News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by chasing on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:22PM (#36129320)
The Web hit the scene in 1991. By 2003 how we shopped, worked, consumed media, communicated with friends and family, and interacted with information was in the process of changing radically. A million "little ambitions" to replace catalogue shopping and how hotel reservations were made were transforming how the world worked.

Bitcoin hit the scene in 2011. By 2023 crypto's mostly a failed get-rich-quick scheme with a couple actual possibly legitimate uses that you can see if you squint just right.

So not only did crypto have much smaller goals than the Dot-Com era, but it failed pretty hard at those goals. And the deep dark secret at the heart of crypto is that — apart from the get-rich-quick stuff — it's neither particularly interesting nor useful. And it takes a lot of set dressing and hand-waving to make it seem like such.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by bombcar on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:32PM (#36129460)
The most "legitimate" use for bitcoin and its friends is transferring funds electronically with people that others don't want you transferring funds with (e.g, avoiding payment processors, laws, etc).

However, it remains to be seen if cryptocurrency could survive doing only that (e.g., without speculators) - because if there's no speculation how do you unload the currency? Only to others wishing to do the same. It's possible, but will it work out?

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by eli on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:40PM (#36129569)
"avoiding laws" is not a "legitimate" use
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by snapcaster on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:44PM (#36129626)
I think you're using legitimate to mean "legal and most reasonable people would be okay with it" whereas the post you're responding to meant "legitimate" to mean an actual real technological advancement that wasn't doable with previous technologies
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by bmoxb on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:31PM (#36130333)
> wasn't doable with previous technologies

But anonymous London shell companies have been available for years!

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by bombcar on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:52PM (#36130604)
Setting up an entire shell company to buy a dime bag is not an efficient use of money.

Of course, apparently fees on bitcoin are so high that buying a dime bag there isn't useful, either.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by bombcar on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:56PM (#36130669)
Exactly. Legitimate can mean "conforming to the laws" in which case law avoidance can't (usually) be legitimate, but I was taking the secondary meaning of "able to be defended with logic or justification" e.g., it allows something that couldn't otherwise be done (currently).

A government that fully supported an actual digital cash that was untraceable (perhaps this is best done with crypto, but you can do it without a blockchain) would serve the same purpose.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by ljf on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:55PM (#36129809)
All the while remembering that all transactions in bitcoin have a permanent ledger - so many friends seemed to think that bitcoin is somehow secret and anonymous - there are ways to make it more so, but by default it is much less anonymous than cold hard cash.
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by Animats on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:10PM (#36130002)
> The most "legitimate" use for bitcoin and its friends is transferring funds electronically with people that others don't want you transferring funds with (e.g, avoiding payment processors, laws, etc).

Yes. I way underestimated the size of the money-laundering industry.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by d3vmax on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:38PM (#36129536)
2009, not even 2011. Agree with your statement.
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by ilamont on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @03:45PM (#36129634)
> And the deep dark secret at the heart of crypto is that — apart from the get-rich-quick stuff — it's neither particularly interesting nor useful. And it takes a lot of set dressing and hand-waving to make it seem like such.

Yep. For an example this week, see "Web3 Can Help Marginalized Communities Share Their Stories" (https://decrypt.co/142763/web3-can-help-marginalized-communi...)

“You can truly own your IP through the whole thing,” Bayne said, highlighting the advantages that Web3 brings to filmmaking. “Your community can be involved through every step, and you don't necessarily need the studios.”

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by dylan604 on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:05PM (#36129945)
>“You can truly own your IP through the whole thing,” Bayne said, highlighting the advantages that Web3 brings to filmmaking. “Your community can be involved through every step, and you don't necessarily need the studios.”

i get you have to have types with very active imaginations to evangelize and get a new thing created, but sometimes, that imagination is just so fanciful that it has the same odds as a snow ball in certain locations. it also makes the speaker just sound completely out of touch and delusional. that comment makes me think someone is quite enamored with the sound of their own voice

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by htormey on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:09PM (#36129995)
I don’t think comparing the timelines of vastly different technologies like this is helpful.

