News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Saturday June 17, 2023 @07:48AM (#36369400)
From my relatively short experience but ongoing with Mac, MacOS lacks a lot of features that Windows has. It has many inferior options that people just accept. Some people find third party software or modifying plists to bend the operating system to their will.

As much as I hate many many many design choices in Apple's ecosystems, I adjust where I can and move on.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by sys_64738 on Saturday June 17, 2023 @08:40AM (#36369713)
Some of the Windows choices are horrendous. Alt-tab to switch apps actually switches between browser tabs in Edge. It's really confusing. There's a litany of other problems too like virtual desktops move all screens instead of just the screen with the cursor, so it's unusable. There's also a case where certain actions with the mouse cause all the windows to vanish. I mean, what was that. Then there's that window history thing which is baffling to use.

macOS has its demons but Windows just plain is confusing.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Saturday June 17, 2023 @09:26AM (#36369987)
Alt-tab to switch between browser tabs in Edge is new, a setting that you can turn off, and in some cases, it's actually very useful, since you can limit the number of tabs. It lets me treat recent tabs the same way as I would treat recent applications, which many websites effectively are. But anyways, that choice is made available to you.

I don't currently use multiple monitors, but I do use virtual desktops, and... that's exactly how I would expect virtual desktops to behave? If it only changed a single monitor, does that mean you'd have to go to each monitor to change to a different virtual desktop? Do you see virtual desktop configurations specific to each screen, or any screen? What happens if your screens are different resolutions. I think that Windows again has the superior implementation here.

Aero shake was pretty terrible, no arguments here.

The window history thing, Timeline, is something that I have disabed, but honestly sounds like an even better version of Recent Files, which is something many people use and might like something more full featured.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by sys_64738 on Saturday June 17, 2023 @10:18AM (#36370358)
I want all these turned off by default and not need to stumble through trying to figure out how to disable them. Windows now feels like using Android where you need to google first to figure out how to modify something. In terms of virtual desktops, having independent control per monitor is so elementary that it makes the feature pretty useless otherwise.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by pulpfictional on Saturday June 17, 2023 @11:52AM (#36371286)
I want it all, I want it now.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:28AM (#36377329)
But these are new features that Microsoft decided would be an improvement for most people, and many people happily use them. For those of us stuck in our ways, yes we have to do a little tweaking, but that's the cost we pay. At least we have the option available to us.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by cassianoleal on Saturday June 17, 2023 @11:58AM (#36371361)
The virtual desktop implementation in macOS is called Spaces. The first time it appeared in the OS, it would always span all screens, so when switching they would all switch together.

Presently the default is for each display to have their own collection of spaces. You can have one display with a single space and another one with 10, or 50 on each. They behave independently and are switched independently.

There is a toggle to restore the old behaviour but I find the new one far superior.

I don't understand the question about different resolutions. Why would they be a concern?

I regularly use my MacBook's display in conjunction with a 1600p ultrawide external display. Different resolutions are not a problem, and never have been.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by tpmoney on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:56PM (#36373304)
> but I do use virtual desktops, and... that's exactly how I would expect virtual desktops to behave? If it only changed a single monitor, does that mean you'd have to go to each monitor to change to a different virtual desktop?

Different strokes for different folks. In my setup yes, each of the three monitors has their own set of virtual desktops. When working on a project for example, I might have my center display configured with the IDE, and a second monitor configured with one virtual desktop per group of related reference materials. So I can switch between API docs, language docs, database query and reference etc on one monitor, while keeping the IDE front and center. The other monitor might contain a space with "office" apps (slack, email etc) and then another with a set of tiled terminal windows for using CLI utilities. If I switch that screen to look at emails, I don't need or want the other screens to change to something else.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by D13Fd on Saturday June 17, 2023 @07:57AM (#36369447)
Like what? I use both every day, hard to think of any major features for my usage other than snapping that Mac OS lacks.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Saturday June 17, 2023 @08:27AM (#36369639)
- Peek at desktop

- Quick hide-all-windows to copy something from your desktop to your clipboard, then bring everything back

- Alt-tab, especially when it comes to apps with multiple windows, and windows in different states, such as minimized

- A modern/fully-featured default web browser without a locked down extension ecosystem. - A start menu for seeing all your applications

- A taskbar with application grouping

- File Explorer is much more full-featured than Finder

- Better settings, especially when it comes to relevant settings being in one place

- The concept of uninstalling an application vs just deleting the application

- In some cases, an actual function key row

That said, I've used Windows for almost 15 years now, and I think many of its choices are second nature to me. Many of my friends are masters of switching windows with Expose, which I absolutely despise. And I still use Windows for work, but use Mac in personal usage. I usually end up frustrated at things that work on Windows but don't on MacOS, but rarely vice versa.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by jitl on Saturday June 17, 2023 @10:03AM (#36370247)
Desktop peek: Part of “Mission Control”: spread thumb and 3 fingers, or press Fn+F11.

