News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by branon on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:15AM (#35875592)
Cat's out of the bag on this one. You will never get all the guns back, not without running a very real risk of instigating civil war.

Ms. Jackson Lee thinks the real cause of the problem is "guns, guns, guns" - I say it's criminals, criminals, criminals. Why's Texas have so many criminals willing to use firearms for evil?

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by jimmytidey on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:40AM (#35876058)
A agree you can't 'get all the guns back', but there are still reasons to consider more stringent controls, two spring to mind:

1) It's about the social permission you give to people by making guns easily available. For example, in many European countries, bars, pubs and drinking are an absolutely central part of life, whereas in the US drinking establishments often have a much more 'taboo' vibe about them. Alcohol consumption is much lower in the US than Europe. Obviously there are questions about cause and effect, but I suspect that if the US made gun ownership into a more transgressive behaviour, there would be less gun crime.

2) Sometimes a tiny bit of friction makes a big difference. In the UK you can only buy paracetamol (Tylenol) 16 capsules at a time. Nothing stops you buying more by going to multiple shops, or by going back in the same shop multiple times. But that extra bit of friction has dramatically reduced the amount of paracetamol lying around in people's homes, and suicide from paracetamol has radically reduced as a result.

I get the principle you are articulating, but, in practice, it's probably quite a bit more nuanced. Texas isn't likely to be a state full of criminals, rather it's a state with different social norms around firearms, and permissive gun laws.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by giantg2 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:14PM (#35876551)
"Sometimes a tiny bit of friction makes a big difference."

If it is a tiny bit of friction, then SCOTUS would likely allow it. If not, it could be struck down. But what tiny bit of friction is being proposed that will have an impact on homicides?

It seems your argument is that reducing the number of guns will reduce shootings and that we can reduce them with "a tiny bit of friction". But the courts are generally holding that if the restrictions prevent qualified individuals from obtaining a gun, then it is not a tiny bit of friction, but an infringement on rights. It seems these are incompatible.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by Ancapistani on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:33PM (#35876865)
> Sometimes a tiny bit of friction makes a big difference

I have three firearms in my safe right now that were 100% legal when I purchased them. They came with a copy of a letter sent to the manufacturer by the ATF that clearly and explicitly states that they are legal as configured. January 31st of this year, the ATF decided that not only are they illegal, but they've always been illegal. If I don't destroy, modify, or register them they will each carry the same penalty as if I had manufactured machineguns in - checks calendar - 22 days.

Oh, and the registration process requires me to sign a statement indicating that I have committed a felony. The ATF has promised not to prosecute me for it, but... well, forgive me if I don't trust the ATF.

This is not the first time I've had hundreds or thousands of dollars of my legally-acquired property declared retroactively illegal.

I'd love "a tiny bit of friction", because this is ridiculous.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mindslight on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:38PM (#35877784)
* * *
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mcphage on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:57PM (#35878049)
> Most "gun control" legislation has resulted in arbitrary technical restrictions, utterly ineffective for their stated purpose

I'm not sure that's true, given the rise in gun violence starting when the last assault rifle ban ended in 1994.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by laverya on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:13PM (#35878287)
The federal Assault Weapons ban started in 1994 and ran for 10 years.

Assault Rifles have universal background checks complete with fingerprints, a multi-month waiting period, and a $200 transfer tax - and have since the 1930s. No new assault rifles have been available for civilian purchase in almost 40 years.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mcphage on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:20PM (#35879141)
> The federal Assault Weapons ban started in 1994 and ran for 10 years.

D'oh! Apparently "what number is higher, 1994 or 2004?" is too much for my primitive human brain.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by laverya on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:50PM (#35879524)
No worries, we've all done it!

And for that matter the most advanced artificial brains screw up math on a regular basis too

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mcphage on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:02PM (#35878125)
> January 31st of this year, the ATF decided that not only are they illegal, but they've always been illegal.

What do you mean here by "always been illegal"?

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by arprocter on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:03PM (#35878944)
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by GaryNumanVevo on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:39AM (#35876034)
> very real risk of instigating civil war.

Doubtful. Especially considering the American Civil war was started by wealthy land owners, but fought by the poorest conscripted Southerners. I don't really think Americans are willing to give up their extremely consumerist lives to fight and potentially die over what is essentially a hobby to most.

