News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by zabzonk on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:42AM (#36197926)
> when cats want something (usually food), they deploy an insistent, chainsaw-like purr

all the ones i know go miaow.

> Scientists at the University of Sussex have shown that that bears some phonetic resemblance to a human baby’s cry.

have these "scientists" ever heard a cat purring, a chainsaw, or a baby crying? three sounds that could not be more different!

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by joe5150 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:33PM (#36198825)
The article is all of 1000 words and doesn't use the term "chainsaw". Whether this is an incorrect embellishment on the part of the Guardian writer or not, I'm not sure it's necessary to belittle these researchers.

https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(09)...

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by __alexs on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:13PM (#36198465)
This first line made me wonder if the author had ever met a cat, or a human baby. Or a chainsaw.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:28PM (#36198737)
Or a motorcycle.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by Merad on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:20PM (#36198589)
I would think that they're referring more to the rumbling sound of a small two-stroke engine idling as opposed to a chainsaw running at full throttle while cutting wood. Here in the southeast US, at least, it not unusual to describe the sound of an engine idling as "purring" or even "purring like a kitten."
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:29PM (#36198750)
Cats sound like a v-twin though, not a chainsaw motor.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by seszett on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:50AM (#36198087)
I have heard all of these sounds, and I totally understand what they mean in this article.

I'm pretty sure it depends on cats though, but I know exactly what they mean by a cat deploying "an insistent chainsaw-like purr that bears some phonetic resemblance to a human baby's cry". I have known cats that did that.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by zabzonk on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:58AM (#36198238)
i have known cats make all sorts of weird noises, but sounding like a chainsaw? no. also, babies don't sound like chainsaws.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by kevincox on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:27PM (#36198731)
I think the "chainsaw" comparison was more about the volume. I definitely know some cats who you can hear from across the room which will bring up a chainsaw comparison as a metaphor for loud.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ilyt on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:34PM (#36198844)
And vice versa we call nice sounding engines "purring", coz they kinda sound like cat purring when idling
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by mikrl on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:13PM (#36198477)
Listen to the pattern of a babies cry. It isn’t just one WAAAAAA, it has stops and intonation.

Similar to my cat (he is a loud purrer) who makes a Puurrrr-hurrr-purrr-urrrr kind of ebb and flow in the same way babies go WAAAAA-AAAA

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ilyt on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:29PM (#36198748)
...do they purr when they want something ? Coz that's what this "scientists" claim
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by katbyte on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:39PM (#36198949)
one of mine just becomes a pest sitting on near and in-front of me making not a peep but ensuring I literally cannot ignore her. The other just sits and watches
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ProjectArcturis on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:35PM (#36198865)
As a new parent, I can confirm that a cat's meow sounds quite a lot like a baby crying from a distance. Damn cat has woken me up in a panic more than once.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by s1artibartfast on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:54AM (#36198168)
I said cat purrs pretty similar to low percussive sound of a two-stroke chainsaw idling.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by captainbland on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:51AM (#36198108)
Yeah it sounds like tenuous pseudoscience to me, but that might just be the T. Gondii speaking.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by USB5 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:26PM (#36198714)
>all the ones i know go miaow

Yeah, these people seem like they've never had cats before. Purring does not mean hunger.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by mschuster91 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:17PM (#36198524)
> all the ones i know go miaow.

The ones I've had/have (five in total) personally, they meow. And loudly at that. But I did also meet cats that trill and "burst purr" to signal they want attention - IIRC, many of 'em were former street cats unlike my other cats who all were "purely" domesticated.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by nerdjon on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:43AM (#36197945)
Going on the last paragraph here.

I have had cats basically my entire life. But my current cats was the first time I had 2 cats from the same litter, and it has been amazing. The difference in how they interact from any of the cats I have had in the past is amazing.

In the future we plan on trying to stick with cats from the same litter and not separate siblings if possible.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:34PM (#36198836)
PAWS insists that you take a bonded pair of kittens instead of a single cat. My best bud growing up came from a pair, but his sister was always aloof.

The notion is that they teach each other not to fight so rough, which is something. We are bad at teaching them. Most of the orneriest little shits I’ve known were singles.

I had one cat that was a single kitten from a feral mother. She was a spitfire. Loved kids, and me, and everyone else could fuck right off. Except my girlfriend, but only on Tuesdays. She had a special hatred of vets. She would probably have lived 2 years longer if she didn’t turn into a wolverine at the doctors office.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by s1artibartfast on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:14PM (#36199536)
I think teaching cats not to play rough is pretty simple but many pet owners don't want to do it. You just replicate what their litter of mate would do.

