It still astonishes me how deluded he was by his own reality distortion field. He continued to incriminate himself repeatedly after it was clear to everybody else that he needed to stop digging the hole he was in.
Just breathtaking levels of PR and legal naivete.
This idea of "IQ is meaningless, he's good at X doesn't mean is good at Y" is what dumb people tell themselves.
no surer sign that a defensive middlebrow poser is about to hold forth.
edit to add: I think most interesting systems are more complex than what a person can understand immediately.
He got into MIT where he excelled and then a job at Jane Street. Even really smart people get rejected from MIT and Jane Street. he may be a fool and delusional but he's not thick .
As for Jane Street, it is a hard place to get into, but MIT is one of the few places where there's an established interview pipeline, which definitely makes it possible for a non-genius to have some a chance of passing. Before Cracking the Coding Interview, it was much harder to learn how FAANG interviews worked ahead of time - same thing applies.
Saying that SBF is "average", if that means 100 IQ, is ludicrous, but SBF is merely very bright, not a genius.
A first semester law/finance student from a bottom tier university would know to shut your mouth and not document your crimes..
Running his mouth is his way of living in a reality where he still has a measure of control over things.
This is more on the spectrum of delusion and delusion has nothing to do with intelligence. Very intelligent people can be highly delusional.
Oh, they got Epstein too AND his girlfriend. Well, the guy did organize sex parties on a private island with underage girls, coke, and prostitution, and had elites, politicians, academics, even some royalty and a president or two as frequent guests, but who's counting? Why even drag them to testify?
And, of course, since justice prevails you can't and shouldn't point at anyone who got through it and only got a slap on the wrist for some minor stuff, or was summarily found innocent, or had the charges thrown, or was never even charged with anything! What could they be other than innocent?
Since that's the case, who would want to anger people with good PR, great legal advice, and friends in power, by making such baseless accusations? In a public forum of all places!
For the delusion to continue beyond Ground Zero was a given, a fait accompli of self-confirmation bias.
Mens Rea
Would it be more accurate to say that the Bahamas agreed to extradite SBF? If not, then it doesn't make sense why the Bahamas would need to complain about the additional charges instead of SBF if they weren't involved in the agreement.
Although FWIW SBF is the last person who should be complaining about having the rug pulled from under them.
He agreed to be extradited voluntarily.
https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/19/business/sbf-extradition-baha...
No wonder people don't trust the law/lawyers.
"An extradition treaty between the United States and the Bahamas, where FTX was based, says a country must consent before defendants can be tried on charges brought after their extradition.
Prosecutors said they asked the Bahamas to agree to those charges, which include conspiracy to bribe Chinese officials and commit bank fraud, but did not know when the Caribbean country would grant its consent." via https://www.reuters.com/legal/bankman-fried-loses-bid-toss-c...
If he had contested the extradition, then he'd be at the Bahamas' judgment for the original charges and the new charges. He decided to come back for the original charges and now the Bahamas decides whether they will allow the US to bring the new charges - basically whether they would have extradited him for those new charges.
If they would have extradited him for the new charges as well, then it doesn't matter. If they wouldn't have extradited him for those charges, the prosecution can't bring those charges. There's no legal gotcha. The legal gotcha would be if he returned and then the Bahamas couldn't consent to them bringing additional charges.
In this case, it's a statement from the US to the Bahamas about what they intend to do to SBF once he's in custody. If the US then goes on and punishes SBF even harder than what they originally told the Bahamas, the Bahamas might feel lied to. Think of it as a "we wouldn't have extradited if we knew he was facing the death penalty" kind of scenario. This rule thus exists to give the Bahamas a chance to remedy that.
Also, I BET YOU that behind the scenes the us is telling the Bahamas "you better not complain about this or else we'll get you on that other thing". Because.... you think US prosecutors would leave this possibility to chance? Why would the Bahamas not complain?
That's right, this is why people view lawyers as dishonest.
Because that concept is consistent with all of US law - See third party standing, third party beneficiaries, etc.
In the US, you usually can't raise claims on behalf of others, whether they are constitutional, contractual, etc.
This was not a surprise to anyone involved - the US, SBF, the bahamas, the lawyers, etc.
They are all quite aware of this.
You can argue this mechanism sucks, or is bad, but the answer to your question is because that's what all of US law says everywhere - this is not some unique feature of extradition. It's a core concept common across both civil and criminal law.
Anyway I understood your point, thanks for making the effort.
Non-lawyer elected officials, actually.
Lawyers are just charged with knowing enough of the mess to be able to advise people - but don't shoot the messenger.
The criminal system is also deliberately adversarial, something lawyers didn't make up either.
The civil system is not, at least.
What do you base this on? It depends on the year but Congress is usually 30-50% lawyers.
A lot of legislative drafting is carried out by lawyers in the Legislative Counsel (of the House of Reps, of California, etc.), anyway.
Unless you mean these rules were written before the Bar associations were a thing
Those that aren't are from very close to founding, done in conventions that were mostly not lawyers :)
These are mostly not modern doctrines created by Congress.
If the Bahamas wanted to keep him, they wouldn't have extradited him in the first place. Why would they want to protect SBF?
Because most countries are, in the general sense, not hugely interested in harboring (or even letting in) foreign criminals.
He's not a Bahamian national, they have zero reason to not turn him over.
The only reason they might want to keep him is to get their pound of flesh, given that he's also defrauded Bahamian citizens, but they seem to be quite happy with letting Uncle Sam foot the bill for prosecuting and jailing him.
Third party standing for rights is basically not a thing in the US, except in rare cases (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_standing)
Even in other realms, this is usually the case - it's very rare for a third party beneficiary to be able to raise rights that belong to someone else.
For example, Bob writes some software and releases it under the GPL. Evilco takes it and ships binaries of it. You get a binary. You ask them for source. They say GFY.
You are a third party beneficiary of Bob's contract with Evilco. Bob has the right to sue them in court. However, you probably do not have the right to sue them for breach of contract.
(There is nuance i'm avoiding here about to make the point).
This is not a crazy as you seem to think, and, in fact, if they cannot, this is a fairly recent (last 30-ish years) change in the state of the law. As the Supreme Court noted in U.S. v. Alvarez-Machain (1992), at that time, prosecution in violation of extradition agreement was invalid and the defendant absolutely could raise this issue independently. (A protest from the other government party may or may not, depending on the extradition agreement, be a factor in whether the prosecution is in violationof the agreement, but that’s a different and treaty-specific question, apart from whether or not an individual charged has the right to raise the invalidity of the prosecution under the treaty.)
1. SBF agreed (voluntarily!) to be extradited from the Bahamas to face ~X charges in the US.
2. After being extradited, he was charged with X + Y charges.
3. He claims that international extradition agreements make this illegal.
4. The judge ruled that, <citing precedent>, international extradition agreements allow the Bahamas to raise a complaint about this - but does not allow SBF to do so [1].
5. US prosecutors have expressed that they are willing to drop the Y charges if the Bahamas raises a complaint in a timely fashion.
6. The Bahamas are incredibly unlikely to raise a complaint on this point.
tl;dr - Expensive lawyers can force government prosecutors to dot all their is and cross their ts, but if they have you dead to rights, you're still screwed. SBF seems really, really screwed.
[1] These parts of extradition treaties are generally very explicitly about the rights of countries, not the rights of individuals.