News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:41PM (#35754546)
I am a professional musician (bassoon player in a symphony orchestra). I can, if I practice it a couple of times a week, achieve and sustain perfect pitch.

I had no semblance of perfect pitch until I decided to practice it at age 24. Before that the only chance I had to guess a note was to put in in relation to my own voice.

Even though I don't practice this anymore (it isn't very useful), I still often just instinctively know what note I hear.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by vnorilo on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:46PM (#35754588)
Cellist for the last 35 years here. No perfect pitch. My "perfect" note identification is based on timbre: I know what each note sounds like on the instruments I know intimately.

For synthetic tones, I will be off +/- 3 semitones because I will be using an aural memory of the cello a string as a reference, rather than recognizing the frequency like the perfect pitch folks do.

Never occurred to me to practice perfect pitch because, as you said, it is not that useful.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by muxator on Saturday April 29, 2023 @01:25PM (#35754996)
Same for me on the guitar: it is easy to distinguish even the same note on different strings. Chords, too. But it's more a timbre plus relative pitch sensibility.

I never felt the "need" for absolute pitch.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by cormacrelf on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:49PM (#35758725)
It is useless for everyone except singers. If you’re a singer, you can cold-start a song in tune and have the band come in seconds later. Hard to do that without the confidence that you both started correctly and haven’t drifted.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Tor3 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:40AM (#35762966)
There's a story about the opera singer Kirsten Flagstad (1895 - 1962) from when she performed at a small place somewhere, singing opera songs with just a piano. Afterwards one from the audience actually complained directly to her that she didn't sing well, she was out of tune. She apologized and said that she had perfect pitch, and the piano wasn't tuned to her inner pitch - and she found herself unable to adjust to the piano.

As for singers in general, I've seen lots of professional singers who don't have perfect pitch but still can cold-start a song - they know their own vocal cords so well that they can start at the right pitch with confidence.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by fsckboy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:44PM (#35756409)
from what I understand, perfect absolute pitch is (to me) of negative value in the sense that it makes you annoyed at a lot of music. I've heard some people say it makes them not enjoy practicing pieces with other musicians. I think "why be aggravated if I don't have to?"
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by psutor on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#35757391)
Same here, also as a former bassoonist - each note on the bassoon has extremely unique timbre, and I find it very easy to identify them.

No perfect pitch for other instruments.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:00PM (#35766586)
You should try it on the baroque bassoon. It works there as well, despite the notes being a half note too low.

Or even the dulcian. The low C is very much the same as the bassoon low C despite being either too sharp or too low depending on school.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by muffles on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:48PM (#35759312)
> because, as you said, it is not that useful.

Having perfect pitch can be useful for a lot of musicians, or educators, or composers in various ways, including:

Improving accuracy in performance: Perfect pitch can identify and reproduce musical notes more accurately and quickly, which can help perform music with greater precision.

Improving music education: Perfect pitch can help people teach music theory and composition more effectively, as students with perfect pitch can better understand and apply the concepts.

Enhancing creativity in music composition: Composers with pitch can more easily hear and reproduce musical ideas in their heads, which can help them create more complex and interesting compositions.

Facilitating communication among musicians: Musicians with absolute pitch can communicate more effectively with each other by using a common standard for identifying notes.

Improving the ability to transcribe music: Musicians with perfect pitch can more easily transcribe music by ear, which can be useful for analyzing and studying music.... the list goes on

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:15AM (#35760921)
Many of your points are unsubstantiated.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:58PM (#35766567)
I am an orchestra musician. Having perfect pitch was only trouble, despite playing in good orchestras at the time.

In the end of Ein Heldenleben the orchestra will not be the same pitch it started and, and for you to be in tune you will have to play notes that will be more than a quarter tone too high compared to what you think is correct.

I found it awful. The only orchestras I have played in that stayed in tune was the Swedish radio orchestra and the Munich Phil. But a major third is 13 cent low there as well.

And regarding most other things: I would have loved to have it during solfege exams. That is about it. The trouble it gave me when doing the work I studied to do it got in the way.