You immediately escalate, make a new loud noise, and perhaps bop them on the head, then walk away. Domestic animals are smart enough to know that this means they crossed a line. Do a consistently and the line becomes very clear

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by PaulHoule on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:17PM (#36198540)
Some cats have a high level of social interest in other cats, but that frequently means aggression when they meet a new cat which could lead to a cat being driven away. (I have indoor/outdoor house cats and a tack room/outdoor barn cat and won’t apologize because I live on a farm with an 1/8 mile driveway.).
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:47PM (#36199088)
Maybe I'll out myself as not living on a farm: what does your property/driveway size have to do with having outdoor cats?
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by PaulHoule on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:48PM (#36199098)
Not likely to get run over by cars.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:04PM (#36199380)
Oh, yes, lol. That makes sense. But they're still vulnerable to injury and disease... and, unfortunately, probably killing a lot of birds and lizards that will struggle with the evolutionary pressure.

But you're probably relying on them for rodent control, right? As a rule, I think all cats should be indoors, but this is a case where it's not so bad if some people get exceptions. Presumably there's plenty of wildlife habitat where small critters can escape your cats without getting in your house!

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by PaulHoule on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:07PM (#36199421)
I think the snakes that live in our yards kill more rodents than the cats.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:12PM (#36199507)
Likely true, and more reason to keep them inside :)
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by jononor on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @07:24AM (#36225479)
The snakes, you mean? ;)
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by stracer on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:44PM (#36215556)
> As a rule, I think all cats should be indoors

Why?

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by kurthr on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:17PM (#36198532)
Just getting two that are the same kitten age (~12weeks) will have many of the same litter qualities... but if you get the runt, they will always be the runt (I think they do better as lone cats).
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by arethuza on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:24PM (#36198672)
We had two Burmese cats from the same litter - their personalities could hardly have been more different!
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by speedgoose on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:49AM (#36198066)
Just make sure they don’t reproduce. It happens.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by kurthr on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:18PM (#36198560)
Your punishment will be the cat going into heat.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by zomg on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:48PM (#36199093)
interestingly, we have a pair of gray rescue littermates who were bonded for ~4 years until we got a third cat (make purebred maine coon) who seemingly broke that bond. to this day, they get along, but everyone needs to keep their space or trouble could break out! :-)
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by boppo1 on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:18PM (#36199594)
Seconding this. I had a tabby and his tortie sister. Wonderful, social, affectionate. I was 100% a dog person and still am, but that tabby was more 'man's best friend' to me than any of my dogs. I miss him enormously.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by cheaprentalyeti on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:51AM (#36198094)
I skimmed the article.

One thing they didn't mention was color vision. The immediate ancestors of the domestic cat were diurnal hunters with color vision. In domestic cats they not only hunt mainly at dusk or night, but the entire section of the brain related to color vision is much smaller.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by dragonwriter on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:35PM (#36198857)
> The immediate ancestors of the domestic cat were diurnal hunters with color vision.

AFAIK, the immediate ancestor has been identified as a wildcat which was most closely related to, and possibly the same subspecies as, the modern African wildcat, F. silvestris lybica, a mostly-nocturnal hunter.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by Tiktaalik on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:03PM (#36198322)
> Why, then, do we consider domestic cats to be loners? ... Although it’s not impossible for two unrelated cats to develop a friendly relationship, a better approach is to bring littermates into a home together.

This article sort of undersells this in framing it as a recommendation, but at this point there is so much consensus that cats are indeed very social creatures, that many cat rescue operations have a policy of trying as hard as possible to only adopt kittens out in pairs or with their mother.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:37PM (#36198916)
The one I’m familiar with didn’t seem to factor in if you had other cats. The problem with pairs is that if one cat ages out, lots of places have rules about only two cats. So you either can’t get a kitten, you have to buy a pure bred, or you get two identical kittens, and hope one is shy and the landlord just thinks they’re seeing the same cat twice.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ilyt on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:31PM (#36198780)
Yeah especially if they will be alone for part of the day. Probably reduces causes of cats destroying things just out of sheer boredom of being alone
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by Simulacra on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:03PM (#36198327)
Perhaps it is the humans that have been domesticated.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:40PM (#36198976)
There’s a theory that the human iris is so small because it helped us in working with canines as mixed hunting packs (nonverbal communication) and that in a way it’s a domestication of humans.

As we push back the date of first contact between humans and wolves that theory becomes more plausible.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:52PM (#36199188)
IMO, it'd be pretty arrogant to assume we haven't adapted in any way to live better with the animals and plants we've chosen to live with day-to-day.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @04:19PM (#36202962)
I'm carrying the bitter taster genes, which are adapted to alkyloid soils in southeastern Europe. Which means that some of my relatives must have migrated farther back than I know because as far as I'm aware I'm four or five kinds of northerner all mashed together.

