News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:35AM (#36692597)
I really despise all the "why you should care about math" takes.

The question is never asked about any other school subject and only mathematics has to justify itself that way. I had to learn about categories of plants and animals, interpret 20th century literature, learn about events from a thousand years ago, I did presentations on the demographics of European countries, how certain chemicals react and much, much more. I never used any of that knowledge for anything, certainly not in my career or in university.

But somehow mathematics is the one field which needs to justify its own existence? Mathematics needs to bend itself over and "be relevant" so that people will actually learn about it? Why? Why not ask the same of any other subject.

Justifying mathematics is easy, especially such a universally applicable subject as calculus. But I see no reason why it should have to justify itself in any way.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by golergka on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:38AM (#36692613)
People aren't doing it because they think they should. They are doing it because they want to.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:01AM (#36692765)
That's because math is harder for most people.

There is no difference between learning a name in history or in biology, or some workflow.

But math reasoning really filters out people in a way nothing else does.

All other topics just require memory and basic reasoning.

Even physics mostly is hard because of math. And philosophy, mostly because of jargon and references. Otherwise, if you break it down, it's not that complicated.

But you can break down a math problem as much as you want, some of them are beyond what you can do comfortably. And a lot of students reach this limit early in their life.

I see this when I play board games with people: there is a threshold of rules and calculation power above which I lose 90% of the players. They just can't enjoy it, because it requires too much effort to play.

It's similar for me and sport. I've been doing exercise all my life, but my brother will always do more, and harder, because there is a barrier after which it's just too painful for me.

Math and athleticism can be trained, but there is a hard ceiling. And even before you reach that ceiling, closing the gap gets more and more expensive for some people, so much the ROI is difficult to justify.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by DC-3 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:35AM (#36693028)
> math reasoning really filter out people in a way nothing else does.

I have known many people, to whom mathematical reasoning comes as easily and naturally as flight does to a swallow, be defeated by literature. Every technical university in the world is brimming with bright young people who could effortlessly describe a Jacobian but would rather gnaw their own hand off than produce a response to a story or sonnet.

> And philosophy, mostly because of jargon and reference. Otherwise, if you break it down, it's not that complicated.

Quite the claim.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:55AM (#36693247)
They are not defeated by literature, they are just not that interested in it, and therefore never practiced, and dislike working on it.

It's not a matter of the field being too difficult. It's a matter of personality.

> Quite the claim.

Yes. I've discussed this claim with people defending the opposite idea, and I've yet to find anybody making a good demonstration that philosophy is hard inby itself.

They point that there is a lot to know. So reference and memory. Like most expertise in the world.

That texts are hard to read. So style, vocabulary. Well, not different than programming or the law on that point. They are easier than higher level math.

They say few people get novel ideas. Yes, creativity is rare, yet it's not particularly linked to the field. You need creativity to find new theorems too.

So they try to bring complicated topics again and again. Once we are done mapping the references, the vocabulary and cleaned out the awful style a lot of writers use to obfuscate their reasoning, the ideas behind are quite straightforward to grasp.

I've stopped doing it now, it takes a very long time, and it's always disappointing. It feels like debugging a program, only to realize it could have been 10 times shorter and easier to read.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by DC-3 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:04AM (#36693319)
As I read it, your argument boils down to:

> When a student who likes literature does poorly in mathematics, it is because he is not clever enough.

> When a student who likes mathematics does poorly in literature, it is because it is boring.

If you truly believe this I have nothing more to say to you.

I will not respond to your comments on philosophy, though I think they are wrongheaded, because I think your position to discuss such things is made untenable by the obvious contempt in which you hold the humanities.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:13AM (#36693397)
> If you truly believe this

Well, I've tried sincerely to find out what was difficult about philosophy for many years. Have you down the same with math?

> because I think your position to discuss such things is made untenable by the obvious contempt in which you hold the humanities.

You assume I was a math head, and that I have disdain from humanities.

That's a total projection which tells me you are not being objective in this discussion. So you are right, it's a good thing we stop there.

But for the record I actually like humanities.

Just because you think a topic is harder than another doesn't mean you prefer one.

I don't even particularly like math, and I'm very bad at it.

I'm probably better than the average Joe, but I'm way better at writing than at calculating.

And I enjoy reading philosophy and sociology.

It's ironic that someone in humanities can be so judgmental of its fellow human, and in a very black and white way.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:10AM (#36692828)
What I specifically dislike is the question "what am I ever going to use this for" or versions of it. Which I only ever hear about mathematics, but which can be asked about every other subject as well.

