News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by synergy20 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @08:57AM (#36643942)
So generous!

The FAANG etc failed me for anything open source sponsorship related.

Their business depends on it, they made a fortune out of it, yet they donate little or nothing to it, or worse, they forked it and was reluctant to upstream anything.

pick Amazon randomly, it went from exploiting to rip-off in my opinion, thanks to its boss , who sails on a luxury yacht and asks all his employees to be frugal. they all look similar to me as far as supporting OSS goes.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by acedTrex on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:19AM (#36644115)
In terms of companies that rip off open source and do not give back meta is certainly one of the more active "give back" companies. React/Native, docusaurus, buck, pytorch, rocksdb...
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by synergy20 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:31AM (#36644226)
yes some big companies did open source projects and Meta is a good role model, for many those OSS projects, they work for the companies themselves first then the community, though they are indeed still 1 million times better than closed and proprietary code. I'm mainly referring to long standing fundamental projects that made the rest projects possible, not those projects that are created and managed by the big companies themselves.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ushakov on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:44AM (#36644331)
Why is Meta obligated to give anything back to these projects?

It was their authors choice first and foremost to publish them as OSS

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by smoldesu on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:00AM (#36644478)
Traditionally speaking, it's because they're the most qualified to do it. Every FAANG company takes from Open Source in order to succeed, so contributing back to a FOSS codebase is the ultimate act of corporate goodwill. You are burning real-life money and engineering hours to fixing a problem for everyone and ensuring that it stays protected under the same Open license that let your company succeed.

There is no legal obligation per-se. Open Source is a charity, but you can understand a lot about a companies motives if you compare their FOSS usage to their FOSS contributions.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by jorvi on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:42AM (#36644883)
I think this misses the point. FAANGs don’t improve OSS code out of goodwill, they do it because it benefits them. Upstreaming those improvements has very little marginal cost, and it bolsters an environment where other companies do the same. Rising tide and all that.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by sroussey on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:43AM (#36645468)
That is the whole point of GPL — to incentivize contributors for the common good.

Goodwill might work for individual contributors, but it’s not enough of an incentive for organizations.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by NegativeK on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:42PM (#36646107)
> it’s not enough of an incentive for organizations.

It _should_ be. There's nothing stopping organizations from doing good things except expectation.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by sroussey on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:41PM (#36714904)
I disagree. It would be nice, sure. I would say that anything based in government funding _should_.

There are real costs and that has real consequences. Expectation is way down on the list.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ianai on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:46AM (#36644921)
It’s not a charity if it becomes or serves as part of a standard. Sort of how semis and the various suppliers/buyers of that industry wind up agreeing on standards despite being competitors in some cases. Definitely things like the Linux kernel make sense to give back to - you’re ensuring the kernel lines up with your own corporate investments in a sense. A company unilaterally needing to fork and maintain their own Linux compatible kernel would need to sink a lot of time and money to come up with something as developed as the modern kernel. And it would become more expensive, unwieldy, and akin to technical debt over time.

It’s clearly not perfect calculus since so many defect from OSS, but there’s also clearly some business sense there.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by smoldesu on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:42PM (#36646115)
> It’s not a charity if it becomes or serves as part of a standard.

Then it just transitions to a charity that everyone relies on. It's been embarrassingly difficult for people to admit this vis-a-vis Linux and the like, but it's obvious in a situation like programming languages. We rely on the enduring charity of it's authors, license-holders and distributors to write and distribute software.

"Giving back" is not an inherently cynical process. Meta has no obligation to publish these patches in the first place, much less work as a part of the community to solve a common issue. But they do, and it's just kinda part of their culture at this point. Yes, they do still gain from it; but so do their direct competitors. It's difficult to characterize as a purely business-motivated decision, because there are much greedier avenues to pursue if that's their MO.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by mlyle on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#36645502)
Good etiquette (social obligations & kindness) and license requirements (legal obligations) are different.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by curt15 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:43AM (#36644324)
btrfs
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by Geezus_42 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:10AM (#36645135)
How long have they been working on a stable RAID 5/6 implementation?
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by 5e92cb50239222b on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:35AM (#36645390)
Why would they? Nobody except a few home users needs RAID 5/6. There's only a small handful of talented filesystem developers (never mind the filesystem, it's equally applicable to all of them), and there's always something to do which will benefit all of us. Especially for something so feature-packed and complicated.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by pgwhalen on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:03AM (#36645067)
"Giving back" might be an understatement for Meta's open source contributions. They are the bedrock of so much OSS in the last decade, it's everyone _else_ that is "giving back."
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by londons_explore on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:29AM (#36644209)
> yet they donate little or nothing to it,

It is all about knowing individual engineers inside these companies. Nearly any engineer in FAANG can, with a little effort, donate their own work time to an opensource project in the form of submitting patches.

