News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by atleastoptimal on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:26PM (#36283407)
Is the inevitable fate of any social media site to be antagonistic to its most dedicated users?
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by maccard on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:40PM (#36283556)
I don't know if it's inevitable, but it's clear at this point that people are unwilling to pay $ for access to the content in the forms we know now. I think until we find a better way of having people pay for content and curation, we're likely to see this happen again. That said, Reddit has (so far) lasted a decade on the throne, which is a third of the life of the www. It's not like there's anoter competitor sitting there ready to dethrone it so I suspect it's here for another while.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Ekaros on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:48PM (#36283673)
When was a last time a big and popular social mediaish or like platform properly died? Media companies have not survived, but platforms seem to have been sticky or then I just haven't used them.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by philistine on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:01PM (#36283843)
I would be interest in seeing Pinterest’s usage numbers. That place has turned into a Wish.com ad farm faster than you can blink.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by MostlyStable on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:59PM (#36283806)
So I think it's relatively clear that Reddit doesn't _want_ to reach some kind of deal with 3rd party apps, but honestly, I think that if they _had_ wanted that, most of these apps could have survived with a much smaller userbase of paying customers. I would have paid the $3-5/month it would have cost to keep my preferred app. And while yes, it definitely would have been fewer people, my guess is that it would have been enough to worth continuing. And if Reddit had been willing to figure out some kind of deal with ads, it might have been even more.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by fnimick on Sunday June 11, 2023 @01:40PM (#36283558)
Yes: https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/

First, platforms are good to users to attract them. Then, they abuse users to attract advertisers. Then, once they think they have a moat, they abuse both sides to extract as much money as possible before it all crashes down.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by chx on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:17PM (#36284035)
It is astonishing to watch the enshittification of Reddit and StackExchange at the same time.

I would say, as much as there is such a thing and it can be dated, Jun 9, 2023 was the end of Web 2.0 -- we found out reddit is not backing down and SE has disabled the backup job to archive.org. For SE the death march to enshittification has been much clearer, starting with the hiring of the new CEO, the firing of community managers to recently first completely ignoring and then going against the community on AI. Reddit just has been mostly wasting their time and money until they realized they need to make money and as Doctorow says, the siren song of enshittification is irresistible.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by ItsMonkk on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:30PM (#36284205)
This is not happening at the same time by pure chance. Once the Fed turned off the free money, all of the negative profit companies need to adapt or die.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by chx on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:54PM (#36284966)
Yeah but it's surprising to see neither have better ideas.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by mostlysimilar on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:23PM (#36284691)
Link to the same article on his personal blog: https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys

Why? It's right the header:

> No trackers, no ads. Black type, white background. Privacy policy: we don't collect or retain any data at all ever period.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by yanderekko on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:08PM (#36283911)
When the most dedicated users are fundamentally hostile to the idea that the social media site may need to limit features for the sake of profitability, it seems likely. Rhetorically the activists here are a step or two away from treating Reddit as a public utility and free API access as a human right. At least until they shift focus to finding wrongthinkers that they want to ban again, then we'll shift back to the usual "it's a private platform sweetie and your presence has negative value" smugness.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by michaelmrose on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:25PM (#36284137)
You are fighting a straw man you yourself erected. Nobody believes they have a right to reddit but nor does reddit have a right to viewership. They are trying to leverage the value their communities bring to the platform. There is nothing morally wrong with this.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by yanderekko on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:33PM (#36284235)
>Nobody believes they have a right to reddit

When people castigate the mere idea that Reddit should be trying to guarantee a return to its investors - and I can point you to examples of this if you wish - it's hard to interpret this as anything other than people saying that their interest to unfettered API access is more important than the interest that investors have in a positive ROI. I guess you could say that this isn't establishing a "right to Reddit" but that seems like hair-splitting to me - "we don't have a right to Reddit but anything that would take Reddit away from us would be evil."

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Eisenstein on Sunday June 11, 2023 @06:00PM (#36286171)
> t's hard to interpret this as anything other than people saying that their interest to unfettered API access is more important than the interest that investors have in a positive ROI.

Reddit is removing all api access to for-profit apps. Anyone willing to pay who contacted reddit has been ignored. By acting in bad-faith, they lost all moral ground at all.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by michaelmrose on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:33PM (#36287518)
Users are deciding whether or not they should trade their comments, moderation, and submissions to reddit in exchange for the platform reddit provides.

Anything that would take functionality or access away isn't "evil" it merely decreases the value proposition potentially putting it below a threshold where its not worth bothering to provide the content that make's reddit worth visiting leaving the shell of reddit owned by its corporate overlords worth little.

The protest is demonstrating to Reddits CEO that it is in fact a negotiation because while they have no right to tell Reddit how to run its ship they don't have to join they voyage much less act as crew.