Alt tab: press cmd-tab to cycle applications, then cmd-` to cycle windows of that application. This typically has better number-of-keypress to get the window you want compared to Windows alt-tab which requires iterating over all windows in the worst case.

Browser: Safari is fits your criteria

Start menu to see all apps: this is called “Launchpad”, and is in the Dock by default for new macOS users, but can be removed.

Uninstall vs delete: apps installed from the Mac App Store can be uninstalled from launchpad. Otherwise, isn’t “apps are files, drag to install, cmd-delete or drag to trash to uninstall” objectively simpler than using a wizard to install, and digging around in a control panel to uninstall?

Function key row: you can swap the behavior of the fn row so that the keys send Fn1-Fn12 by default, and needs the fn key held down to send commands like “volume up”.

Settings layout: this one is opinion; I’ve always found Windows settings horribly organized. From 2001-2007, there’s no contest that System Preferences is better organized than Windows XP’s control panel. From 2007-2015, the Vista-era control panel split things awkwardly between the “new style” Vista panels and old-style windows XP/2000/98 panels. Since Windows 10 things are on more even footing in my view, although some details in macOS Network and Displays are annoyingly hidden in some versions.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by Gunnerhead on Saturday June 17, 2023 @11:49AM (#36371242)
Also for desktop peek you can customize “hot corners” to show the desktop when you put your cursor in one of the corners.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:50AM (#36377424)
I... should have thought about this. Will give it a try!
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by karaterobot on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:17PM (#36372853)
> Alt tab: press cmd-tab to cycle applications, then cmd-` to cycle windows of that application. This typically has better number-of-keypress to get the window you want compared to Windows alt-tab which requires iterating over all windows in the worst case.

Except that you can select a window with cmd-tab and then have absolutely nothing happen as a result. It will show windows that it does not let you muster on screen, except with a secret key combination it does not tell you about. The existence of this secret method of actually getting the application to do what you expect it to in no way excuses the default behavior of not doing what it should do.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by wrs on Saturday June 17, 2023 @03:34PM (#36373746)
I'm not sure quite what situation you're describing with the secret key thing, but in case it's relevant: Cmd-tab selects applications, not windows. If the application has no windows open, then when you cmd-tab to it, you won't switch to a window (but you will see the menu bar switch). The situation cannot occur in Windows because it insists that an application must have at least one window open to interact with it at all.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by karaterobot on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:11PM (#36374086)
You can see a description of the problem, and its obscure (in the sense of being hidden) solution, in this stackoverflow thread.

https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/112350/cmdtab-does...

All applications are open in this case. MacOS just doesn't display anything in certain quite common cases, such as one of its windows being hidden or minimized. There is a mechanism to display these windows (the obscure, well-kept secret does work) but Apple chose not to apply it.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by wrs on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:45PM (#36374983)
Aaaah, minimized windows, a feature I only use by accident. I always “disable” the cmd-M shortcut.

(“Disable” meaning set it to cmd-opt-shift-ctl-M for all apps.)

But still, switching to the app does show all the non-minimized windows. And minimizing a window is explicitly asking for it to be hidden. So it would be wrong to show it every time you switch back to the application.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by kristiandupont on Saturday June 17, 2023 @03:11PM (#36373481)
>Alt tab: press cmd-tab to cycle applications, then cmd-` to cycle windows of that application. This typically has better number-of-keypress to get the window you want compared to Windows alt-tab which requires iterating over all windows in the worst case.

In the case where you need to switch to a window that you haven't been using for a while, perhaps. But switching back and forth on the other hand, is infuriating because the z-order is polluted. And I also find it incredibly frustrating that all the other windows are brought to the top just because they happen to share a process.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by prewett on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:01PM (#36373990)
Launchpad can also be started by taking four fingers spread out and bringing them together into one spot. I think that is enabled by default. (Control panel, at least in older versions, also had a little animation for all the gestures, and you can assign different functions to them)

You can also swipe up with three fingers to get a view of all the windows on your current desktop (and also select other Spaces). Normally I just use Cmd-Tab, but if your window is very visible this can be faster. I keep my source control app's window hidden behind Xcode, and then 3-swipe-up to click on it when I need to commit something.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:49AM (#36377421)
Desktop Peek: I'll try setting this up on a hot corner and see how it works for me. I don't think I'll use it with a keyboard shortcut, so maybe I can remember to use it this way.