Prior to the web, in the 1960s/1970s we had packet-switching networks, such as ARPANET which were the basis of modern computer networking.

The original ARPANET (precursor to the internet)was just used to connect computers at research institutions. I.e it wasn’t used by that many people relatively speaking.

It took another 20 years for the web to come along and more for it gain widespread adoption.

Is Bitcoin, a very low level protocol, more analogous to ARPANET or the web? Even if you dislike crypto, is this comparison really helpful?

All technology is built on the shoulders of previous giants. Building a secure, scalable, sufficiently decentralized distributed computer system is hard. I.e it’s going to take a long ass time. Hence I’m not surprised at how far we have come since BTC was released.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by IntelMiner on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:51PM (#36130590)
So if Bitcoin was the "ARPANET" what's that make NFT's? The most utterly useless offshoot of "blockchain" I've seen yet
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by notahacker on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:52PM (#36130602)
Whilst it's certainly a valid point that different technologies don't have exactly the same adoption curves, we're not talking about decades of behind closed doors innovation to make microcomputers people would want to use packet switching technology to share stuff on, we're talking about adoption curve of the most-hyped thing since the "information superhighway" of the 1990s, something which involves stadium sponsorship deals, Sand Hill Road and more electricity consumption than most countries. And generally the "it's like the early days of the web" stuff is coming from pro-crypto people, usually those who are pretty keen on stressing that their portfolio is not an experiment as doomed to obsolescence as a 1960s comms network (and that POS and faster transaction throughput on different blockchains isn't "better"). The issues the present crypto industry suffer from for the most part aren't scaling or lack of technology, they're philosophical.
Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by htormey on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @06:00PM (#36131536)
I disagree, I don’t think this is just about adoption curves and hype cycles.

I think fundamentally the infrastructure required to build decentralized applications is hard and has pushed the limits of computer science (zero knowledge proofs etc).

I think people have inflated expectations about how long it will take this technology to mature. Today it’s still very technically hard to build a scalable dapp that’s easy to use. Assuming this is something consumers actually want as opposed to a solution in search of a problem, this will take more time to solve.

Sometimes greed makes people think a technology is a lot further along than it actually is.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by the_snooze on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @05:27PM (#36131097)
>Is Bitcoin, a very low level protocol, more analogous to ARPANET or the web? Even if you dislike crypto, is this comparison really helpful?

ARPANET knew who it was for and what it was for: for researchers to share data and compute resources that would otherwise be expensive to do across vast distances. Audience and use case. What's the equivalent for cryptocurrency?

>Building a secure, scalable, sufficiently decentralized distributed computer system is hard.

Who actually wants that, and for what practical purpose?

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by chx on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @06:16PM (#36131740)
> Building a secure, scalable, sufficiently decentralized distributed computer system is hard.

Have you heard of git?

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by Nursie on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:11AM (#36134685)
> Even if you dislike crypto, is this comparison really helpful?

AFAICT the comparison is only made because, faced with a decade and a bit of failure to deliver, cryptocurrency and blockchain proponents need an argument as to why it's still going to be HUGE, and is still a case of "just you wait, you'll see", rather than admitting it's not looking very hopeful.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by topranks on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:19PM (#36143721)
Email was a massive hit from day 1 on the Arpanet.

Whereas crypto still struggles to do anything novel or get popular with anyone outside of speculation.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by topranks on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:23PM (#36143786)
> Building a secure, scalable, sufficiently decentralized distributed computer system is hard.

Yep. This blockchain/PoW/PoS way they’ve come up with to do it, with a built in cryptocurrency, doesn’t really cut it.

The trade offs to be “sufficiently decentralized” make it slow, expensive and unscalable. Making it effectively useless for real-world applications. The whole of Ethereum has as much power as a raspberry pi.

Re:Molly White Tracks Crypto Scams. It’s Going Just Great by microtherion on Tuesday May 30, 2023 @04:40PM (#36130445)
> Bitcoin hit the scene in 2011. By 2023 crypto's mostly a failed get-rich-quick scheme with a couple actual possibly legitimate uses that you can see if you squint just right.

You forgot that already by 2022, you were able to use multiple slurp juices on a single ape!