Yes, math is hard and definitely not for everyone, which I think is perfectly fine. But arguing that something has no use to you, because the first time in your life you actually have to engage in complex logical thinking is just lazy. The value of mathematics is independent of how hard it is.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by butterNaN on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:14AM (#36692843)
I feel your complaint is valid, but I your ire should be directed towards people who are supposed to answer this question, not the people who are asking it.

My guess is that answering "what am I ever going to use this for" is easier for other subjects, sometimes almost intuitive. For Maths, it needs to be defined as soon as it starts getting abstract.

"what am I ever going to use this for" is a perfectly valid question. People who are supposed to answer it should do a better job of doing so, writing good curriculum, and overall communication.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:29AM (#36692983)
>My guess is that answering "what am I ever going to use this for" is easier for other subjects, sometimes almost intuitive.

How so? What am I ever going to use my skills in analysing 20th century literature for. What am I ever going to use my knowledge about Roman history for? What am I ever going to use my knowledge about the structure of our government for? Certainly no employeer of mine ever cared, my University didn't care, nobody seems to have ever cared, except my teachers.

The question is bad because:

- People ask it, but only of mathematics

- People answer it, as if mathematics alone has to face that challenge

If school is about job training the answer is simply "because it contains the broadest possible techniques to understand the world and is vital in basically any data-based scientific pursuit and a basic understanding is needed for any trade which uses measurements". Somehow I think ancient history does not have such an answer...

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:01AM (#36694679)
> What am I ever going to use my skills in analysing 20th century literature for.

You can use the same skills to spot when a news article is trying to manipulate you.

> What am I ever going to use my knowledge about Roman history for?

You can see how empires fall, and vote against those things.

> What am I ever going to use my knowledge about the structure of our government for?

Understanding why things happen around you is the first thing you need if you ever want to try and change something you don't like.

> Certainly no employeer of mine ever cared, my University didn't care, nobody seems to have ever cared, except my teachers.

You might care, though. Or you might not know what you know now without them.

Thankfully you did all those things, so now you can write a well-written letter to the correct person in government, citing the parallel problems with the current education system and the fall of Rome, and stop children being taught this stuff (-:

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:41AM (#36695256)
You are completely missing the point here. If you know "why empires fall" (nobody does) then you could just teach that, the historical context would be almost irrelevant and even the premise of a cyclical history, which can be broken by voting, seems completely insane.

>Thankfully you did all those things, so now you can write a well-written letter to the correct person in government, citing the parallel problems with the current education system and the fall of Rome, and stop children being taught this stuff (-:

Okay, that was funny.

I think what you are trying to articulate is education as a hollistic system, not with the goal of expertese, but with the goal of offering some moral foundation and grounding in the world and society. But if you believe in that the utilitarian stance of education immediately becomes irrelevant and "when am I ever going to use this" becomes a non-sensical question, which misses the point.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:37AM (#36696159)
> If you know "why empires fall" (nobody does)

I said see how they fall. Not every way, and not necessarily why, but how.

> then you could just teach that, the historical context would be almost irrelevant

I don't think you can see how they fall without historical context. That is the how.

> even the premise of a cyclical history, which can be broken by voting, seems completely insane

I didn't mention a cyclical history. Some things repeat, but that doesn't mean in general history is cyclical.

I don't mean to comment in a way that's too much on the nose, but I've just broken out various statements of yours and shown how they didn't follow from what I said. Spending time studying literature in a controlled environment, can help train children to read what's being said, as opposed to what they guess is being said. It's not perfect, but it can help a lot.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by rhaway84773 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:24AM (#36692933)
Math is abstract. Very few to no other school level subjects are abstract.

That’s why you hear discussions about pushing algebra out, but not about pushing arithmetic out.

That’s why some schools replaced algebra with “data science”.

Abstraction isn’t easy.

But that’s precisely why math, especially algebra and the like, is so essential. It’s the only path to building abstract reasoning among students.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by derangedHorse on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:39PM (#36699672)
I don’t think it’s the abstraction, I think it’s the perceived lack of usefulness. I’ve known many individuals who are bad at math but can understand the abstraction of most programming constructs. I think it’s mainly because the pay off of learning programming has a higher immediate value (it can be used for a variety of tasks and can even help score a high paying job).
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by TRiG_Ireland on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:09AM (#36694007)
> What I specifically dislike is the question "what am I ever going to use this for" or versions of it. Which I only ever hear about mathematics.

I've often heard it asked of languages, specifically Irish.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by Sodman on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:06AM (#36694751)
I always disliked Irish (and languages, in general) in school. However, now that I'm over a decade out of college I find it to be one of the few subjects I wish I'd paid more attention to when I'd had the chance... Sure, it's not particularly useful in adult life, but neither is organic chemistry, for most folks.

