Oh yep sorry I should have noted that as well - I just thought NPR's (slightly) deep(er) dive was also interesting & worth a read as a bit more of a case study where someone was VERY CONVINCED that low interest rates were the way out of inflation, and, uh, so far the evidence is not compelling that they were correct.
$200k in the 80s would be $600k buying power now. But it’s barely middle class.
Our society is entirely a wealth preservation scheme for people who cannot prove they did the work, they just have political documents of power.
So, in your list the only true cause of inflation remains.
What is inflation? It’s prices going up. Or quality of service going down while priced the same. What is “supply chain disruption”, now? It is: you should pay more for the same delivery service, or if you refuse - your delivery will be delayed. “It’s not inflation, it’s just supply chain disruption” - was a political slogan then. No need to repeat it now: inflation is officially here already.
Housing, the stock market, crypto.
Supply of goods and services could mostly keep up with any increased demand so you didn't see inflation so obviously there.
However that allows bank A to loan 100% of their money to bank B and 100% to bank C.
This is extremely problematic. And now with bank failures they are too scared to put it back in place.
Just this concept alone creates huge inflation.
Crypto is gambling to me, so let's ignore that for my post.
Housing is mostly about debt financing (the same is true for commercial real estate). It is always true that financing rates have a large impact on valuations. People mostly buy homes on the monthly payment (cars too). If rates rise, they monthly payments rise. Most people will elect to buy a cheaper home, or wait for prices to fall.
Economics doesn't allow us to conduct controlled experiments. We have to work with the messy data that we have. When the vast majority of some of the smartest economists in the world who currently live and who have lived, all agree on principle of supply and demand, I find it compelling. When money is removed from circulation, demand drops. This almost always results in a reduction in prices. Rejecting the law of supply and demand is really out there as a fringe argument.
It would be interesting to see whether a country that had little-to-no dependence on global trade — North Korea, say — would actually see its internal economy benefit from low interest rates during an inflationary crisis.
Nothing happens in a vacuum. Things can't be reduced so much. But the idea that lowering interest rates will bring down inflation is not mainstream for a reason.
Lowering the interest rate below zero means that QE becomes irrelevant and that the central bank should undo all of it. Afterwards the central bank should raise the minimum reserve requirements above 50% and tighten its money supply as much as feasible. As holders of bank balances want to avoid negative interest fees, they will choose to invest in certificate of deposit accounts. The original borrowers now have an incentive to refinance their debts with this source and repay the money creating loans they have gotten from their banks which ultimately reduces the circulating money supply. If lenders refuse to accept a -10% return and instead lend at the rate of inflation, then borrowers will know when to stop without the government or central bank telling them to restrain themselves.
Erdoğan has invoked religion multiple times to justify his insistence on low interest rates (Islamic finance prohibits interest). I don't know whether it's a genuine belief but it's his stated one.
The difference is, perhaps, that I haven't heard of a Western politician using such phrases directly when addressing the people - but that might just be because such politician would be considered a hypocrite. It works differently when religion is involved, too.
Islam prohibits Riba which roughly translates to usury or unjust gains. While today it's widely believed to mean all forms of interest, that wasn't always the case. Even Caliph Umar was of the opinion that the definition of riba was ambiguous.
The bulk of Islamic finance today involves structuring financing arrangements that are functionally equivalent to interest bearing loans but let everyone pretend otherwise.
Turkey, unfortunately, hasn’t gone as far as to abandon the natural rate hypothesis.
[0]: https://economicsfromthetopdown.com/2023/03/23/inflation-the...
You can once you have actually understood MMT. How is the price anchor managed under MMT theory? How does that work during a boom and thereby solves the problem you posit? What are the three system stabilisation mechanisms in MMT theory?
MMT suggests moving the stabilisation policy from the market for money to the market for labour and leaving the market to determine interest rates. That stops the current problems - price gouging, SME decimation, boom/bust in construction and increased mortgage rates.
MMT moves the stabilisation policy from the market for money to the market for labour. They are not doing that in Argentina and Zimbabwe. They are following IMF dogma.
Therefore they demonstrate the problems with neoliberalism.
