News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by disruptiveink on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:19AM (#36356956)
We're not "all going to die", but "A lot of your coastal historical cities are going be be underwater and parts of your country will become uninhabitable, meaning you and everyone else will need to move elsewhere" is absolutely horrific.

Add that to housing being increasingly out of reach for most people and it's hard to not feel disillusioned. In some sense, you could argue that "Work all your life to be able to buy a house on land that will be destroyed" is worse for morale than the Cold War's version of "We'll probably all just die from nuclear war at some point all at the same time".

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by timmg on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:38AM (#36357255)
> "A lot of your coastal historical cities are going be be underwater and parts of your country will become uninhabitable, meaning you and everyone else will need to move elsewhere" is absolutely horrific.

Which cities and what timeline are you talking about? Sea level has risen like a half a foot in the last 70 years. That's not all that fast.

Meanwhile, places like Netherlands are increasing their land area over that time.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by acdha on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:55AM (#36357604)
How much more are you willing to pay to rebuild Miami after bigger hurricanes do more damage? They probably aren’t going to end up permanently underwater but everything suggests a lot of pricey real-estate is going to end up getting washed away (California already has billions of dollars in real estate threatened by erosion) or regularly flooded. There’s no realistic long-term outcome other than relocating from the affected areas and letting them become buffer parks (hopefully with lush mangroves in Florida).

That’s in a rich country with a lot of resources, and at least a history of helping other states out. Bangladesh is facing another climate change-boosted storm but has thousands of people who are still homeless from last year’s storm which also hammered food production. That’s the kind of scenario where things get ugly because millions of people live in areas which will see the worst impacts but lack anything like the resources to harden infrastructure or relocate large numbers of people.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by mdorazio on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:13AM (#36357961)
You didn’t really respond to the parent comment’s question. Sea level around Miami will rise about a foot over the next thirty years and a little over an additional foot over the following 30 years [1]. Most of Miami is about 6-8 feet above sea level. So again, what timeline are you worried about? Other parts of the Florida coast are definitely screwed, though (ex. The Keys).

[1] https://climatecenter.fsu.edu/topics/sea-level-rise

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by pyrale on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:09PM (#36359015)
The rise is a mean. That means that high tides, water surges due to storms, etc. will also be amplified.

If you consider the current risk of flooding as a stochastic process, moving the mean may result in an exponential risk increase.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by WorldMaker on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:12PM (#36359082)
Most of Miami is 6-8 feet today because Miami has had mayors (mostly democrats) for multiple decades now that took climate change seriously, made it a core part of city planning, and overall, in general, the city paid a lot of money to avoid some of the most egregious mistakes ahead of time in its infrastructure.

"Miami is going to be fine, mostly" isn't a slam dunk argument that climate change won't have real impacts, because Miami has already been fighting against it. (A lot of the rest of Florida has more to worry about in part because they haven't been nearly as proactive.)

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by acdha on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:24PM (#36360415)
Yes, we’re not going to rename it to New Atlantis with submarine tours but that doesn’t mean everything is fine. Storm surges are the most dramatic problem since the max matters more than the median for where you can build things, but there are other problems around the water table rising and septic systems. Flooding of low roads, parks, etc. is common even without storms and storm flooding can take longer to drain, too.

Before they moved, some family members saw hefty increases for insurance premiums and restricted coverage – and that trend is just getting started. Each of the things which needs to be hardened or redesigned costs billions, and there’s no guarantee that those projects will be enough, or that there won’t be other impacts on the economy if, say, popular tourist beaches aren’t as attractive due to erosion or some hotels are severely damaged.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by timmg on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:09AM (#36357903)
> How much more are you willing to pay to rebuild Miami after bigger hurricanes do more damage?

We have continued to build in disaster-prone areas. That's a real problem. But that is somewhat orthogonal to climate change.

Imagine a world without climate change. Are there still hurricanes? Is Miami still a low-lying city in a high-hurricane area? Do we continue to build more condos there?

Imagine a world without climate change and ask again: How much more are you willing to pay to rebuild Miami after "a big" hurricane does damage?

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by katbyte on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:04AM (#36357807)
> rebuild Miami after bigger hurricanes do more damage

Miami will likely end up mostly underwater and dykes and seawalls will not be able to protect it. The city is built on porous limestone that will allow seawater to just bypass them unless you dig down past that limestone bedrock layer.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by Turing_Machine on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:14PM (#36361185)
> How much more are you willing to pay to rebuild Miami after bigger hurricanes do more damage?