We are chock full of adaptations to time and place.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by mschuster91 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:19PM (#36198577)
Don't get why you got downvoted, because IMO it is based on a historical truth - cats have served as pest control for literally millennia of human history and did such a good job at it that they have managed to get humans to take cats with them while migrating towards new areas.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by katbyte on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:43PM (#36199035)
They still do an amazing job of it. There is likely no better solution (poison is bad as it kills local wild life, traps require more effort)
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by mrguyorama on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:51PM (#36199161)
Cats are TOO good at it. Our love of them as friends is resulting in broad extinctions of bird species.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by katbyte on Monday June 05, 2023 @09:14PM (#36206797)
if you live in any urban area us humans have already outdone them by far. and globally excluding islands with no predators it is likely humans are still the leading cause in one form or another (habitat, pesticides, herbicides)

us destroying bird habitat and their food sources are far more an issue then cats but hey lets just focus on cats instead of those.

not to mention in many ares outside urban centres cats are pretty low down on the food-chain and are as much prey as predator so the main reason to keep your cat inside is so it doesn't become somethings meal

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:53PM (#36199205)
> poison is bad as it kills local wild life

Cats do, too, unfortunately.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by katbyte on Monday June 05, 2023 @09:14PM (#36206793)
if you live in any urban area us humans have already outdone them by far. and globally excluding islands with no predators it is likely humans are still the leading cause in one form or another (habitat, pesticides, herbicides)

us destroying birb habitat and their food sources are far more an issue then cats but hey lets just focus on cats instead of those.

not to mention in many ares outside urban centres cats are pretty low down on the food-chain and are as much prey as predator so the main reason to keep your cat inside is so it doesn't become somethings meal

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by digging on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:51AM (#36213714)
Fuck it, I'll just start throwing grenades at bird nests. We've done worse, right?
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by katbyte on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:56PM (#36215748)
sadly thats likely to matter little in the long run after all the damage we humans have already done
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by somat on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:52PM (#36199187)
humans, almost by definition are domesticated. domicile: the house, domesticated: comfortable around the house. houses are built by humans.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by PaulHoule on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:15PM (#36198496)
Compare that to a raccoon which they tell you not to let in your house because it might have rabies. Both raccoons and foxes can learn to come around when you feed them but neither one is an animal you can live with, it will attack you or trash your house, either one of which is unusual behavior for a cat.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by galleywest200 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:17PM (#36198541)
Pet raccoons are more common than one would think. They were kept as a pet in the White House once.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebecca_(raccoon)

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by dekhn on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:31PM (#36199807)
I read the book Rascal growing up (about a kid who raises a raccoon in Minnesota). Then I worked with a guy who grew up in minnesota, and he had raised a raccoon in pretty much the same way.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ChrisRackauckas on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#36198638)
> either one of which is unusual behavior for a cat.

Not really. Depends on the cat.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by hinkley on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:35PM (#36198869)
Fuck this, fuck that.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:17PM (#36198543)
There's quite a difference among cats in how they vocalize with humans.

There's less variation in how cats vocalise with one another.

Vaccinations, neutering, checkups in the first 18 months ran $900 in vet bills. That's $1800 for two kittens.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by Jtsummers on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:36PM (#36198898)
Every shelter will provide vaccinations, many shelters will also fix the cats or provide a coupon for an associated vet (so it only costs you the time, and tending to them during recovery, not money). It should not cost $900 in 18 months for a healthy cat (an unhealthy cat, on the other hand, may cost that and much more).
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by wk_end on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:55PM (#36199229)
Not sure what your vet bills have to do with any of this, but...

It's true: pets are expensive, particularly pet health care, at least in part because (as with human medicine, but perhaps more absurdly) we've allowed professional organizations to strangle supply for vets, both explicitly by limiting the number of schools/class sizes, and implicitly, by putting onerous requirements on getting into those schools and/or getting certified. I was interested in a second career in veterinary medicine, but learned that there's exactly one veterinary college in the entirety of Western Canada, located in the (lovely, but) cold and remote prairie city of Saskatoon, which accepts a total of something like 80 students per year. Absurd.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by eterevsky on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:32PM (#36198808)
This article is a rare exception to Betteridge's law: "any headline ending in a question mark can be answered with the word 'no'".

In this case the article contents imply that the answer to the titular question is "kinda" or "at least to some extent".

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by noman-land on Monday June 05, 2023 @02:37PM (#36200952)
The law still holds because of the word "can". It's actually ways true.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by cancerhacker on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:35PM (#36198863)
> And as for the disturbing claim that your cat would eat you if you died at home and your body weren’t discovered: don’t believe it.

