News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by acedTrex on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:19AM (#36644115)
In terms of companies that rip off open source and do not give back meta is certainly one of the more active "give back" companies. React/Native, docusaurus, buck, pytorch, rocksdb...
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by synergy20 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:31AM (#36644226)
yes some big companies did open source projects and Meta is a good role model, for many those OSS projects, they work for the companies themselves first then the community, though they are indeed still 1 million times better than closed and proprietary code. I'm mainly referring to long standing fundamental projects that made the rest projects possible, not those projects that are created and managed by the big companies themselves.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ushakov on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:44AM (#36644331)
Why is Meta obligated to give anything back to these projects?

It was their authors choice first and foremost to publish them as OSS

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by smoldesu on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:00AM (#36644478)
Traditionally speaking, it's because they're the most qualified to do it. Every FAANG company takes from Open Source in order to succeed, so contributing back to a FOSS codebase is the ultimate act of corporate goodwill. You are burning real-life money and engineering hours to fixing a problem for everyone and ensuring that it stays protected under the same Open license that let your company succeed.

There is no legal obligation per-se. Open Source is a charity, but you can understand a lot about a companies motives if you compare their FOSS usage to their FOSS contributions.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by jorvi on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:42AM (#36644883)
I think this misses the point. FAANGs don’t improve OSS code out of goodwill, they do it because it benefits them. Upstreaming those improvements has very little marginal cost, and it bolsters an environment where other companies do the same. Rising tide and all that.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by sroussey on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:43AM (#36645468)
That is the whole point of GPL — to incentivize contributors for the common good.

Goodwill might work for individual contributors, but it’s not enough of an incentive for organizations.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by NegativeK on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:42PM (#36646107)
> it’s not enough of an incentive for organizations.

It _should_ be. There's nothing stopping organizations from doing good things except expectation.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by sroussey on Thursday July 13, 2023 @03:41PM (#36714904)
I disagree. It would be nice, sure. I would say that anything based in government funding _should_.

There are real costs and that has real consequences. Expectation is way down on the list.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by ianai on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:46AM (#36644921)
It’s not a charity if it becomes or serves as part of a standard. Sort of how semis and the various suppliers/buyers of that industry wind up agreeing on standards despite being competitors in some cases. Definitely things like the Linux kernel make sense to give back to - you’re ensuring the kernel lines up with your own corporate investments in a sense. A company unilaterally needing to fork and maintain their own Linux compatible kernel would need to sink a lot of time and money to come up with something as developed as the modern kernel. And it would become more expensive, unwieldy, and akin to technical debt over time.

It’s clearly not perfect calculus since so many defect from OSS, but there’s also clearly some business sense there.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by smoldesu on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:42PM (#36646115)
> It’s not a charity if it becomes or serves as part of a standard.

Then it just transitions to a charity that everyone relies on. It's been embarrassingly difficult for people to admit this vis-a-vis Linux and the like, but it's obvious in a situation like programming languages. We rely on the enduring charity of it's authors, license-holders and distributors to write and distribute software.

"Giving back" is not an inherently cynical process. Meta has no obligation to publish these patches in the first place, much less work as a part of the community to solve a common issue. But they do, and it's just kinda part of their culture at this point. Yes, they do still gain from it; but so do their direct competitors. It's difficult to characterize as a purely business-motivated decision, because there are much greedier avenues to pursue if that's their MO.

Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by mlyle on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#36645502)
Good etiquette (social obligations & kindness) and license requirements (legal obligations) are different.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by curt15 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @09:43AM (#36644324)
btrfs
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by Geezus_42 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:10AM (#36645135)
How long have they been working on a stable RAID 5/6 implementation?
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by 5e92cb50239222b on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:35AM (#36645390)
Why would they? Nobody except a few home users needs RAID 5/6. There's only a small handful of talented filesystem developers (never mind the filesystem, it's equally applicable to all of them), and there's always something to do which will benefit all of us. Especially for something so feature-packed and complicated.
Re:Meta pledges Three-Year sponsorship for Python if GIL rem... by pgwhalen on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:03AM (#36645067)
"Giving back" might be an understatement for Meta's open source contributions. They are the bedrock of so much OSS in the last decade, it's everyone _else_ that is "giving back."