The main difference for me is that it's relatively easy to "fill in the gaps" for any other subject we learned from the ages of 12-18. Irish however, is niche enough - and learning resources generally technologically behind - that it's still quite tricky to self-teach or "quickly google" answers to things. That makes it unique from most other primary/secondary school subjects which are more universally taught across the world.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by TRiG_Ireland on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:05PM (#36701676)
I asked that question in school (strange to look back on, as I'm now fascinated by languages), and the only answer the teacher could give was that doing well in Irish would give extra Leaving Cert points. That struck me at the time as depressing.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by DarkNova6 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:48AM (#36693163)
> math reasoning really filter out people in a way nothing else does.

Disagree. I say: Bad math teachers really filter out people in a way nothing else does.

"Here is a list of rules which can be used in specific circumstances. I am not going to tell you why you would need them and the exam will feature several corner cases. Also, I will not provide any examples or detailed explanations because what would other people think of me, then?"

This is over the top, but boils down my experience starting from highschool. I was in love with math when I was in primary and middle school. I really did.

But Highschool and university killed every last bit of enjoyment I used to have.

Okay, I did really like the first 2 semesters of math. I found an amazing online class which covered the same topics we did. Finally I understood and doing the exercises with such ease felt like cheating.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:06AM (#36693339)
True.

But even with the best teachers for every field, math or sport will filter out people way more harshly, and sooner, than any other field.

You can smooth things out with quality teaching, but there is a human hardware limit, and you reach it sooner with those two.

Many people don't like to hear it because their ego is bruised or because it goes against the idea that "everybody can do anything".

This is wrong. Birds fly, fishes swim. There is nothing bad about either.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by CodeSgt on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:33AM (#36694275)
> This is wrong. Birds fly, fishes swim. There is nothing bad about either.

I have a hard time with this mentality. I would have agreed a few years ago perhaps, and do still agree that we all have our own aptitudes, but the level of absolution in a statement like this just isn’t really quite as applicable to humans in my opinion. There are things I never thought I’d be capable of that I’ve recently begun to excel at.

What I thought was a hardware limit turned out to just bug in my psycho-software that needed a patch. Obviously at the extreme end’s of the spectrum, the human hardware limit is very real. But for most (healthy) people, engaging in most activities, I believe that any perceived immutable barriers or obstacles are almost entirely psychological.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:09AM (#36694801)
> I believe that any perceived immutable barriers or obstacles are almost entirely psychological.

Laws of physics are laws of physics. And biology is applied physics.

People in sport have known that for a long time. You can train as much as Usain Bolt, he still has a huge advantage.

Thinking the other human characteristics are not affected by this is weird. You will never be Von Neumann, no matter how much you spend in the class room.

It's not that training has no effect, it does, a lot. Yet this doesn't remove the fact we have a variability between individual.

And there is not a tipping point, it's a spectrum for each characteristic.

It turns out math exhibit some early barrier in that spectrum. There is nothing wrong with that.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by greatwave1 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:36AM (#36695165)
There's a big difference between edge cases like Usain Bolt and Von Neumann, and the barriers that most people actually run into.

The vast majority of people are not biologically incapable of making it through high-school level math, or even becoming a very capable mathematician with enough high-quality teaching and dedication.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:45AM (#36695324)
Just using the extremum to show there is a difference.

The difference is not limited to the extremes. Why would it be?

Hence spectrum.

And math meet people early in the spectrum.

EDIT: thread limit reached, so I can't answer down there.

But in short, it's a HN comment, not a study. But I've been in 11 schools in my life. Some private ones with their own church inside, some for special kids, some for poor kids with a higher degree of violence.

I saw it again and again. The average math teacher is not worse than any other teachers. But the first field kids have a hard time is more often math than other fields. In fact, kids that are good at math usually can do ok in any other, even if not great. The reverse is not necessarily true.

At this point I'm just repeating the argument in the other comments.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by greatwave1 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:52AM (#36695433)
What evidence do you have that the biological limitations for mathematical ability meets people early in the spectrum?

I can think of several anecdotal counter-examples... students who seemed to have been falling behind, but with the right teacher were able to make significant improvements and become a top performer.

You can also take a look at many of the studies done on the educational gap, to see that better schooling can have a massive impact on secondary and post-secondary educational outcomes. Surely this wouldn't be the case if poor performers had some "biological limit" that prevented them from succeeding in high school math.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:53AM (#36695447)
>The vast majority of people are not biologically incapable of making it through high-school level math, or even becoming a very capable mathematician with enough high-quality teaching and dedication.

It was hard for me to accept, but I know that after many years of University math education there are things I will never be able to understand. I have had very good grades in my Masters, but I realized that I will never be able to do research in pure mathematics.

