News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by mperham on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:55PM (#36249746)
I think most will agree that the CCS connector is godawful compared to Tesla's NACS. But why? Does anyone know why CCS was designed so poorly?
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by guardiangod on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:04PM (#36249855)
Backward compatibility with J1772 (AC only charging standard).
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by api on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:04PM (#36249858)
Can’t the Tesla plug also do that? You can plug a Tesla into a normal outlet.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by jvanderbot on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:13PM (#36249948)
You cannot plug a Tesla into a normal outlet without a brick of an adaptor.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by api on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:22PM (#36250053)
I have a Nissan Leaf and have a brick of an adaptor for J1772. I think it's required for some kind of ground fault or other check circuitry because I know the car has its own built in charging system that deals with AC.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by ajross on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:48PM (#36250319)
Oh, come on. A Tesla (excuse me, "NACS") plug with AC adapter attached is still less than half the size of a CCS connector. This is what it looks like:

https://shop.tesla.com/product/sae-j1772-charging-adapter

It's just a passive connector. All the signaling is handled internal to the car (which actually supports CCS too, there's a equally passive similar-looking CCS adapter you can buy).

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by Robotbeat on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:56PM (#36250410)
The adapter isn’t big. I put it in my pocket sometimes. But it’s worth noting the Tesla plug that does both AC and Fast Dc charging is smaller than the J1772 plug that does AC alone. And the J1772 to Tesla adapter is purely mechanical and conductive, no active components. So it’s cheap and you can buy 3Rd party ones.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by jvanderbot on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:30PM (#36251413)
Oh! We're talking about the connector. For some reason I thought we were connecting to wall power, which requires a brick sized power converter and thick cable.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cptskippy on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:40PM (#36251514)
It's not even a power converter, it's just some contactors and a microcontroller that tells the EV what sort of power source it is. The EV talks to the micro and if the input power is compatible the contactors close and deliver AC directly to the EV. The charger onboard the EV takes that AC input and converts it.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by amluto on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:24PM (#36251943)
It’s also functionally identical to the equivalent J1772 device. You can (unwisely!) use dumb adapters in either direction.

It’s unwise because there is no way for a passive cable or adapter to tell the car to limit current to anything below 80A.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by Robotbeat on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:00AM (#36257920)
I use a dumb adapter. The J1772 charge box still is able to talk to the Tesla car to negotiate charge current. The digital pins are still present.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cptskippy on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:33AM (#36258401)
> It’s unwise because there is no way for a passive cable or adapter to tell the car to limit current to anything below 80A.

Yes there is, the adapter just passively adapts all 5 pins. The J1772, CCS Combo 1, and NACS are all pin compatible. The EV has an ECU that can detect what is plugged by sensing the configuration on those 3 pins and negotiate accordingly. For older Teslas to support the CCS Combo 1 adapter they require an ECU upgrade. The adapter only needs to passively connect all 5 pins.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by amluto on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:54PM (#36264038)
You’re missing the point.

If your dumb adapter is actually rated for 80A and the J1772 protocol is never extended to allow more than 80A, you’re fine.

If your dumb adapter is rated for less than 80A, but your car and charger negotiate more than the rating of your adapter, you may have a problem. See, for example:

https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0045/1110/5114/files/JDapt...

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cptskippy on Friday June 09, 2023 @05:45PM (#36264586)
Are there any EVs besides that Model S/X that can L2 charge above 11.5kW?

If everyone adopts NACS then this won't be an issue because even the lower end adapters support 11.5kW. The longer it takes for North America to standardize, the greater the possibility of your hypothetical scenario becoming a reality.

*https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B09DCTJCTV/

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by api on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:01PM (#36249825)
CHAdeMO is pretty bad too. They’re both needlessly complex and chunky. My guess is that it’s the usual dynamic of industry consortia designing by a committee that heaps a massive number of requirements on the design that must all be met.

That being said the FTC should require that Tesla open the connector spec if they are going to do this.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by throwaway69123 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:04PM (#36249854)
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by fnimick on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:08PM (#36249904)
That's not open. That much is clear when GM and Ford have to sign licensing agreements to add the connector to the car and get access to a NACS to CCS adapter, which won't work on vehicles from automakers that haven't signed that agreement.

Not to mention that "open for others to use" is not the same as "developed by an independent trade association to remove undue influence from one company over the process", which is how it should be.

Imagine Tesla can't figure out V2H, so they deliberately exclude it from the connector to hold back the rest of the industry that wants to move forward with it. Is that okay for you?