The project can help in various ways. Make sure licensing stuff is in place so that whatever IP review process the company has goes smoothly. Make sure PR's are reviewed fast. Delegate responsibility ('hi, would you like to be maintainer of this feature?'). Make sure contributions are publicly recognised (ie. Public page of maintainers/biggest contributors).

Remember that most engineers inside big companies are trying to generate good content for their performance review. "Wrote and open source some code" is usually one of the checkboxes.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:01AM (#36644499)
> Nearly any engineer in FAANG can, with a little effort, donate their own work time to an opensource project in the form of submitting patches.

I know at least one of those letters that does not want you doing that without jumping through hoops and getting prior approvals. I will let you guess which one that is.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by londons_explore on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#36645016)
Thats the "with a little effort" bit. But as long as you have a business case (eg. "we are adding this feature for our use, but it will lower our costs if it is upstreamed rather than maintained as a private patch"), it will usually be greenlighted.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by atomlib on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:45AM (#36644912)
Typically FAANGs have a clause that they own everything that you code even outside of working hours.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by fmajid on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:50AM (#36644959)
No, Meta’s contract has explicit carve-outs for Open-Source work done on personal time that are more generous than Canonical’s (I had to choose between the two 3 months ago).

Meta has its own production fork of CPython, Cinder:

https://github.com/facebookincubator/cinder

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by dehrmann on Saturday July 08, 2023 @03:05PM (#36647655)
This isn't legal/enforceable in California. Your own work on your own time on your own equipment is your own property. It's messier if you're building a direct competitor or using proprietary knowledge.

There's a whole Silicon Valley episode on this.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by 8n4vidtmkvmk on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#36644989)
Writing open source code is not one of my FAANG check boxes. Could maybe do it as 20% with lawyer approval.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ushakov on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:40AM (#36644295)
Are the companies at fault for not paying for something that is sold for free?
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by nradov on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:04AM (#36643997)
Meta contributes a huge amount to the open source community.

https://opensource.fb.com/

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by stevefan1999 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:33AM (#36644235)
React alone is one of the biggest feast Meta brought to open source community, and shaped the web from monolithic pages (back then PHP and jQuery is the majority) towards modular components design. Later they even introduced functional programming paradigm in the mix.

Next.js exists too which mashed up PHP/Ruby style with React.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by YetAnotherNick on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:46AM (#36644345)
It's easy to blame the boss, but I don't think its the companies responsibility to give back to open source just because they use it. If you think open source is helping you, you could contribute it in your time without expectation to get paid for it. Most open source projects work like this. And if some company needs some extra feature, they should pay market rate for it.

Assuming the company doesn't have clause to not allow contributing to open source. These companies should be publicly shamed if they use any open source code.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by mickael-kerjean on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:12AM (#36644600)
From the many people who asks for things, only a tinny percentage are actually willing to pay for it. Take Microsoft, I had one of their employee asking me to support their azure stuff: https://github.com/mickael-kerjean/filestash/issues/180. When I found out the dude was actually employed by Microsoft, I somehow though he could give a hand, but no he was just there to make some feature request ...
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ActorNightly on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:30AM (#36644771)
If you are going to attempt to make bombastic criticisms, at least get your facts right. Amazons boss certainly does not sail on a yacht.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by kemayo on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:41AM (#36644864)
They're referring to Bezos' yacht: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/19/style/bezos-yacht-koru.ht...

One can argue to what extent Bezos is still ultimately "the boss" at Amazon given that he's not the CEO any more, but...

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by synergy20 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:40AM (#36644862)
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/19/style/bezos-yacht-koru.ht..., this is indeed delayed thanks to COVID, it is his own yacht and I am pretty sure he sailed on yachts before building himself one.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ActorNightly on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @03:02PM (#36700026)
Yeah that fine and all, but the person in the article is not the CEO of Amazon.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by vitus on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:44AM (#36644903)
Between pytorch (Meta) and TensorFlow (Alphabet), I'd be surprised if there's much if any ML work today that doesn't rely on OSS projects from FAANG companies.

