News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by londgine on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:17AM (#36351163)
If this wasn't connected to the blackout, this would be great news. There are a few mods, who when reddit was young, decided to squat every existing country's subreddit, along with common words. Those subs now work well with active mods below them. But the squatter still has full power, and can override any other mod. Now it will hopefully be easier to kick those mods.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by e2le on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:27AM (#36351239)
It's often struck me as odd how some moderators can be modding 50+ sometimes even high as 100+ subreddits. Why so many? I doubt they can be reasonably expected to moderate all of them. Shouldn't there be a limit?
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by CSMastermind on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:58AM (#36351513)
I moderated a few decently popular subreddits for a while (a couple hundred posts a day, nothing crazy).

I will say that most moderation work on Reddit can be done independently of a particular sub and scales okay across subreddits. Like the additional effort of moderating 100 subreddits vs 1 would be nowhere near 100x. It would probably be closer to like 5x the amount of work.

And there are benefits to moderating many subreddits.

Most moderation is keeping your automod filters up to date to stop the never-ending onslaught of porn bots, crypto scammers, and obvious fake accounts looking to farm karma. Everyday I'd scan through both the stuff the filters caught and the stuff they didn't and tweak the automod settings to be better, then most of the time I'd copy paste those settings across subs.

The other hard part of being a mod is communicating with the other mods. Like I would only be online moderating one hour out of the day and so all communication with async with anonymous strangers. This again benefits from having mods span many subreddits because you can quickly get to know the other moderators in similar spaces and you all pass information around to each other.

For subs that require user verification this again is a better user experience if you moderate several similar subs because users can verify with you once and be approved across many subs.

The communities actually tend to do a pretty good job of moderating themselves via reporting and downvoting so even if there's only one mod on a subreddit they act way more like an appeals process than an initial judge of fate, most content moderation is actually outsourced to the community as a whole with the mods only responsible for curating a space free of obvious spam and acting as an appeals process for people who have content on the borderline.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by FemmeAndroid on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:14AM (#36351662)
Thanks for writing this down. I don’t know about the details of Reddit moderation for popular subs, but I’ve moderated a pretty tiny one, and have some friends who moderate small communities elsewhere.

The perception that Mods are all power hungry and looking to impose their will is all consuming in some circles, ans it frustrates me. Most of the moderation is pure drudgery that is uninteresting and un controversial. Occasionally a mod will be wrong, or cross a line, and that sucks. But there is a real lack of appreciation for the work these volunteers do day to day.

Like, when I talk about this stuff with some friends who are nerds but don’t hang out in the same circles as any mods, they have no idea that mods are actually doing work beyond occasionally banning someone.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by pbae on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:40AM (#36351872)
It can be one way for many subs, and another way for others. Go to a sub that deals with controversial issues, find a threat with a lot of deleted posts, and look up that thread on unddit.com. Often times you will see mods deleting all dissenting opinions and not allow any discussion about it to even take place.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by dclowd9901 on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:38AM (#36352379)
> Most of the moderation is pure drudgery that is uninteresting and un controversial.

You’ve illustrated the point perfectly. I’m too cynical (and realist) to believe you moderate subreddits for any greater purpose. If not for the lulz, you must do it for the power. You don’t have to be honest with us, but you should at least be honest with yourself.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Nexxxeh on Friday June 16, 2023 @04:20AM (#36353187)
Are you being sarcastic or otherwise intentionally contrary, or do you genuinely believe that some people (if not you) like helping others?
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by 101011 on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:07AM (#36351590)
Very interesting perspective, thanks for sharing. What are your thoughts on a mechanism to oust existing mods? Is there any path you'd be willing to see? Or a lesser of two evils? E.g. mods being able to kick each other out with some plurality vs community members holding that power at some high voting threshold
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by CSMastermind on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:42AM (#36351896)
I'd be fine with some kind of election mechanism built into subreddits settings that could be turned on to allow community member to vote on mods.

With that said consider a subreddit for a podcast or youtube channel where the host/channel might legitimately want to have total control over moderation and I don't think it'd be appropriate to remove them.

Also consider that the vast majority of subreddits are moderated by volunteers who are only doing it because no one else will. You'd probably get more milage out of a way to force community members to take turns serving as moderators than you would having a mechanism to remove existing mods.

