Is this the south of England? In my experience, anyone north of Birmingham holds the opposite attitude.
Many monarchists are offended by republican views. For that reason alone, I would have recommended against a republican demonstration in the middle of a large crowd of monarchists (if I'd been asked!)
Also, I don't think republicanism is very widespread among cops, a group of people that tend to have an authoritarian mindset.
I think some people have a sense that the monarchy "is theirs", as if this hyper-privileged family were their own children.
I didn't watch any of the coronation coverage on purpose, but it's been devliishly difficult to avoid. Something that struck me is that many of the most ardent monarchists in the crowd seemed to be yanks and aussies. I find that really weird.
It's not weird if you consider that only foreigners who give a shit will bother to come. Add that they to them this whole thing is distant enough to treat it as a theme park where they can larp their mediaval fantasies and it only makes sense.
Too bad they aren't phased by covering up sexual crimes then uh?
We've handed over many public spaces to private interests and cctv proliferated that way, arguably with even less oversight than had the gov done it.
By and large the UK feels like a gutted country, where every scavenging corporation took one organ and left.
[1] https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/475342/police-step-up-su...
Yes, it was.
> But that's the point of protest!!
No, it is not.
From Cambridge Dictionary: "protest": a strong complaint expressing disagreement, disapproval, or opposition.
You can express your dissenting opinions without being rude. And, by the way, the monarchy has been in UK for centuries, and it is still there: if you don't like it, you have any day available to protest. No need to pick that particular day when you can be most disruptive.
There are people thinking that we should not spend our public money on the monarchy. This viewpoint is absolutely topical on the very day when a large chunk of money is being spent on celebrating something they don't want to celebrate.
If you think that is rude, bad for you. Sometimes people will be rude to you and you have to take it.
They may be right, they may be wrong. They surely have the right to express their opinions. But the fundamental question is: who cares? Or, actually: how many people care?
If enough people cared, that would be on the agenda of a major political party. If it isn't, they have to suck it up.
I don't know. But I care about their right to shout their slogans and wave their placards more than I care about the existence or non-existence of the monarchy.
I do, too. I would have sympathised more with them in any other day, though.
Actually, I personally could not care less about coronation, so every protest going on that day just slipped over me :-)
If you didn't care, why would you even be in this thread?
Maybe they care but are scared by the nazi squads, ehm the police?
Why should your right to be seen be more important than the right of the government to organize a nice party for an event that will be in history books?
You have the right to protest, but the others must retain the right to ignore you. You talking in the centre of the public square, in the middle of the market, is ok; you screaming in my ear is not.
Unless you want to call right-leaning and left-leaning dictatorships both "fascist".
I will not comment on the rest of your reply, as it shows clearly how careless, stupid and ignorant you are.
"Peacefully attending a public gathering in yellow shirts with printed slogans" is my perfect definition of a protest. You take a message with you, I can read it and decide whether I'm interested in joining your protest or just go on with my life.
My comment's parent called me authoritarian because I said that printing the message on my car would not be acceptable.
... Yes pick a day when no one will notice.
sips tea with pinky out
The monarchy is classism personified.
Do you not think that by not being anti-monarchy you're tacitly OK with a class based society, and that's a part of where the conformism comes from - class identity?
Bear in mind the various loyalty swearing that goes on - MPs, Armed Forces, Police, is loyalty sworn first and foremost to the Monarch - implicitly a person at the top of a heirarchy of class.
No. Newborn babies aren't anti-monarchy either. Are they part of the problem? This rhetoric of "silence is violence" is deeply polarizing.
Actually they are since monarchy is at odds with the basic human rights we are all born with.
Similarly, we're born with human rights as ratified in the UN Declaration of Human Rights. To your point, they're moot if not enforced -- I get that. But it's easier to enforce what exists than to fight for the original law.
Why does the UN get to dictate human rights and not some other body? Did those human rights exist before the UN or not?
After the New Model Army chopped off a previous monarch's head (they purged parliament and the remaining MPs passed legislation that found King Charles I guilty of treason) I can see why subsequent monarchs were somewhat keen to have an oath of Loyalty.
This is exactly my position too.
And if you force me to chose between a) democracy, free speech and right to protest OR b) a monarchy, then I will very quickly become an anti-monarchist.
The fact that the government felt that they had to rush in legislation in the last week which was - completely predictably - used to detain people unlawfully, to save possible embarrassment during the coronation, has done nothing to improve my view of our monarchy whatsoever.
I struggle to believe that this would have happened without some sort of implicit or explicit pressure from Buckingham Palace. They did afterall have veto rights on aspects of BBC coverage [0] so it seems highly unlikely to me that they weren't also working with the government to attempt to "contain" possible protests.
[0] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/05/revealed-roy...
As for why I support this, I think it makes sense diplomatically to have an apolitical head of state and I also believe the British monarch functions similarly to second amendment in the US. If the UK ever needed to revolt against the government the monarch serves as way in which the public (and armed forces) could side with the state over the government. I cannot express how much I like that our armed forces swear allegiance to a largely powerless Monarch that represents the state rather than Rishi Sunak.
