News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by ip26 on Sunday May 14, 2023 @04:43PM (#35941214)
Planned obsolescence can be a good thing. Cans from the fifties and sixties still work. Nobody wants to use them; they are heavy, uncomfortable, have poor performance, need an amp to drive, and use huge old school connectors. They are from a time when music was enjoyed seated in one place.

Products that fail prematurely or wear out while the owner still wants them are poorly designed. The pinnacle of design is a product that works flawlessly until the day you are through with it, at which point every part fails simultaneously. Such a product wasted no excess material in being over-engineered, nor consumed exotic high performance materials when they were unwarranted, nor repair visits, nor extra fuel in transport.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by alexvoda on Sunday May 14, 2023 @05:00PM (#35941319)
> Cans from the fifties and sixties still work. Nobody wants to use them; they are heavy, uncomfortable, have poor performance, need an amp to drive, and use huge old school connectors. They are from a time when music was enjoyed seated in one place.

And there is still a market for them because some people still want to enjoy music seated and do nothing else at the same time. Of course, plenty more people want something else.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by adhesive_wombat on Sunday May 14, 2023 @05:01PM (#35941324)
> The pinnacle of design is a product that works flawlessly until the day you are through with it

Indeed, but for maximum utility, the second hand market is included in the "you" here. Things can continue to be useful to someone long after the first owner is through with them.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by ip26 on Sunday May 14, 2023 @06:09PM (#35941779)
Fair, I should probably say "the public" instead of "you". Many things enjoy a long second-hand life before the public's appetite for the product is gone.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by RobotToaster on Sunday May 14, 2023 @05:18PM (#35941418)
>The pinnacle of design is a product that works flawlessly until the day you are through with it

What about the 2nd, 3rd, etc user of the item? You're ignoring the second hand market.

I use Cameras that were made in the 30's, they still work despite the original user being "through with it" some time ago.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by voldacar on Sunday May 14, 2023 @05:46PM (#35941610)
By "huge old school connectors" I assume you mean the 1/4 inch TRS connector? Which is still totally normal on non-cheap headphones?
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by scns on Sunday May 14, 2023 @06:02PM (#35941730)
More like 5 pin DIN connectors (MIDI) but different. If you take a lot at old electronics you will see things for the first time.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by FieryTransition on Sunday May 14, 2023 @06:08PM (#35941767)
Wouldn't that be too big? A typical failure point of all my wired headphones/buds has been the connector or whatever the connector plugs into. A bigger connector creates more leverage, which in turn creates more force, which has been a problem. So for mobile usage, wireless audio seems to just eliminate a whole range of problems and failure points, so it's not all good to use physical connectors?
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by KerrAvon on Sunday May 14, 2023 @11:53PM (#35943719)
Connectors break because the materials are cheap, not the force per se. Size doesn’t really matter.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by voldacar on Monday May 15, 2023 @02:05AM (#35944375)
I've had a ton of old headphones and I've never seen something like a 5 pin DIN connector. The old IBM keyboards do use a 5 pin DIN though.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by iamacyborg on Monday May 15, 2023 @02:23AM (#35944468)
Old keyboards in general if I remember correctly, and mice.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by wkat4242 on Monday May 15, 2023 @05:04AM (#35945438)
Keyboards yes, mice no. XT and AT keyboards had a big DIN plug until the PS/2 popularized mini DIN for both keyboard and mouse.

But in the XT/AT days mice just connected to the serial port with a 9 pin D sub. Mice weren't all that common in those days anyway as most programs were still text based.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by astrange on Sunday May 14, 2023 @11:15PM (#35943525)
> Nobody wants to use them; they are heavy, uncomfortable, have poor performance, need an amp to drive, and use huge old school connectors.

Are you thinking of Stax electrostatic headphones? That describes them, but they can sound amazing and people definitely still use them.

60s headphones used the same jacks we have now, but they don't last forever and the plastics then weren't as comfortable as the ones now.

Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by npteljes on Monday May 15, 2023 @07:59AM (#35946816)
Planned obsolescence isn't a good thing, it means that the thing will fall apart far sooner than it should. What you mean is simple engineering: the product's lifespan is not being artificially, consciously limited. They might think that you won't need it long, and plan for that, by choosing materials, construction methods etc accordingly, but this is not planned obsolescence.
Re:Fairbuds XL review: the excellent noise-cancelling headph... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Monday May 15, 2023 @04:32PM (#35954097)
I think planned obsolescence can be a not-bad thing if the obsolescence phase is actually planned.

Is the product going to be trashed? Is it made of recyclable materials? Does it have materials in it that are hazardous to the environment? Can it be easily disassembled so those materials can be processed differently?