When someone says Reddit moderator you're thinking of /r/news or /r/funny not the person running the sub for their favorite book or local sports team or interest group. There are way more of those moderators and you almost need to handle the two use cases differently.

For the truly top subreddits I think Reddit should be employing people directly or indirectly to do the moderation. At the very least they should be compensating those people and reviewing their performance.

Reddit should also make better mod tools and do way more to help with moderation. It's offensively bad what they offer today. If Reddit actually gave a damn they would force every software engineer at the company to spend 2 weeks as the moderator of a subreddit once a year and I guarantee this problem would be solved quickly.

I also think some semblance of moderator hierarchy would be extremely helpful. Have some sort of mod council that oversees all of Ask* subreddits and another for sports subreddits and another for NSFW subreddits. Those content domains will all have similar needs and having someone looking at the bigger picture across individual subs would be very helpful.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by stcroixx on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:33AM (#36357173)
The host of a podcast having total control of a community seems like the perfect example of illegitimate control. I'd assume they'd remove any critical discussion to the point it would devolve into their own personal website where all it's good for is promoting the product. Users with anything critical to say would be banned, posts removed. That's about as anti user as it gets.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by slikrick on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:36PM (#36413697)
then those people can make their own different sub, there is no need to completely take over and remove a moderator team.

that has been the standard in all of reddits history.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by mrtksn on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:53AM (#36352496)
Thank you for writing these interesting insights. However, I wonder what was your motivation to do moderation and what made you stop?
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by CSMastermind on Friday June 16, 2023 @03:49AM (#36352952)
I was a contributor to a sub with a specific interest group (think something like your favorite programming framework). I got some value out of the community and so when someone suggested 'it would be really nice if a sub existed for xyz' I just went ahead and made the subreddit and was like, well here you go. By default, when you make a subreddit you're the moderator.

Then once that subreddit grew a little bit two things happened: first moderators of similar subreddits asked if I would be willing to help them out on their subs. The second was that moderators from other subreddits who enjoyed the community would reach out and ask if I needed any help moderating the sub. I both cases I said sure and eventually I ended up just being added to a bunch of subreddits as a moderator.

I would spend about an hour a day doing it and I think I kept it up as long as I did for the social aspect of it - I didn't want to burden the other moderators by leaving.

Then there was a highly politically charged let's say discussion that cropped up on the subreddit around some specific language (think similar to the default git branch being called "master"). It was exhausting to moderate, and it all suddenly felt like it wasn't worth it.

I also said to myself, hey I've got a lot to lose here, I've got a high paying job at a top company, and what happens it someone upset about this issue decides to email my employer and cause trouble? That could have real consequences for me. I'm taking a risk here and it's no longer worth it.

So yeah, I deleted the account and just walked away.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by taude on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:59AM (#36358873)
thanks for your perspective on how this worked....
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by unclekev on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:59AM (#36351516)
Power mods are a real problem on Reddit.

It's the same group of people who strong-armed a lot of smaller subreddits into participating in this 'protest'.

The end result of this protest looks like it's going to be that Reddit is going to remove a lot of the mods that the community has despised for years.

It would seem this mod pity party is backfiring in the most spectacular way possible.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by 101011 on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:10AM (#36351621)
I don't think that's true. r/nba, a top 10 active subreddit at the time of going private, put it to a public vote where the overwhelming majority of the community voted to suspend indefinitely.

This was during the NBA finals, mind you. Hard to put that sort of result on a small group of mods.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by unclekev on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:14AM (#36351666)
> put it to a public vote

Those votes were brigaded by people pushing the blackout, they are not representative of the overall community.

The average user of Reddit completely ignored/scrolled past those polls because "whats this doing in the NBA sub"

I find it hard to have any faith in those polls considering one of the subs that I mod that has ~3500 members got just over 4800 votes on the poll.

The other sub I mod with 1300 members got 800 votes (which averages 10 posts per week from a core regular group of users)

I do not believe for a second that a sub with less than 100 'active' monthly members had more than 60% of the total lifetime population of that sub come online all of a sudden and vote in the communities best interest.