Of course it's a convenient narrative: that Americans would take up arms in a glorious battle to defend the Second Amendment. But, ultimately it's a marketing tactic pushed by gun manufacturers, a scare tactic to get people to buy up excess inventory before the next capital 'D' Democrat takes office.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by giantg2 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:53AM (#35876274)
What these people are missing is that it's not just consumers that would be involved. We can already see how law enforcement is split on the issue when you look at how many rural sheriffs are refusing to enforce new gun laws as they are enacted in various states. This is an issue that has a strong urban/rural divide, which means there are people in all manner of roles that could be on either side. And yes, some companies or people take advantage of that, just as other do from reporting on mass shootings while largely ignoring the everyday shootings that pose a bigger threat.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by Ancapistani on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:42PM (#35877010)
> I don't really think Americans are willing to give up their extremely consumerist lives to fight and potentially die over what is essentially a hobby to most.

I strongly disagree with the characterization that firearms are a "hobby to most".

That might have been the case as recently as the 1980s, but the push for gun control in the 1990s, culminating in the "Assault Weapons Ban" of 1994, galvanized gun owners. I believe that a comfortable majority of gun owners today see through a political lens, not as a hobby.

There's a reason the AR-15 became so prominent so quickly: they were (ineffectively) banned in 1994. When the Assault Weapons Ban expired in 2004, they flew off the shelves. They became symbols of the resistance to gun control, to the point that they acquired the nickname "America's Rifle".

Now consider that in 1994, there were far, far fewer ARs in citizens' hands and a gun culture that was largely oriented around hunting. In 2023, American gun culture is firmly rooted in political activism.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by andrewstuart2 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:18AM (#35875657)
If you want to use firearms for any purpose, you probably go to the place where firearms flow like milk and honey.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by rolph on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:20AM (#35875706)
Its the fomentation of hate, fear, and protracted power struggles.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mindslight on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:32AM (#35875927)
It doesn't seem like criminals per se (apart from murders by highly organized crime), but rather people with severe mental health problems. Mental health problems that are seemingly due to freebasing social media memes telling them everyone is out to get them, which have been given a pass due to being called "political discourse". For example by the time someone is answering their front door with a gun and pointing it at whomever is there, it's clear that person is suffering from a paranoia that should make them ineligible to possess firearms.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:23PM (#35876688)
Do you have evidence for that because psychologists disagree with you.

But let's pretend they don't. I'm all for universal mental health care. How does that help? What can we do to curtail gun violence, if we take the stance that it's a mental health issue? Evaluate everyone before letting them buy guns? Sold! Hell, I'll give mine back (after I've damaged them beyond use so no one can have them in the future).

We can play "Is it mental health?" all day but even if it is and we're going through a period of collective psychosis, I don't see how addressing mental health could ever really help here.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mindslight on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:34PM (#35876884)
Evidence for what, specifically? It's pretty obvious that society is having a major mental health crisis, likely caused by social media, and this isn't particularly controversial when talked about in any other context. But in this context, the groupthink of one political tribe is to focus on extremist solutions about the tools themselves, all but guaranteeing that nothing will really change.

And yes, I specifically said that mental illness should make you ineligible to possess firearms (isn't this already federal law or am I getting it confused with state laws?). There likely needs to be more implementation details to make this restriction actually effective. And there needs to be buy in from actual gun owners to police their own communities, rather than it being seen as more top-down nanny state regulations to be ignored.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:04PM (#35881501)
What you're saying, in the specific and the broad sense (beyond the scope of this conversation) is controversial. You're making a very bold claim. Can you share the data? Collective mental health across a single geography would be a fascinating read.

Again, let's pretend you're right. How do you bar someone from buying a gun because of mental health issues that are undiagnosed? Do we do a psych eval as part of purchasing a firearm? There's no part of common sense that allowed your local community to strip guns from you because then you'd be breaking a law by trying to steal from somebody and you'd probably get shot. We are talking about people with mental health issues that, in this scenario, have violent tendencies. I honestly see any way that declaring a mental health state of emergency can actually do anything to stop mass shootings unless it's also paired with stopping fun sales, strict red flag laws and legal confiscation of existing weapons.

Happy to hear an implementation plan that isn't just thoughts and prayers. Abbot (R, TX) says he's all in on mental health now, so let's see what that piece of sh comes up with.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by Ancapistani on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:03PM (#35877253)
> For example by the time someone is answering their front door with a gun and pointing it at whomever is there, it's clear that person is suffering from a paranoia that should make them ineligible to possess firearms.

First, let me say that "pointing at whomever is there" is a big step too far. Also, arbitrarily pointing a gun at someone who is not a threat to you in order to intimidate them is already a separate crime in the US - "brandishing". In the few states that don't have specific brandishing laws, that act typically falls under "assault" or "assault with a deadly weapon".

