Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by gizmo686 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:37AM
(#35888018)
We have a budget process. If they fail to pass a budget, we get a government shutdown. Shutdowns are already extreme, but at least they are well understood and incremental. A 1 day shutdown is not too bad. A 1 year shutdown is untenable. Why do they need more leverage?
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by neodymiumphish on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:40AM
(#35888073)
I answered that in my second paragraph. They've proven they're incapable of developing a budget that doesn't balloon. Non-discretionary spending is through the roof, as evidenced by their demand of latching spending to the 2022 budget levels. That's last year. How is this extreme or outside the realm of even negotiation?
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by rootusrootus on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:57AM
(#35888316)
Recall that the largest contribution to the budget shortfall is not increased spending, but tax cuts. If this were not simple gamesmanship, the proposed solution would include tax increases to pay for that which we have already agreed to purchase.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by neodymiumphish on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @11:28AM
(#35888800)
That's absolutely false. Federal revenue increased by nearly 20%.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:29AM
(#35887911)
Cutting 1/3 of discretionary non-military spending is extreme.
(edited for typo)
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by neodymiumphish on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:38AM
(#35888047)
And it's discretionary spending they're trying to cut, not non-discretionary.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by neodymiumphish on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:38AM
(#35888029)
They want the levels set to the 2022 levels. The idea that they increased by 1/3 in one budgetary cycle is bonkers.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:44AM
(#35888140)
Huh? 2020 budget was $6.5T. 2021 was $7.3T. 2022 was $6T. 2023 is $6T. Considering inflation, spending is down ~10%.
And any increases were across the board. Asking them to cut all of the increases from only ~10% of the expenditures is ludicrous.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by roflyear on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @11:01AM
(#35888375)
Also debt ceiling is not the budget. Lots of incorrect info in this thread.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by harimau777 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:09PM
(#35889404)
Without including meaningful tax increases, I don't think that the Republican bill can really be said to be a serious proposal. "We get everything we want and you get nothing" isn't a good faith negotiating position.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by neodymiumphish on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @04:41PM
(#35893194)
Spending is the side of the equation that's most problematic, though. Renevue has increased substantially lately, but the federal government has continued blowing past it at pretty insane rates. Both parties are obviously at fault, but this is the first major effort intended to curb it that we've seen in a long while.
Re:The four times the United States government defaulted on ...
by petrocrat on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:42PM
(#35890718)
The term ballooning is so qualitative and subjective that it is essentially a Barnum statement.
How would you determine if the number for the debt is too high? And why?
And how would you determine if it is too low?
For example would the calculation consider the current population? the current factory capacity? Agricultural capacity? the year? Interest Rates? Tax Revenue? The populations desired rate of saving? The current desires and goals of the nation and its citizens? If there is no exact formula, then would a representative body that debates and agrees on a best estimate number be a reasonable way to decide that? If so isn't that what congress does already?
Legislators across both aisles have demonstrated they have no interest in decreasing spending. This bill forces their hand while there's still leverage.