It's not their job to make Reddit profitable. If they wanted reddit to be profitable they could have not spent years adding negative value to the platform and wasting expensive developer hours. Alternatively they could have made third party app access a paid feature instead of asking developers to predict and then pay for usage.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by yanderekko on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:15AM (#36288383)
>Anything that would take functionality or access away isn't "evil" it merely decreases the value proposition potentially putting it below a threshold where its not worth bothering to provide the content that make's reddit worth visiting leaving the shell of reddit owned by its corporate overlords worth little.

Sure, this would make sense, but obviously there's a lot of moralized rhetoric being thrown around here which go beyond a dispassionate expression of "if you do this Reddit will no longer be personally valuable to me and I will leave." Uncharitably, people are trying to wrap up their ill-based moral indignation in these dispassionate expressions - "if you do this than I'll be so outraged that Reddit will no longer be personally valuable to me and I will leave." The moral indignation still lacks justification, though.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by atemerev on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:09PM (#36283930)
Yes, if you want to keep that sweet growth. If you are OK staying where you are as a relatively niche outlet (like HN), you are safe. But transitioning to the general public stage will require you to sell your soul. No getting around that.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by CSMastermind on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:12PM (#36283974)
I've long thought that the only way to make a sustainable social media platform is to have it be controlled by its contributors.

Governance is human problem and not a technical one. We have a few millennia of experience organizing and governing human effort, yet the control structure of every subreddit is akin to some kind of Oligarchy with unelected moderators wielding considerable power. These moderators in turn are at the mercy of the Oligarchical Reddit admins.

A better system would be to offer different governance types as a choice for organizing the subreddit. Have different types of built in voting mechanisms if people want to use them but still allow 'dictator' subreddits if people want to use them.

Set up a revenue sharing system where each subreddit gets the portion of money they generate for Reddit. Allow the governance structure the subreddit has decided on to dictate the way those funds are split between moderators and contributors.

Then set up some sort of governance structure that rolls up the Subreddits. As an American I'm biased towards the way the US does things but I'm sure there are other good ways to do this as well. You could have the equivalent to 'states' similar to the sections of a newspaper: Sports, Entertainment, Money, Technology, Travel, etc. with the equivalent of 'counties' within those (football, baseball, basketball or books, video games, movies, etc).

Replace the corporate Reddit structure with the equivalent of a federal government: have the 'states' hold a 'constitutional convention' and delimit powers that the corporation should have and reserve every other right to the individual 'states'. Then you can have some kind of election system that governs the corporation, CEO being equivalent to president, etc.

Then you have a system that broadly aligns the interests of the participants and provides mechanisms for information to be transmitted when needed for decision making.

---

The other problem that social media needs to solve is that of anonymity and content presentation. Here I think Reddit fails by having a global karma count instead of one that's localized to the 'state' and subreddit you're on. If they did that then users could actually gain reputation and credibility within the context of a space.

They also should offer identity services that allow the verification of information like employment, citizenship, education, etc. that some subreddits have their own haphazard mechanisms for verifying. This would allow moderators to leverage this type of credential more easily and users to have more trust in sharing them (because they're sharing with Reddit proper not some random subreddit moderator).

Finally, they should have some sort of verification system that lets users tie their accounts to their real identity. Obviously anonymous accounts should still be allowed but this type of verification system tamps down on many of the problems that social media platforms face.

---

If anyone wants to fund the development of a platform like this let me know lol

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by shagie on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:32PM (#36285939)
> Here I think Reddit fails by having a global karma count instead of one that's localized to the 'state' and subreddit you're on.

This information exists and is maintained on the backend.

Pull up your profile on old.reddit and click on "show karma breakdown by subreddit".

Note that this isn't publicly available (/u/johnsmith1234568 has 1k karma in /r/someIdeoligcalSub - they're banned from participating here).

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by newqer on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:18PM (#36300374)
Complete with a police force and secret service.

Of course an independent judiciary system to keep the powers at be in check.

I'm going to be a virtual lawyer that specializes in subreddit law.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by cragfar on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:23PM (#36284117)
This is 99% manufactured drama by the power mods wanting to be able to keep modding 100+ subreddits with their 3rd party tools and AI companies wanting to mine reddit data for free. The fact that Spez has let them do it for this long has probably put him in the hot seat.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by TX81Z on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:42PM (#36284306)
The fact that he isn’t keeping his free labor force happy is the problem. Other companies put hundreds of millions of dollars and thousands of staff into moderation. This moron has people doing that FOR FREE and he’s pissing them off.

Seriously, do you have any clue how much just YouTube alone spends on content moderation? Or Facebook? These are absolutely massive investments.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by cragfar on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:47PM (#36284361)
There's always another power hungry person to step up. The site would probably be better if the entire crop were removed outright. How many social media websites have you used where you can't even comment on a basic news forum for the first two months?
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Eisenstein on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:25PM (#36284708)
Why don't you mod then? Everyone thinks it is an easy job with all these 'power' perks, then when they get onboard they figure out it is actually a lot of work and mostly just pissing people off because you can never please everyone.

