News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by chungy on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:38AM (#36092568)
In general, I'm not sure what the idea of putting Dolphin on Steam was supposed to gain. First, I have a hard time conceiving why I'd even want to manage it from Steam, but aside from that, it seems like it'll only attract attention from people wanting "free games".

It's sad too, since the Wii is a console that makes it extraordinarily simple to dump your own game discs and use the emulator in a completely legal fashion.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by wtallis on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:50AM (#36092609)
> In general, I'm not sure what the idea of putting Dolphin on Steam was supposed to gain. First, I have a hard time conceiving why I'd even want to manage it from Steam,

In case you haven't heard of it, Valve sells the Steam Deck: a handheld gaming console with Steam as its primary UI. Under the hood, it's a low-power AMD x86 system running Linux (specifically, Valve's SteamOS distro). So having Dolphin on Steam would be the optimal way to make Dolphin available to Steam Deck users, just like having Dolphin available on the Google Play Store is the optimal way to make Dolphin available to Android users even though side-loading is an option.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by dgellow on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:55AM (#36093126)
Dolphin doesn’t need to be on steam to be used on a steam deck. You can install any program you want, it’s not restricted to steam.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by genocidicbunny on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:15AM (#36093226)
To most people, if it's not on Steam, it doesn't exist, especially on a Steam Deck. So while anyone can still install it outside of Steam, by not being available via Steam their possible audience is significantly reduced.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by bigDinosaur on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:40AM (#36093334)
Is this so true of emulators? Emulators already often require lots of work to go find the games themselves (which certainly would not be distributed on Steam), so how much effort is actually spared for the users? Very little.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by asveikau on Saturday May 27, 2023 @11:04AM (#36095388)
> Emulators already often require lots of work to go find the games themselves

That used to be true, but today, ROM sites are very easily discoverable on Google. People also sell ROMs on hard drives and SD cards on Amazon, many of them qualifying for Prime delivery.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by wtallis on Saturday May 27, 2023 @01:08PM (#36096339)
> That used to be true, but today, ROM sites are very easily discoverable on Google.

I'm pretty sure it hasn't been true at any point in the past 25 years. ROM sites have always been easy to find, even pre-Google.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by asveikau on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:02PM (#36099292)
I used to find them on IRC fserves. I first started doing that maybe 26 years ago. Using an IRC client and a command line, so not stuff most people off the street would be familiar with. Later on I remember them being traded on apps like Hotline. I don't recall it being super easy in the few years after that. It wasn't a mainstream thing, you had to know a little bit about the communities involved.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by bowsamic on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:45AM (#36093354)
Yes but if you make an emulator available to most people, most people are going to use it for piracy, and you are obviously going to attract a lot of attention from the law. I'm not saying that emulation should be illegal, but really this is a case where I am literally not surprised at all that Nintendo would act
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by das_keyboard on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:53AM (#36093652)
But is it really piracy if there is no way to buy and play the original game except for completely overpriced second-hand stuff?

I now it is legally, but morally I don't think people are doing something wrong here.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by _aavaa_ on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:22AM (#36093793)
Is it? Yes.

Should it be? No.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by bowsamic on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:21AM (#36094137)
That really is irrelevant. Companies don't want it to be there, and will use their immense powers to try and stop it being there. It isn't worth the risk of trying to put it on Steam
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by numpad0 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:46AM (#36095239)
That view is just a result of massive cultural/language barrier between ja-JP and en-US(-gaming) community. Not a global thing.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by dgellow on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:28AM (#36094174)
Dolphin is by far the most well known emulator in its category. Honestly emulators don’t really have their place on a game marketplace, that would really just be an incentive for people who want to easily pirate games for free.

Anyone interested in emulating a Wii or GameCube for legitimate reasons will easily find Dolphin and can install it on their Steam Deck.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by refulgentis on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:23AM (#36095059)
> Anyone interested...will easily find Dolphin and can install it on their Steam Deck.

Anyone?

Really, anyone?

rubs forehead

It's easier to have it on Steam. When I was 15, 25 even, maybe I'm so excited and hellbent on getting an emulator that I actively figure out the 10 step process to sideload. As a casual, it's much nicer when it's one step.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by chungy on Saturday May 27, 2023 @11:25AM (#36095547)
> maybe I'm so excited and hellbent on getting an emulator that I actively figure out the 10 step process to sideload.

Steam Deck isn't locked down. From Steam itself, you just "exit to desktop", and bam you're met with a KDE desktop. Running Linux. You can do whatever you want. Including installing emulators and games that aren't distributed on Steam. It only takes one step: "flatpak install dolphin-emu"

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by account42 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:28AM (#36136675)
> Honestly emulators don’t really have their place on a game marketplace, that would really just be an incentive for people who want to easily pirate games for free.