Alt+Tab: Using Ctrl+` tab switch between windows of an application is annoying second layer to me. I'm going to have to live with it, because the half-dozen or so third-party applications that I've tried to recreate Windows behavior either fail, work differently than I want, or have been abandoned.

Browser: I was specifically saying not this. I really really try to like Safari, but every time I start trying to use it as my primary browser, I start running in to annoying roadblocks that insist I work in the "Apple way".

Launch Pad: I forgot about this, I removed it from the dock. Doesn't open as easily as the start menu, with it's own dedicated button, and organizing it is terrible. Just like Launchpad on iOS. Start Menu Tiles and the ability to mix files/apps is way more powerful and behaves the way I expect. I do really like Raycast/Alfred, but I miss the comfort of an organized start menu.

Uninstall - I do think that this is fine, but an uninstall wizard is sometimes helpful. For Backup settings mostly, but I guess there really should just be a better way to do that.

Function Key Row - I do have this swapped to function keys by default, but what I was referring to was the touchbar macbook models. Terrible design choice that was thrust upon users.

Settings: Fair points on the different styles, but that doesn't bother me much. Like I said, I've been Windows for a really long time, so the familiarity outweighs the inconsistency. System Preferences was okay, but had options scattered where they shouldn't be. And System Settings now is definitely worse.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by ankurdhama on Sunday June 18, 2023 @04:33AM (#36378359)
> Alt tab: press cmd-tab to cycle applications, then cmd-` to cycle windows of that application. This typically has better number-of-keypress to get the window you want compared to Windows alt-tab which requires iterating over all windows in the worst case.

Sure, it may save you some keypresses but it introduce the cognitive overhead of - do I need to switch to the window of current app or other app and then decide which key combination to press.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by Gigachad on Saturday June 17, 2023 @09:35PM (#36376499)
> The concept of uninstalling an application vs just deleting the application

Uninstalling is a workaround for the failure of windows to actually contain an apps data. The way macos handles it is much better.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by djfdat on Sunday June 18, 2023 @12:33AM (#36377350)
But isn't there app data still left around on the disk somewhere in Library? Aren't apps able to generate and save off app data outside of the .app?
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by Gigachad on Sunday June 18, 2023 @01:07AM (#36377502)
They can, though I guess it depends on what the user is actually trying to do when they remove a program. I'd say the user wants to free up disk space and to not have the app start up on boot or run in the background consuming resources. Deleting the .app does this while on Windows, the uninstaller is the only way I know how this would be done.

The fact that the app might leave some documents and configs behind seems inconsequential. If you delete Word, you wouldn't want it to wipe out your documents with it for example. The fact that some configs remain in system dirs doesn't really matter when they take up no space.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by HDThoreaun on Saturday June 17, 2023 @01:01PM (#36372036)
It's just a far more opinionated OS. Always "my way or the highway". MacOS doesnt have a good window manager because it was designed for every app to be Fullscreen and then use three or four finger scroll to switch apps. The designers really want you to use their preferred way of managing windows so they make the traditional method suck.
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by xn--cr8h on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:02PM (#36372676)
...so that you can't see the time? why would you want that?
Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by kagakuninja on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:05PM (#36374036)
The roots of MacOS UI principles date back to the 1980s. Even the current UNIX based MacOS was created in 1999 based off of the Next OS.

Multi-finger gestures were introduced with the iPhone in 2007, and eventually made their way onto laptops. Not only is MacOS 10 / 11 not based on multi-finger gestures, you can only use gestures if you are using a laptop or an Apple touchpad. The default mode of using MacOS is mouse based.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by Toutouxc on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:16PM (#36374704)
> Not only is MacOS 10 / 11 not based on multi-finger gestures, you can only use gestures if you are using a laptop or an Apple touchpad. The default mode of using MacOS is mouse based.

Well, every single one of their input devices supports the gestures. Built-in trackpads, Magic Trackpad, Magic Mouse. I’m not saying you’re wrong, but for me (Mac user of 9 years) macOS is decidedly gesture based, and I consider them one of its biggest strengths.

Re:Ask HN: Why does Apple refuse to add window snapping to m... by HDThoreaun on Saturday June 17, 2023 @07:57PM (#36375987)
Ok? They abandoned their roots and went all in on the trackpad gestures. I'm not saying it's the right choice, it's just the one apple made.