Almost every person I know struggled with math far more than I did. How would they become research mathematicians if I couldn't after years of study? The belief that secretly almost all people are better at mathematics than me, despite me trying for many years, seems utterly absurd.

Do you think I really am in the bottom ~50% of the population in terms of mathematical ability? Because I know I will never be a pure mathematician.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by greatwave1 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:16AM (#36695812)
> Do you think I really am in the ~50% of the population in terms of mathematical ability?

I don't know nearly enough about your personal background to make any sort of judgement on to what extent your success up through university came from innate "mathematical ability" versus other factors.

But I do know that making it through a Masters-level program makes you a very capable mathematician, even if were unable to start a career in pure mathematics.

You made it further along in your mathematical education than 99.9%+ of students, and I have a very hard time believing that "biological predisposition" is what's stopping many people from making it past high-school level math.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:30AM (#36705676)
I am not a mathematician at all and I have never been. My contributions to mathematics are exactly zero.

But even if I were, why did the hundreds of people I studied with in school and university fail far more than I did. No, I didn't work especially hard and often times I was explaining things to other students, it weren't the teachers, we all had the same. It also wasn't motivation, I didn't need all that much to succeed. Was it just luck that I outperformed most people given the opportunity?

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by jameshart on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:23AM (#36694990)
Nobody is claiming that 100% of people can be trained to run a 100m in 9.58s.

But there is some number of seconds which 90% of people can be trained to run 100m below.

And it wouldn’t surprise me if it’s a much lower number than you think.

Likewise not 100% of people can develop the mathematical horsepower of Von Neumann. But 90% of people can attain some level of proficiency in higher mathematical concepts… how high a level would that be? Higher than most high schools aim I would suspect.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:48AM (#36695373)
I don't disagree with any of this, I'm just stating math is a topic that shows the limits of people quicker in the curriculum than other fields.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by CodeSgt on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:31PM (#36700401)
> Obviously at the extreme end’s of the spectrum, the human hardware limit is very real.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by jameshart on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:37AM (#36694325)
Different humans (in the 90th percentile at least, to eliminate the extreme outliers) are not equipped so vastly differently for mathematics or athletic activity as fish and birds. Thinking that some people can fly and some can swim and that’s just that seems very reductive.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:10AM (#36694817)
Indeed. After all, this is an HN comment, not a white paper. It comes with the usual caveat.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by sublinear on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:31AM (#36696052)
I wasn't the best math student in school and there was a lot I didn't fully understand back then, but I eventually learned it all and more as I got older. I know I'm not the only one. It seems more like a function of time and effort than a "human hardware limit".
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:17PM (#36696904)
> You can smooth things out with quality teaching, but there is a human hardware limit, and you reach it sooner with those two.

Shmaybe. But I doubt many people ever approach it. What they hit is, instead, a "software lockout" - a limit of the kind that some hardware vendors (such as those making oscilloscopes or farming machines) put in their products, where the hardware is already there, but its capability is restricted in software, and you need to pay to have the restrictions lifted.

If you'd seen me as a kid, you'd say I am one of those people with rather low "hardware limit" when it comes to math. But then, when I was around 13, that limit suddenly shot up so high and so fast, it may as well have disappeared. What happened? I started to learn to code, with an intent to make videgames. Eventually I reached the point when I was trying to figure out how to rotate some sprites, and made a mental connection between what I want (understanding how to implement rotating images) and what I was taught at school (trigonometry). Immediately, math switched from being something I had to learn, and became something I wanted to learn. So, what you'd think was a severe hardware limit, was actually a purely software one - and it went away the moment I found the magic unlock code (which, in my case, was "find something that makes math seem relevant and exciting, instead of a bullshit chore").

And yes, I'll admit that I do have a hardware limit relevant here - most kids do well at math without having to find a motivational "cheat code", but people like me, with impaired executive functions, can't naturally power through bullshit, and need workarounds to keep up. But this is a different kind of limit. It's also one we're getting increasingly good at understanding, recognizing and overcoming, and it teaches us that what you see as hardware skill limit, may just be a software limit induced by another problem.

Or, in short, if someone told the twelve year old me the things you wrote here today, it would have derailed my life. Fortunately, nobody did, and this lazy and dumb-ish kid ended up handling undergrad-level math perfectly fine.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by joedevon on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:59AM (#36693896)
Perhaps teaching math in an accessible way is the real challenge. When I was a kid...a looooooong time ago...you were greeted with "Math Problems" on day one. Perhaps a better word than "problem" would attract more devotees.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by blitz_skull on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:47AM (#36694443)
You didn't go to the high school I went to. Some people, fundamentally, just cannot do math.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by greatwave1 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#36695959)
Was it a good school in a wealthy area?

