News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by AceJohnny2 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:43PM (#36499719)
Not being sympathetic to SBF here, but that's quite the legal gotcha.

No wonder people don't trust the law/lawyers.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by mdasen on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#36500226)
It's not a legal gotcha. Let's say that he didn't voluntarily come to the US. The Bahamas then extradited him. He's then here. In this case, the prosecutors must get permission from the Bahamas for the additional charges.

"An extradition treaty between the United States and the Bahamas, where FTX was based, says a country must consent before defendants can be tried on charges brought after their extradition.

Prosecutors said they asked the Bahamas to agree to those charges, which include conspiracy to bribe Chinese officials and commit bank fraud, but did not know when the Caribbean country would grant its consent." via https://www.reuters.com/legal/bankman-fried-loses-bid-toss-c...

If he had contested the extradition, then he'd be at the Bahamas' judgment for the original charges and the new charges. He decided to come back for the original charges and now the Bahamas decides whether they will allow the US to bring the new charges - basically whether they would have extradited him for those new charges.

If they would have extradited him for the new charges as well, then it doesn't matter. If they wouldn't have extradited him for those charges, the prosecution can't bring those charges. There's no legal gotcha. The legal gotcha would be if he returned and then the Bahamas couldn't consent to them bringing additional charges.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by RandomBK on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:28PM (#36500146)
Why is it a gotcha? These kinds of treaties in general only care about the 'feelings' of nation-states, not individuals. The rule exists because countries often have some say in whether to extradite, and they make that decision based on known facts.

In this case, it's a statement from the US to the Bahamas about what they intend to do to SBF once he's in custody. If the US then goes on and punishes SBF even harder than what they originally told the Bahamas, the Bahamas might feel lied to. Think of it as a "we wouldn't have extradited if we knew he was facing the death penalty" kind of scenario. This rule thus exists to give the Bahamas a chance to remedy that.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by hsjqllzlfkf on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @07:46PM (#36500315)
I fully agree with the person you're responding to, and it is a gotcha. I also understand your point that the offended party is the Bahamas, but if the US said it would pursue some charges, why is it then trying more? Why is it that the mechanism is "one parry can do what it wants unless the other party complains" instead of "one party can only do what it agreed to"?

Also, I BET YOU that behind the scenes the us is telling the Bahamas "you better not complain about this or else we'll get you on that other thing". Because.... you think US prosecutors would leave this possibility to chance? Why would the Bahamas not complain?

That's right, this is why people view lawyers as dishonest.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by DannyBee on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:23PM (#36500631)
"Why is it that the mechanism is "one parry can do what it wants unless the other party complains" instead of "one party can only do what it agreed to"?

Because that concept is consistent with all of US law - See third party standing, third party beneficiaries, etc.

In the US, you usually can't raise claims on behalf of others, whether they are constitutional, contractual, etc.

This was not a surprise to anyone involved - the US, SBF, the bahamas, the lawyers, etc.

They are all quite aware of this.

You can argue this mechanism sucks, or is bad, but the answer to your question is because that's what all of US law says everywhere - this is not some unique feature of extradition. It's a core concept common across both civil and criminal law.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by hsjqllzlfkf on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:27PM (#36500650)
Hey I'm sure this all makes sense to lawyers :-)

Anyway I understood your point, thanks for making the effort.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by DannyBee on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:39PM (#36500762)
Let me go further - Lawyers didn't make this up. Elected officials did :)

Non-lawyer elected officials, actually.

Lawyers are just charged with knowing enough of the mess to be able to advise people - but don't shoot the messenger.

The criminal system is also deliberately adversarial, something lawyers didn't make up either.

The civil system is not, at least.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by civilitty on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:50PM (#36501308)
> Non-lawyer elected officials, actually.

What do you base this on? It depends on the year but Congress is usually 30-50% lawyers.

A lot of legislative drafting is carried out by lawyers in the Legislative Counsel (of the House of Reps, of California, etc.), anyway.

Unless you mean these rules were written before the Bar associations were a thing

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by RandomBK on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @10:40PM (#36501618)
Given much of this comes from English Common Law, we get to blame time immemorial for how our legal system works.
Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by DannyBee on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:28AM (#36505418)
These things are older than the US, for the most part.

Those that aren't are from very close to founding, done in conventions that were mostly not lawyers :)

These are mostly not modern doctrines created by Congress.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by HWR_14 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @10:55PM (#36501712)
> Why would the Bahamas not complain?

If the Bahamas wanted to keep him, they wouldn't have extradited him in the first place. Why would they want to protect SBF?

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by vkou on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @04:41AM (#36503898)
> Why would the Bahamas not complain?

Because most countries are, in the general sense, not hugely interested in harboring (or even letting in) foreign criminals.

He's not a Bahamian national, they have zero reason to not turn him over.

The only reason they might want to keep him is to get their pound of flesh, given that he's also defrauded Bahamian citizens, but they seem to be quite happy with letting Uncle Sam foot the bill for prosecuting and jailing him.

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by kosievdmerwe on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:50PM (#36500838)
Yeah, it's an incredibly obvious loophole to suddenly "discover" new charges after the person is in your possession.
Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by tengwar2 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:28PM (#36523645)
Death penalty happens to be the one thing that usually figures in extradition treaties with the USA: the USA must guarantee that the death penalty will not be applied. Of course there are some other countries which still use the death penalty, but they are usually not the sort of placed which have extradition treaties.
Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by DannyBee on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @08:20PM (#36500608)
It's pretty standard, even outside extradition.

Third party standing for rights is basically not a thing in the US, except in rare cases (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_standing)

Even in other realms, this is usually the case - it's very rare for a third party beneficiary to be able to raise rights that belong to someone else.

For example, Bob writes some software and releases it under the GPL. Evilco takes it and ships binaries of it. You get a binary. You ask them for source. They say GFY.

You are a third party beneficiary of Bob's contract with Evilco. Bob has the right to sue them in court. However, you probably do not have the right to sue them for breach of contract.

(There is nuance i'm avoiding here about to make the point).

Re:Sam Bankman-Fried fails to dismiss criminal charges relat... by freejazz on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:21AM (#36507797)
really? you think that when extraditing an alleged criminal, we should ask the alleged criminal if they want to be extradited? That can't be right...