News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by tomcam on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:19AM (#36268699)
In his book “Practical Ethics” he recommends infanticide up to 2 years old as a logical extension to abortion.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:36AM (#36268784)
Yes. Do you have a point to add to that? Do you feel there’s some reason he’s obviously wrong for example?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by yossarian1408 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:44AM (#36268809)
Relevant context. Singer has a lot of clout because people read some of his stuff in a first year philosophy class. For those who didn't get the memo that the man is a crazy misanthrope, him taking the idea of infanticide seriously is a pretty good indicator of what his specific grift actually is.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by burgh on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:39AM (#36269058)
Why not take infanticide seriously? A 23 months old human is generally less intelligent than a dog and has a consciousness vastly different from us. If the lives of people (and everyone else) got better from killing such a being, then why not?

Certainly seems less cruel and unnecessary than forcing a pig live a tortuous life until it's killed solely for the taste of its corpse.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:15AM (#36269233)
> A 23 months old human is generally less intelligent than a dog

Wow. Do you have any experience with little kids? With 23 months my daughter was drawing pictures, singing songs, laughing at my jokes, reenacting scenes from theater plays, etc.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:18AM (#36270675)
The question isn’t if 2 year olds are intelligent it’s if dogs are of comparable intelligence to a human 2 year old. They are.

> As for language, the average dog can learn 165 words, including signals, and the "super dogs" (those in the top 20 percent of dog intelligence) can learn 250 words, Coren says. "The upper limit of dogs' ability to learn language is partly based on a study of a border collie named Rico who showed knowledge of 200 spoken words and demonstrated 'fast-track learning,' which scientists believed to be found only in humans and language learning apes," Coren said.

> Dogs can also count up to four or five, said Coren. And they have a basic understanding of arithmetic and will notice errors in simple computations, such as 1+1=1 or 1+1=3.

> Four studies he examined looked how dogs solve spatial problems by modeling human or other dogs' behavior using a barrier type problem. Through observation, Coren said, dogs can learn the location of valued items (treats), better routes in the environment (the fastest way to a favorite chair), how to operate mechanisms (such as latches and simple machines) and the meaning of words and symbolic concepts (sometimes by simply listening to people speak and watching their actions).

> During play, dogs are capable of deliberately trying to deceive other dogs and people in order to get rewards, said Coren. "And they are nearly as successful in deceiving humans as humans are in deceiving dogs."

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/08/090810025241.h...

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:12PM (#36273157)
I have been replying to OP who literally said:

> A 23 months old human is generally less intelligent than a dog and has a consciousness vastly different from us. If the lives of people (and everyone else) got better from killing such a being, then why not?

So what is your point?

Is today "rationalist edgeloard"-day?

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by burgh on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:52PM (#36276085)
Seems like you can easily relate to 23 month old humans. That's cool. Now try to expand that empathy to other entities of comparable mental faculties and complexity of emotions. Then imagine the horrors we, as a species, casually inflict on them. If you need inspiration, here is a link I found from google: https://thehumaneleague.org/article/factory-farmed-pigs

Now tell me how a painless infanticide (arguably committed for utilitarian good) is even nearly as bad.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @07:21PM (#36276337)
In fact, I do acknowledge that many things we do to animals are horrific. But this is just whataboutism.

So you are really telling me that you are ok with killing little kids for "utilitarian good" (whatever that is)?

You still haven't answered my question: do you have any real-life experience with little kids? I am pretty sure you haven't, otherwise you wouldn't spew such obvious bullshit.

Now let's remember what you said in your original post:

> Why not take infanticide seriously? A 23 months old human is generally less intelligent than a dog and has a consciousness vastly different from us.

Honestly, that's one of the most fucked up things I have ever read on HN. Congratulations!

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by burgh on Sunday June 11, 2023 @04:26AM (#36279397)
I'm sure it feels like that to a loving parent, especially when you think about your own child. Your feelings are valid.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by chasd00 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @08:45AM (#36269999)
a 23 month old human will beg for their life. Doesn't that contradict his position on killing sentient animals?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:23PM (#36277687)
Do you think dogs and pigs who are aware of what’s about to happen don’t?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by chasd00 on Sunday June 11, 2023 @10:23AM (#36281694)
That the point, the author can’t have it both ways.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:23AM (#36289136)
Peter Singer aims for consistency, for not having it both ways. If killing a being of neural structure X is moral then have the same standard for human and non-human animals. He isn’t pretending that being in or out of its mother is morally relevant. If killing a nine month old “fetus” is moral killing a 3 minute old baby is. Singer will bite all those bullets.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:58AM (#36268862)
Are you being serious? Or is this just some wicked kind of sarcasm?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:19AM (#36269251)
To the downvoters: do you have any experience with little kids? As a father of a 2 year old, it is pretty obvious what's wrong with infanticide...
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday June 10, 2023 @07:08AM (#36269485)
Well, I am a former embryo and fetus. I was given the opportunity to be born, and so I became pro-life. That seems like a pretty obvious and logical decision.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @07:22AM (#36269561)
Abortion of a 12 week old fetus is in no way comparable to infanticide. That's the point I am trying to make.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday June 10, 2023 @07:29AM (#36269607)
What makes it different? Umbilical cord? Immersed in amniotic fluid? Roundly dehumanized and unpersoned by society?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:08AM (#36270157)
Do you eat meat?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:31AM (#36270311)
Not on Fridays, no. For many years I've offered this up as a sacrifice for my little brothers and sisters who are murdered because of a "human right".

