So its going to make the minisplit work harder but to what extent at 30 and 40 degree air outside?
1) What should I do to get up to PPS? Should I just run a tube to their inlets through my window?
2) How is heating / cooling handled? The weather here swings wildly. I'd be reluctant to pump hot or freezing air in. Might work well in spring / fall which are peak allergy season, though.
3) What's a good way to monitor air quality on the cheap?
I'm looking for opinionated recommendations.
2) Ideally you get a PPS system with a heat recovery unit. Also important is to have the PPS demand controlled based on an indoor air quality monitor that measures PM and CO2 and then only pushing in the right amount of air to meet your target values for PM and CO2. This way you can save a lot of energy costs and temperature differentials.
3) Thanks for asking ;) We maintain popular open source air quality monitor kits that are very easy to assemble and use industry grade sensors [1]
Friendly note: "Join thousands of makers builing their" that's probably meant to be "building".
You'd be operating at a much lower delta, split over two coolers. At best, the transfered power would scale with the delta, due to tuning it might scale worse.
I think you might be better off just skipping the heat-pipes of cpu coolers and using aluminum plates positionned in both airflows. CPUs need heat-pipes because the heat source is sooo small. Here your heat source will be much bigger, especially in terms of surface area.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pipe
So what is the working temperature range for CPU cooler heat pipes? Though they maybe be optimized for 100F temperature difference, CPU's also don't always run at full speed and maximum power. So perhaps CPU coolers would still be useful at lower temperature differentials (and lower absolute operating temperatures.)
That's not quite what I meant. I effectively meant: just make one big, wide heatsink. Then have the intake run through the left side of the heatsink and outtake through the right side. No 'heat transfer between the heatsinks' needed.
So what if you redo your experiment with lower positive-pressure flows? This is:
1. Keep the 280-m^3/hr purifier on the whole time.
2. Start with the 220-m^3/hr positive-pressure system running.
3. Wait for the particulate-level to equilibrate, then record the particulate-level and the pressure-difference (between outside and inside).
4. Reduce the air-flow of the positive-pressure system by, say, 20-m^3/hr.
5. Loop back to Step-3 while the air-flow of the positive-pressure system isn't negative.
With the objective to be to determine how low the positive-pressure system's flowrate can get while still maintaining its benefits, reducing heating/cooling losses.
So in a way it does exactly what you say and finds the ideal equilibrium to keep just the right amount of pressure needed.
Now that we have a CO2 meter, I am strongly considering wiring it to an air exchanger and having a PID controller just keep the house co2 below 600-800 ppm, and the pm 2.5 below 10 ug/m3.
There are lots of enthalpy recovery systems on the market, some that can recover >75% of the 'waste' energy, though mostly aimed at larger customers. You need to do a cost-benefit analysis to see if it makes sense to spend the upfront cost.
Guessing that there are two main scenarios there:
1. A leaky house where positive-pressure causes flows to come out of various leaks all around.
2. A well-sealed house where positive-pressure causes flows to leave through a well-defined channel.
The first-case might be harder to recover heat/coolness from, as the (high/low)-temperature air might leak in a way that'd be harder to make use of it.
The second-case would seem to offer a stream of warmer/cooler air that could be used with a heat-exchanger or heat-pump or something.
To note it, well-sealed houses might have issues with relatively poor ventilation, making positive-pressure more desirable -- much like how the OP describes wanting to keep CO2-levels down with their positive-pressure system.
Edit: I'm in Australia. Here's a comparison of filter types for different locations: https://www.filtermakers.com.au/selection-guide/
One important thing to point out with PPS systems is that you need to get the air from fully polluted to zero polluted in ONE pass as unlike air purifiers, there is no recirculation. So the filter quality is super important.
An alternative for critical facilities like datacentres, is they often just go into recirculation mode. This wouldn't work in locations with persistent air polution.