(Venezuela used to be a big oil producer until 2016, at which point it declined, leading to an inflation blowup https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/venezuela/crude-oil-pr... ; Maduro has been really bad for the country)
Money printing tries to paper over this but makes the problem worse, because the money they actually need is dollars, and only the US can print dollars.
https://infocielo.com/axel-kicillof/telefono-milei-axel-kici...
Here is a news article showing how the money printing machine is out of control in Argentina:
https://www.bloomberglinea.com/latinoamerica/argentina/deuda...
That's opposite of Ortodox dogma.
Downside is the devaluation of the Lira, but this also has an upside; Turkish exports become more competitive.
Turkish exports become more competitive
This is neither automatic, nor blanket. "Turkish exports" are a result of internal production of inputs, plus imports of inputs, followed by a "value add" phase, followed by exports. In many cases, the greatly increased cost of imported inputs meets or exceeds the export gains.Also, the naïve view that currency deval is always beneficial to exports is simply untrue. It always complex and multifactor for each scenario and each country... and even each good. A better general rule: A modest, consistent devaluation of currency is good for your exports, as it allows enough time for your value add staged to find internally produced substitute inputs. If deval is very fast, few businesses can adapt fast enough. If deval is very slow, it is hard to notice the effect.
Can you explain how it can exceed the export gain?
Say there is some Turkish export product, to keep it simple let's say it's a car which needs some metal as an input, that has to be imported. If the Lira goes down, this means the metal becomes more expensive in terms of Lira's. So this has to be accounted for in the price of the exported cars. However, that accounted price increase is the same as the rise in import price. What is left is the added value within Turkey, which has become cheaper because of the Lira drop.
So even though export price drops are slower than the drop of the Lira, they still drop.
Does this follow necessarily? If wage-earners have a fair degree of bargaining power or if wages are indexed, then the decrease in value of the lira will result in an increase in nominal wages. And in a condition of steady but substantial inflation, currency can be reduced to a medium of exchange rather than serving as a store of value - or in the case of contract negotiations, as an indication of the future value. Chances are, wage earners and others contracting for future delivery will just naturally take inflation into account when arranging the contract. Their payments might be in lira, but they way they set their prices is derived from the lira/euro exchange.
This is all basically what anti-inflation hawks mean when they say "we have to prevent inflation expectations hardening" etc. They want people to believe that a dollar today will have about the same value as a dollar next year.
So if you have a generally stable currency that depreciates and finds a new level, it might make the economy more competitive. If you have a currency that regularly varies, sometimes up, sometimes down, a depreciation might not mean much to its competitiveness (because an investor expects that the depreciation today has no relation to its value next year). And if you have a currency that is steadily declining, well, everyone has already accounted for that possibility so relative prices quickly adjust to return to the previous levels.
I never thought about tourism this way. Hat tip! WTO says:
Tourism is an export sector. It is a source of foreign exchange earnings; it grows a countryʻs national output; it is subject to the rigours of the international marketplace.
You wrote: "that has doubled in size as a % of GDP"To clarify this phrase: Do you mean: Tourism, as a share of GDP, has _recently_ doubled? Google tells me: 2014: 4.7% -> 2019: 11% (LGTM)
Or do you mean something else? (I promise: I am not nitpicking.)
At some point it makes more sense for commodity producers to leave the oil or copper in the ground because the commodity in the ground is more valuable than what can be earned digging it up, converting it to cash and the losses of holding the cash relative to inflation and taxes.
When things reach that point nations typically have enforced capital controls, fixed exchange rates, and then will nationalize commodity producers and will attempt to implement some form of commodity price controls. Production drops to nothing and the end result is usually a concentration of wealth and power in a small percentage of well connected individuals who strip the country of wealth. This leads to entrenched strong men and oligarchs (Russia, Venezula, Zimbabwe).
The best part is that initially the middle class cheers inflation with rising property values and wages. As the inevitable enshittification and looting of the economy ensues it isn’t obvious that a choice was made and who is to blame. The misery is blamed on foreign powers, the political opposition, and the poor while power and wealth end up in the hands of a few.
Has it? Everyone in the West was smugly predicting hyperinflation for the Turks in spring of 2022, but it just hasn't materialized.
The results have been grim for the lira, to say the least.
The episode finishes with a note that they've appointed a new finance minister who has said "the country has to return to a rational basis for its economic policy". So we'll see what changes are made - or whether this person lasts in this role for very long.
1. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/1180819327 [transcript]