Chromium underpins nearly every major browser that isn't Safari or Firefox. And even more narrowly, V8 powers Node (and Deno).

More Google contributions: Angular, Kubernetes, gRPC, Golang.

Microsoft: C#, TypeScript, Language Server Protocol, VSCode.

Meta: React, zstd, Apache Cassandra, LLAMA.

This isn't even getting into open source patches (Google has consistently been one of the top 10 Linux kernel contributors for the last decade), systems papers that have inspired research and other systems (BigTable, Dynamo, MapReduce, Colossus, Spanner), standards work (HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 were both adapted from Google technology), security vulnerability work (Project Zero).

(The above list is definitely Google-skewed because that's what I know.)

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by pjmlp on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:34AM (#36645385)
Even stuff like UNIX, C, C++, to extend your example.

People apparently forget the amount of money that was and is injected into them.

Someone has to put the money on the table to attend ISO meetings, buy the standards, implement the features into existing C and C++ compilers, for example.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by bee_rider on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:21AM (#36645259)
Some of these are great examples.

Chrome, though, is a kind of mixed bag. It already has too many features, most likely the reason it underpins so many other browsers is that nobody can keep up with the rate at which Google shovels shit into there.

They should slow down. It would be nice if they could just spend a couple years working purely on stability/performance/security, but alternatively they could just stop, it would be better for the ecosystem.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by krlacn on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:33AM (#36645367)
A lot of these (but not all) strike me a flashy things for which you get promoted. Many people don't need any of these.

What FAANG does not do is support critical yet underappreciated Unix infrastructure. By this I mean directly donating to developers without trying to take over the projects.

The quality of FAANG code, especially in the fault-tolerant machine learning space, is questionable as well. I'm not sure why so many commenters (in other comments!) attribute near magical qualities to any output of FAANG.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by charcircuit on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:44AM (#36645477)
>By this I mean directly donating to developers without trying to take over the projects.

FAANG are not charities. If they are sold a license for the software for $0, then they don't have much of reason to pay for it.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by synergy20 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:57AM (#36645581)
Talking about fundamental OSS projects that is not for-profit at all.

Many of Google's OSS projects are there to help its profits, if not, Google could stop or kill it at will which is fine and is 1 millions times better than closed code, still not the same as projects like python etc.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by paulddraper on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:56PM (#36650749)
Well of course they are there to help with profits.

Do you think they are irrational?

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by tayo42 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:22PM (#36645874)
yeah i feel like there are tons of reasons to criticize these big companies, but open source, theyre pretty good for the most part. not sure what else you could expect from them.

there is graphql, rocksdb and folly. they also open sourced their js engine for react native too.

maybe a good criticism is we depend to much on these companies free stuff lol

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by weinzierl on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:49AM (#36644950)
This is disappointing but certainly not surprising and to some part we as an open source community have to blame our selves.

I know it is not a popular opinion but the AGPL is there for a reason. If you release your code under a permissive license you should not be surprised that others benefit from it - sometimes massively. That is how it is supposed to be. You can still lament that it is unjust and I feel you, because in a sense it is. If it really bothers you, the solution is easy. Next time choose the AGPL.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by catlifeonmars on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:27PM (#36645919)
AGPL is kind of a sledgehammer.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by dehrmann on Saturday July 08, 2023 @03:09PM (#36647693)
I've released open-source projects under an Apache license because I want others to benefit from my work. I knowingly didn't choose GPL-flavored licenses because they limit people's ability to do this.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by mliker on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:00AM (#36645030)
React, PyTorch, Tensorflow, and many others, all from FAANG. Benefits the ecosystem and their businesses. Not a bad trade.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by patrec on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:12AM (#36645154)
What did Amazon rip off from you?
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by kasitmp on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:18AM (#36645227)
An interesting example of a big company profiting from open source: Microsoft, going from fighting open source to copilot.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by kylevedder on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:19AM (#36645244)
It's stupid sour grapes comments like this that make me hate HN commenters.

Meta and Google have both contributed an enormous amount to open source (creating PyTorch, TensorFlow, Chromium, contributing to clang/LLVM, Linux kernel, HTTP standards), but you're mad because they didn't sponsor your work and a bunch of people mindlessly upvoted it.