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by DoesntMatter22 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:06PM (#36250539)
"developed by an independent trade association to remove undue influence from one company over the process", which is how it should be."

Why should it be that way?

Tesla created the best charger and people want to use it. What's the problem?

They've already opened all their patents. Objectively they are the most free and open car company in history.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by kjksf on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:14PM (#36250641)
The design is open which means that GM or Ford can build their own adapters and their own chargers.

The deal is for access to Tesla's supercharger network.

The superchargers cost money to produce, install and maintain.

The land on which they are installed costs money to lease.

Tesla installed, in US, over 12 thousand chargers and the rumored cost of a supercharger is about $50k. That's $600 million, not counting the land and other costs.

Those chargers are Tesla's property.

It would be preposterous for government to meddle in a business deal where Tesla sells access to their property to others.

Ford and GM are free to build their own supercharger network but I'm guessing that they would rather pay Tesla than spend $600 million and 10 years to build something that is only as good as what Tesla has today.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by nickv on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:39PM (#36250933)
I think GM and Ford are paying a licensing fee to use the supercharger network, not to use the connector type.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by numpad0 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:22PM (#36250739)
CHAdeMO was just an extreme early optimization. It supports 400A/1kVDC(400kW) on basically the same connector as the original L1 plug for a Leaf, supporting faster charging than V3 Supercharger, which… just later turned out to be a moot point.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cptskippy on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:42PM (#36251540)
CHAdeMO supported faster charging than a Supercharger, but the Leaf never has because the pack is too small. I believe it peaks at 60kW.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by ajross on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:19PM (#36250021)
It was originally supposed to lock out Nissan and CHAdeMO (Tesla wasn't yet considered a threat) from the US and European[2] markets. Traditional automakers didn't actually want their EVs to succeed[1], they just wanted to make sure no one else's EVs did either.

As it happened, it worked well enough. Nissan never sold enough Leafs to make much of a dent, largely because of the lack of a good DC charging network.

The real threat was the company actually trying to win.

[1] Much better to sell high margin pickups and SUVs than risky technology bets.

[2] It always needs to be repeated: CCS is actually two incompatible charging connectors. The DC/fast charger connector is mostly compatible between the two, but the AC half is either a J-1772 or a Mennekes, and the signaling for those is done via two different overlays on top of the CCS layer.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by throw0101b on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:06PM (#36250533)
> I think most will agree that the CCS connector is godawful compared to Tesla's NACS. But why?

I'm asking a different "why": Why is CCS (allegedly?) "godawful compared"? Because of size? Or is there something else?

What makes Telsa's (supposedly?) 'good' or at least 'better'?

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by ajross on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:15PM (#36250646)
It's less than half the size, takes maybe 1/4 the force to insert, doesn't have a fiddly mechanical push-pin in the connector, and is locked by the car vs. the connector. It shares the same connectors for both DC and AC and will autodetect. It even delivers more current, though at 400V instead of the 800V that recent CCS devices can deliver.

But most of the magic is that there's no UI to the charger device. You pull in, plug in, and walk away. Literally. Your phone will buzz automatically when the charge reaches the level required for your next leg. This part remains Tesla-only. CCS devices at these chargers need to start the current manually with the app.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by vel0city on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:00PM (#36251731)
> But most of the magic is that there's no UI to the charger device.

This is good, and this is bad. It's yet another charging app I need to manage my payment info. I can't just arbitrarily choose a different payment method when I'm there. I'd greatly prefer just a basic card reader so I can choose a payment method. Sure, plug and charge if I didn't supply payment method ahead of time, but otherwise it's just another charging app I need to manage.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by amluto on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:08PM (#36252244)
I would argue it’s 100% bad. Tesla should not have a monopoly on determining whether a car gets to charge when it plugs in.

But apps with accounts and ToS and such should be banned outright IMO for any charger or at least any charger that receives any sort of public funding. Anyone with a compatible car should be able to charge, without an account, just like at a gas station.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by Ajedi32 on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:14AM (#36253050)
Yeah I like the idea of payment happening automatically, but that should be optional and implemented via kind of standard payment protocol between the car and the charging station, not via a proprietary app.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cavisne on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:59AM (#36253410)
The plug and charge protocol is open

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118

While what you say is true about a gas station, I think a lot of the standard privacy arguments dont really hold for a car.

Its literally illegal to drive a car without it being built to the standard the government likes, with an identifiable ID printed on the outside of it, with a valid license with your name and date of birth on, and current registration.