Then on the other side of it, you've got subs with millions of members that had 20k responses. The average user did not (and does not) care. Now that those subs have been re-polled without being flooded by protesters, it's a overwhelming "No, leave us out of this"

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Larrikin on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:47AM (#36351948)
Is this more rigged election without evidence talk? I browse Reddit maybe 20 minutes a week, on the weeks that I think to use it. I'm subscribed to maybe a dozen subs. I voted in favor of the strike in the one sub that was kind of late to asking about the protest and I noticed in time.

I understand the value of the site even if I don't use it that often. It seems to be on the road to death and was hoping that it could be saved.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by yanderekko on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:32AM (#36357161)
>Is this more rigged election without evidence talk?

I mean, the user above just provided his personal testimony on the subject.

In any case, why should we have a presumption that a poll with say 10k votes on a sub with 10m users is a representative sample of user opinion? Not only would I say that we shouldn't, but I'd say that we shouldn't for reasons that the pro-blackout people often point to - that even if the changes don't impact most users it does disproportionately impact powerusers and mods.

But when someone says "maybe powerusers and mods are disproportionately influencing these polls" then we're suddenly asking for strong evidence??

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by hombre_fatal on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:09AM (#36357891)
If you're just someone who browses 20min/week, I'm not sure you represent the average user in any of your subreddits either much less one that should be weighing in on whether other people get to use the subreddit. ;)

"I barely visit Reddit so I'm completely cool with them staying offline" is kind of a given.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by fzeroracer on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:54AM (#36352013)
So you're a mod. Who's to say you personally did not brigade or tilt the poll in the other direction? I'm curious what makes you immune to random calls of conspiracy and corruption. It's especially ironic since you claim most mods are scum and corrupt, so I'm curious if you think you somehow are not.

Now if you have actual evidence of brigading then by all means. Post it. Post those 're-done' polls.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by alsetmusic on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:09AM (#36357906)
> they are not representative of the overall community.

I would suggest that they are representative of the most invested users.

I don't have a Reddit account. I just scroll and pass the time. But contributors have different needs / concerns than I. (I'm in favor of u/spez being replaced, however. What a dick.)

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by efreak on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:33PM (#36374275)
I read (and very occasionally contribute to) a large number of subreddits that I'm not subscribed to. Recently I use redreader, but I'm the past I did it via the main Reddit website, simply by visiting /r/a+b+c+d..... to show all the posts on the same page.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by satvikpendem on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:25AM (#36351748)
Selection bias, most casual users are not going to fill out a poll. The only ones who would are those who are likely to support the protest. This is clearly visible when you look at how many total votes there are compared to how many subscribers the subreddit has.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by markmark on Friday June 16, 2023 @04:11AM (#36353128)
8000 votes out of 7.5 million members. I'm on r/nba every day and didn't see the poll.

People will say statistically 8000 votes is sufficient for an accurate sample, but only if the voting isn't brigaded.

All comments on other basketball subs at the moment are overwhelmingly in favour of re-opening the sub.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by fsdjkflsjfsoij on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:57AM (#36357658)
r/nba and r/hockey are particularly interesting examples because the threads before the shutdown were overwhelmingly in favor of keeping the subs open and all the upvoted posts were openly trashing the mods over their decision. The poll was also posted in the ModCoord discord servers so was almost certainly not representative of the average r/nba or r/hockey user.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by nedt on Friday June 16, 2023 @04:01AM (#36353041)
They are still more democratic than the power CEO.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by laserbeam on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:03AM (#36351551)
I don't think it matters. As long as the members of a community have no problem with X being a mod, X should probably remain a mod for that community. If the community eventually hates X, X should be removable.

Reddit was the best place for self governed forums. I don't think arbitrary limits for how much one can mod would affect the quality of the site in the slightest.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by yanderekko on Friday June 16, 2023 @10:26AM (#36357048)
Yep. Given that this is HN, try looking at /r/California. It's basically a person fief for a single user (granted, he's not nearly as obnoxious as many Reddit mods.) Yet simply because this user owns the obvious name, there is no real alternate sub for California-level news.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by bb611 on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:40AM (#36358484)
> Yet simply because this user owns the obvious name, there is no real alternate sub for California-level news.

Alternatively, the users aren't bothered by the moderation there and no one's felt the need to start an alternative.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by coffeebeqn on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:56PM (#36359939)
It’s exactly what happened to digg. MrBabyMan etc owned the front page so everyone who disagrees or just doesn’t care for their content left