It does happen, and not out of malice. Source: father in law died over the summer, "Garfield" (sigh) was rescued after 3 weeks when FIL was discovered, coroner report mentioned "evidence of post mortem scavenging".

"Garfield" (sigh) is to all appearances just a well adjusted cat, if a bit of a whiner.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by mmh0000 on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:38PM (#36198934)
Imangine how terrible life would be without "Garfield" (sigh)[1]

[1] https://garfieldminusgarfield.net/

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by austin-cheney on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:37PM (#36198901)
There is a massive difference between preference and avoidance of prolonged starvation.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by TedDoesntTalk on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:43PM (#36199031)
I might do the same if I didn’t have any other food choices for 3 weeks.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by coldtea on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:39PM (#36198943)
It's like few that commented here about the "purr" (people commenting how cats meow and don't purr, how the purr is not like a chainsaw, and so on) bothered to read (as opposed to skim) the article or deploy some basic reading comprehension. The article begins with saying cats meow to ask for things. It EXPICITLY says that "Anyone who has lived with a cat has experienced their household companion meowing to them, clearly trying to communicate something or other (perhaps “dinner time” or “Help, I’m locked in the closet”)".

When the article talks about the purr, is in addition to that. It even literally starts that section saying "And it’s not just the meow.".

As for the purr, they don;t refer to the "satisfaction purr" cats do when you pet then (or sometimes the agitated purr they have when they're stressed), that you knee-jerk assumed it does. The article links to the relevant research where they describe those "solicitation purrs" and the audio analysis they did on them:

"Here we report how domestic cats make subtle use of one of their most characteristic vocalisations — purring — to solicit food from their human hosts, apparently exploiting sensory biases that humans have for providing care. When humans were played purrs recorded while cats were actively seeking food at equal amplitude to purrs recorded in non-solicitation contexts, even individuals with no experience of owning cats judged the ‘solicitation’ purrs to be more urgent and less pleasant. Embedded within the naturally low-pitched purr, we found a high frequency voiced component, reminiscent of a cry or meow, that was crucial in determining urgency and pleasantness ratings. Moreover, when we re-synthesised solicitation purrs to remove only the voiced component, paired presentations revealed that these purrs were perceived as being significantly less urgent."

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098220...

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by yellowapple on Monday June 05, 2023 @02:25PM (#36200751)
> As for the purr, they don;t refer to the "satisfaction purr" cats do when you pet then

Before today, the only sort of "purr" I'd ever heard anyone refer to is a "satisfaction purr". What your quotation describes as a "solicitation purr" is what I reckon most people would call a "meow" or maybe a "yell". One of those cases where colloquial v. scientific uses of a word diverge rather severely, I guess.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by coldtea on Monday June 05, 2023 @08:45PM (#36206591)
>is what I reckon most people would call a "meow" or maybe a "yell"

Again, no. They refer to a different kind of purr that cats do when asking for something, distinct from a meow. A purr that most people might not even have noticed as it occurs next to (and between) meows.

And this special purr also has an embedded higher frequency component similar to a meow, as they explain, that they had to amplify and do some signal processing to hear properly.

It's funny how people are not willing to read the study (or read carefully), but would rather assume that scientists (and even worse: scientists studying cats) don't know what a meow and a purr is, and just use the terms incorrectly!

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by somat on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:46PM (#36199072)
Hell yeah they are. cats have had darwinian pressure for thousands of years to be comfortable around humans(perhaps this needs to be phrased more generically? comfortable in clans?). It is not much compared to dogs. But as a counter example try raising a bobcat kitten as a house cat. Domestic cats are very amiable in comparison.

Note that this appears that I have raised a bobcat, I have not. but I have heard stories from them who have.

Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by vngzs on Monday June 05, 2023 @01:01PM (#36199339)
After volunteering with baby and adult lions, I've since viewed cats more as "small lions" than I see lions as "big, wild cats." The only difference I could ascertain in their behavior in captivity was that lions were more deadly when they acted up.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by user6723 on Monday June 05, 2023 @02:00PM (#36200311)
Your cat doesn't eat you because you are bigger than it is. Simple as.
Re:The big idea: Are cats domesticated? by ivanmarsh on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @01:31AM (#36223224)
Cats aren't domesticated... they are wild animals who choose to cohabitate with people due to a symbiotic relationship. Grain storage drew mice, mice drew cats, humans realized cats were keeping mice out of their grain... didn't murder all the cats.

Your cat will cohabitate with you with no social interaction at all if that's how little effort you put into it. If you want a relationship with your cat, you have to spend time with it and learn to speak cat.