That said, it's very common for people to answer the door armed. I do. Generally that's a holstered pistol on my belt, but if I'm not wearing "street clothes" at the time it could be a tiny pistol in my pocket, a full-size pistol in my hand behind the door so it can't be seen, or a carbine similarly concealed.

Why? I grew up in a place where police response averaged a half hour or more. My home was a half mile (~0.8km for those of you outside the US) down a private gravel road; if someone was at my door that I didn't expect or recognize, chances are they were unwelcome. Generally that means salesmen, but we weren't the only people familiar with police response times, so precautions were well-founded.

Today it's partly a habit for me. Like many people, I have a cloud-connected camera system around my home and a doorbell camera. I never have to go to my door without knowing who to expect when I open it. It's not entirely habit though - if I'm physically answering the door and don't recognize the person on the other side, I can reasonably expect that the purpose of the interaction will be to eject them from my property. A firearm is nothing more than a tool to facilitate doing that with minimal risk to myself and my family.

> And this should be policed by other gun owners!

We do! Gun stores have the ability to deny a sale to anyone, at any time, for any reason. They exercise it regularly. If you don't believe me, find someone who can legally own a firearm and have them go into a gun store while smelling of weed, or alcohol. Alternatively, have them act erratically in the store. Then ask to buy a gun. Chances are they'll be refused service and told to leave at that point. If not, the person at the counter will give them a "Form 4473". There's a fair chance that the employee will use the time spent by the customer to fill out the 4473 to call the police. If the customer fills it out and their answers indicate that they are not a prohibited person, expect the employee to call in the background check and then pretend that the response is delayed. The customer will be instructed to come back later, at a specific time or when called. Police will be present when they're told to return.

Seriously. I've worked in a gun store and spend a fair amount of time in them, and I've seen this (or variants thereof) play out many times. If you come in and can't suppress your crazy long enough to hold a courteous conversation, you're not buying a firearm from them.

> But it's been drawn into this culture war where if we admit that Crazy Bob perhaps shouldn't have guns, then the "liberals" win or whatever.

What I see is that we're not afraid to "self-police", but see attempts to pass laws with an arbitrary means of depriving citizens of their rights without due process as a (rather obvious) attempt for the government to acquire the tools to disarm citizens at their leisure. In other words: it's not that we think Crazy Bob should be armed, but that we would much rather risk Armed Crazy Bob than to give the government the ability to apply the "Crazy" monicker to whomever they like.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mindslight on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:53PM (#35877995)
> if I'm physically answering the door and don't recognize the person on the other side, I can reasonably expect that the purpose of the interaction will be to eject them from my property

This is exactly what I'm talking about. First, it's unwarranted to think that your only action will be to tell them to get lost. What if they're asking for help? (And while it's certainly one's right to refuse to help someone, that minority opinion isn't particularly interesting)

Second, using this word "eject" indicates that you have set yourself up for a confrontation - from the same exact vein as the social media fueled paranoia I'm talking about. If you cannot answer the door with your priors set to that of civil society rather than action movie, then you aren't being particularly responsible.

> We do [police other gun owners]

Sure, sometimes. But if your buddy is having some mental health problems, and rejects your casual offer to hold his guns, do you escalate the situation to compel him to relinquish them? Or do you look the other way, knowing that he would end up on some kind of permanent flag list? That's the dynamic I'm talking about, and it's ultimately one that requires trust, which has broken down.

> we would much rather risk Armed Crazy Bob than to give the government the ability to apply the "Crazy" monicker to whomever they like.

Well at this point you aren't merely "risking" Crazy Bob. Rather there is an endless supply of Crazy Bobs continually shooting up public places, often broadcasting their psychoses ahead of time, while many gun advocates cling to this possibility that government might declare someone crazy for political purposes - while many simultaneously adopt aggressive craziness as a political movement!

One way or another something is going to break, and I'd much rather have it be this ignorant political groupthink than most everyone's basic right to self defense as referenced by the second amendment.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by outside1234 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:18AM (#35875652)
The good news is that guns are made of metal and metal rusts. So outlaw the military weapons and replacement parts and wait.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by mech765 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:20AM (#35875704)
World war one rifles coated in cosmoline are just as ready to shoot today as when they were stored in a barrel 100 years ago.