If not, what makes you confident that your peers were falling behind due to some sort of innate inability, instead of as a result of compounding poor teaching or other environmental factors?

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:36PM (#36697256)
Well, I have the same experience, and I went to 11 different schools, including rich and poor ones.

And I also got into teaching between dev gigs.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by blitz_skull on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:17PM (#36702423)
Do factors matter?

Unless you can mass edit all the factors, then it remains that some people simply cannot do math past a certain level.

But for what it’s worth, it was a very small school in a VERY poor area. (Median income probably at or below $20k / year) The teaching was actually above-average for the area, but probably below average over a national rating.

I do think factors matter in my personal anecdote of my particular high school. However my LIFE has reinforced my observations: most people are profoundly bad at math, from a seemingly fundamental level.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by nborwankar on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:08PM (#36699072)
Very interesting tgat you mention bad math teachers. I agree. During my teaching assistant stint during graduate studies in applied and pure math, I had one student who was failing. Talking to her I learned that a math teacher in high school had made her feel very stupid - she stopped learning. This happens more often than is recognized especially to girls but not just to girls.

I told her to come to office hours and I gave her problem sets to solve, first easy then progressively harder. As she got confidence that she could do this her demeanor in class changed and in the space of a month she went from failing to a B-

After this I started asking anyone who said they had math anxiety or did not like math if they had a bad math teacher they remembered. I have asked close to a hundred people this over the last 30+ years and invariably they not only remembered the name of said bad math teacher but also relived how they were told they were dumb and would never be good at math. They stopped learning at that point.

Nonetheless math is hard because it is not an evolutionary survival skill we developed. I say jokingly that math is an unnatural act. I am not a gifted math student but I like solving problems and I would just solve every problem in the book ploddingly and stubbornly. So I dont hate math and I am not in love with it either. It is a very powerful tool for problem solving and also gives you powerful analytical capability you can use in other places in life.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by hirvi74 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:12PM (#36704260)
> I like solving problems and I would just solve every problem in the book ploddingly and stubbornly.

Maybe that is all it takes to be a "gifted" math student?

Tangental:

I have always hated the term gifted. I will not deny there are some absolute phenoms out there in regards to any domain. Those individuals are few and far between and should be celebrated because of it. Maybe I am being semantical, but being "slightly better" does not make one gifted.

Learning a subject that is being taught to someone quicker than their peers does not make them gifted. Show me what they have created or discovered with their alleged "gift," and then we will see.

Von Neumann is not remembered because of how much quicker he learned math than others or how easy the subjects were for him. He is remembered for what he discovered and what he created -- that is what makes one truly gifted in my opinion.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by trinovantes on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:19AM (#36693456)
Math as a field of study might be hard but in my experience math pre grad-school is just memorization as much as any other subject. I studied for my exams by simply doing countless exercises and memorizing every problem pattern to the point where I'm just plugging numbers into a series of formulas, even if I don't fully know why I'm doing so.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by foofoo4u on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:04AM (#36694725)
This is my experience as well. And unfortunately, many of my teachers feed into this. "Ok kids, today we're going to learn this new formula. You put a number in, do some arithmetic, and you get an answer out. I am not going to bother explaining the importance of this formula, how it came into existence, nor its practical application — likely because even I don't know. But what I do know is it's important because everyone says it is and it will be on the exam. Now get cracking." A parody of course, but I say captures the sentiment which completely drained my desire to learn math. I got good grades, but only after I learned to accept that it is futile to learn the importance of what I am learning and instead simply focus on rote memorization of solving the problem, even if I don't know why it works.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by Izkata on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:38PM (#36699642)
> Ok kids, today we're going to learn this new formula. You put a number in, do some arithmetic, and you get an answer out. I am not going to bother explaining the importance of this formula, how it came into existence

Short story time: I never could memorize various geometry equations, like surface area or volume of basic shapes. Then one day while bored at my part time job, I found a paper and pencil and decided to use what I'd just learned in calculus to see if I could derive one of those equations, by leaving variables in instead of using concrete numbers.

It totally worked, I reinvented the volume of a sphere equation and ever since that day I've never forgotten it because now every part of the equation has meaning. I know why it is the way it is, and it makes sense.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by foofoo4u on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:20PM (#36700277)
This gets to the heart of what math class needs. Which is a process of learning how to re-invent formulas, constants, and other concepts. Through this, students will come to appreciate why such things exist. And they will appreciate it further if students are first challenged to solve such problems in the absence of it.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:15AM (#36694884)
There is truth in this, but even then, to apply the formulas to many problems, you need to have seriously strong pattern recognition abilities, and the capacity and flexibility to adapt what you know to the given situation. Then piping the right thing into the other right things requires a deeper understanding, not always of what the thing very nature, but at least what it does, and what's it compatible with.