Most colleges I went to had special classes for students with perfect pitch as they were taught different strategies. In my final exam in "Gehörbildung" the two top scoring students did not have perfect pitch.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by edbaskerville on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:57AM (#35759800)
My experience with pitch memory is nearly identical to yours (but only 34 years playing cello, not 35).

Absolute (perfect) pitch really does seem to be a whole different thing neurally, akin to (and perhaps actually related to) the difference between learning a language before a critical age and learning one afterwards.

I'm gonna try to teach it to my kid, because, why not. Even if it's not that useful most of the time, there are definitely times when it would come in handy for me, e.g., being faster at transcribing notation from recordings. If he doesn't end up using it, that's fine.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:38PM (#35766390)
I suggest not to do it. It is really painful in the orchestra when the orchestra has gotten sharper than what you are comfortable with and you have to play a minor third. I remember playing Mahler 2. The hall was hot as hell and the orchestra had risen from A441 to what must have been A445. I had to play a major sixth and it was borderline revolting.

I stopped practicing it after some experiences like that. Knowing what note to play by some absolute measure is only useful if you are playing alone. What you play in an ensemble is relative to a lot of other people.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:49AM (#35763042)
On the bassoon this was (and is) the case for me. It even translates to instruments very close to the bassoon such as dulcian and the French basson. If I hear a baroque bassoon I know what note it is in 415.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klysm on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:47PM (#35754595)
I’m curious how much initial effort it took you to get decent at it
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:07AM (#35783933)
Not very much, surprisingly. It was in a period of my life when I was practising a lot, which might have helped.

It took only about a month before I went from having to reason about what note it was to just knowing instantly.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klysm on Saturday May 13, 2023 @04:49PM (#35932561)
I usually use the technique of finding the interval from the lowest note I can hum - did you reason with a similar technique?
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by 0x445442 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @12:47PM (#35754601)
Interesting, I didn’t know perfect pitch was something you could practice. My son was a pretty high level french horn player and from a very early age he had perfect pitch. His teachers always told us it was something you’re born with.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by opan on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:46PM (#35756442)
I had an English teacher tell me once that being a good speller was something you were born with (she was not the best speller despite teaching English, and I was pretty good, to be clear). I think saying stuff like that is just how people cope with their own lack of trained skills and how they justify not improving. I've seen similar excuses from people who don't quite feel like learning to solve a rubik's cube.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by belter on Saturday April 29, 2023 @01:13PM (#35754868)
How far does it go on your own case? Are there degrees of it?

Can you do the level harmony recognition like in the video below or it's more the individual notes when played on it's own?

https://youtu.be/hli-9maxDjY

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:07PM (#35766633)
Not quite that extreme. I could use it for harmonies if it wasn't too many dissonant notes because I couldn't tell the notes apart.

However, that is something I trained before doing the perfect pitch thing. Being able to pick apart harmonies is extremely useful. Having perfect pitch just made it a little easier.

I always found it hard on the piano. I wonder if it is related to the fact that everything sounds good on the piano, even things that are badly composed. Parallel fifths in a chorale on the piano? Sounds wonky but ok. In a chorus? Awful.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by helaoban on Saturday April 29, 2023 @01:16PM (#35754895)
Could you elaborate on your method? That's quite impressive considering it's widely believed to be untrainable past a certain age (at least that's layman my understanding).

Did you start with a complete inability to identify notes, and now are able to identity them immediately (i.e like acquiring a new language?).

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by hluska on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:36PM (#35755749)
The idea that you cannot attain perfect pitch as an adult has been thoroughly debunked. The University of Chicago’s study is most famous but results have been replicated at many other schools. Adults can develop perfect pitch just fine.

The issue seems to be that most adults find it useless and as artists they’re better off spending their time elsewhere.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by coliveira on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:01PM (#35755972)
Yes, the biggest problem to acquire perfect pitch is that Western music is made exactly to wash away the difference between keys. Instruments are designed so every key is relatively the same. Things would be different if every key had a slightly different relationship. This used to be the case in medieval music, that's why early composers thought about different keys having different moods.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by pjlegato on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:12PM (#35757764)
That statement is not true of Western music in general, only of most (not all) classical and poular music since roughly the 18th century, when "equal temperament," tunings designed to make all keys sound the same, became popular.[1]

Much Western music, such as that written during the the Baroque, Renaissance, and medieval eras, as well as certain modern genres like barbershop quartets, modern classical, electronica, microtonal and atonal music, etc. use a variety of other systems such as some form of just intonation[2], where different keys sound very different as they exhibit differently sized versions of the same interval.

