News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:06PM (#35990024)
Just yesterday I was trying to sign up with Verizon for my new address. Fiber is not available in my building, so they offer "5G Home Internet" for $60-$80/mo, which is crazy expensive for what it is. I asked whether there were ADSL lines available, since these were recently available for as cheap as $15/mo. It seems this is no longer the case. Maybe there's a market here?

EDIT: I am in the US, and I've just realized this is a UK-oriented article. Nevertheless, the point might still stand.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by andy_ppp on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:20PM (#35990261)
It’s still always interesting to see how vested interests and rent seeking seems to be a big part of US business culture. I wonder if the US would be more or less successful without these uncompetitive business practices.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by asdfman123 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:53PM (#35992439)
> vested interests and rent seeking seems to be a big part of US business culture

This is also true about nearly every other country that exists or has existed throughout history. US is notable for being, on average, much more competitive and less corrupt.

(But it's heading in the wrong direction, and that's only on average. Many countries have caught up, and a few others have surpassed it.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by andy_ppp on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:56PM (#35994667)
This sounds like American exceptionalism - I'm not sure the prison industry or the water industry being more competitive is good or that they are less corrupt than the state running them.

Corruption of markets happens because of no regulation or because of too much regulation. I personally think where to draw this line is an art and very difficult in an extremely polarised country like the US.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by asdfman123 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:05PM (#35994794)
No, it's not. You have to be careful about American exceptionalism, but America really did/still does lead the world in a lot of things.

It's still pretty good on the corruption index, although getting worse: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by andy_ppp on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:14PM (#35994904)
I don’t think capturing broadband markets and preventing other players entering would count on that scale as corruption although the sums of money involved are not doubt astonishing. You’re talking about something different to the context we were in as far as I can tell.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by asdfman123 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:46PM (#35995293)
Actually, believing this kind of monopolistic behavior is in any way unique to Americans is a perverse form of exceptionalism
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by andy_ppp on Friday May 19, 2023 @03:53AM (#35998991)
That’s not what I said, I said America is worse in many industries than for example the EU generally. For example farming, prisons and broadband all have various regulatory capture and vested interests that are far worse than anything we see in Europe.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by toomuchtodo on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:07PM (#35990045)
T-Mobile 5G Home Internet is $50/month. They’re using spare 5G capacity because they overbuilt their network. You’ll see congestion during peak usage times, but it’s fine otherwise.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:09PM (#35990073)
>You’ll see congestion during peak usage times

Yeah, that's kind of the issue. That, and latency.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by syntaxing on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:11PM (#35990127)
Not OP, but I used tmobile ISP for over two years during the whole Covid era. Worked pretty good for what it is, managed to get about 200 Mbps down and 20 up. I hit 500 Mbps but moved away from that area at one point. I only just switched to fiber recently because a 1G fiber line was installed and only cost $60 a month.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:23PM (#35990299)
>Worked pretty good for what it is,

Sure. The "for what it is" is doing a lot of heavy lifting, though. See also: it's rather expensive for what it is.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by ianlevesque on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:18PM (#35991972)
What? I feel like people coast on experiences from 5-10 years ago. This isn't a 3G hotspot. Ping time right now is 53ms and I'm getting 200/20 for $50, all included, no additional fees. This is outside their actual ideal service area too.

