Buy an AC, get comfortable, and if this is a real issue to you, sit down and think long and hard about how best to affect the problem. You'll find better options than not running your AC.
(Edit: for perpective, most residential dwellings in Canada run heaters from november to march and AC from june to september. This is a big problem - your AC, your whole carbon footprint is less than a fraction of a percent of CO2 per year. This issue is systematic and will not be solved by voluntary simplicity
And about moving - where do you go? I'm happy where I am with hitting -30C to -40C in the winter, but we are having historical forest fires right now, first ever acutal tornado alert in my life and are hitting 30-35C multiple times a week, and trying to go higher North is only mining towns and fishing villages. Southern Hemisphere?)
I really think that "after all I don't have much impact" is what's killing the planet. It's always somebody's else fault and no one takes responsibility or does anything.
So this is a systemic issue, where the people actually impacting the problem are at the top of compagnies, governement and international regulators. That's where any change can happen - any individual change has an effect that is either non perceptible ("setting an example for others" is impossible to measure) or measurably negligible (making your footprint smaller).
So things like recycling or running the AC less have nothing to do with the problem or the solution - we need to affect the system itself, and to do that we have to go through companies, governement and international regulation.
Issue is that virtually no one is trying to do that. Few people try to impact local governement, fewer national or international entities.
I think this is because the "energy" needed to think and find a way to have an impact is drained into all the individual action stuff.
Like a pressure cooker - individual action is the valve letting of enough steam so that nothing happens. Remove the valve - what happens?
Big industry is one of the root causes of all of this and even if individual choice is a factor I'm pretty sure that if just 500 people would stop lining their pockets for a couple of decades and instead really took our global interests to heart that we might be able to put a dent in this. But as it is I'm not very hopeful that that will ever happen. In fact they'll probably use the crisis to further increase the wealth gap.
It's important to understand where the biggest offenses are and keep things in perspective, but this shouldn't absolve one of all personal responsibility either.
As individuals, pretty much the only ways we can influence the world for the better are going to be small by definition, and it makes sense to be considerate of which levers we do decide to pull.
Tasmania will fare well (probably) and has hydroelectricity (and inbreeding (allegedly)).
New Zealand has geothermal, two islands to choose from, but is getting over run with hollyweird seppo's looking for Middle Earth. At least Sam Neill is a (recent) native New Zealander.
As a Canadian you're welcome in either although you may get tired of explaining your accent isn't from (central northern) America.
To illustrate, we know that a bullet proof way to make a person's carbon footprint zero is for them to die. But no one would ever advocate this for obvious reasons.
So lowering carbon footprint should not be the only goal. One should be reducing the harm done.
There's a study in Japan showing that people avoid using heating due to inflation and more people die from stroke for example because of this. I.e. discomfort is not just a feeling, it can have harmful consequence.
And yet I always hear people fret about the energy use of AC but not heating.
I think it's based in our naturalistic fallacy.
Heating all of Chicago to be bearable in the winter is seen as "natural" as humans have been heating our homes for millennia. But Las Vegas cooling it's interior spaces is seen as strange and unnatural. And yet, cooling a warm environment is better from an environmental point of view than warming a cold one.
I think people who need AC in the summer are the same people who overheat their homes in winter.
Is this true? Why would it be better for the enviroment?
Most heating works by directly generating heat, via electric resistance or burning a fuel source. (Heat pumps are the exception.)
More details here if you'd like to jump into more details:
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/8/1/014...
> results indicate that climate control in Minneapolis is about 3.5 times as energy demanding as in Miami
I don't think that comparing the two is fair though. It's very hard to not get sick in a house at 10 degrees Celsius. 40 degrees Celsius is an immense discomfort but won't get me sick.
It's just a heat pump, and fairly efficient all considered. And not nearly as damaging to the climate as the folks who live in cold places and use fossil fuels to heat their homes. I don't think I'd feel guilty about getting some relief, it's not unreasonable.
A refrigerator also has a heat pump, but we just call them refrigerators.
Part of the problem is in temperate climates, if you have "A/C" you probably _also_ have a furnace. They might run on different fuels (electric vs. natural gas) so it makes it harder to get a ballpark estimate for the overall efficiency.
In really cold climates (e.g. Minneapolis, Montreal) heat pumps often also need a supplemental furnace or fireplace because the heat differential inside vs. outside exceeds what the pump can handle. Depending on your fuel source, you still come out ahead, but not as much.
