- Ads that follow new mothers even after miscarriage [1],
- Age discrimination on employment ads [2],
- Cambridge Analytica was also mostly about targeting,
- probably many more.
Perhaps we should explore some actual transparency in the context of ad targeting.
[1]: "How to stop pregnancy ads following you after a loss" https://www.tommys.org/about-us/charity-news/how-stop-pregna...
[2]: "New Research Shows Job Ads Deter Applicants Age 40 And Older" https://www.forbes.com/sites/sheilacallaham/2022/09/26/new-r...
It's getting funny - in a sad, tragicomic way - to see people getting so worked up about other people having biases against them, afraid that such people being allowed to publish/speak/exist will somehow, somewhen lead to bad thing for you and yours. At the same time, people are completely ignoring that there exists a whole industry that's actively malicious, that's harming you right now - one that doesn't even hate you, but rather denies you your humanity, and cares only about extracting some money off you. If you become poor, or sick, or die in the process? This group couldn't care less.
Yes, that's the advertising industry, and associated sales and marketing cultures.
I suppose the trick is, it's hard for people to realize who's consistently screwing with their lives - with tragic outcomes such as those hinted in the comments above - when the perpetrator controls the very means people use to communicate and learn about the world.
EDIT:
It's doubly hard because this means the perpetrators are among us - among our friends, among our families, even ourselves - many whose work involves either directly or indirectly, to a greater or lesser degree, attempting to screw over innocent strangers. It shows that, the way modern economy is structured, it's really hard for anyone to be fully innocent. It's very uncomfortable to think about, even more uncomfortable to talk about. It's much easier to focus instead on hypothetical others, somewhere out there, that are out to get us.
I was going to disagree with this, but then I was opening with a disclaimer along the lines of "other than the ones green washing the oil industry, and the ones who were encouraging people to smoke long after it was known to be dangerous, and the ones working for gambling companies, and the ones selling alcohol to alcoholics".
I used to work for a big ad agency, and while I'm not aware of any projects we took on which were actively harmful to quite that degree there was definitely a general culture of not really caring about whether or not what we did was worthwhile. Several projects I worked could only be described as redistribution of money from one company to another, because we all knew they'd have no real benefit to anyone - the people being advertised at didn't want the ads, and the company being advertised for wasn't going to get any sales from them. I was explicitly told on a few occasions not to add detailed analytics because then the client would have hard numbers on how useless the campaign was.
I guess i understand the sentiment, but we shouldn't shame people away from discourse. Everyone should be allowed to be wrong, if comments are made in good faith.
You’ll find plenty of people that agree with you, but usually because they’ve conflated this with genuine interference.
There’s nothing wrong with suggesting people think before speaking. To say otherwise basically outs you as a child.
A better one would be “please understand that this is talking about advertising and regulation in a country with norms very different from your own. If you don’t know the difference, don’t jump in with comments about how you think things should be.”
Like if someone defends this advertising under the First Amendment, that isn’t very relevant to the UK is it?
The ongoing insinuation that the US is the One True Way to run a State has caused so much legitimate worldwide damage. It’s sad to see supposedly enlightened HN commenters continue to perpetuate it.
Even the USA? Prescription drug advertisements are illegal in the UK, except when aimed specifically at medical professionals. When I visit the USA, it throws me every time when I see prescription drugs advertised on prime-time TV.
Funny. Ads seems to absolutely everywhere in the UK. It feels very overwhelming. Reminds me of those famous crossings in New York and Tokio.
So advertisements can and are everywhere so long as they are not misleading, targeting kids or grossly offensive (I imagine)
My country (Japan) likely has one of the highest rates of child gambling addiction in a developed nation.
The number of times I heard "I spent all my savings on the casino haha, gotta skip some meals I guess" was ludicrous.
That was in highschool. And now I see it in middle schools. (Siblings)
I have done my part ensuring my sibling doesn't get involved in that garbage.
The are all fundamentally designed around the same psychological hooks.
So instead we have pachinko parlors. They do not have age restrictions.
We also have gacha games which heavily push gambling and incentivise the spending of money for png images.
It's just that the generation has moved onto gacha games with systems that are even worse. They tend to be better designed and more easily accessible.
The shirt sponsor ban is a pre-emptive measure so that when the goverment comes after the Premier League they can point to the fact that betting companies have been banned from sponsoring shirts. Betting promotion in the form of pitchside displays / TV ads before & during games will still be allowed.
Large advertising spends have pilfered a tremendous amount of pharmaceutical influence in mainstream media. So much so that much of the salary of mainstream news personalities is funded by drug companies. It has become exceptionally difficult to criticize or challenge drug companies on major tv and print outlets.
You likely come from a culture that lets pharmaceutical companies advertise on TV. You likely come from a culture that doesn't restrict fast food companies from advertising during children's programming. You likely come from a culture that doesn't force all product placement to be clearly marked with an icon on the programme.
Advertising in the UK is much more heavily regulated than in other countries. We don't believe in the right for companies to advertise whenever or wherever they like.
Gambling is fully legalised, in part so that it is easier to regulate, including regulating when and where it is advertised. There is talk from banning gambling companies from being shirt sponsors.
This is, I think, a more mature approach than banning or heavily restricting online gambling and pretending it isn't a problem.