News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by scaredginger on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:04PM (#36304206)
For me, the discomfort is that Mr Beast's content relies on exploiting people's desperation due to the lack of social safety net. It's not his fault that they're in such dire straits to begin with, but he's nonetheless behaving opportunistically and his actions have no chance of changing the system that landed these people in such tough situations
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by voidhorse on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:27PM (#36304368)
Right, exactly. It takes advantage of systemic problems and relies on the perpetuation of those very problems for its continued feasibility and existence. This is why it feels kinda dirty and wrong to us even though it has a surface presentation of being "morally good".

It's sort of like a recast economic version of colonial white savior ideology—"educate" the primitives—"donate" to the impoverished, all while ensuring the inequalities and social division persist.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by cm2012 on Monday June 12, 2023 @11:15PM (#36304713)
Would it better if he paid the people to make beads or dig holes instead of entertaining his viewers?
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by namarie on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:39AM (#36305911)
I think so, yes. It'd be even better if he just gave the money, no strings attached.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by junon on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:36AM (#36307740)
But then he'd have no money to give away. I don't see how it's this difficult to understand. Either you have Mr Beast as we do now - curing blindness and deafness, giving people houses and cars, raising millions for tangible, proven reforestation and sea cleanup efforts - or we don't have Mr Beast at all.

I also find his videos uncomfortable to watch for many of the same reasons stated here, but I don't find them harmful, and I can appreciate how he's helped these people.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by garte on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @07:29AM (#36308583)
But these videos only get watched exactly _because_ they are demeaning. So the problem is the nature of the videos itself and this alone disqualifies any good this guy supposedly does.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by junon on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @12:09PM (#36312308)
I don't agree with that assertion at all.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by blitzar on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @06:05AM (#36307947)
That would be like the pimp giving their stable of ho's money and not making them prostitute themselves.

Who then would pay for their pimp-mobile and bling, and the upkeep of the ho's?

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by HDThoreaun on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @12:21AM (#36305266)
He’s making these peoples lives better though. How would him not doing this stuff help anyone? Just because he’s not overthrowing the system the happiness he’s provided is worthless?
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by operator-name on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @03:55AM (#36307012)
https://nitter.lacontrevoie.fr/pookleblinky/status/130932576...

In doing good, Mr Beast bring to light the uncomfortable lack of support we provide as a society.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by HDThoreaun on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:14AM (#36310517)
Mr beast is not able to upend society and convince enough voters to provide a better support system. You’re advocating for doing nothing, that’s what would happen if he focused on politics instead of fun videos.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by em-bee on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @03:17PM (#36315449)
i don't see the parent comment as suggesting that pointing out the lack of support in our society is a bad thing. personally i think pointing out how the social net is failing is exactly what we need. if that is really the effect that his videos have then that is good.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by em-bee on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @07:39AM (#36308710)
is he really? how much good is a one-time payment of a lump of money helping? sure, it may allow someone to afford something they could not before, but unless they are able to invest that money into something that will improve their live for the long term, then such a payment doesn't really do anyhing to actually change their situation.

one time payments need to be used strategically, and we know from lottery winners that many don't know how to do that.

if we want to help people we need to work on changing systems that allow them to raise their income or lower their monthly expenses or carefully guide them to use one time payments to fix a problem in their life that will have a long term benefit.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by em-bee on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @08:51AM (#36309506)
the eye surgery is obviously an example of a one time payment with a long term benefit. if he is able to generate income to solve more problems like that then he is indeed helping people.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by sodapopcan on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:39AM (#36310881)
Also paying off debt.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by HDThoreaun on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:25AM (#36310656)
I think he’s doing more good than you will in your life. I donate half my income to the global poor and I think he’s doing more good than I will.

Keep on working on fixing our system, but it doesn’t make sense to complain that others aren’t when you are extremely unlikely to succeed.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by em-bee on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:25PM (#36313564)
i have no qualms with MrBeast's business model. using his youtube videos to raise money to help people in whichever way is certainly not a problem. most of the entertainment industry is doing a lot worse (by keeping the profits to themselves).

the question is not, who is doing more, but whether what anyone of us is doing has any lasting effects. so it matters how the money is used. most of what i have seen from MrBeast is giving random amounts of money to individuals, which sometimes can be helpful, but often only provides short term relief. his recent examples of paying for eye surgery or funding an orphanage are an improvement over that, and if that is where MrBeast's philanthropy is heading, then i am all for it.

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by bigger_cheese on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @12:51AM (#36305499)
I agree with you, I have only seen one of his videos in which he paid for people to have cataract surgery I found it strangely absurd.

The issue is if he was to instead start using money to tackle systemic issues then it moves beyond philanthropy and it becomes political. "I paid for 1000 people to have cataract surgery" as a video hits a lot differently to "I lobbied congress to make cataract surgery free"

Systemic change is hard and a lot of people won't want to engage with it. It is easy to look at an altruistic act and say "this is a good thing" a lot harder to question the underlying causes that necessitated the act.

There is a famous quote "When I give food to the poor they call me a saint. When I ask why they are poor they call me a communist."

Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by veave on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:55AM (#36307479)
Why should he be in charge of changing the system?
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by red-iron-pine on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:11PM (#36313363)
Or put simply, he's not lobbying for improvements to minimum wage, or housing, or healthcare, or transportation -- he's schleppin for views. It's poverty-porn.
Re:MrBeast Became the Willy Wonka of YouTube by TheLML on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @06:45AM (#36323933)
The basic counter point to that is that dozens of millionaire content creators partake, too. For many people it's also a novelty to be in a MrBeast video. For those already rich content creators an additional motivator may be the clout, of course.