) Isaac Newton.

2) James Clerk Maxwell.

3) Albert Einstein.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by Keyframe on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:01AM (#36809846)
I'd put Faraday up there as well.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:15AM (#36809924)
Absolutely. Faraday was in a league of his own and his considerable acclaim still doesn't do him justice.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by drumhead on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:17AM (#36810931)
Newton was more important I think. He basically invented physics as we know it. He didn't have the 200 years or so of work in the field that Einstein had to build on. He was effectively starting from scratch. He's the point at which the modern world starts, when humanity started to understand the world around them instead of letting themselves be subjects of superstition.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by rand0mx1 on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:59AM (#36811233)
Do you forget Galileo's work regarding Motion?
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by sclarisse on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:54PM (#36808795)
Relativity is insane. Einstein literally rewrote the formula for “add two velocities together”. You know, like 20 km/s + 20 km/s, WHICH YOU WOULD THINK just turns into 40km/s, but it’s actually ever so slightly less.

It goes really deep in terms of what it affects in physics.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:17PM (#36808949)
> Einstein literally rewrote the formula for “add two velocities together”.

No, he didn't. There's a reason we are talking about the Lorentz transformation, not the Einstein transformation.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Lorentz_transformat...

> In physics, analogous transformations have been introduced by Voigt (1887) related to an incompressible medium, and by Heaviside (1888), Thomson (1889), Searle (1896) and Lorentz (1892, 1895) who analyzed Maxwell's equations. They were completed by Larmor (1897, 1900) and Lorentz (1899, 1904), and brought into their modern form by Poincaré (1905) who gave the transformation the name of Lorentz.[3] Eventually, Einstein (1905) showed in his development of special relativity that the transformations follow from the principle of relativity and constant light speed alone by modifying the traditional concepts of space and time, without requiring a mechanical aether in contradistinction to Lorentz and Poincaré.[4] Minkowski (1907–1908) used them to argue that space and time are inseparably connected as spacetime.

Einstein did great work, no doubt. But his work was still a product of his time, and was 'in the air'. If it hadn't been for Einstein, other people would have made similar discoveries soon. They were already in the process, after all.

However I suspect, it would have probably taken several great scientists and a few more years.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by heyoni on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:43PM (#36809096)
But that’s kind of the point with Einstein. Work was going towards the aether and in the wrong direction. It was a leap rather than an incremental or logical next step to come up with relativity.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:03PM (#36832215)
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by heyoni on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:09PM (#36832251)
I might need to dig up college notes because I didn’t even know there were 3 kinds of aether theories…but yes, the Lorentz aether (so far) reads a lot like special relativity.

Thanks for the rabbit hole!

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by carlmr on Friday July 21, 2023 @02:31AM (#36810650)
>Eventually, Einstein (1905) showed in his development of special relativity that the transformations follow from the principle of relativity

But that for me is really the point. Even if Lorentz had the math right, he didn't have the explanation, which Einstein delivered. And that's the valuable part in science. Having a model that explains the world better than previous models.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by bsder on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:23AM (#36809978)
General relativity is insane and was definitely a bit ahead of its time. It took decades before we could test many of the implications.

Special relativity was being worked on by several people contemporaneously. The fact that it is called "Lorentz Contraction" should tell you that other people were working on it.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by JackFr on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:56PM (#36808803)
Newton.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by antod on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:15PM (#36808923)
Well if it takes Newton to act as an example of "That level of insight happens very rarely in history", then the point stands. Unless that was what you were getting at?
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:21PM (#36808967)
Well, Leibniz was a contemporary of Newton who could rival him.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by krastanov on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:47PM (#36809127)
I know Leibniz did important work in calculus. But what about gravity, mechanics, and optics? Newton revolutionized quite a few things.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Saturday July 22, 2023 @10:58PM (#36832187)
Have a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gottfried_Wilhelm_Leibniz for some other things Leibniz did.

