News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Waterluvian on Saturday June 24, 2023 @06:19PM (#36463159)
I love this.

I’ve been making games as a hobby, but I’m terrible at graphics. I finally found personal success when I went for retro, low res stuff. It’s a lot easier to fake it (but arguably much harder to really nail the aesthetic.)

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Schiendelman on Saturday June 24, 2023 @06:37PM (#36463264)
I struggle with the same thing! I have a great core loop but can't make it not look terrible. :)
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by lockhouse on Saturday June 24, 2023 @07:47PM (#36463791)
I’m so bummed I missed the golden age of text based games. I can describe things but can’t draw them to save my life.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by LeoPanthera on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:05PM (#36463896)
For what it's worth, there's a small but very dedicated group of IF fans still.

Check out:

https://ifdb.org

https://ifcomp.org

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by elliotpo on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:08PM (#36463918)
thank you for this
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by mysterydip on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:21PM (#36463997)
Still going strong as a niche. Lots of good tools nowadays. Why not give it a go? And coincidentally this book just released. I got the PDF version and am loving it: https://if50.textories.com/#buy
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:25PM (#36464349)
> Lots of good tools nowadays.

Inform 7 has kinda "won" by popularity, for obscure historical reasons (you can read The Digital Antiquarian's "Teaching the Old Z-Machine New Tricks" series to see what exactly happened to make Inform so dominant), so on a first search that's the tool you're most likely to find, but I just want to plug TADS 3 for anyone interested in interactive fiction development.

Inform is interesting, especially in concept, but it has a huge amount of very serious drawbacks due to its extremely static nature (no dynamic allocation, no creating lists on the fly and appending to them, etc), lack of general programming constructs, and "natural language" syntax, whereas TADS 3 is actually a very excellent little language that's got all the modern amenities and is just a joy to write games in, and has a simply shockingly powerful standard library / world model. TADS 3 feels like Ruby/Smalltalk had a baby with C and it specialized in IF.

Also, try the adv3Lite library instead of the default standard library — the name is a bit of a misnomer, as it's just as complete as the default one, it just has superior design sensibilities and a huge host of new features stolen from Inform. Adv3Lite adds basically everything thay was good about Inform 7 to TADS 3.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by anthk on Sunday June 25, 2023 @04:09AM (#36465966)
I prefer Inform6, a dumb as hell OOP language but you can go to "low level" stuff in order to implement things. Also, it has Spanish support thru infsp6, which is my native language.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Sunday June 25, 2023 @07:46AM (#36467213)
Nice! Yeah Inform 6 is still solid. TADS 3 is more like it than 7.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by em-bee on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:15PM (#36464295)
besides interactive fiction there are also many MUDs still going.

https://mudlistings.com/ has a section, which MUDs are looking for builders and writers

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:19PM (#36464314)
Like the other reply to your post said, there is a small but very dedicated, active and most of all supportive interactive fiction community still regularly making very well-made and interesting literary works, as well as producing new development tools, and we would love to have you! There's even a yearly competition for short interactive fiction that you can submit to if you don't want your work to go completely unnoticed.

I really can't stress enough how supportive and engaged and surprisingly active this community is — you wouldn't think it possible for a genre that has been officially dead for so many years, but somehow the community has kept going, producing works of really substantial worth and inventiveness that are genuinely sometimes even better than what was produced when the genre was officially alive. Many of them very long and complex, too. I highly recommend you check out IFDB, check the tags for parser (I find parser IF in the general tradition of Infocom much more interesting and impressive than hypertext, since there's am actual world model and stuff there) and "long-form." You'll see some impressive stuff. You should also check out https://intfiction.org, it's a very friendly community forum for discussing interactive fiction reviews, design, and development, and it's shockingly active — I've posted there a few times and always got several replies, and there's always people talking there.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by le-mark on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:49PM (#36464156)
It is sooo depressing to show off a game you put your heart into only to hear “the graphics suck”. It turned me off from the hobby a long time ago.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Waterluvian on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:00PM (#36464217)
You just reminded me of a comment I saw a dev make when someone posted the same criticism:

“Or your sense of imagination has atrophied.”

Maybe a bit pithy, maybe a bit sour, but what really resonated with me was the idea: graphics can rob us of that role in the production. I’m sure I’m about to say what’s obvious to many but: I just realized that I’ve lost a sensation that was dear to me as a kid: taking the handful of pixels and the box art and building the graphics in my mind.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:10PM (#36464265)
I'm in the same boat, being in love with making games but really quite terrible at graphics (and with no real enjoyment for learning either, sadly). I tried pixel art several times, but ended up solving my dilemma with parser interactive fiction instead. I lucked out in that a) I'm an excellent writer and b) I'm obsessed with puzzle-y, simulationist games with a lot of exploration and atmosphere, so parser IF is perfect for me.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Waterluvian on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:26PM (#36464356)
If I wanted to write an IF game but needed a very detailed game state (inventory, levelling, stats, etc.) is there a direction you might point me in for an engine or an engine design?

I looked at the popular IF engines and they all felt very focused on story and branches and not really on if you need game systems and a lot of state.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:37PM (#36464397)
> I looked at the popular IF engines and they all felt very focused on story and branches and not really on if you need game systems and a lot of state.