I should note that I'm not an expert by any means; my brother in law works in this field and he gave me a crash course a couple weeks ago. So I probably feel like I know it better than I actually do.
Does it though? That seems to be some kind of subcultural jargon that matches neither common (which uses central heating and air conditioning for any central system that cools with a heat pump regardless of how it heats) nor industry usage. (My fairly nee system, marketed as A/C, has both a two-way heat pump and a gas furnace to back up the heat punp for heating.)
https://thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/human-deaths-from-...
https://www.wunderground.com/cat6/Which-Kills-More-People-Ex...
> In a 2014 interview in the Washington Post of University of Miami climatologist Larry Kalkstein, who has published numerous research papers on weather-related mortality, weighed in on the matter: “Comparing apples to apples, which would be to evaluate acute or short-term responses to weather, I would always give the nod to heat-related deaths. However, if you are considering the seasonal differences in daily mortality, rather than just the “spikes” that we find with acute deaths, I can see why one can argue that winter (or cold-related) mortality is greater.”
https://www.wunderground.com/cat6/Which-Kills-More-People-Ex...
Edit: I see we are citing the same article :)
Note that this article also discusses other factors, such as seasonal changes in death rates due to diseases--but it, unlike the one you referenced, correctly observes that temperature is a factor in such deaths. The fact that flu season is worst in winter is because temperatures are colder than optimal in winter. So the increased flu death rate in winter should at least partly be counted as an increased death rate due to cold. The excess deaths methodology takes these kinds of things into account.
Secondarily, many may lack the basic physics knowledge to think about both as heat transfer nor to recognize the most important parameters: temperature differential and isolation.
On the other hand, people may have some awareness of poor deployments of air conditioning into leaky and barely insulated structures in hot climates. These are indeed wasteful, but so would heating that structure if it were transplanted to a cold climate. But, it is the structure that is inefficient, rather than the heating or cooling method...
Does that make the problem worse? Technically I have to say yes. But on any meaningful scale? I think the manufacturing of the unit has had far more impact than any usage, and probably will for the entire time I own it. And it’s a drop in the bucket compared to, say, owning and using a car.
I didn't think Italian weather would follow me here.
Anyway I'm thinking about installing solar panels totalling 800W (maximum allowed without additional permits) on my balcony next season and powering a small AC unit off of that - I suppose it's fair, considering it will be running using renewable energy and only when it's actually needed.
Why on earth would a government put up barriers to energy independence? Is this because the Polish grid is not stable enough to deal with a substantial fraction of power from renewables or to protect commercial interests?
Specific regulations for on-grid systems in Poland are:
-3,68kW limit for single -phase installations - that's actually a technical limitation.
-10kW limit to receive subsidies for purchase of the system.
-50kW limit for net-billing as a private person, but you'll have to first ensure your connection has the capacity to handle that - it's usually 12kW or less, so you'd need to apply for an increase, which will go through depending on the infrastructure in your area.
Overall large PV farms in Poland lately went through series of temporary downtime in situations where the grid went above the safety threshold of 253V, but prosumers were largely unaffected by this.
Everyone is in on it because panels are cheap and electricity has become expensive, so the investment pays itself off in a few years - especially when you go over the subsidised limit of 2600kWh annually per household with children. My sneaky plan with those panels is to remain below that threshold.
The other obvious solution would be to place a bunch of solar (PV) panels on the roof. These are 50% deducible in your taxes in the next 10 years. You can do that also in condo. The upside is that by design the excess energy is sold to the local network, powering other apartments/houses locally. You can also join a solar community. You can also decide to buy only certified energy that comes from hydroelectric or pv or eolic (see for example Dolomiti's offers) and compensate CO2 produced by energy and/or gas at home with certificates (as well, Dolomiti's offers).
Our solar, since Jan 1st, has produced over 4 MWh of power, of which 1 was used by us and 3 were used by other apartments in the building (and we got paid for it, even if just a little).
Regarding floods, yes, it was bad. But many reasons are linked to anthropic (mis)use of the soil. You can (if you read Italian) read up a bunch of things written by the Wu Ming collective commenting the whole event.
I am considering emigration as well, but for other reasons.
I get the exact figure of my electricity mix generation in my bill, it's 90% in my case (Castelli Romani, Lazio, Servizio Elettrico Nazionale).