Conversely, much non-Western music also uses some kind of equal temperament (where keys all sound the same), such as Chinese, Arabic, Indonesian, Thai, and Native American music.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_temperament [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just_intonation

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by musicale on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:31PM (#35756859)
I hadn't actually heard of the Chicago work before, but this is interesting:

"These results suggest that the acquisition of intermediate absolute pitch ability (significantly above chance but below ‘‘true’’ AP performance) depends on an individual’s general auditory working memory ability" [1]

Apparently learned absolute pitch wasn't as accurate as "true" perfect pitch.

[1] https://www.academia.edu/download/52277554/Auditory_working_...

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by hashmap on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:58PM (#35758483)
This isn't quite right; the University of Chicago study replicates what has already been known for a long time - that musicians can develop their pitch memory around the timbral context clues of a particular instrument. However, this learned pitch does not generalize to other instruments and/or common everyday sounds (train horns, washing machine vibrations) in the way that people with absolute pitch can instantly identify.

An analogy to this might be that a colorblind person if shown enough fabric and told what the colors were can eventually associate the texture of the fabric with a given color and can learn to do this translating in their head, but they will not be able to train their eyes to see color no matter how much practice takes place.

Rick Beato covers the subject rather well in his video "Why Adults Can't Develop Perfect Pitch" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=816VLQNdPMM

If it were the case that such a substantial number of amateur test subjects could develop absolute pitch from doing a few exercises, we would expect to see commensurate numbers of musicians who spend thousands of hours playing music to also develop this skill, but this is not and has never been the case.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by freedomben on Saturday April 29, 2023 @01:34PM (#35755095)
How does one "practice" perfect pitch? (genuinely asking so I can try it, not trying to make some dumb rhetorical point about it not being possible)
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by 49531 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @01:50PM (#35755290)
There are tools you can use that will play a note like C and then another note, and you listen and guess what the 2nd note is. It just takes a bit of consistent trial and error learning, after a bit you get the hang of it and kind of create a mapping of what notes sound like in your head. I use a app called Tenuto for it, but I am sure there are others out there.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by sparky_z on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:06PM (#35755454)
That would be practising "relative pitch", which is a standard part of ear training. "Perfect pitch" means being able to identify the 2nd note when played by itself, without hearing the 1st note to reference from.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by pclmulqdq on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:21PM (#35755600)
I had an ear training teacher who claimed to have acquired perfect pitch by listening to a tuning fork for 10 minutes a day, and training himself to remember the pitch as a reference. I doubt very much that this worked long-term.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by C-x_C-f on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:06PM (#35756643)
I don't have perfect pitch but if there's no sound around I can accurately recall the pitch of my alarm (the standard Android one) within a half tone, so I think that strategy makes sense
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Tor3 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:46AM (#35763008)
That's simple pitch memory. I started playing guitar at 12 and at that time used a tuning fork - and I noticed that after a while I could hear the "right" note of the A string in my head and I didn't really need the fork anymore. That ability is just pitch memory (which can be thrown off) combined with learning the timbre of the instrument you play (in my case a guitar string).

And yes, that's not the same as perfect pitch, which typically includes much more than the above. I certainly don't have it, even if I can pick any string first time in the morning and hear if it's "off". Because that's all I can do. But then again I don't get annoyed by "out of tune" sounds in the world around me, unlike what people with perfect pitch sometimes tell about.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by diydsp on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:07PM (#35755466)
There are a handful of Android apps. Some use samples. Others have addl ear training exercises that are even more useful than PP.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by ska on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:17PM (#35756737)
There is some good evidence that children whose first language is tonal (e.g. chinese) develop perfect pitch at much higher rates than those whose is not (e.g. english). This strongly suggests that at least if you catch it at the right developmental stage, it is learnable.