So what? If Nintendo fails to provide a way to buy the games on that device its on them. We really don't need to make excuses for corporations generating unneccesary E-waste due to their greed.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by i2cmaster on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:36AM (#36094235)
Maybe people that clumsy shouldn't be doing legally gray things with computers.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by brookst on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:28AM (#36095096)
Yes, and technically people can just code their own emulators, too.

Convenience is important.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by dgellow on Sunday May 28, 2023 @01:42AM (#36101480)
You can install dolphin on your steam deck via flatpack. It’s a single command.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by extrememacaroni on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:39AM (#36093332)
It's not like having dolphin on steam will give you access to free gamecube and wii games. You will still have to get them yourself and/or any bioses that may be required, I dunno.

Which means a bit of hacking, which means you should already be capable enough to install emudeck on your steam deck. Which is vastly superior to any single emulator on steam itself.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by DevKoala on Saturday May 27, 2023 @05:59AM (#36093428)
Srsly. I don’t get what the point of this was.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by Eduard on Saturday May 27, 2023 @06:41AM (#36093600)
> It's not like having dolphin on steam will give you access to free gamecube and wii games. You will still have to get them yourself and/or any bioses that may be required,...

Yet.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by bhelkey on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:49AM (#36094815)
From Dolphin's FAQ [1]

>Where can I download game ISOs/ROMs ?¶

>Short answer: You don't. Buy games and dump them with a Wii.

>Long answer: Downloading commercial games is illegal and thus strongly frowned upon by the Dolphin developers.

[1] https://dolphin-emu.org/docs/faq/#couldnt-dolphin-use-more-m...

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by wkat4242 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#36096683)
"Strongly frowned upon" lol. Wink wink

Ps this is not a moral judgement, I would use it myself except I don't like Nintendo's style of games. I owned a Wii and bought some games but I was really bored. I modded it and downloaded everything I could get and not a single game could capture my attention. I missed good fpses, it was all party game and kiddyish stuff like Zelda and Mario. So I've never looked at Nintendo since.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by philistine on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:12AM (#36094077)
I would bet good money that this is exactly why a DMCA was sent; someone at Nintendo was shown a Steam Deck, which is a big Switch competitor, loading Dolphin and playing Gamecube games for free with better performance than what Nintendo themselves deign to provide us.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by i2cmaster on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:35AM (#36094230)
Is there a reason you can't just use the normal OS package repo like everyone else?
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by chrisldgk on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:47AM (#36094346)
No, but the average (read: casual) user isn’t comfortable using the command line to install packages from the command line (and I don’t think SteamOS comes with a package manager UI), so there’s a huge potential install base for users if they could install it via the UI.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by dawidpotocki on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:03AM (#36094467)
It comes with Discover, the KDE Plasma GUI package manager. You can install Flatpaks using it on SteamOS.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by Tams80 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:57AM (#36095326)
Which just paints an even bigger target on it.

When it was on its own website and hosted on its own servers, with mostly word of mouth (online) spreading it, Nintendo were probably not too happy, but accepting that it was legal.

But when Valve, who are sort of competing with Nintendo, host it and promote, that's another matter. Especially when many people do play games using it that they have not legally obtained.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by freddie_mercury on Saturday May 27, 2023 @03:58AM (#36092881)
Putting it on Steam means all your games have (seamless, Steam) cloud saves for all your games.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by ekianjo on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:34AM (#36093035)
Only if they implement steam cloud saves. Its not automatic.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by kevingadd on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:36AM (#36093042)
It's pretty close though, there's a mode where you can just point Steam Cloud at a folder and it will sync it.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by Legion on Saturday May 27, 2023 @04:50AM (#36093099)
Dolphin's Twitter account stated that cloud saves was part of the Steam release.

It really is one of the main reasons to do a Steam release. Seamlessly playing your savegames and save states on desktop PC over to Steam Deck and back again made RetroArch one of the killer Deck apps IMO.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by chungy on Saturday May 27, 2023 @11:33AM (#36095598)
Even without Steam, you could use Syncthing for your Dolphin-emu data.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by MikusR on Saturday May 27, 2023 @01:27PM (#36096505)
Or even an ftp server and rsync.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by Jochim on Saturday May 27, 2023 @11:07AM (#36095409)
Steam has been much more than just a store-front for a while now. There's a few features that would take the Dolphin team a lot of effort to implement independently but can be integrated without much effort through Steam. A few examples would be:

- Steam Remote Play: Seamlessly playing your Wii games from your TV.

- Steam Workshop: Authoring, distribution, and management of modifications to the emulator.

- Steam Input: A powerful abstraction layer dealing with different controllers and the mapping of their inputs. Sharing and downloading input maps from the community is directly integrated.

- Steam cloud save: Share configuration and save data between computers.

- Steam's multiplayer API could potentially have made it much easier to use Dolphin for multiplayer games.

Most of these things can be achieved without Steam but they're less convenient, more difficult for non-technical users, and yet another thing to manage, update, and keep track of.