> Main interests

> Mathematics, physics, geology, medicine, biology, embryology, epidemiology, veterinary medicine, paleontology, psychology, engineering, linguistics, philology, sociology, metaphysics, ethics, economics, diplomacy, history, politics, music theory, poetry, logic, theodicy, universal language, universal science

> Notable ideas

> Algebraic logic, Binary code, Calculus, Differential equations, Mathesis universalis, Monads, Best of all possible worlds, Pre-established harmony, Identity of indiscernibles, Mathematical matrix, Mathematical function, Newton–Leibniz axiom, Leibniz's notation, Leibniz integral rule, Integral symbol, Leibniz harmonic triangle, Leibniz's test, Leibniz formula for π, Leibniz formula for determinants, Fractional derivative, Chain rule, Quotient rule, Product rule, Leibniz wheel, Leibniz's gap, Algebra of concepts, Vis viva (principle of conservation of energy), Principle of least action, Salva veritate, Stepped reckoner, Symbolic logic/Boolean algebra, Semiotics, Analysis situs, Principle of sufficient reason, Law of continuity, Transcendental law of homogeneity, Ars combinatoria (alphabet of human thought), Characteristica universalis, Calculus ratiocinator, Compossibility, Partial fraction decomposition, Protogaea, Problem of why there is anything at all, Pluralistic idealism, Metaphysical dynamism, Relationism, Apperception, A priori/a posteriori distinction, Deontic logic, Well-founded phenomenon

Both Leibniz and Newton did a lot of interesting things, with only some (but very notable!) overlap.

I particularly like Leibniz's calculator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped_reckoner and Newton's telescope.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by JackFr on Friday July 21, 2023 @06:13AM (#36812075)
Yeah - I meant to agree, emphasize and provide another example.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:15PM (#36808931)
> Einstein's insights were on a scale quite a bit beyond what anyone else has done since then.

I wouldn't quite say 'anyone else'. There's always John von Neumann.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by krastanov on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:41PM (#36809081)
That is a great point to bring up! I do not necessarily disagree, but there are gradations, and some contemporary geniuses disagree with your assertion:

Wigner may have said it best: "Einstein's understanding was deeper even than von Neumann's. His mind was both more penetrating and more original than von Neumann's. And that is a very remarkable statement."

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Saturday July 22, 2023 @11:05PM (#36832222)
Maybe. But von Neumann also revolutionised more fields than Einstein.

I guess which one you want to put on a higher pedestal depends on various judgement calls.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by mjhay on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:24PM (#36808987)
His relatively young death was such a tragedy. Von Neumann's intellect really was superhuman.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by anyfoo on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:37PM (#36808673)
There are smart mathematicians who absolutely deserve their Fields Medal.

And then there are people like Gauss and Euler, who lie so far beyond all comparison, it boggles the mind.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by JackFr on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:59PM (#36808816)
I believe it was Freeman Dyson describing Feynman, and I paraphrase, but some geniuses are like you and me, just much, much smarter. And some geniuses just see the world in a way we never can.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:22PM (#36808971)
The usual target of sentences like that is typically John von Neumann.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by iambateman on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:37PM (#36808674)
Yea, starting by saying he isn’t literally-the-greatest-physicist-in-history feels kind of like an unfair comparison.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by JohnBooty on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:12PM (#36808900)
Yeah. It's both factually accurate and weirdly.... negative and insulting.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by duxup on Thursday July 20, 2023 @10:09PM (#36809226)
I also am no Einstein.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by mrfox321 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:30PM (#36808624)
Einstein expanded several fields of physics.

Special + general relativity

Microscopic definition of Brownian motion

Photoelectric effect

Mass-energy equivalence

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:25PM (#36808991)
An interesting bit of trivia is that Einstein explicitly did not get his Nobel for relativity. That was still considered too controversial at the time.