I haven't seen anything equivalent for learning later in life though, although ear-training exercises clearly make your estimation better if you are disciplined about it, but that is relative, not absolute.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:03PM (#35766108)
I began by listening to a C. After a week I could find it reliably every time. Then I did it for all the other notes.

On bassoon I recognize all notes by their timbre. When I did this it started being something else. After a while I didnt recognize the notes. I just knew. I sometimes still have this. My harp colleague plays a note and I just know what it was.

I told this to a friend of mine who teaches solfege at college level (royal Danish conservatory) and she said that in her line of work perfect pitch isn't a gift it is a work-related injury.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#35755515)
I took a music theory class in college that had a very heavy ear-training component.

The TA in the course would often talk about the concept of "pitch memory", both absolute and relative. In other words, perfect pitch isn't a binary concept of you either have it or you don't, but it's your ability to remember and reproduce absolute pitches from memory. What we think of as "perfect pitch" is the extreme version of this, where your pitch memory is basically long-term and you can sing a middle-C on command. But many people have decent short-term pitch memory. One girl in my ear training session (a pretty accomplished cellist) could remember absolute pitches for the whole 1.5 hour session; if we came back to a note, she could get it, but she was usually lost in the beginning of the session when we came in cold. I (9 years of violin training, starting at age 7) had a pitch memory of about 5-10 minutes - while we were working on a specific interval, I could remember and reproduce the base note without being prompted by the piano, but once we moved on to another interval I'd lose it. My wife (no specific music training) goes off-key after about 20 seconds.

It wouldn't surprise me that training this ability when you're young leads to much longer-term memory than training it as an adult, the same way that training gymnastics when young leads to the ability to do a back handspring from muscle memory, or training a foreign language gives you a much better ability to speak it without an accent.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by vnorilo on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:45PM (#35755831)
I think pitch memory is not at all the same neural phenomenon as perfect (absolute) pitch.

I had an ear training teacher who would play a bunch of random atonal notes on the piano between exercises to "reset" our ears. Only works for relative ears.

Similarly I (relative pitch) retain the key of a piece I practice. But if someone plays a random sequence of pitches it pretty easily makes me lose my anchor or at least make it lose focus by a semitone or three.

Whereas the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them. Which is also a source of discomfort and difficulty, for example when they need to transpose or work with a different A4 than their "internal" learned one. Where us relative normies would just shrug and accept the new A4.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klipt on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:01PM (#35755965)
> Whereas the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them

Actually they're not immune to being thrown off, there was an experiment where people with perfect pitch were played a long orchestral piece that very slowly detuned, e.g. over the course of half an hour dropped one semitone. The study found this also detuned their sense of absolute pitch, not just immediately after but also months later.

https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/perfect-p...

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by humanizersequel on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:54PM (#35758079)
Nothing in that article mentions their sense of pitch being detuned "months later."
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by maroonblazer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:10PM (#35758539)
A good friend of mine in high school had perfect pitch. We played music together and he would complain about his 'anchor' of pitch getting thrown off if/when we wouldn't tune to A 440Hz but instead something else slightly up or down from A440.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by smeej on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:24PM (#35758615)
My choir director finds it easier to transpose organ pieces on the fly than "set the organ to a different key" and just play the keys as written for that reason: There's too much dissonance between what his fingers know they're playing and what his ears are hearing.

He was one of those little kids who had absolute pitch from the start, though, and he definitely views it as a two-edged sword!

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:18PM (#35756158)
I think there's different components to pitch memory, including both relative and absolute pitch. (I suspect there's more than that, too - some people seem to just hear a chord as a single unit while others pick out the individual notes in it, some people have a very good ear for timbre.)

I don't have perfect pitch, but I actually seem to have anchored on A=443Hz. When my violin teacher insisted on 440Hz it would cause me discomfort the same way you describe, just feeling wrong. And I've found that when I try to tune an instrument from memory, I'm consistently sharp. (Assuming I'm not off by a whole-tone, because I don't have perfect pitch.)

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klipt on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:37PM (#35757461)
Have a look at this study about moving the "absolute" pitch anchor: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/perfect-p...

Maybe you could apply their methodology to yourself to retrain your A to 440Hz?