This means loading the entire problem space in your head.

And this is hard.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by projectazorian on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:47AM (#36695351)
Sounds like great preparation for Leetcode interviews ;)
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by kamaal on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:19AM (#36694939)
>>But math reasoning really filters out people in a way nothing else does.

Learning Math is just like learning a language, the issue is the script/alphabet/symbols used to communicate, its dictionary, its grammar are all complicated its hard for common people to get a grip on it.

Almost all people can follow logical sequence of arguments provided they understand the language in which they are described.

This language so far is the greatest barrier to bringing Math to public. Probably a new teaching method is needed.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:44AM (#36695307)
The language is the least relevant thing about learning mathematics. It is arbitrary and rooted in historical circumstance.

Saying math is about the language is like saying programming is about learning syntax. It is entirely irrelevant, the meaning is what is important.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by kamaal on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:57AM (#36696540)
>>programming is about learning syntax.

It indeed is, how do you communicate meaning without words/symbols?

Make an attempt to reply to this very comment by any means apart from using words/symbols.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:55AM (#36695479)
> Almost all people can follow logical sequence of arguments provided they understand the language in which they are described.

No.

I know people that have been explained repeatedly with absolute patience and love that correlation was not causality, with simple examples. They agree on the moment, but wait a week and they still mix it up again and again.

That's one of the smallest and easiest logical concept to grasp, and they never integrate it.

Practically, in day to day life, mixing correlation and causality served them very well. It's actually often true. But as soon as it's on the news or a graph on the internet, it's over. Because it's abstract.

And the persons are not dumb either: they are very competent in other fields.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by kamaal on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:00PM (#36696606)
>>I know people that have been explained repeatedly with absolute patience and love that correlation was not causality, with simple examples. They agree on the moment, but wait a week and they still mix it up again and again.

You just proved to them correlation doesn't imply causation in some cases, but no amount of examples will be sufficient enough to prove that is the case in all the cases. This is exactly my point.

If they have seen cases where a cause was strong correlated with some data, so as far as they are concerned, at least in that case they were logically able to conclude there was some connection.

To prove your point, you have to in some way prove a total disconnect between the two(correlation and causation), until then you really haven't proven anything substantial to them. Note you will need some mathematical formulation to do it(Symbol manipulation), which is basically learning a new language from grounds up. It could be impossible. Hence my point.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by lolinder on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:33AM (#36695134)
There's a major chicken and egg problem here—is math hard and therefore it has to justify itself, or is it hard because people don't think it's relevant and so they care less to try?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:46AM (#36695342)
Why would something being hard mean it has to justify itself?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by lolinder on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:49AM (#36695388)
Because why put in the effort if it isn't going to bring any benefit? An easy subject can be swallowed even if you don't see the purpose because it doesn't cost you much.

That said, I lean towards the other option: it's considered a waste of time, so no one puts in the effort, so it seems harder than it really should be.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by zer8k on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:42AM (#36696249)
I can second that. I was an pretty good programmer as a kid. I'd go home and write whatever I could imagine on the old 286 box my parents had. I spent time in "gifted" programs at school, etc.

However, I hated math. HATED it. Did so poorly in it through high school I ended up in college in basic algebra. It wasn't until college I found out I loved math and it was only because I got lucky and had a string of amazing professors.

I suspect this is true for other subjects as well. I also hated exercise until I discovered what I liked doing. PE teachers ruined it for me. Runs were terrible because there was no cadence. Push ups were terrible because no one checked form. The entire exercise of pre-college education is a box checking effort to get you ready for the factory. Perhaps we simply need to stop having the unmotivated teach the motivated. This goes true for research professors forced to teach as well.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by Dwelve on Thursday July 13, 2023 @05:54AM (#36706897)
Can you elaborate how you and your brother compare in sports?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by rnkn on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:24AM (#36692932)
Hello mathematics, meet philosophy.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by paulcole on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @07:27AM (#36692957)
> The question is never asked about any other school subject

Are you kidding? Every tech-bro on the planet makes their disdain for literature, philosophy, etc. extremely well known.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:13AM (#36694861)
It's hard to make out your actual point given it's couched in stereotype.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by paulcole on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:48PM (#36698701)
I don't think it's that hard.

But if it is, then my point is that people absolutely do make the same complaint about any subject they don't like being told to learn.