Let alone the fact that the vast majority of cars are sold with gps trackers bolted on if they are financed. Requiring a credit card tied to that vehicle is the least of your privacy worries.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by toast0 on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:46AM (#36253288)
I've yet to see a charger with a card reader or that accepts currency. I suspect it's because there would be too many transactions of small value that the payment processing fees are more than the electricity. Which gets you into the yucky mess of I owed chargepoint $0.11, and they charged me $20 and are going to hold onto the rest of my money forever.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by vel0city on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:11AM (#36257313)
It was definitely rare to see a couple of years ago but most dispensers I've seen installed in the last year or so around me seemed to have actual credit card terminals. I've used a few.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by toast0 on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:06AM (#36258941)
Fair enough. I think it makes sense as the market develops and charging is less PHEVs like mine and more full EVs with large batteries that can pull a meaningful amount of dollars out of the plug.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by cavisne on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:49AM (#36253320)
Ford has already announced they will support plug and charge on Tesla chargers also

The whole paying on a terminal/using an app thing is the wrong approach I think. Ultimately to charge there is a handshake protocol between two computers, just sort out payment then (and thats the standard NAC supports https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118)

Adding a payment terminal is just adding another handshake and computer into the mix, a computer that needs to be (mostly) connected to the internet, exposed to the elements, and vulnerable to skimming devices.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by jsight on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:16PM (#36251874)
It is almost as big as the gap between MiniUSB (not Micro, Mini) and Lightning.

The plug is smaller and self-locates, but is also significantly more robust.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by steveBK123 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:51PM (#36252124)
It is 2x the size, 4x the weight, and clearly more prone to failure because CCS stations have failure rates easily 10x the rate of Tesla.

It is incredibly rare to see a broken Tesla charger, and if you do, for it not to be repaired by the time you come back. Even at big 12-16 stall stations, it's incredibly rare to see a single one broken.

CCS chargers being broken is the norm, with typical 2 or 4 stall stations often having 1 broken. It's not unusual for the broken stall to go unprepared for weeks to months.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by tdeck on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:27AM (#36253142)
Is it the connector itself that's broken? Or something about the connector's electrical characteristics that causes the charger to break? It seems like the maintenance schedule is orthogonal to the connector design.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by CameronNemo on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:56AM (#36254271)
AIUI the connector requires a clip (at least go some vehicles), and if that clip breaks you cannot charge.

At least that happened to me with some L2 chargers.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by steveBK123 on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:40AM (#36255885)
Very much yes it would seem.

Bigger plug also goes with bigger heavier cables, the liquid cables require cooling to charge at high speed, one of the many failure rates is the cooling system which then reverts the chargers to operate at 20% power.

Another of the failures is the locking mechanism, which is obviously strained by the heavy cable.

The plug has to be put in just-so at sort of an awkward alignment/angle, doesn't go in easily like a NACS plug. Presumably the alignment leads to a lot of thrashing wear & tear.

I simply never saw Tesla stalls break at this rate. It isn't getting better either. EA changed brands and some of their NEW stalls begun failing. This after they abandoned maintenance at some sites as they were planning to replace with the new stalls. The other excuse is EA is fully beholden to OEMs for parts whereas Tesla makes their own. So another EA excuse has been they can't get parts.

You don't read about Tesla chargers getting stuck to cars / frying cars / etc as the same rate. Remember in the US there's probably 10x more Tesla cars in the wild, so you should hear charging horror stories at 10x the rate if their chargers were equally bad.

Instead, you hear 10x the CCS horror stories in US than you do Tesla, from 1/10th the population of cars.

Honestly I just don't care about all these "principle of the thing" arguments, I just want to charge my car.

And we aren't going to make a mass EV transition without working, ubiquitous, easy charging. Tesla is the only company to even remotely have this going on right now. And again I say this as a Tesla seller, BMW owner, Elon disliker.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by WorldMaker on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:40PM (#36261240)
Among other things the "latch" that secures the connector in place (both to make sure the fit is tight and to avoid accidental removal, especially in high voltage modes) is a part of the plastics of the connector on the charge cable in CCS1 and under human mechanical operation but a part of the connector design on the car itself in NACS and firmware operated.

It can be too easy in rough removals to accidentally break the latch on the CCS1 charging cable (and busy car owners may not be careful enough to avoid the rougher removals) and it may be dangerous to operate with a broken latch so some of the software is (usefully) over-cautious about that. Even with the gentlest of usage by people, it's still a mechanical part prone to slow wear and tear from repeated use.

Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by remir on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:08PM (#36251205)
Design by committee is my guess.
Re:GM to use Tesla charging network, joining Ford by nxm on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:22PM (#36252316)
Design by committee