There is no evidence that hurricanes are getting bigger or more frequent. If anything, the record shows the opposite.

https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/pastdec.shtml

Edit: this data set goes through 2022 (the previous chart only went up to 2004)

https://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/hurdat/All_U.S._Hurricanes.htm...

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by acdha on Saturday June 17, 2023 @01:20PM (#36372225)
The scientific consensus is that hurricanes will be stronger and wetter, but it’s complicated to say exactly what that means regionally since there’s considerable natural variation and we have limited historical records for most of the oceans and many regions which weren’t historically densely populated. There’s a good overview here which discusses different aspects and the confidence levels on predictions both globally and for the Atlantic:

https://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/global-warming-and-hurricanes/

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by pyrale on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:04PM (#36358949)
> Sea level has risen like a half a foot in the last 70 years. That's not all that fast.

The pace of ice melting is still an unpredictable process due to its non-linearity, but the current imbalance between ice melting and new snow in the Greenland ice sheet commits a 27cm rise, according to [1]. This with current temperatures (not temperature rises).

From my layman understanding, antarctic runoff is less understood, but also its effect is potentially much larger. Article : [2]

Finally people with more knowledge than me, IPCC AR6, have estimates based on paleoclimates that depend on climate trajectory. [3], box TS4 pp. 77-78. Their optimistic story is 28-55cm by 2100. Their pessimistic assessment is "Under the higher CO2 emissions scenarios, there is deep uncertainty in sea level projections for 2100 and beyond". Also note that even in the best scenario, sea doesn't stop rising after 2100. Sea level rise is likely locked in for centuries.

A last word on "mean sea level": it's just a mean, impact may be worse for some areas.

> Meanwhile, places like Netherlands are increasing their land area over that time.

That's, like, a tiny confetti of wealthy people. Not sure this kind of anecdotal information is relevant to rising sea levels.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-022-01441-2 [2] https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/201... [3] https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/downloads/report/IPCC_AR6...

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by jjulius on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:29AM (#36357100)
> In some sense, you could argue that "Work all your life to be able to buy a house on land that will be destroyed" is worse for morale than the Cold War's version of "We'll probably all just die from nuclear war at some point all at the same time".

In some sense, sure, I guess - maybe mostly for those who bought a house on land like this a long time ago. But if you're choosing to buy a house on land in an area like this now, or in the future, or even the relatively recent past, when we all know the risk and/or inevitability of it's eventual destruction, then I don't know what to tell you...

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by disruptiveink on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:36AM (#36357221)
Depending on how bad it goes, it's unavoidable without upending your (current) life. Sure, let's assume things don't go too bad and you just avoid properties at close to sea level right next to the ocean. That's fine.

But what if you're expecting for things go real bad? Do you rule out living in NYC completely? Do you preemptively move out of Florida leaving all your family behind? The issue is that this is not a swift "now the bad thing happened and it took us all together" crisis. For the better or worse, humans are actually reasonably ok with dealing with situations like that.

This is a "your life is going to suck at some indeterminate point in the future, maybe, and depending on where your roots are, maybe you can avoid it at the cost of continuous great personal expense" crisis. No one can possibly be well prepared to deal with that and I'd wager that's where the incredible frustration around climate change comes.

Re:Stop Telling Kids They’ll Die from Climate Change (2021) by WorldMaker on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:29PM (#36359384)
Even if you are smart enough to move somewhere safer (or lucky enough to have generational wealth there), you can't avoid the effects of things like refugee crises when the worst happens. If people have to leave NYC or Florida in large mass waves, that's going to destabilize in its own ways anywhere there are escaping to in large groups. There's a perspective that "nowhere" will be safe from the effects of climate change because if you aren't the ones getting flooded out (or drought destroyed or wildfire devastated or tornado wrecked; flooding isn't the only thing that gets extra energy in global climate change) and are lucky enough to be in whatever "the nice places" will turn out to be, you get to possibly deal with everyone else. (Some will make some money on that as slum landlords, perhaps, so there's a "silver lining" for disaster capitalists, but those are the same people that will be just fine turning any "nice place to live" into a terrible place for all in its own ways by preferring money to human happiness and kindness.)

America has some lovely sometimes self-delusional myths of being a shining beacon for refugees in a crisis, but anti-immigrant rhetoric is already in a bad place this decade and overall America's worst internal refugee crisis was the dust bowl of the Great Depression and it took a lot of effort and today a lot of politicians don't believe the drastic changes made to save the country from the Great Depression were good changes and have spent the last few decades rolling them back and/or destroying them and/or trying to run a Great Depression speedrun like it is a GDQ category that should have been banned pre-emptively. That probably doesn't bode well for the next crises.