Tech bros (generally) don't like being told to learn about art. And non-tech bros (generally) don't like being told to learn math.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by arolihas on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:55PM (#36704166)
It can be hard to understand something when someone is more interested in being offended.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:56AM (#36705856)
Another stereotype. I'm not offended by people substituting lazy stereotypes for thinking. I just think it comes out badly when they try and articulate points.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by paulcole on Thursday July 13, 2023 @07:51AM (#36707771)
Did you really not understand my original point?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:34PM (#36712940)
Not really, no. It just seemed to be a continuation of a made up category, and I don't understand the point of doing that.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by arolihas on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:44AM (#36709014)
What stereotype do you think I am referencing? Their point was so simple I am honestly baffled at how anyone could possibly be confused or genuinely find it inarticulate.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:20PM (#36712733)
The stereotype that if someone disagrees it must be because they're offended.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by arolihas on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:14PM (#36713689)
That's not what a stereotype is. And I didn't even make the claim that everyone who disagrees with me is offended.

I just said it can be hard to understand something if you are offended by it. In this case it seemed likely, because the obvious point was that different people have different preferences towards subjects and look down on others. For example, some people in tech have a disdain for literature or other "soft" subjects like the humanities.

When you complain about the stereotype and state that it obscures this point suggests that one could be offended by it and it is clouding their judgement. The fact that the OP simplified their point and you still refuse to understand it because it's a "made-up category" supports this notion.

But hey, maybe you aren't offended by the term "techbro". It's perfectly possible that you lack reading comprehension skills. It's also possible that you are being deliberately obtuse and disingenuous

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Friday July 14, 2023 @04:08AM (#36720794)
> And I didn't even make the claim that everyone who disagrees with me is offended

When you say:

> when someone is more interested in being offended

Because I disagree, that is the stereotype I'm talking about. You weren't making an abstract point; you were stereotyping me based on nothing other than my questioning of paulcole's point.

Technically it's true that you never claimed that everyone who disagrees with you is offended, but that's you getting confused: you were commenting on something I said to disagree with someone who isn't you.

> The fact that the OP simplified their point and you still refuse to understand it because it's a "made-up category" supports this notion.

Please quote where the OP simplified their point and I replied?

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by arolihas on Friday July 14, 2023 @08:56AM (#36723291)
They simplified here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36674076#36712940

You didn't reply directly to that but you responded here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36674076#36712940

Maybe you disagree with this stereotype, but you didn't counter it. You just said it's too hard to understand. It can be hard to understand things when your emotions are clouding your judgement, but that is just one possibility. I listed a couple other possibilities in my previous comment. I guess you can call it a stereotype, I would call it an inference. You just seem butthurt about a fairly innocuous term, because clearly you have the reasoning skills to understand what is being said. Feigning ignorance is not a good look. Best of luck to you!

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Friday July 14, 2023 @09:24AM (#36723659)
You pasted the same link twice, so I don't know what you mean. However I can guess that you've realised I didn't respond badly to a clarification, but don't want to retract what you said.

You keep guessing emotional reasons: "butthurt", "emotions clouding judgment", "being offended".

If this is the way you view the world, and how you perceive motivations that's fine, but please don't pretend that this constant insinuation is reasonable or anything but lazy, or in any way useful to any discussion.

It's purely subtractive, and the discussion would've been better (other than any benefit you got out of talking to someone this way) if you hadn't made these comments.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by arolihas on Friday July 14, 2023 @12:44PM (#36726433)
That's a poor guess mate, since the link I posted twice was your own response. I have nothing to retract. I guessed other reasons too in previous comments, like maybe you are being disingenuous.

The other one comment I meant to paste there was the simplified point he made. You couldn't figure out this is the one I meant to share? He only made two comments, I find it hard to believe you couldn't figure out what I was referencing, seems like you are just being disingenuous again. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36674076#36698701

If you want to add something to the conversation, maybe you can explain why the stereotype is completely ungrounded in reality. You would have a tough time doing so, since in other comments you're talking to people who are downplaying the utility of learning ancient history and literature.

You claiming you don't understand the point paulcole is making at all is ludicrous. None of your comments have added anything at all of value, whether you had an emotional motive behind them or not. You saying a stereotype is hard to understand is just undermining yourself.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by projectazorian on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:51AM (#36695414)
Now now, let’s not be unfair, a bit of room is permitted for surface level study of classical philosophy, maybe some Nietzsche.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by roel_v on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:00AM (#36693292)
"The question is never asked about any other school subject"

Huh? People around me asked that all the time in high school & beyond.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by alpaca128 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:05AM (#36693322)
> I see no reason why it should have to justify itself in any way

If you cannot justify to children why you force them to sit in school for hours every day you shouldn't be surprised by the consequences. Though weirdly schools tend to be very surprised in my experience. And yes, this question is absolutely asked in other subjects too, but less often as they're not as abstract and usually related to things people encounter every day.

> Justifying mathematics is easy

And thus left as exercise to the reader?