Take a look at the availability of the mosin nagant rifle.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by linksnapzz on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:20AM (#35875695)
Clearly, the technology for making things out of ...ferrous metals...is beyond the ken of ...Americans.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by tehwebguy on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:21AM (#35875713)
So we get manufacturing back in the US. Win-win!
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by Ancapistani on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:11PM (#35877349)
FYI: there's a pistol sitting on my desk in front of me, right now, that I had disassembled last night to thoroughly inspect and clean. It was made in 1909.

That 114-year-old pistol is not only still functional, the only way you could tell it wasn't factory-new when I bought it a few years ago was that the black hard rubber grips were starting to turn a little brown at the edges, and the nickel finish was discolored in a few places on the slide. I've since restored the grips and carefully polished the finish to correct those two points.

Off the top of my head, I have at least two shotguns, one pistol, and four rifles that have been in my family for >100 years. One of those rifles is so old that I'm unsure who first acquired it. It's a "Pennsylvania long rifle". Made long before serial numbers were "a thing", I'd date it to about 1820 based on the style. I know my great-great-grandfather had it, because I have a photograph of him using it as an old man in the early 1900s.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by throwawaysleep on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:42AM (#35876084)
You can slowly kill the gun culture over generations, both through legal restrictions and social ostracism of gun owners. Happy that my home country of Canada is becoming ever more anti gun.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by Ancapistani on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:44PM (#35877028)
Statistics show that laws have had the opposite effect in the US - they've fostered an anti-authoritarian cause that has become by far the dominant meme in gun culture.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by WillPostForFood on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:42AM (#35876093)
Why's Texas have so many criminals

Texas isn't an outlier in crime. It ranks 21st in murder rate . 84% of the population is urban (15th most urban state). Dallas and Houston are the 4th and 5th largest metro areas in the country, and struggle with the same crime problem as other big metros like New York, LA, Philadelphia, Chicago, Atlanta.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:17PM (#35876601)
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by WillPostForFood on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:23PM (#35876685)
Yes, the article is combining suicide and murder to come up with a combined "gun violence" metric. It is not a relevant statistic when talking about crime specifically.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:06PM (#35881509)
Technically suicide is a crime and shooting yourself with a gun is a violent act, so... Seems about right
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by WillPostForFood on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @02:12PM (#35891153)
Technically suicide is a crime

No it isn't, not in any of the 50 states is it a crime.

Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by stepbeek on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:50AM (#35876229)
Didn’t Australia do this? Or are you saying that the US is unique in gun culture? Not rhetorical, I’m genuinely interested.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by birdyrooster on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:56AM (#35876335)
I am far less free now that there are daily mass shootings. Me and millions of people stay in their homes and never go to populated places. It sucks and I would be willing to go to a deeper level of hell if it meant undoing these shackles.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:19PM (#35876636)
You didn't say if you have kids or not but as a parent, those worries are multiplied. There are lots of things we won't do because of the additional risk. The terrorists (white nationalists, red pills, etc) are winning.
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by igetspam on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:12PM (#35876519)
Sorry, clarifying questions: Are you saying Texas has more criminals? And would that apply to red states in general, as they have the most mass shootings?
Re:US on track to set record in 2023 for mass killings after... by giardini on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:02PM (#35878939)
branon asks: "Why's Texas have so many criminals willing to use firearms for evil?"

What kind of a question is that? Have you ever heard of a criminal who was willing to use firearms for good? If you were in a "Criminals' Bar" and said what you say above, they would laugh you out of the room! The very definition of a criminal requires that s(he) do evil, their very reputations ride upon how evil/badass they are perceived.

I, for one, am glad to see the broad acceptance of firearms in society. They bring with them a protocol that is commonly known, demands respect (under risk of death) and that encourages the adoption of etiquette (good manners), which is a necessity in a civil society. But while firearms keep our society safe, there is a price to pay. It's a sort of tax on society: you don't want it but it is necessary.

Back to the original question:

FWIW if you're a criminal, you'll get more laughs than money by beating someone with say, a shovel or a rake (as long as you don't overdo it). But you can't make decent money in stand-up comedy these days either. Soooo...

In all seriousness fighting is a physically demanding task, especially if it is necessary to survive each encounter. One seeks a tool that will maximize the harvest at least risk and least effort. The firearm comes immediately to mind. For good reason the Colt .45 revolver was call the "Great Equalizer":

https://thefederalist.com/2020/07/31/the-story-of-how-samuel...

The same Colt .45 revolver was called the "Peacemaker".

Finally, the more people, the more incidents of crime and thus more criminals. Texas is a growing state. For more details on crime growth maybe ask Joe Biden?