The worm is turning and the top power-mods are going to get Caesar'd.
It's an obviously choreographed play and Reddit is going to win this one.
But I guess with the way things are going that may not be a problem to consider in the coming years.
I'm not so sure that the subs "naturally" replacing themselves will work out so well.
First, top moderators are very experienced at doing the specialized work of moderating high-traffic subreddits. They've built up automations and other modes of operation that have been created and refined over years (and Reddit is also shutting down some of these methods next month). So this is like a manager saying "Fine, my whole team can quit, I'll just hire new employees, they're all replaceable." That is eventually true, but that doesn't mean there will be no suffering if you allow your entire team to quit instead of trying to appease them.
Second, I can't imagine Reddit's traffic numbers aren't hurting right now. I'm one of the most Reddit-addicted people out there and it's been downright useless the last two days. There is basically no content and I keep seeing the same things because only a tiny selection of subreddits hit the front page. Personally, I've actually found myself on Instagram of all things. What if this just breaks my habit and turns me in another direction to replace that habit?
Third, the motivation to create or move to alternatives is spiking, and I'm not sure we can predict when that momentum hits a critical mass. Subs "naturally" replacing themselves still depends on their core engagers sticking to Reddit itself. Reddit is somewhat lucky that they aren't in Digg's situation where there was a single completely obvious alternative available straight away, but the fact that we're hearing people talk repeatedly about Mastodon (which has grown by 4x in less than a year), Lemmy, and Kbin can't be dismissed as a complete nothing.
Uff i ve been trying to find them , and also trying to make mine more active but it doesn't seem to be workign ...
I'm fine with not providing them with content or ad views anymore if they don't want to work with 3rd party developers.
Maybe I'll build myself a nice little HTML-scrapper app for Reddit instead.
There is a vocal amount of non-mods who are also participating.
Also "mods" are still users of reddit. When I'm an admin of a Facebook group, I'm still a 'facebook user'.
I suspect a vast majority of reddit users don't have a dog in this fight and just want to use the site.
That's the rub here compared to Twitter. It's not run by huge companies/content creators/personaliies providing news, but by users posting news or discussions. And if they leave, that does directly impact the content of the site, despite being a minority.
What's worse than pissing off the workers of your business is to piss off those who do all the work for free.
tbh right now it feels like mods, and especially power-mods (who are moding several high traffic subs), are revolting. I actually enjoy this blackout because a lot of small subs became active refuge for people who doesn't really care about the whole drama. Honestly I'm curious how this will play out but I can see subs just "naturally" replacing themselves with new ones.
fyi 92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people https://imgur.com/a/rjE8YuW as discussed here too https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23173018. And it's probably got worse in the last 2 years.