I'd love symmetric fiber for $50, but 'for what it is' isn't doing much lifting at all.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by larksimian on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:09PM (#35992648)
Eh, it's relative. You can get that for like 10 euros a month in Romania and they throw in a mobile phone and some cable channels to boot I think.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by hnav on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:05PM (#35994033)
yeah but you can haphazardly hang fiber off of telephone poles in Romania
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by syntaxing on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:30PM (#35992891)
Hmm not sure if I totally agree. Like sure, it’s a no brainer for my situation since I get 1G fiber for $60. But I have a bunch of friends and family paying $50 for Comcast for 200/10 copper lines.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by pitaj on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:09PM (#35990082)
How is the latency for these 5G home internet services?
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by syntaxing on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:12PM (#35990145)
Over 100ms most of the time, it worked fine for WFH when I had meetings. Terrible if you want to game.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by mdasen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:40PM (#35990544)
That's rare. T-Mobile averages 53ms latency according to Ookla/Speedtest.net
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by no_wizard on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:14PM (#35992704)
Try the fast.com or speed.cloudflare.com instead. Ookla is pretty easy to game by the ISPs
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by syntaxing on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:26PM (#35992837)
T-mobile != T-Mobile ISP. For the better or worse, anything going through the ISP plan is bottom of the barrel. You can look through all the post on the T-Mobile ISP subreddit. Even those with 500 Mbps speed are close to 100 ms of latency.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by exact_string on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:31PM (#35990412)
This is interesting since I remember having much lower latency for 3G, perhaps < 50 ms, about 10 years ago. :) At that time, some of my friends were even using the home 3G to play games.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by swimorsinka on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:16PM (#35990206)
Some of the people on my team had to switch back to Comcast after trying it for a few months. Video calls were laggy and would drop packets constantly. This was in Colorado fwiw.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by toomuchtodo on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:22PM (#35990294)
Your experience is highly dependent on how close you are to the nearest mobile base station and its utilization profile. If it's distant or highly utilized, you will have degraded performance vs being closer or less utilized.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by zten on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:25PM (#35993609)
I've got Verizon 5G for $25/month extra on top of my cell phone bill, and the tower is right across the street. It's pretty competitive with Xfinity's 1.2Gbps service since they didn't bother throttling it. I also get 350Mbps up. Seeing 15ms pings to servers in Sacramento from SF.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by rcme on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:08PM (#35990063)
ADSL is too slow for most modern internet usage.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:09PM (#35990093)
I emphatically disagree. If you live in a city, it's quite sufficient for IPTV, a bit of youtube, spotify, etc.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by bradfa on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:15PM (#35990187)
YouTube, Netflix, music streaming, most video conferencing, and general web browsing all work fine on a 1.5Mb/s link in my experience. It's certainly not fast, but it's fast enough to do the basics.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by lucb1e on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:51PM (#35990747)
Most things you mention are a matter of buffering and waiting it out, so those will work in a 'basic' fashion as you say. But video conferencing? Even in a 1:1 call, where you need to download only one audio and video stream, if you don't live alone (most people don't), I would be very impressed if you got a router that can recognise and prioritise the call traffic to the point where that works smoothly.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by bradfa on Monday May 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#36031974)
I used to have 768kbps down / 128kbps up cable internet. There was some buffering on Netflix at the start of a stream but it was fine. When we got upgraded to 1.5Mbps down / 256kbps up there was basically no buffering at the start of Netflix or YouTube streams and FaceTime worked fine.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by rcme on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:18PM (#35990241)
Sure, you might get away with consuming a single video stream. But you shouldn't be surprised that there is very little demand for this.

A single HD video stream (1080p) can require 8 mbps. Trying to consume multiple of these, especially with a realtime protocol like WebRTC, is impossible on an ADSL connection.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:22PM (#35990280)
I suspect there may be a fair few people in my position who would be happy to scale down. Whether or not that is actually the case is, indeed, a question for market research.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by rcme on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:37PM (#35990511)
I don't think you'd be happy scaling down. You may think you'd like it, but when you can't watch a video on your phone and laptop at the same time (and that's not even talking about anyone else using WiFi in the home), you'll quickly realize why no one uses ADSL any more.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:20PM (#35992772)
>I don't think you'd be happy scaling down.

My current setup is ADSL. I am trying to replicate it elsewhere.

As a subject-matter expert on "things I like", let me assure you that I am indeed very happy with it.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by CrampusDestrus on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:52PM (#35990753)
Yes, consume consume and keep consuming. Earn less and consume more!
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by jdofaz on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:44PM (#35990623)
My DSL is 15/1, it's fast enough to stream 4k. The upload stinks but its cheap and reliable.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by pavon on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:45PM (#35990635)
Do you specifically mean ADSL to exclude ADSL2 and ADSL2+? Through the entire pandemic I had a 20Mbps ADSL2+ line, and we had no problems with two of us remoting into work or one of us remoting in while the other streamed Netflix.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by ihattendorf on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:59PM (#35990880)
If you're referring specifically to ADSL then yes, however VDSL is passable, typically 100 down/10 up. Fiber would be ideal, but not worth 4-5x the price IMO (currently paying $33/month).
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:13PM (#35992693)
Ah yeah, I think I had VDSL in mind! Thanks!
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by somehnguy on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:55PM (#35991658)
Disagree, it’s not ideal but it’s perfectly usable. I lived in a rural town with 4.5mb/s down and .25mb/s up DSL for a couple years and even 4K Netflix worked perfectly fine.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by esaym on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:03PM (#35991769)
"Too slow" is most always the wrong word. Too much buffer bloat is what causes most of the problems. I survived fine on a 6/.5kbs dsl connection from ATT for years. I had set up a few QOS rules on my router using fq_codel. Night and day difference. I was regularly on voip calls for work while netflix was showing on two different TVs with no issues. It is really depressing that bloat is still an issue.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by pivo on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:45PM (#35990644)
I tried Verizon 5G for several months. It could be very fast (600Mbps down, maybe 100Mbps up) but it wasn't very reliable. We had some days where it just didn't work (maybe two days out of six months.)

It's $50/mo (IIRC) if you have mobile phone service with them. For me, the worst part was that they want you to mount their 5G device on your window, and I'm in the city and have only a few windows. It's not an ugly device really, but I don't want to glue a big device to my living room window.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by mdasen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:48PM (#35990699)
I'm surprised they're quoting you $60-80/mo. Verizon's 5G home internet is $50/mo (or $25/mo bundled with one of their premium wireless plans or $40/mo bundled with Visible's $35/mo Visible+ wireless plan).

