News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by api on Friday June 09, 2023 @05:54PM (#36264694)
For real or are they purchasing dodgy “offsets?”
Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by troyvit on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:08PM (#36264886)
I don't know why you're getting downvoted, the efficacy of carbon offsets is debatable:

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/18/greenwas...

https://earth.org/is-carbon-offset-a-form-of-greenwashing/

And there are plenty of dodgy players out there that large organizations use:

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/18/revealed...

And there are plenty of government programs that just don't work:

https://e360.yale.edu/features/phantom-forests-tree-planting...

I'm sitting here asking myself how much Amazon cares about that, but also wondering how the "unknown Swedish startup" will approach being green.

Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by belval on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:00PM (#36264783)
Probably a bit of both, but their competition in this article is unproven and unbuilt data centers. Ultimately DCs don't exist in a vaccum, if the energy in Europe makes it possible to be 100% renewables without dodgy offsets then everyone will be, not just evroc. If it's not possible then nothing in the articles gives me the impression that they have a secret sauce that would make their 100% renewables "true 100%".
Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by conradev on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:06PM (#36264871)
It’s a lot of renewables:

> The top 25 corporate solar users in 2022 include:

> Meta

> Amazon

> Apple

> Walmart

> Microsoft

https://www.seia.org/news/solarmeansbusiness2022

Just as one data point

Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by Bang2Bay on Friday June 09, 2023 @05:59PM (#36264771)
offset is what its name suggests. sometimes its ok if a company innovates or pays money to others to innovate.
Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by vladf on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:15PM (#36264964)
Sure, but the reasons offsets are dodgy is because they actually aren't fungible in the way you're hoping for.

Say a paper maker is about to cut down a forest in the US. It buys up the rights to do so for $1M. Then, instead, it sells $1M worth of carbon credits to Amazon (maybe for a premium) for its data center greenwashing and doesn't end up cutting the US forest.

But then, secretly, or through some shell company machinery, it buys a plot of land in the Amazon and cuts trees down anyway to match its demand. Even though US law makers evaluate the counterfactual of the paper maker cutting trees down in the US, the net amount of trees in the world goes down.

Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by belval on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:24PM (#36265098)
Doesn't have to be that complicated to be dodgy. A bunch of carbon offset works on optimistic to downright stupid metrics for carbon capture.

For example they buy a plot of land and then raze it, then they will plant 10k saplings and take that figure at face value even if most of those won't take and actually become trees.

Then they will estimate the CO2 captured by averaging it over the entire life of the tree (say 30 years) and count year 1 as if it captured 1/30 of the CO2 even though the carbon capture potential of tree is not constant throughout its life.

Beyond that they will double count the carbon credits of the plot of land by selling them twice.

Finally after all the above, they will sell the plots after ~5 years to buy some other plots and it will be razed anyway. No one actually checks that the carbon capture forest will be there in 10 years, let alone 30.

Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by xyzzyz on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:25PM (#36265718)
I know that you are just trying to make a point, but just to be clear: no paper maker in US is importing Amazon trees to make paper out of them. That would be exceedingly idiotic from profit-making perspective.
Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by iLoveOncall on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:03PM (#36264831)
This is made perfectly obvious by "running on 100% renewables".

You can see more details on https://sustainability.aboutamazon.com/environment/renewable...

It's when there are mentions of "net zero" that carbon credits are purchased (which Amazon does too, but not for what we're talking about).

Re:An unknown Swedish startup’s €3B bid to build a green riv... by apendleton on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:55PM (#36265416)
They're still pretty squirrelly about the specifics of their commitment, though. In particular, it's not clear if it's hourly accounting (but the fact that they don't say so suggests to me that it isn't), and there doesn't seem to be any discussion of additionality. In other words: it might be that exactly the same amount of renewable generation, and exactly the same amount of fossil-fuel generation, are going to occur with this pledge as would have without, and this is just shuffling some numbers between columns in a spreadsheet.