It is like people who say 'those who cannot do, teach'. Hey, maybe teaching is hard work and most people suck at it?

The type of person who thinks mods are all power tripper do-badders who could be easily replaced is usually the type of person who doesn't bother reading the rules of the community before posting, or who resorts instantly to insults in disagreements, or who think it is funny to piss people off.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by cragfar on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:53PM (#36284964)
Do you even use reddit? I'm genuinely curious because your post comes off as someone who doesn't know how it works. To be a mod I would have to cozy up to the current mods and play politics to become one. I was banned from r/news years ago for saying the migrant caravan existed in response to a comment saying there was no evidence that migrant caravans existed and linked one of the multiple videos. The message was simply "get out" followed by a presumptive muting so I couldn't respond to it. I was also blanket banned from ~70 subs because I made one post correcting someone in r/nonewnormal.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by TX81Z on Sunday June 11, 2023 @04:09PM (#36285095)
“If you think everyone around you is an asshole, chances are…”
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by cragfar on Sunday June 11, 2023 @04:31PM (#36285331)
That's not even close to what I was saying. Were you just hoping it was with that response?
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by BrotherBisquick on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:57PM (#36286150)
And that there is why the system of volunteer moderators doesn't work.

You bring up legitimate concerns and you're met with either stony silence, or you get called an asshole.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Eisenstein on Sunday June 11, 2023 @06:19PM (#36286314)
How do you propose to engage with people who are antagonistic?

Have you ever worked a customer service job?

By thinking that people who deal with the public and their complaints and entitled attitude constantly are the ones who are unreasonable by default, you show a powerful ignorance about how many people act when they want something and can't immediately get it for any reason.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by TX81Z on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:35PM (#36287202)
I’ll never figure with an internet this vast, anybody would be unable to take a hint that a particular community doesn’t want them and move on to one that does.

If a community bans you it’s the wrong community for you, it’s not a conspiracy at play, you just don’t belong.

Find the people who do share your views and go play in that sandbox.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by delecti on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:10PM (#36285722)
I've used reddit regularly for 14 years and have never been banned from any sub. I share Eisenstein's assumptions. Also, having looked up what r/nonewnormal was, I don't fault any mod for noticing a pattern and trying to save themselves some trouble, even if casting a wide net has false positives.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Eisenstein on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:17PM (#36285796)
> To be a mod I would have to cozy up to the current mods and play politics to become one.

Anyone can start a subbreddit. And in your subreddit, you can do all the work it takes to create a community, and then you can ban people for whatever reason you want and feel that tasty power that the mods love so much, and see how awesome it is to get cursed at, told how terrible you are and how much your community sucks, and how they are going to dox you and plant meth on you so that you lose custody of your children.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by TX81Z on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:39PM (#36287232)
“Yes, but you see the problem is I want to pee in YOUR pool. If I were to build my own pool then I’d have to swim YOUR pee.”
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by BrotherBisquick on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:54PM (#36286131)
> Why don't you mod then?

because the current crop of powermods have a stranglehold on who and who cannot be appointed to be a mod, and they refuse to take applications from anyone with opinions right of Trotsky.

No one's saying being a mod is easy. We're saying we want the power-hungry extremists to get out of the way, and to let reasonable professionals do the job instead, professionals whose only interest is to enforce the rules as written, and not to exclude people who disagree with them.

Your argument is circular, and is perverse. Your powermod friends are hurting the community, and everyone is calling for them to step down, and you respond with "hey you do the job if you think it's easy!" WTF? We can't do it because you won't get the hell out of the way!

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by Eisenstein on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:10PM (#36287058)
You want to take over already existing communities instead of building your own? Who is the extremist here?

Stop being lazy and put in the work, then whine about your situation. As it is you just sound like someone annoyed because things don't work the way you like but you don't want to do anything but complain.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by BrotherBisquick on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:49PM (#36286091)
The powers that be have deemed that they don't care what the "free labor force" wants or thinks. They care about the experience of the users, not the experience of the rulers of petty internet fiefdoms.

Reddit has indicated that it wants to pay for content moderation. So be it. Who are you to tell them how they run their company?

Maybe when we move away from "volunteers" then the "volunteers" can get real jobs that pay real money! It'll be good for them.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by TX81Z on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:41PM (#36287253)
That’s my point: they benefit from a huge volunteer labor subsidy. They can’t afford to moderate it themselves as they clearly don’t have the financial resources.

They are free to run the biz into the ground, won’t be the first or last to do so. Meanwhile YouTube will keep printing cash.

Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by JasserInicide on Sunday June 11, 2023 @02:47PM (#36284356)
That's just how most VC-funded projects run. Give away the product for free to build a community. Once it's large enough, start building the real money making products and start exploiting said community. Then IPO/get acquired and fuck off with money.
Re:Reddit Strike Has Started by freediver on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:20AM (#36290049)
That is true of any business, as long as the business model does not align incentives.