What many call AC or air-conditioning, a lot of the world calls "heat pumps", and modern heat pumps are not only incredibly efficient, but they work both ways, and are also one of the most efficient ways to heat homes in the winter. So there's a good chance that by replacing or augmenting your home's heating system with a two-way heat pump (aka AC), you can actually increase your home's energy efficiency.
And some quick research and back of the napkin math makes me think that residential air conditioning accounts for less than 2% of carbon emissions. [0.37 (residential share of total electricity consumption) * 0.17 (air conditioning's share of residential electricity use) * 0.25 (electricity's share of total emissions) = 1.57%]. You are one out of 8 billion people. Your individual contribution to carbon emissions is a drop in the bucket of that 2%, and remember, a heat pump may actually increase your home's energy efficiency. At scale, heat pumps are definitely a potential net-win.
All that to say, don't beat yourself up or suffer too much over this. Individual choices are not the driving factor of climate change. Climate change is driven by industry, specifically oil and gas, and the responsibility needs to fall on those industries to account for negative externalities. You can offset your own carbon emissions for probably under a hundred Euro a year. But what really needs to happen to reduce carbon emissions is that large companies and industries need to be held accountable with carbon taxes.
TL;DR, just get AC to protect yourself and your family, and spend your suffering and energy pushing for industries to be held responsible instead of beating yourself up about it.
Only if you would otherwise heat your home using electricity anyway (or if that electricity is produced using low-emission methods).
If it’s produced using gas plants, co-generation is likely still more efficient, for example – but these will hopefully also be phased out at some point.
Balkonkraftwerk = Balcony Power Plant
Thank you Germany for your language.
Really? Please explain how that will fix anything. Governments can't do anything about climate change. Only a private sector innovation to sequester excess carbon would actually work.
I'm not convinced your using AC contributed to global warming.
Taxes on transport based on the efficiency.
This kind of taxation would have the direct impact of rebalancing consumptions towards a smaller carbon impact globally.
I find it arrogant to talk about saving "the planet." It's usually about saving the comfortable status-quo lifestyle of the developed world.
When in reality it's one of those unusual instances where the developed world is actually seeing a planet full of people, instead of just their little bubble.
The problem is it's a bit late for that.
Also if you deploy a mini-split (heat pump) it’s extremely efficient and it can both cool in the summer and offset heating needs in the winter. Heat pumps are 400% efficient compared to gas heat because they move heat energy.
If you augment gas heat in the winter with a heat pump it can be 4x the efficiency. That’s a huge win for your climate impact.
Your life and comfort are important. Look to those first. Then say, “of the things available to me what can I do to help?” Counterintuitive as it may sound this can lead to both taking good care of yourself AND optimal practices that fight climate change.
For example one of the biggest things I can do to help is use my words. If I convince ten neighbors to deploy solar I 10x my positive impact. If I call my representative and say “make rooftop solar more cost-effective with net metering rules and installation credits” I potentially influence the rules that make tens of thousands of people more likely to go sustainable.
You and quite a few others. I know a doctor and some other people through him in the South of Italy and they're ready to pack it in because it's simply unmanageable. They're the lucky ones, with options and skills that are in high demand elsewhere.
Heat pump heating is the most efficient way to heat a space (well, not counting simply putting a block of highly refined plutonium in your house).
I'm resisting the urge to buy AC because I feel like AC makes the problem worse, not better. Especially as electricity in Italy is 90% gas produced, I just think it's such a nonsense to buy AC and then make global warming worse. But I'm frying since 2 weeks at this point.
I barely remember a week or two of cold weather this year in winter.
The difference in winter temperatures and amount of snow in Poland is just gigantic. I remember every christmas having snow in Poland, I remember up to -30 degrees temperatures in southern poland, lately it's been rainy and warm 7/8 degrees C.
The only thing that can save the planet is a fair carbon tax, because the situation feels more and more desperate every day, we need to slow this thing up.
Heat is not the only problem, both the countries I have more family (Italy/Poland) are short in water and it is getting desperately worse every year. Climate-change driven disasters are getting so common here in Italy, we've had just a disaster flood in northern Italy 2 months ago after such a long draught. I've never ever in my life seen 38 days of rain over a 43 days span from May to June in southern Italy.
I am seriously considering emigration as an answer to climate changes. I seriously cannot even fathom the pain tourists visiting Italy in summer (at least those going to historical cities like Rome or Naples) endure.