Why would you want DSL? In my area, Verizon's DSL is 3.1Mbps which really isn't good for much and costs $75/mo ($40 for the DSL and $35 for the required home phone service with it). You also have to pay $3.50/mo for the router or buy it for $100.

Verizon stopped expanding Fiber for the most part which is a shame. AT&T is doubling its fiber deployment in their markets.

Do you have a cable provider that's your broadband provider? Verizon is generally only offering 5G Home Internet in areas where there are other broadband options so it seems curious that you'd be interested in DSL over a cable connection offering 100x the speed.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:15PM (#35992715)
>$25/mo bundled with one of their premium wireless plans

I mean, this contributes to my point: it's only "cheap" if you buy into their plan and also upgrade your phone. For a variety of reasons, this isn't a good fit for me, and I'm beginning to suspect there might be a small-but-respectable market of others who resemble me.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by timerol on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:55PM (#35990812)
Note that if you use Verizon for your cell phone and have a 5G plan, the price halves. Setting up AutoPay lowers it further, down to $25 best case. (I'm currently paying $35 for 5G Home Plus.)
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by abawany on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:41PM (#35991491)
Verizon 5G Home Internet is also typically $50/mo - were you ordering through the building, which might be taking a cut?
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:14PM (#35992702)
Nope! This is straight through Verizon's main website.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by abawany on Friday May 19, 2023 @01:59AM (#35998314)
I just double checked as a new customer - you're right that it's 60 usd/m but it goes down to 50/m if you autopay using a debit card (strange Verizon artifact - but annoying). Edit: I've been a customer for a year and while the early months were rough wrt. reliability (1), it is now pretty rock solid in my area and I typically get close to 300mb/s though I don't game so I'm not sure how it is with that.

1: so rough that I wrote a script that power cycled the modem every time it disconnected, since that was faster than waiting for it to recover. I haven't used that scheme for months now though since it was no longer necessary.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by mym1990 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:48PM (#35991580)
I just got Verizon home internet for 25$ a month, and they offer 200$ back if you stay on the service for 6 months(I am also on their phone service so that may be why the price is cheaper?).
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by schwoll on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:49PM (#35992404)
Ask them for a landline phone. They'll either have to run new copper or choose to install fiber. Once they run copper then get a DSL company to run through that. Generally they won't want to run copper and don't want competition so they'll go ahead and run fiber. In either case I believe the law they're constrained by is local ordinances giving them a region based monopoly for traditional landline access in exchange for ensuring everyone has a phone. If you force the issue they'll run SOMETHING to your door. And through that something you'll have more options.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by CapstanRoller on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:37PM (#35992990)
* * *
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by jeremyjh on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:08PM (#35993403)
They would run fiber to do that though. Hence GP's point that they will run SOMETHING.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by schwoll on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:34PM (#35993692)
Correct. This is all based on my previous knowledge of my local monopoly agreements that someone told me about years ago. They refused for months to install internet until I asked people in my vicinity if anyone had asked for a phone line. Nobody had. So I did and instead of copper they ran fiber within 2 weeks.

I can only infer what happened but they really didn't want me to be without a regular phone line so I determined that was their legal weakness. The only way companies that large move like that is if something threatens their status with the local government. A call from a resident saying the company wouldn't install a phone line is a big no-no in my understanding.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by Faaak on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:38PM (#35993720)
In Spain they use the 4g/5g infra for that and provide you with a 4g to RJ11 adapter
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by CapstanRoller on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:56PM (#35994673)
In my area (Washington State, USA) this doesn't happen.

If you ask for phone service, Comcast will sell you a "landline" that just consists of a combo box cable modem and VoIP ATA. You can buy it with internet access or without, and they still give you the same equipment. The ATA part gives you an analog phone line to connect to your house phone wiring, but everything outside the house runs over existing coax infrastructure.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by omginternets on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:17PM (#35992734)
This sounds like great advice! I'll do this first thing tomorrow. Thank you!
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by schwoll on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:25PM (#35993612)
No guarantees bc it entirely relies on your local ordinances, but it did work for me when the company was giving me the runaround about internet. I just asked for a landline phone and they had fiber installed within 2 weeks.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by MisterTea on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:58PM (#35993275)
Will they still run copper? Out here on Long Island Verizon will not install new copper and existing cu lines are on 3rd party life support. Work had to replace a copper phone line for the fire alarm with an internet bridge and wireless backup after it went dead and the tech told us "We don't run new copper."
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by schwoll on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:28PM (#35993644)
In a bunch of areas the companies rely on legal monopolies that were given to them by the local governments. The agreement was they get a monopoly if they agree to install phone lines for everyone who asks. If they don't run copper then the next thing they'll do is run whatever is their preferred equivalent. It's a quasi government+private monopoly agreement that benefits both and ensures residents get phone lines.