However, getting back on topic here, the fact the UK has a monarch in my opinion has zero relevance to the fact the UK is becoming a place increasingly hostile to protest. Instead, it seems to me to be far more to do with the fact our two major political parties both have authoritarian tendencies, which I suspect stems from the UK having cultural values which lend themselves to certain kinds of authoritarian social policies.
Specifically, laws around limiting "improper" behaviour like rowdy protests, being rude online, and consuming porn that's a little too edgy seem to be ways in which our dislike of improper behaviour manifest politically. In most ways we're quite a liberal society, but there are certain ways that our conformist and overly polite nature seems to work its way into our politics via democracy – protest perhaps being the most clear example of something that people here seem to struggle with since freedom of expression requires an acceptance of impoliteness.
> Specifically, laws around limiting "improper" behaviour like rowdy protests, being rude online, and consuming porn that's a little too edgy seem to be ways in which our dislike of improper behaviour manifest politically.
Jimmy Saville was way worse than any porn, yet his main enabler just became king. The outrage about the “impolite” seems very unevenly distributed.
No. They dont.
>He’s also powerful enough that people can be arrested for protesting his coronation.
Also No. That was the government.
I'm responding to this post:
> If the UK ever needed to revolt against the government the monarch serves as way in which the public (and armed forces) could side with the state over the government. I cannot express how much I like that our armed forces swear allegiance to a largely powerless Monarch that represents the state rather than Rishi Sunak.
The article we're commenting on makes it very clear that the UK is a monarchy and that the monarch has the power to disrupt public life at great expense to the public and to have said public arrested for offending them.
It absolutely doesn't. The article doesn't even mention the word monarchy.
It was written before the recent arrests at the coronation.
We can talk about what influence the monarchy may try to exert on the government behind the scenes (and I believe there will be some - and there shouldn't be) but back channeling aside, our democratically elected government is the body which runs our country, not the monarchy, and therefore is correctly the target of this article.
You don’t need a monarch to have problems with police overreach and overly draconian/authoritarian laws being brought in.
I think we can safely say that this happens in all types of political/governing systems.
That’s the crux of the issue being talked about in the article.
The issue of the Royal Family is related (and particularly relevant given recent events) but the two issues should not be conflated fully.
I was up in arms, and shouldn't have even commented.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/08/royals-vette...
The UK is a democracy.
> Can I ask why someone wouldn't be anti-monarch in 2023?
The sibling comment by kypro [0] answers this question much better than I could have. But at the same time, I'm not the British Royal Family's most diehard supporter by any means.
The UK is a democracy, technically a more well functioning democracy than some supposedly first world nations.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index#List_by_countr...
I never understood how this conformist attitude came to be exhibited from a people that on every other occasion, to the styles itself as proud.
Seems like, domestically a very different game is played.
What we call 'The King's Peace' is the British sense of fair play. You can do whatever you like as long as you don't interfere with my equal right to do the same. Where those two try to occupy the same space, then the current majority opinion will prevail and the minority suppressed.
Breaching the King's Peace is a public order offence.
The right to protest in the UK is the right to be heard and listened to voluntarily, not to dominate proceedings or act in a manner that heads towards terrorism. Where there is intelligence that physical disruption was on the cards, the authorities are right to step in and head it off. That is the British way.
Most people in the UK still support the monarchy. Nobody stopped Spiked publishing their views on Republicanism, and nobody was forced to read it. That's free speech.
If the individuals objecting had waved a few placards and otherwise been respectful to those whose views differ from their own they would have been left alone. They didn't do that and were removed. I suspect that was the idea since that leads to greater publicity.
A bit difficult to get heard once you get arrested for having violated no law… Funny that when putin does this to political opponents he's a dictator, but king charles is a great guy uh?
Come to the Bay! Honestly it's not the first time I hear the exact same sentiment from Brits living here in California.
Has King Charles made any efforts or donated any money to causes that could help the people in this time of recession and retraction from the EU? I know he isn't supposed to be involved in politics, but if he doesn't speak as the "conscious of a nation" then he really does seem without purpose at great cost.
People here don't care about being monitored by CCTV because they believe that so long as you keep your head down you'll be fine – and that any respectable person is going to keep their head down anyway.
You'll also find a lot of people here just dislike the act of protest in general. Again, I think it's because protest involves drawing attention to yourself which a large percentage of people here dislike on an instinctive level. So you find even the most agreeable protests seem to receive some level of pushback and shame which I think bleeds into our attitude towards policing. That said, I don't know what it's like in other countries. I just get the sense that the UK has a much more conformist attitude which enables the state to take a more authoritarian approach to policing protest here.
As an example, I'm not an anti-monarch but I was extremely angry about how the police handled anti-monarch protestors during the coronation. Yet when I've spoken to people about this over the weekend, most people have expressed to me that it was rude for there to be protestors at the coronation... But that's the point of protest!! Still, this doesn't change the fact that the act of protest is largely incompatible with our otherwise polite and conformist culture.