News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by philwelch on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @10:51AM (#3675840)
What I really want is a SimCity where I can build a "New Urbanist" city. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Urbanism

The SimCity games I've played in the past rely too heavily on separated zoning and car traffic, often with broken transit AI (sims don't go backwards to reach a nearby transit stop) and no concept of walkability. While I don't think you should have to build your SimCity in a new urbanist style, it would be nice to make it an option.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by jonnathanson on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @02:58PM (#3676860)
Streets were basically pure downside in most iterations of SimCity. There was almost no point to making them. The second you laid down some road, you were incurring more problems than you were solving. As one of the posters mentioned here, it was entirely possible -- and maybe even optimal -- to design cities entirely devoid of roads.

I distinctly recall more than a few rail-only cities that flourished a lot better than any of my road-based or mixed-transportation cities ever did. Seemed vaguely unrealistic, until I realized what SimCity is actually about. At its heart, SimCity is about two things: 1) Acquiring residents; and 2) keeping the lives of those residents as comfortable and stress-free as possible. (Seriously -- the game would require you to take this to almost Wall-E levels of extremity).

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by j45 on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @05:57PM (#3677700)
I used to start with a little bit of road and override it with rail. Overtime my whole city was just rail.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @04:35PM (#3677366)
That's what really annoyed me about 4. The lack of new traffic and urban designs. I really wanted:

- Roundabouts

- Traffic Circles

- Shared Spaces (no separation between road and sidewalk)

- Light Rail

- Street Cars

- High Speed Rail

- Bus Stops that didn't take up a whole block space

- People Movers (like the one in Miami, FL)

- Bike Lanes / Bike Paths

- Bridging neighborhoods together with sidewalks

- Walk-able Plazas that residents would actually use instead of being lazy

- Small 2 lane highways

- Bridge control

- Better street control so that every intersection doesn't force cars to stop and go.

And why on earth did they claim the Mono-Rail was the fastest public transit and best for intercity connectivity?! Monorails are notoriously slow and terrible for anything other than amusement park transportation.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by tylerritchie on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @06:22PM (#3677775)
Monorails aren't inherently flawed, are they? Isn't it just that implementations are generally older and not particularly high quality?

My largest complaint regarding Sim City 4 was that the transportation add-on was almost essential to the game, yet it was an add-on, and cost extra.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by philwelch on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:03AM (#3678650)
What's the distinction between roundabouts and traffic circles?
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by qntm on Thursday March 08, 2012 @09:00AM (#3679704)
The terminology isn't fixed, but in my book, a traffic circle is where traffic on the rotary has to yield to traffic entering, whereas traffic on a roundabout has priority over traffic entering.

Roundabouts are typically smaller (down to a mini-roundabout with an island just a metre or two across, compared with traffic circles which can be hundreds of metres in diameter). As a result, roundabout traffic typically moves slower, and they're MUCH safer.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by philwelch on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:37PM (#3680956)
The "yield to traffic inside the roundabout" rule is the safer and more efficient rule, more or less regardless of roundabout size.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by ginko on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @01:06PM (#3676393)
This exactly.

The rigid separation of zones drove me nuts when I last played SimCity 4. Here in Vienna it's completely normal to have flats, shops and offices in every building. As far as I know this is even more extreme in Asian cities.

What I would love to see would be a triangle slider for zoning where you could for instance say this block should be 60% residential , 25% industrial and 15% commercial. Maybe some industries or commercial venues will require higher percentages to settle but this could also be an interesting tool.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @04:28PM (#3677333)
Or no zoning like in some cities in Texas. Where businesses usually, naturally gravitate towards busy intersections and shopping districts on their own.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by dfc on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @07:09PM (#3677969)
No zoning? I do not believe it. Or do you mean no-zoning like 802.11 is "unregulated"?
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by ChrisNorstrom on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @07:27PM (#3678023)
Houston Texas is like that. A few other cities too. There are no zoning laws. It has pros (economic), it has cons (personal) but it does work in specific situations. It allows the free market to decide where it wants to go. Zoning sometimes fails because you end up with massive neighbors without a grocery store or business areas too close together without residential areas nearby and forcing people from other areas to commute there. It can get messy. But when there are no zoning laws businesses naturally gravitate toward heavy loud noisy streets and intersections anyway. Industrial companies naturally go far out where the land is cheaper. And residents go towards the areas that suit their lifestyle or that they can afford. It doesn't always work out perfectly but that's the theory anyway. Anyone from Houston please chime in.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by dfc on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @07:39PM (#3678070)
There are no zoning laws in Houston but there are significant land use restrictions. Free market is such an ambigious term in discussions like this...
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by joshAg on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @07:46PM (#3678099)
No zoning at all.

My engineering ethics class covered a case in Houston, which has 0 zoning of any kind (or at least it did in the late 80's early 90's at the time of the events we covered. things might have changed) and the effects of putting a heavy metal incineration plant near government subsidized housing and elementary schools.

Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by ssmall on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @07:24PM (#3678013)
Its true. I know Houston is that way and there might be more, smaller cities.
Re:Electronic Arts bringing back ‘SimCity’ franchise after 1... by smalter on Wednesday March 07, 2012 @11:16AM (#3675931)
In my experience, what you wrote is true. But the insane simcities that this guy built, http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=N..., didn't have any streets.