I find it personally revolting that people would assent to my own murder. I am the product of an unplanned pregnancy, and it is mere happenstance that I was not strangled, torn limb from limb, had my skull crushed, and my spine snipped apart at the nape of the neck, then carefully extracted piece by bloody piece, reassembled in a dish (to make sure that nothing was left behind to infect mom - abortions are "safe"), and dumped in a biological waste bin to be incinerated. I escaped that fate, but others do not, so I abstain from meat on every Friday of the year.

I do not understand why you and all the others would not assent to my grisly murder as an infant, as a 50-year-old, or perhaps not even as a feeble and helpless 96-year-old hospital patient, but you would readily take up the speculum and scalpel just because I had an umbilical cord attached.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:06AM (#36270561)
Then why are you ok with slaughtering and eating animals that are more sentient than a 12 week old fetus?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by NoZebra120vClip on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:13AM (#36270634)
tu quoque
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:36AM (#36270836)
Cultures that don’t practice infanticide are the exception in the historical and anthropological record. Not killing your children was invented by the Egyptians, taken up by the Jews and spread by the Christians, Muslims, presumably other Abrahamic faiths and cultures derived from them. It has not been obvious to the huge majority of people ever born that there was anything wrong with infanticide. If you think it is obviously wrong you might want to make an argument of some kind.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:08PM (#36273103)
> Cultures that don’t practice infanticide are the exception in the historical and anthropological record

That's a non-argument. People did all kinds of horrible things in the past (human sacrifice, cruel corporal punishment, slavery) and yet it is now obvious to us that these things are bad. I think it is safe to say that infanticide is one of the things that we don't need to debate in modern times.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:21PM (#36277675)
You’re saying that it’s obvious infanticide is wrong. I’m pointing out that most humans ever have disagreed. Then you’re saying it’s obvious again and that it doesn’t need to be debated. Your “argument” is that the current moral fashions of your society are true and that this is obvious to all.

At best this is an attempt at persuasion by “Everyone else is doing it and so should you.”

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by spacechild1 on Sunday June 11, 2023 @05:42AM (#36279725)
Again, the same thing can be said about slavery.

In fact, if something is perceived as horrible by most people in current society, I think the burden is on you to explain why and when it is justified. (So far your only argument was that people in the old times did it, which is no argument at all.)

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by barry-cotter on Monday June 12, 2023 @07:16PM (#36302760)
Ok, so you’re assuming moral progress of some kind. Do you have any principled arguments for whatever it is you believe?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by avgcorrection on Saturday June 10, 2023 @04:57AM (#36268860)
The “cutoff” always comes up in abortion debates, and when someone argues for a very late term abortion, the other side is sure to bring up infanticide. Polite people/amateur philosophers leave it there. Professional philosophers pick up the slack and deal with the heinous leftover questions…
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by tomcam on Saturday June 10, 2023 @01:28PM (#36272593)
Legislators, and therefore voters must also deal with the heinous leftover questions.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by basisword on Saturday June 10, 2023 @05:36AM (#36269044)
If it’s in relation to abortion cutoff times it’s an important question to ask. I’ve never met someone with a rational answer to that question. It mostly boils down to what they personally feel comfortable with emotionally (and that’s fine, but not something you can apply in law for all people).
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by George83728 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:10AM (#36269212)
> It mostly boils down to what they personally feel comfortable with emotionally (and that’s fine, but not something you can apply in law for all people).

Every democratic country has laws which are motivated by the way people feel emotionally. Check out this map: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_in_Europe#/media/File...

12 weeks in Germany, 24 weeks in the UK. Why is there such a difference? Because these laws are based on how people feel.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by iinnPP on Saturday June 10, 2023 @08:39AM (#36269973)
Canada's is legal up until the fetus leaves the womb. It's also possible to kill a fetus inside the womb and suffer no consequence for said killing.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/arianna-goberdhan-fetus-homi...

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by specialist on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:15AM (#36270193)
That Canadian law does not cover the edge case of first-degree murder for a fetus is a hole in the rules, not permission to kill.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by iinnPP on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:48AM (#36270445)
I'm not sure what you're trying to say. Do you have more recent information that shows it is now illegal to forcefully terminate the functionality of a 40-week fetus while in the womb in Canada?

Calling it a hole in the rules is inaccurate. It's not a person. You can disagree if you want.

My post was informational and intentionally lacking opinion.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by specialist on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:02AM (#36270534)
FFS.