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by unc0n on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:40PM (#35757491)
When I played in a youth orchestra our music director told us that certain European orchestras use A=443Hz (he said ones in Vienna specifically but there might be others). Perhaps you have a history of listening to many recordings with such tuning.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by pclmulqdq on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:39PM (#35757957)
441+ is also very common in the US. Top-tier orchestras rarely use 440 at this point.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:01PM (#35789654)
It differs. 442 or 443 are the most common ones. My orchestra tunes 442. When I worked in Germany it was usually 442, but some orchestras tuned 443.

Vienna Phil have historically gone even higher, but are probably down to standard levels by now.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by cardy31 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:04PM (#35758519)
I’m a former pro musician. I’m a drummer so lol I don’t have perfect pitch, but I met a few folks who did. Having true perfect pitch sounds awful honestly. The world is constantly out of tune and it takes effort to ignore it.

I knew many more people with very good relative pitch. In school those people would get a middle C at the start of ear training class and ace every note after that because they knew where that C was.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Psychlist on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:01AM (#35759589)
>the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them. Which is also a source of discomfort and difficulty

Not least because the argument about "what note is this" and "what note do you think you're singing" starts basically day one of singing lessons. Trying to learn any practical music when you can hear the difference between close frequencies mean you're effectively learning colours from a group who insist that blue and green are the same colour.

One of my party tricks used to be saying the song and artist from the first 5 seconds of a track. These days with samplers and synthesisers that's almost impossible. I still get tripped when I hear some samples, like "that's the bass guitar from {song x} WTF" in the middle of some otherwise pleasant song.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:23PM (#35766275)
I did not have perfect pitch before this exercise. During it I very much had it.

I didn't recognize the notes like I do on bassoon. I just knew. I sometimes still do, but not every note I hear. Now it is just once in a while.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by q7xvh97o2pDhNrh on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:23PM (#35756791)
> ...could remember absolute pitches for the whole 1.5 hour session; if we came back to a note, she could get it, but she was usually lost in the beginning of the session when we came in cold.

> had a pitch memory of about 5-10 minutes - while we were working on a specific interval, I could remember and reproduce the base note without being prompted by the piano, but once we moved on to another interval I'd lose it.

This is really interesting! Did either of you ever try a spaced-repetition-style approach? It seems like you've basically described the shapes of your respective forgetting curves — I wonder what would happen if you tried to train with the specific goal of extending that window, rather than just noting what your window is during other training. Maybe it's possible to work your way up to long-term perfect pitch in this way?

Especially in your case, since you already have data that your window of 5-10 minutes could extend to 1.5 hours, it seems quite doable. I wonder what would happen if you'd spent an extra 30 minutes/day for a few weeks just on this — e.g., focus on remembering 10 minutes out the first week, then 12-15 minutes the next week, etc...

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:33PM (#35756877)
We didn't - the ear training portion was all devoted to developing better relative pitch and being able to name intervals and chords. It was more just the TA noting "Oh hey, you can remember that pitch I played earlier in the session, do you have perfect pitch?" and then a quick aside. As other comments mentioned, it's usually not worth it as a musician to develop really good absolute pitch, because you'll almost always have a reference note available.

It would've been a neat psych or neuroscience study, if the psych and music departments got together though. If I were still in college I'd suggest it. :-)

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:21PM (#35758259)
I wish I was in this class?? LINK????
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:37PM (#35759252)
It was Tonal Harmony and Counterpoint. Unless you're at the specific college I went to, it wouldn't do you any good (and I think the professor I had died recently, I took it almost 20 years ago), but an equivalent course is offered at most universities and liberal arts colleges.

FWIW I found it well worth it. My mom had been encouraging me to take something far outside my major (physics at the time, then I switched to CS), and was suggesting Art History. I couldn't make Art History work with my schedule, but I took this music theory class and it was great.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:28PM (#35758317)
Wow, but YES, but NO at the same time ::

there are the certain skills which can be "forgot" but can be picked up {"like riding a bike"}

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by echelon on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:38PM (#35758675)
> It wouldn't surprise me that training this ability when you're young leads to much longer-term memory than training it as an adult, the same way that training gymnastics when young leads to the ability to do a back handspring from muscle memory, or training a foreign language gives you a much better ability to speak it without an accent.

