"Renewable" is a broad set of terms. Importantly from your first link on GCP it says:
> Google is carbon neutral for our operations today, but aiming higher: our goal is to run on carbon-free energy, 24/7, at all of our data centers by 2030.
Carbon-free, 24x7, is a stronger commitment than carbon-neutral which would include using renewable power offsets. Amazon's methodology is at https://sustainability.aboutamazon.com/renewable-energy-meth... which makes this clear as well.
https://www.electricitymaps.com/blog/announcing-our-partners...
https://blog.google/inside-google/infrastructure/data-center...
It's like when I see the sign "0% pollution" on EVs, it's so far from the reality, it's the same order of magnitude of (direct and indirect) pollution than a fossil fuel vehicle, and a few order of magnitude larger than a bicycle (which is not exactly 0 too, it contains plastics, and a little bit of maintainance)
And OVH is a dumpster fire.
AWS now is basically "you don't know how to run a database, or a KV store, or a network, etc. so here it all is as an API with a markup." Some companies still have talent that knows how to run things efficiently and just need CPU, RAM, and storage.
The thing is that when you will need to leverage the other services of AWS, they will be there, while you will need to migrate if you're on one of those server providers.
I think, in practice, what folks are complaining about is that AWS has the worst UI known to man. In which case, you can use GCP for their nice UI and still get the benefits of a hyperscaler.
I don’t mean to say that the simpler services have no place in the market but it’s pretty narrow. The fact DO and Linode offer things like Kubernetes now is evidence of that.
That might suck, they leave their job, and you're stuck maintaining the monster.
When a developer starts whining they can't figure out how to use an IAM role, it usually means they want to run their entire application as a root user whose SSH key they have sitting in Dropbox.
Stay away from my software please.
AWS UI is filled with manual and tedious bullshit to do every day things. It really doesn't have to be this way, making things annoying to configure correctly leads to mistakes or lazy overly broad permissions.
If they weren't the first they wouldn't have made it.
Terraform isn't hard!
And in the world of AWS Terraform is still manual and tedious (compared to e.g. CDK).
So you would not trust most developers?
Even a lot of Sysadmins i.e. Devops find it confusing.
A lot of people just pretend it is fine by being ignorant and not learn any of it. They would follow 1-2 processes that works and never do anything else. You ask them why or how it works and you can't even get a real answer out of it.
Obviously not? Most developers are incompetent clowns. I don't feel this is controversial?
There are plenty of excellent, security conscience, etc developers who take a look at IAM or any of the other dozens of sticky AWS traps and run away screaming.
"AWS has the worst UI known to man, except for Azure and GCP".
It still amazes me that when you add members to AAD groups the interface pops up and tells you 'change may not be displayed yet'. It's like, YOU HAVE ONE JOB.
And this is mostly for security reasons: I'm not familiar with Azure but AWS and GCP setup is very complex and it's very easy to make a mistake that would impact the security of your infrastructure. Tier 2 providers like DO, Scaleway, Linode before Akamai, etc generally offer products whose setup you can fully understand and that helps a lot in giving you the confidence that you didn't mess up and shot yourself in the foot without knowing it.
I use AWS daily and have for the past 5 years, but despite all that I wheep
Yes, I'm speaking from experience.
Now compare the cost of it for a month/year compared to other providers
This is also a necessary for making the other AWS products appear attractive - customers are willing to pay for the engineering effort, training, lock-in and added complexity to use the fine grained "serverless" services because they are shown the the cost savings vs EC2.
It’s literally in the name… web services.
To put it another way: a DC in a wooden shack connected to a low carbon grid (France) surely has bad security but a low environmental footprint too.
And this Swedish startup is?
(though some stuff in AWS is painful like IAM, etc so maybe it can be done better)
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/18/greenwas...
https://earth.org/is-carbon-offset-a-form-of-greenwashing/
And there are plenty of dodgy players out there that large organizations use:
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/18/revealed...
And there are plenty of government programs that just don't work:
https://e360.yale.edu/features/phantom-forests-tree-planting...
I'm sitting here asking myself how much Amazon cares about that, but also wondering how the "unknown Swedish startup" will approach being green.
> The top 25 corporate solar users in 2022 include:
> Meta
> Amazon
> Apple
> Walmart
> Microsoft
https://www.seia.org/news/solarmeansbusiness2022
Just as one data point
Say a paper maker is about to cut down a forest in the US. It buys up the rights to do so for $1M. Then, instead, it sells $1M worth of carbon credits to Amazon (maybe for a premium) for its data center greenwashing and doesn't end up cutting the US forest.
But then, secretly, or through some shell company machinery, it buys a plot of land in the Amazon and cuts trees down anyway to match its demand. Even though US law makers evaluate the counterfactual of the paper maker cutting trees down in the US, the net amount of trees in the world goes down.
For example they buy a plot of land and then raze it, then they will plant 10k saplings and take that figure at face value even if most of those won't take and actually become trees.
Then they will estimate the CO2 captured by averaging it over the entire life of the tree (say 30 years) and count year 1 as if it captured 1/30 of the CO2 even though the carbon capture potential of tree is not constant throughout its life.
Beyond that they will double count the carbon credits of the plot of land by selling them twice.
Finally after all the above, they will sell the plots after ~5 years to buy some other plots and it will be razed anyway. No one actually checks that the carbon capture forest will be there in 10 years, let alone 30.
You can see more details on https://sustainability.aboutamazon.com/environment/renewable...
It's when there are mentions of "net zero" that carbon credits are purchased (which Amazon does too, but not for what we're talking about).
"In an evaluation of some of the world’s largest greenhouse gas emitters, the investor engagement group Climate Action 100+ found no company has fully disclosed how it plans to reach net-zero."
"Some of the boldest pledges rely on carbon removal technologies that don’t even exist yet, or at least not at the scale required. Many more are heavily reliant on carbon offsets, which allow companies to invest in “nature-based” programs like tree planting or forest protection to counteract their own emissions. Offset projects, however, have been plagued by allegations of flawed accounting, greenwash and sometimes even of actively fueling climate change."
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/jul/26/climate-...
That is, they say they'll do something, but they don't even know how, or at least won't tell for some reason... meaning that there's no way to check if they're doing the necessary work or mostly fugding with the numbers (some high profile cases where companied just patently fabricated numbers regarding their progress have already been revealed in the news).
I believe there's zero indication that companies are serious... emissions in 2023 are set to be the highest ever recorded (and this is not because of higher emissions in developing countries, the developed world is still leading the shameless business-as-usual route)... that's in the middle of a global economical crisis... imagine if the economy had been doing really well!
Until actual emissions start to fall dramatically, don't believe in these companies empty promises.
The price of "green" tariffs in the UK skyrocketed identically to traditional tariffs, when energy prices doubled or tripled in the last few years.
I have ratty-ass computers running at home with weeks worth of uptime. More is not really needed, ironically my home stuff usually has much longer uptimes than the prod infrastructure that I work on, that has constant restarts due to upgrades, configuration, etc.
> Studies by 451 Research have shown that AWS’ infrastructure is 3.6 times more energy efficient than the median of U.S. enterprise data centers surveyed and up to five times more energy efficient than the average in Europe. 451 Research also found that AWS can lower customers’ workload carbon footprints by nearly 80% compared to surveyed enterprise data centers, and up to 96% once AWS is powered with 100% renewable energy—a target we’re on path to meet by 2025.
[1] https://aws.amazon.com/energy/sustainability/
EDIT: