Except for 1979:
* https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-debt-default-idUSN1E76A0...
* https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/01/heres-w...
Not exactly the same thing.
Doesn't matter the reason. Doesn't matter the justification.
> It HAS defaulted when transitioning off the gold/silver standard, when the world moved off Breton Woods, and during the Civil War.
If moving off of Breton Woods was a default, then your first statement is wrong, and the US hasn't defaulted on its debt in 50 years:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bretton_Woods_system#Paralysis...
(Changed it)
[0] Unless you count forcing the treasury department to take extraordinary measures, which has happened several times; and has been going on since January.
Legislators across both aisles have demonstrated they have no interest in decreasing spending. This bill forces their hand while there's still leverage.
(edited for typo)
And any increases were across the board. Asking them to cut all of the increases from only ~10% of the expenditures is ludicrous.
And how would you determine if it is too low?
For example would the calculation consider the current population? the current factory capacity? Agricultural capacity? the year? Interest Rates? Tax Revenue? The populations desired rate of saving? The current desires and goals of the nation and its citizens? If there is no exact formula, then would a representative body that debates and agrees on a best estimate number be a reasonable way to decide that? If so isn't that what congress does already?
When Nixon decided to end Bretton Woods.
There were no other countries capable of going to war with the sole global superpower. Not even remotely close. Western Europe desperately needed the US to continue standing off the Soviets. Who was going to declare war? Nobody of course.
That remains true today (China for example can't project force outside of its borders effectively and the Europeans still desperately require the US to stand off the Russians).
These are questions I'd like to have have a grip on. Not an economist, obviously.
An open question, nobody really knows. As I recall, the president has no option that isn't technically a constitutional violation. We might want to throw this to the SCOTUS and settle it.
People who think things won't change (not only referring to this specific issue) because the USD is still quite strong, remains the world reserve currency, and has survived rough waters in the past have a perfectly reasonable argument, even if it will inevitably be wrong one day. And those who take a bearish outlook on the situation also have a reasonable argument - we're obviously living through a major inflection point in history, the world has been de-dollarizing for decades, and the global economic (and geopolitical) winds are shifting. It's quite reasonable to see a storm on the horizon right now.
The hedging/insuring is "real" stuff. In an economic collapse any sort of financial vessel will become worthless. But after all is said and done, land, rare metals, and "things" in general will all maintain their value. Bill Gates and Ted Turner are currently the top 2 owners of farmland in the US. [1]
[1] - https://www.farmlandriches.com/largest-farmland-owners/
But then due to poor economic policy we found ourselves in a situation where we had far more issued debt (currency) than we had gold. We were forced to default on those debts, withdraw from Bretton Woods, and basically just told the rest of the world 'deal with it.' A famous quote from the Secretary of the Treasury at the time was, "The dollar is our currency, but it's your problem."
A default is by definition when you break a contract. On July 1944, the US signed the Bretton Woods Agreement. Agreements between countries change, they aren't contracts. That is why I don't think it is literally a default. Also, history has shown it was a sensible and beneficial thing to do.
The reason we were forced to default (or whatever you want to call it) on our obligations under Bretton Woods is that our economic policies were enabling inflation to start spiraling out of control. Cumulative inflation from 1913 to 1970 increased 306%. That was a major problem. From 1913 to today? It's 3091%. This causes countless problems in society. Take wealth inequality for instance. Workers have always expected annual raises, even in times of negligible inflation, but in inflationary times those those raises often struggle to even keep up with inflation. This [1] is a graph of real wage for workers. It understates the picture as it starts in 1979, at which point the decline was already in full swing.
But even there, you see but a 10% real increase in wages over the past 40 years. By contrast, real GDP/capita [2] has increased by more than 100%. And not only are there are far more basic costs to life today than in 1979 (internet, electronic devices, etc) but many things like housing and education costs have accelerated dramatically far ahead of nominal inflation. So you have a world with more billionaires than ever, and one where more people than ever can't afford to even feed themselves without government assistance. And this is not even scratching the surface of the issues. Basically we had a small problem in 1971. Instead of solving it, we stuck a bandage on it - leaving a later generation to solve a dramatically larger problem.
It HAS defaulted when transitioning off the gold/silver standard, when the world moved off Breton Woods, and during the Civil War.
I’d note that each of those defaults were related to the total collapse of the existing rules for national/global finance.
So ultimately, these defaults do bolster the case for the “never defaulted” folks: a default could literally bring an end to the current global financial system.