Another bit: at the time Einstein worked on Brownian motion the theory of atoms was still not entirely accepted by everyone. His worked helped settle the matter.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by adrian_b on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:29AM (#36811014)
I would say that after a century of continuous successes, the theory of atoms was very well accepted by everyone.

The matter of the existence of the atoms has become pretty much settled in 1865, when Johann Josef Loschmidt was the first who determined the size and mass of the atoms, and then his results were well used by others, like Maxwell and Stoney (who determined the electric charge of the atoms).

Nevertheless, the improved theory due to Einstein has lead to more precise results about the atom properties.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by adrian_b on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:20AM (#36810964)
Actually I consider that by far the most valuable theoretical advance due to Einstein is the concept of stimulated emission, besides spontaneous emission and absorption, which has lead to the development of masers, lasers, atomic clocks and many other related devices, which have become an indispensable part of modern life.

This is also one of few of his works, together with the general relativity theory that he published around the same time during WWI, where he introduced new mathematical relationships between physical quantities, instead of just giving new interpretations to relationships already found by others.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by luxuryballs on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:31PM (#36808629)
Considering the throng people who have received one I’m not even sure “Nobel-level” is actually about the work.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by newsclues on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:33PM (#36808640)
There are smart people, and then there are the people smart people know are smarter than them by an order of magnitude.

The world is run by smart people, built on a foundation of knowledge creating by generations of the greatest minds that make smart people look normal.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by eru on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:25PM (#36808999)
> The world is run by smart people, [...]

Some smart people are involved in running the world. But we also have plenty of less gifted people in charge.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by newsclues on Friday July 21, 2023 @09:46AM (#36813686)
What I am saying, is that the brightest minds of a time, may be smart, but most of them are using the fundamental knowledge created and saved over many generations of brilliant thinkers.

There are smart people working at SpaceX today. But they are walking on the shoulders of giants like Aryabhata, Newton or Einstein.

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by dieselgate on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:47PM (#36808744)
Actually saw this comment before reading but the article gives sufficient context for the comparison in my opinion.

> Well, he was no Einstein. And he’s not even up to the level of Heisenberg, Pauli, Schrödinger, Dirac, the leaders of the quantum revolution of the 1920s. One of the reasons for this was his birth date. He was born in 1904, so he was 3 years younger than Heisenberg, 4 years younger than Pauli. Those few years were enough to place him in the second wave of the quantum revolution and behind the main wave of discovery, in what [philosopher of science] Thomas Kuhn called the “mopping-up operation,” applications of the new theory.

Edit: not saying I agree or not

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by strikelaserclaw on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:49PM (#36808761)
Einstein was a genius of genius, Oppenheimer was a genius.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by lmpdev on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:58PM (#36808810)
There are almost 1,000 Nobel Laureates over the last century

There is only one physicist who moreorless created half of our contemporary understanding of physics

Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by philwelch on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:27AM (#36809996)
Someone wins the Nobel Prize every year. There’s been less than five Einstein level physicists in all of human history.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by mr_mitm on Friday July 21, 2023 @04:30AM (#36811431)
... that we know of. Who knows how many people of Einstein's caliber grew up in some slums who never got the chance to develop and to prove themselves.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by Gibbon1 on Friday July 21, 2023 @04:42AM (#36811500)
I know this Mexican dude. No education beyond high school. Designed an embedded controller running lisp on a Microchip PIC. He wrote the interpreter in assembly himself. He pulled that off in three weeks having never programmed anything before.
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by mixmastamyk on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:38PM (#36821503)
Sounds cool. Any links to a blog, etc?
Re:Hollywood Movie Aside, Just How Good a Physicist Was Oppe... by lbsnake7 on Friday July 21, 2023 @04:00PM (#36818887)
I’ve heard of this before. That there are geniuses tolling away in fields but because they don’t have the right resources, no one knows who they are. But Isaac Newton changed science without the Industrial Revolution. Without running water or cars or electricity or modern medicine. Cream rises to the top and natural geniuses like that would be very apparent very fast.