Like, say the positive-pressure system has a duct that pumps outside-air directly to locations where a resident spends a lot of them time -- like their bed, a work desk, or a couch in a living-room. Could they get reasonable air-quality that way, even if the system isn't strong enough to clean up other areas of their home that they might spend less time in?
I’m wondering if the airflow was in a loop but not mixing the entire room, or the filter wasn’t Hepa (or close), or it wasn’t reaching its claimed throughput/filtration, etc.
I recently installed a Merv13+Merv16 filter on my newly upgraded HVAC system and am able to drive PM2.5 to 0 with a minimal fan setting of roughly 2ACH. (Granted, we haven’t had wildfire smoke that strongly since installing it, but I induce bad air from time to time and it cleans it up quickly.)
So PPSes are sold as a damp prevention mechanism; as long as you install one when you air-tighten it's doing the job that natural airflow would otherwise take care of.
Also worth noting: each successive option added a zero to the price.
Your best option is a centralized or decentralized automatic ventilation system with heat exchanging and humidity control. On top of that, the better the insulation the less the air is cooling down near walls/windows and the less likely the humidity is condensing into water causing mold. And then last, the less humid the air inside the house is, the more it can cool down before condensation is happening - so keep the humidity low not only with automatic ventilation but also by making sure to not cause humidity by cooking, showering (and breathing, haha) and if you do, air out for just a few minutes.
I am not saying you don't need one, but here in Sweden modern houses do not use humidity controls and are still air tight and mold free, maybe at the cost of letting more air and energy be swapped. Older houses have local vents at the baths which are humidity sensitive and will blow out excess humidity quickly, again at the cost of wasted energy.
I suppose that controlling humidity centrally will somewhat save energy, but at what cost and complexity?
The reason why houses in Sweden can be mold free is because people get taught that they need to air out their house on a regular basis. And if you look it up, it tells you to air out not during noon (even though it's warmer so you lose less energy) but in the morning and late evening - specifically for humidity control.
So...
> maybe at the cost of letting more air and energy be swapped
Yes, exactly that. But since we are in the context of air pollution, opening windows to air out isn't a great idea. That's why I mentioned an automatic ventilation system (which pretty much always contains filters).
> Older houses have local vents at the baths which are humidity sensitive and will blow out excess humidity quickly, again at the cost of wasted energy.
Not only that, fresh air will also be sucked in from somewhere else outside - which then again brings the air pollution inside.
I got curious and read a little, it is generally accepted here that higher pressure in the house can actually lead to mold, maybe because there is no moisture control and it is expected that some of the moisture generated in the house will be driven into the walls, probably assuming the walls are not perfectly sealed. On the other hand air pollution in Sweden is a non-issue, except maybe for a couple of streets in Stockholm.
So you are left with reducing the humdity by airing out in some way (with windows, with a very non-airtight building, or using automatic ventilation). Or, of course, you can use a dehumidifier.
Anyhow, although leaky houses can help deal with moisture, that's pretty much an incidental effect. Leaky homes also comes with significant expense in the form of heat loss, worsened indoor air quality, pathways for bugs to enter the home, etc. There's a reason why we've been moving towards ever-tighter houses, even with the upfront costs and effort required for air sealing, insulation, and mechanical ventilation.
In the GP's tropical climate, I'd expect that humid air leaking into the house does very little to actually dry out the wall cavities; if anything, there's a good chance that those leaks would do the opposite and support any mold growth.
Here is how to read the graph: The black line is the outside air PM2.5. The green-yellow-orange-red bars are the indoors air PM2.5.
A bit of background, my house is in Northern Thailand that has similar levels of air pollution every year than what we see currently in North America and Canada and it took me a few years to get my house to zero PM even when having the worst wildfires around. So before installing a positive pressure system and making my house air tight in the process, I experienced with all types of air purifiers but did not find anything that works consistently at very high pollution levels.
The experience with these wildfires let me actually found AirGradient and we are proud of open sourcing many of our air quality monitors.