This is a function of time, not age.

Adults can (though seldom) learn languages to perfect fluency with zero accent. It's all a matter of how much time and immersion you put into it.

Adults are mostly too busy and have too many responsibilities. Children have all the time in the world.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:01AM (#35760841)
The brain’s ability to learn does change by age, as an extreme example people who didn’t learn to speak until like 8, will never be able to.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by alfiedotwtf on Saturday April 29, 2023 @09:51PM (#35759027)
I've never heard of pitch memory before, but this makes total sense. When things make noise around me, I sometimes remember songs that have that note. My favourite one was my motorised stand-up desk which when going up would sound the same as Beyonce's Crazy in Love - and when I think about it right now, I hear the pitch, the song, and that motor in my head.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by wyager on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:16PM (#35759404)
(Neuro-)Physiologically, it's not clear to me why the sense of pitch should decohere. It's not like the cochlea is physically unstable, and the hartley-ish-transformed data the brain is pulling out of the cochlea should be quite repeatable. I wonder if the brain converts the cochlear data into some other representation that is not (inherently) stable, and those with perfect pitch have or develop a more stable version than most other people.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:06AM (#35760869)
Absolute data points rarely make sense, they are rigid and inflexible, which is not good against an always changing environment.

You should be able to recognize the same scene both with a clear sky and a partly cloudy one, and it’s hardly important that this tiger had a deeper voice, the important part to recognize is the fact that there is a tiger. But even something as trivial as movement coordination is constantly updated by feedback mechanisms, like training with weights and dropping them in the end will temporarily make the movements “weird”.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by AbsoluteCabbage on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:17PM (#35765145)
That’s not what perfect pitch is. Perfect pitch is “color hearing”- recognizing the unique sound properties of each not along the scale, much in the same way colors of the rainbow can be distinguished. It can also be trained for.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:23PM (#35755616)
May you please explain ELI5 what "perfect pitch" means?

(I was told I was a musical savant, and once I was told that, I was scared away from music... my Violin teacher was known to be owb of the best, SO i dont know what "perfect pitch" is, as I attribute it to 'bad actors'

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by hluska on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:34PM (#35755724)
Perfect (or absolute) pitch refers to the ability to distinguish a note (correctly) when you hear it played. Singers with perfect pitch can sing a particular note on command.

If you had perfect pitch, I would be able to play notes on a piano and you would be able to distinguish each. There is a continuum of perfect pitch - some may have perfect pitch after they have warmed up, others may retain their perfect pitch for a short time after they stop playing and others (apparently) always have it. In that aspect, it’s a little like memory.

Mozart and Ella Fitzgerald are two famous people you’ve likely heard who had absolute pitch though I have never read or heard anything that suggests either found it terribly useful. Of the musicians I know who have worked to develop it, it’s mostly kind of a party trick.

If you’re interested in perfect pitch, you should likely learn about relative pitch as well. Whereas perfect pitch refers to the ability to correctly distinguish a more cold, relative pitch refers to the ability to distinguish notes in relation to each other.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:02PM (#35755981)
thank you for the 'perfect pitch' response <3
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Gunax on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:08PM (#35757211)
But how accurate does it have to be to be considered perfect? As in within one hz? What about very high frequencies, where a single hz is much smaller, relative to the frequency?
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by AlecSchueler on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:35AM (#35760700)
Within less than half a semitone seems more likely. The frequencies of the notes don't matter as the relationship between the pitch classes are unchanged.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by h0h0h0h0111 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:51PM (#35757599)
>I have never read or heard anything that suggests either found it terribly useful

Allegedly, Mozart transcribed Allegri's Miserere after hearing it performed once in the Vatican: https://www.classicfm.com/composers/mozart/guides/mozart-all....

Perhaps apocryphal, but sounds pretty useful to me.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:54AM (#35761096)
I don’t think that it is attributable to absolute pitch, that might not even be required.