The hole in the rules called out, from the OC you linked:

A handful of private member's bills introduced in Parliament over the last couple of decades have tried to remedy what seems to be an arbitrary distinction in law. The most recent was in 2016, when Saskatchewan MP Cathay Wagantall tabled Bill C-225, which would have made it a "separate offence to cause injury or death to a preborn child during the commission of an offence against the child's mother."

[deletia]

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by iinnPP on Saturday June 10, 2023 @01:03PM (#36272342)
It's not a hole, it's working as intended. It is desired by groups in Canada who favor abortion rights[0]

I'm just replying to the other countries laws and including Canada. Which is related to the article really, more so than many countries.

You seem to think I am siding on a negative opinion, but I am not.

0: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/private-members-bill-violen...

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by basisword on Saturday June 10, 2023 @08:49AM (#36270025)
Well yes, obviously there are laws based (maybe) on majority opinion or average opinion. What I mean is that opinions will vary and you can’t satisfy everyone. There is no objective right or wrong cutoff hence why there is philosophical debate about it.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by SanderNL on Saturday June 10, 2023 @06:09AM (#36269210)
That’s so interesting. Thanks for the book recommendation.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by specialist on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:13AM (#36270181)
Ugh, that's awful.

Apologies, but I could not find any recommendations for killing babies. Please clarify.

Practical Ethics 3rd ed [2011], Peter Singer https://libgen.is/book/index.php?md5=02C20FF721FBFC562268D14...

Perhaps an earlier edition advocated infanticide?

https://libgen.is/search.php?&req=singer+Practical+Ethics&ph...

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by FrustratedMonky on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:52AM (#36271007)
Seems logical. What is the problem?
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by FrustratedMonky on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:59AM (#36271080)
Counter example.

Kids with Down Syndrome as part of the defect have a cute personality, they are very smiley.

People on the right choose to have these kids in order to keep them as pets.

There are tests for Down Syndrome. There are people on the right that choose to have these babies and not abort them. This is choosing to force someone to live with a disability.

If we did not have a test, and have chance to abort them, then shouldn't we allow abortion after they are born and see the defects. Why force kids to a lifetime of suffering because of Religious Virtue Signaling.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by tomcam on Saturday June 10, 2023 @01:37PM (#36272697)
That is repugnant, rude, provably wrong, and ignorant af.
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by FrustratedMonky on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:00PM (#36272979)
well, not provably
Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by dang on Saturday June 10, 2023 @03:38PM (#36274235)
We need you to stop using HN for ideological flamewar. You've been doing it a lot, and breaking the site guidelines a lot in other ways too, such as by crossing into personal attack:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36247136

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36243998

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36243288

and failing to edit out swipes:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36195095

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36195079

I don't want to ban you because I don't get an impression of malice or abuse from your comments, but we need you to review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the intended spirit of this site. Ideological battle, political battle, and flamewar are very much against that spirit. We want curious, thoughtful, substantive, respectful conversation. Please do that going forward, and refrain from posting when you can't.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by FrustratedMonky on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:54PM (#36277528)
Got it. Dumb luck I saw this post, it was hidden. I didn't know anything was getting flagged. Didn't know how to see these messages.

I'd say it is 50/50, some of my posts were responses in-kind, and to me, some seem more like the other person was the one with the problem, and maybe flagging is itself an attack. Definitely some gray area in interpreting these. And, there are definitely some hot button topics that get flames going everywhere, and I got in the crossfire.

But, I did review the guidelines, and your history of past warnings to others. So know there is a 'two wrongs don't make a right' rule.

So, I'll watch it. I'd rather keep HN as it is than fight.

Re:Tyler Cowen Speaks to Peter Singer by RobinL on Saturday June 10, 2023 @02:18PM (#36273264)
Whether you agree with him or not, this true argument is, of course, more nuanced and I do not think this is a helpful way of presenting his argument.

I believe the relevant section is page 169 of this: https://www.stafforini.com/docs/Singer%20-%20Practical%20eth...

Some of the text copied and pasted, but it should be read and interpreted in context:

ABORTION AND INFANTICIDE

There remains one major objection to the argument I have

advanced in favour of abortion. We have already seen that the strength of the conservative position lies in the difficulty liberals have in pointing to a morally significant line of demarcation between an embryo and a newborn baby. The standard liberal position needs to be able to point to some such line, because liberals usually hold that it is permissible to kill an embryo or fetus but not a baby. I have argued that the life of a fetus (and even more plainly, of an embryo) is of no greater value than the life of a nonhuman animal at a similar level of rationality, self-consciousness, awareness, capacity to feel. etc., and that since no fetus is a person no fetus has the same claim to life as a person. Now it must be admitted that these arguments apply to the newborn baby as much as to the fetus. A week-old baby is not a rational and self-conscious being, and there are many nonhuman animals whose rationality, self-consciousness, awareness, capacity to feel. and so on, exceed that of a human baby a week or a month old. If the fetus does not have the same claim to life as a person, it appears that the newborn baby does not either, and the life of a newborn baby is of less value to it than the life of a pig, a dog, or a chimpanzee is to the nonhuman animal.