Ok, that does not sound reassuring. What does that mean for my account if the server I am on disappears? Can I still login? Will my posts disappear? (probably not, but join-lemmy.org doesn‘t say if I am not mistaken)
My email provider has some way to make money. There is a good chance that it is around in 10 years. What about these servers? Who is running them and why should a single one still be around in 10 years?
If the choice of a server really is not important, why doesn’t join-lemmy.org have a "join random server" button.
Maybe these are non-issues. As a casually interested person I genuinely don’t know.
IME the reason they don't have a "join random" button is that would be bad for smaller instances and a "join largest and most popular instance" would be criticized for showing favoritism and discourage adopting the entire point of decentralized technology. Matrix gets this criticism all the time because they push a default sever in their defacto standard app Element.
As a casually interested user? Just Google what to do because more users will trust the latest tweet or reddit thread more than a FAQ page. You most likely created an email account without going to "email.acme.org" and asking what provider to pick and probably have gone though a few providers without much loss.
https://infosec.pub/pictrs/image/c34aab77-9c37-4264-b821-750...
And a beginners guide
There are literally thousands of sites that let you login with your google account.
Why would I deliberately tie multiple logins to one credential, which may or may not go out of my control for any or no reason whatsoever? I'm not even talking about Google specifically here, I'm talking in general terms.
The more I hear about the federated multiverse, the more I see it as just another centralization abstraction layer on the decentralized network that is the internet.
If we want decentralization, why can't we just use the internet like ye olde days?
I get the convenience and also the security benefits, but there‘s a whole lot of risk, too.
> If we want decentralization, why can't we just use the internet like ye olde days?
I'm not sure how you come to this conclusion. The internet is indeed already decentralized, yet connected, allowing you to traverse networks to reach resources that are more often than not outside your 'home' network.
Federated social media is exactly that, but for posting and interacting with content. Its killer feature is that you don't have to create an account everywhere, but are able to interact from your home instance with any other instance in the network. Exactly like the internet.
If we'd go back to ye olde days, it would be like pre-internet from a network perspective. Having to log in physically on a specific network to access its resources. Or when talking about the internet until ~2008 (and to some extent still true): creating a separate account for every forum you'd want to participate in.
I fail to see how "but everybody is doing it" is a valid argument.
This is also a problem with mastodon. As well as the fact that instances constantly shut down or have insane admins.
Lemmy is probably taking on too large of a problem. No one has got federated systems to work as nicely as centralised ones yet.
They never will. Federated systems have certain advantages over centralised ones. One of the principal advantages is that it allows hosting costs to be shared more widely, which means you don't need a single entity with hundreds of thousands of dollars to maintain the thing. Another is that toxic communities can be more easily isolated from the rest (so that the communities you like don't become quickly overwhelmed by racists).
One of the disadvantages is that there is more friction than a single, centralised system. It is, by definition, not as seamless. The seams are the feature. It's just the trade-off you make.
It's not perfectly seamless, because I wanted to minimize the risk that it will redirect some non-lemmy site with matching URL structure/elements. However, I've tried to make it as seamless as possible.
... From a technical perspective. But most people don't care about that. It's a social network, and they want to use it as one. They already have the experience of reddit, where there's thousands of seamless communities and one account gives you access to all of them. Lemmy feels like a big step back for anyone who doesn't care about the technical details. Which is basically everyone.
I expect that Lemmy will grow and some of the frictions (bugs, unclear accounts, insane instance sysadmins, moderation tools at the community/magazine/subreddit level, moderation tools at the instance/server level, etc.) will decrease in time. The two biggest threats are 1) too many consuming-only users and 2) big-tech (im looking at you Facebook) deciding that they need to directly compete.
I would honestly say: "Fuck them"
The Web was a better place before it was too easy to use and the unwashed masses entered. If they don't want to learn... let them stay in their walled garden.
So no, it's not just "unwashed masses", it's people who value their time too much to spend it on some social media technical issues.
I'm not competent with tech (I'm not a developer, just a lurker on HN) and I find Mastodon as easy as email if you understand email.
What are these tech people competent about? Do they understand email, at least conceptually?
The problem is the apps people like to use are no longer available, and Reddit doesn't permit them to just accept user API keys instead
The comments suggest the API pricing was just a stunt to hide the fact that Reddit wanted to kill third party apps in general, and in particular the ability of third parties to use Reddit posts to train AI models.
That's not an option. Even if it was, reddit's tone death measures, such as undeleting accounts and threatening everyone and kicking out mods who protested, already killed the community and makes the decision of continuing to use Reddit as a questionable moral decision.
People seek a reddit alternative, and rewarding reddit for its bullshit stunts is not it.
But it isn't. People aren't looking for an alternative to email.
When's the last time you heard of Fastmail saying that they were now blocking all emails from Zoho because they didn't like the way a single Zoho user was using Zoho?
Yet this is the sort of thing we see in the Fediverse when one admin takes issue with another admins attitude.
I get defederating from known bad actors, but these days it's not uncommon to lose access to an instance because admin don't like other admin policies (ergo some defederation over "The_Donald")
As far as which instance to join, well, that’s kinda like email, too. Look at the instances that are out there (the email providers in this example, like Gmail vs Mailfence), see if you like their policies and moderation and community “vibe,” and join the one that suits you.
https://beehaw.org is a big one that I like very much. Not really any memes there, the user base tends more toward the mature and considerate, and overall the level of interaction feels much better than Reddit ever did, post Digg exodus.