It’s “just” insanely good memory for music.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by coliveira on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:03PM (#35755998)
Perfect pitch means that you can identify (give the name of) different pitches without the help of instruments. This is a rare ability even for trained musicians.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:32PM (#35756282)
We need a GPT for musical pitch. (unpack that)
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by KeplerBoy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:56PM (#35757107)
The (fast) fourier transform has been around for a few centuries. It's kind of a big deal.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by gabereiser on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:22PM (#35758606)
I would imagine relative pitch is more useful/practiced? I was a musician in a rock band for many years (you never heard of) and I have relative pitch. I started in orchestra on the cello at age 7. Banged on drums during middle school. Picked up guitar in high school and formed a band. I can identify chords and I can tell you what note if I have another note as a reference (like you do with your voice).
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by spaceman_2020 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:58AM (#35760016)
Do you recommend any routine to help a young child learn absolute pitch? I’m talking under 3 years of age.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Tor3 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:53AM (#35763082)
Rick Beato made a video or two about that. His son Dylan has perfect pitch. What he did when the boy was very little was to let him listen to various types of jazz music - he can't be certain, but his theory is that if the music is "interesting" in the sense that it's not always predictable then the brain automatically zooms in on that and gets interested - and that's what gave the boy perfect pitch (I believe this theory relies on an underlying theory - a quite common one - which is that babies are actually born with perfect pitch but lose it relatively early, just as all babies are born with the ability to hear every sound in every language, and that also gets filtered off as they get older. This last one is pretty certain, the other one is still debated).
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:17PM (#35766707)
I would have found it useful in school. At work it got in the way.

Unless your kid is going to.play one of those perpetually out of tune instruments like the piano I wouldn't recommend it. I had a horn colleague that had the crazy kind of perfect pitch (he still has, but he is retired) and perfect metronome tempo and all that. He called it a curse.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by spaceman_2020 on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:55AM (#35771138)
Interesting perspective. I'm an amateur musician and always thought that absolute pitch would have made me a better musician. I wanted to make sure that my kid gets the opportunity to acquire perfect pitch, even if he doesn't decide to take up music in the future
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:00PM (#35778334)
I find that being able to hear the note you are about to play before you play it is great, but having that note absolutely anchored into something that might not be in tune with what is around you is really just a hindrance.

There are certainly people that like their perfect pitch, but I did not. There is a reason they teach in in many asian countries between the ages 2 and 5. A girl I studied with told me they never told you the note they started on when they did melody dictation. You were just supposed to know.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Tor3 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:22AM (#35762820)
What you describe sounds like pitch memory, which doesn't have the same qualities (and problems) as actual absolute ("perfect") pitch. I also remember pitch. I can grab my guitar after a week away from it, touch a string and know if it's out of tune. I can tune it without a tuner.

But what I'm actually doing is remembering the pitch with the help of the timbre of the guitar string (or harp string, for my wife's harp - I hear if a string is "off" even if it's the first single note I hear in the morning). I believe I would quickly be bewildered if I heard pure sine tones. And that's it. There's nothing more which is even close to what people with absolute pitch can do. I haven't run into that many of them, but it's like they see all the music in color, it's a different world (and they are often constantly bothered by out-of-tune sounds from life). Hit some random notes in parallel and they can tell you the notes instantly. And so on and so forth.

The other thing is what happens if they lose the perfect pitch.. which does happen, with age, for many, or at least it de-tunes a bit (drops half a note, for example). Then, when it's gone, they don't even have relative pitch to rely on. Rick Beato interviewed a couple of people this happened to. I don't want to be there. My little ability to tune without a tuner is enough for me, and what it is is trained pitch memory - not absolute pitch. And it's relatively common, unlike absolute pitch.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:52PM (#35766020)
I have tone memory on a bassoon. I described this in another post. It even translates to baroque bassoon, tuned half a not lower.

When I practiced pitch instrument did not matter. I could tell what note a sine wave was.

I never made any differenriation between what I had and absolute pitch. Functionally they wäwrre the same and I believe that if I would have kept it up for a couple of months it would have been permanent. Some of it still lingers. I can still tell whether a tuning A is 440 or 442. Sometimes i just know what note is being played, regardless of instrument. When that feeling comes I am never wrong.