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:12AM (#36693390)
>If you cannot justify to children why you force them to sit in school for hours every day you shouldn't be surprised by the consequences.

Nobody told me why I should learn about ancient history or 20th century literature.

>usually related to things people encounter every day.

Basically nothing I did in school had anything at all to do with things I encountered every day. I played video games and hung out with friends. I didn't study European art history in my time away from school.

>And thus left as exercise to the reader?

Yes. I assumed that most people on this website understand the inherent value in abstract thiking and broadly applicable problem solving techniques.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by mtVessel on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:25AM (#36693533)
Oh, you mean the kind of abstract thinking and problem solving skills you develop from reading history and literature and applying them to the events of the day? Yeah, I totally understood that. Still not sure where Calculus fits in, though.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:34AM (#36693632)
>Yeah, I totally understood that. Still not sure where Calculus fits in, though.

If I need to tell you how one of the most important theories in mathematics, with broad applicability to all data-based academic fields and all careers which have to do with manipulating and investigating data, is important, then the entire school system has failed you. And I am not sure what you are doing on a site like this.

>Oh, you mean the kind of abstract thinking and problem solving skills you develop from reading history and literature and applying them to the events of the day?

lol

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by LunaSea on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:22AM (#36693504)
> Yes. I assumed that most people on this website understand the inherent value in abstract thiking and broadly applicable problem solving techniques.

This absolutely doesn't match what is thought in elementary and secondary schools.

You are thought how to apply things and not how to think (in an abstract way or not).

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:29AM (#36693574)
Yes, math education is generally bad.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by jodrellblank on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:44AM (#36693738)
> "Nobody told me why I should learn about ancient history or 20th century literature."

Did you ever ask?

I assume not, since you claim nobody ever asks that question about ancient history - so why would anyone have told you? If you did ask, doesn't that rather undermine your claim that nobody ever asks this question about other subjects and people only ask it about mathematics?

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:53AM (#36693827)
>Did you ever ask?

No. But I also didn't question its value.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:09AM (#36694798)
Why not?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by constantcrying on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:41AM (#36695264)
Because: "I also didn't question its value. "
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @11:14AM (#36695776)
You didn't question its value because you didn't question its value?
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by acheong08 on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:16AM (#36693424)
I think it’s useful to justify math at a young age. I fell into the “math doesn’t matter” group and regret it since stepping into software engineering
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by EliRivers on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:19AM (#36693462)
And thus left as exercise to the reader?

Zing! I feel you'd want to know some of your readers get it :)

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by nicbou on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:10AM (#36693369)
This drove me nuts when I was a student. No one gave me a solid reason, even though it was right there.

Math is a language that is required to describe how the world works. It's the official language of certain spheres of society that seriously impact your life. If you don't speak it, other people will make decisions for you that you can't understand.

It's also really useful if you deal with finance, engineering, computers, statistics etc. If you don't speak math, these doors are closed to you.

This would be a lot more evident if they had us solve real world problems with math.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by foofoo4u on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:12AM (#36694840)
Same. For K-12, at least, I believe the reason why no one could give a solid reason is because the teachers who are teaching the subject have literally no professional industrial experience with math. They have nothing to share with no real-world insights. I presume this should come to no surprise. According to GTP, the average salary range of a mathematician in the US is, "$80,000 to $100,000, while more experienced mathematicians can earn up to $150,000 or more." With salaries like these, no one working professionally as a mathematician would choose to downgrade to become a teacher, with teacher pay, lower respect and deal with uninterested, rude, problematic students.
Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by maccard on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @08:23AM (#36693514)
> The question is never asked about any other school subject and only mathematics has to justify itself that way

Hard disagree here. When I was in school, there were constant discussions among the teenagers about "why do I need to learn a dead language (irish)", "why do I need to learn french/german, they can all speak english", "why do I need to study geography, I'm never going to need to be able to categorise volcanic vs fold mountains".

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by yodsanklai on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:00AM (#36693910)
> somehow mathematics is the one field which needs to justify its own existence

I'm convinced that justification doesn't make students more motivated anyway.

That being said, justification is needed, not for the students, but for people designing syllabus. They require arbitrage because there are so many hours in a day.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by _rm on Thursday July 13, 2023 @02:20AM (#36705611)
Teachers of calculus should have to justify why people should learn it, given 99% of them will never use it, and could be taught something else challenging that they will use instead.

But the same does also apply, and get called out just as often, regarding the humanities, especially given 99% of people can fulfil their humanities interests for free and at their leisure and on their phone with Wikipedia.

Re:Proof You Can Do Hard Things by ed-209 on Thursday July 13, 2023 @09:30AM (#36708816)
The author is trying to motivate kids, not make a case for the existence of math generally.