If you need complex game states and world models and object simulations and relational stuff, then you definitely want to do parser based interactive fiction instead of hypertext interactive fiction, the latter of which is what it sounds like you looked at.

Hypertext interactive fiction isn't really so much a game as a choose your own adventure approach to traditional fiction, whereas parser-based interactive fiction is a lot like a text-based immersive sim like deus ex or system shock — the two major engines have very powerful and in-depth relational world models that can do a lot of impressive things such as simulating the expansion of a gas and its attenuation through rooms or fluid simulation or tying arbitrary things together with ropes. Both of them automatically come with very complete and powerful systems for doing all the stuff you listed by default.

The two parser IF systems I'm talking about are Inform 7 and TADS 3. I would personally recommend the latter if you already know how to program, though. Inform is interesting, especially in concept, but it has a huge amount of very serious drawbacks due to its extremely static nature (no dynamic allocation, no creating lists on the fly and appending to them, etc), lack of general programming constructs, and "natural language" syntax, whereas TADS 3 is actually a very excellent little language that's got all the modern amenities and is just a joy to write games in, and has a simply shockingly powerful standard library / world model, a far more deep and extensive one than Inform has even with extensions. It often feel a like everything I could possibly want to model in TADS 3 has either already been done, or is a trivial combination of things. Additionally, TADS 3's documentation is so much better than Inform's I can't even begin to describe it. TADS 3 feels like Ruby/Smalltalk had a baby with C and it specialized in IF.

Also, try the adv3Lite library instead of the default standard library — the name is a bit of a misnomer, as it's just as complete as the default one, it just has superior design sensibilities and a huge host of new features stolen from Inform. Adv3Lite adds basically everything thay was good about Inform 7 to TADS 3.

Don't let the fact that Inform 7 seems more active or gets more fanfare deter you from TADS. There's a very active little community of tads users that are very eager to help and will answer almost any question you have immediately, and the documentation is so astoundingly excellent I've basically never felt the need for a search engine because everything I want is in one of the three 600 page manuals on different aspects of the language and standard library or in the standard library reference manual. also although tads three the language hasn't been updated or changed since 2012 the compiler is updated and improved regularly.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Waterluvian on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:43PM (#36464422)
Thank you so much for taking the time to provide all this guidance. I definitely missed the boat by not knowing to look for “parser” IF.

I’m excited again to know there’s choices out there for this kind of thing.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by logicprog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:04PM (#36464525)
Hell yeah! Here's some links:

Here's a list of worldsim-heavy, huge parser IF games I've compiled myself: https://ifdb.org/playlist?id=5wvcywn58ojmsxqi&type=wishlist

Here's the TADS 3 website: https://tads.org/

Here's the adv3Lite and TADS 3 documentation: https://faroutscience.com/adv3lite_docs/

An explanation of adv3lite: https://users.ox.ac.uk/~manc0049/TADSGuide/adv3Lite.htm

The TADS 3 compiler: https://github.com/realnc/frobtads

My TADS 3 mode for Emacs (has most of the features of the VS Code one, despite not having an LSP, since the VSC one has very simple auto completion): https://github.com/alexispurslane/tads3-mode

The TADS 3 mode for VS Code: https://github.com/toerob/vscode-tads3tools

IF Development Forums (very active and friendly, a few TADS 3 people around, including me, I'm a new regular): https://intfiction.org

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by em-bee on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:44PM (#36464428)
look at MUDs. some of those are fully programmable. i am most familiar with LPmuds, which are written in LPC, which is a complete programming language. (Pike a general purpose programming language is derived from LPC. and there are also a few small MUD engines written in Pike)

though for a standalone game a full MUD may a bit much since they are designed for large words with hundreds or thousands of players. but take a look at the available game engines and see which ones come with decent documentation for you to get started easily.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Donckele on Sunday June 25, 2023 @02:20AM (#36465529)
Can you recommend any mud “engines” that can be used on a modern linux system which are easy enough to get into (both for users and devs) and battle tested for security?
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by em-bee on Sunday June 25, 2023 @11:50PM (#36475565)
i am afraid that this is rather difficult to answer. the first question is where you really want to go with this?

some of the issues to consider are:

do you want to potentially commercialize the game? that rules out some engines (most notably some LPmuds) because their license only allows noncommercial use.

then you have to consider the size of your future game. some MUDs are huge and their code has a long and checkered history. while they are more likely to be battle tested, i don't know if a huge engine would be a good start for a new game because it would prescribe a lot of game mechanics already, and may not be so easy to get started with.

personally i would rather opt for a small engine that doesn't have more than basic game mechanics so that you are free to develop your own. but those are most certainly not battle tested, and there are probably quite a few that were started but are now abandoned.

finding a small, active and tested engine may not even be possible.

i would recommend to actually play and build with a couple of MUDs that are based on potentially interesting engines to familiarize yourself with how it works and see if that is something that you'd be comfortable to work with, and then take it from there.

Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by Donckele on Monday June 26, 2023 @03:43AM (#36476853)
Thanks for the response. If you have any links, to where I could start exploring, then I would be grateful.
Re:Atari VCS Myst “Demake” by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:28PM (#36464361)
It’s possible to hire someone on fiverr to make retro pixel sprites for very low cost. I sometimes hire two people, give them the same instructions, then choose the sprites I like better.