News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#35755515)
I took a music theory class in college that had a very heavy ear-training component.

The TA in the course would often talk about the concept of "pitch memory", both absolute and relative. In other words, perfect pitch isn't a binary concept of you either have it or you don't, but it's your ability to remember and reproduce absolute pitches from memory. What we think of as "perfect pitch" is the extreme version of this, where your pitch memory is basically long-term and you can sing a middle-C on command. But many people have decent short-term pitch memory. One girl in my ear training session (a pretty accomplished cellist) could remember absolute pitches for the whole 1.5 hour session; if we came back to a note, she could get it, but she was usually lost in the beginning of the session when we came in cold. I (9 years of violin training, starting at age 7) had a pitch memory of about 5-10 minutes - while we were working on a specific interval, I could remember and reproduce the base note without being prompted by the piano, but once we moved on to another interval I'd lose it. My wife (no specific music training) goes off-key after about 20 seconds.

It wouldn't surprise me that training this ability when you're young leads to much longer-term memory than training it as an adult, the same way that training gymnastics when young leads to the ability to do a back handspring from muscle memory, or training a foreign language gives you a much better ability to speak it without an accent.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by vnorilo on Saturday April 29, 2023 @02:45PM (#35755831)
I think pitch memory is not at all the same neural phenomenon as perfect (absolute) pitch.

I had an ear training teacher who would play a bunch of random atonal notes on the piano between exercises to "reset" our ears. Only works for relative ears.

Similarly I (relative pitch) retain the key of a piece I practice. But if someone plays a random sequence of pitches it pretty easily makes me lose my anchor or at least make it lose focus by a semitone or three.

Whereas the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them. Which is also a source of discomfort and difficulty, for example when they need to transpose or work with a different A4 than their "internal" learned one. Where us relative normies would just shrug and accept the new A4.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klipt on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:01PM (#35755965)
> Whereas the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them

Actually they're not immune to being thrown off, there was an experiment where people with perfect pitch were played a long orchestral piece that very slowly detuned, e.g. over the course of half an hour dropped one semitone. The study found this also detuned their sense of absolute pitch, not just immediately after but also months later.

https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/perfect-p...

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by humanizersequel on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:54PM (#35758079)
Nothing in that article mentions their sense of pitch being detuned "months later."
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by maroonblazer on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:10PM (#35758539)
A good friend of mine in high school had perfect pitch. We played music together and he would complain about his 'anchor' of pitch getting thrown off if/when we wouldn't tune to A 440Hz but instead something else slightly up or down from A440.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by smeej on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:24PM (#35758615)
My choir director finds it easier to transpose organ pieces on the fly than "set the organ to a different key" and just play the keys as written for that reason: There's too much dissonance between what his fingers know they're playing and what his ears are hearing.

He was one of those little kids who had absolute pitch from the start, though, and he definitely views it as a two-edged sword!

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @03:18PM (#35756158)
I think there's different components to pitch memory, including both relative and absolute pitch. (I suspect there's more than that, too - some people seem to just hear a chord as a single unit while others pick out the individual notes in it, some people have a very good ear for timbre.)

I don't have perfect pitch, but I actually seem to have anchored on A=443Hz. When my violin teacher insisted on 440Hz it would cause me discomfort the same way you describe, just feeling wrong. And I've found that when I try to tune an instrument from memory, I'm consistently sharp. (Assuming I'm not off by a whole-tone, because I don't have perfect pitch.)

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by klipt on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:37PM (#35757461)
Have a look at this study about moving the "absolute" pitch anchor: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/releases/perfect-p...

Maybe you could apply their methodology to yourself to retrain your A to 440Hz?

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by unc0n on Saturday April 29, 2023 @05:40PM (#35757491)
When I played in a youth orchestra our music director told us that certain European orchestras use A=443Hz (he said ones in Vienna specifically but there might be others). Perhaps you have a history of listening to many recordings with such tuning.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by pclmulqdq on Saturday April 29, 2023 @06:39PM (#35757957)
441+ is also very common in the US. Top-tier orchestras rarely use 440 at this point.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:01PM (#35789654)
It differs. 442 or 443 are the most common ones. My orchestra tunes 442. When I worked in Germany it was usually 442, but some orchestras tuned 443.

Vienna Phil have historically gone even higher, but are probably down to standard levels by now.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by cardy31 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:04PM (#35758519)
I’m a former pro musician. I’m a drummer so lol I don’t have perfect pitch, but I met a few folks who did. Having true perfect pitch sounds awful honestly. The world is constantly out of tune and it takes effort to ignore it.

I knew many more people with very good relative pitch. In school those people would get a middle C at the start of ear training class and ace every note after that because they knew where that C was.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by Psychlist on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:01AM (#35759589)
>the "real" perfect pitch people are always anchored, no matter how much noise anyone throws at them. Which is also a source of discomfort and difficulty

Not least because the argument about "what note is this" and "what note do you think you're singing" starts basically day one of singing lessons. Trying to learn any practical music when you can hear the difference between close frequencies mean you're effectively learning colours from a group who insist that blue and green are the same colour.

One of my party tricks used to be saying the song and artist from the first 5 seconds of a track. These days with samplers and synthesisers that's almost impossible. I still get tripped when I hear some samples, like "that's the bass guitar from {song x} WTF" in the middle of some otherwise pleasant song.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by bjoli on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:23PM (#35766275)
I did not have perfect pitch before this exercise. During it I very much had it.

I didn't recognize the notes like I do on bassoon. I just knew. I sometimes still do, but not every note I hear. Now it is just once in a while.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by q7xvh97o2pDhNrh on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:23PM (#35756791)
> ...could remember absolute pitches for the whole 1.5 hour session; if we came back to a note, she could get it, but she was usually lost in the beginning of the session when we came in cold.

> had a pitch memory of about 5-10 minutes - while we were working on a specific interval, I could remember and reproduce the base note without being prompted by the piano, but once we moved on to another interval I'd lose it.

This is really interesting! Did either of you ever try a spaced-repetition-style approach? It seems like you've basically described the shapes of your respective forgetting curves — I wonder what would happen if you tried to train with the specific goal of extending that window, rather than just noting what your window is during other training. Maybe it's possible to work your way up to long-term perfect pitch in this way?

Especially in your case, since you already have data that your window of 5-10 minutes could extend to 1.5 hours, it seems quite doable. I wonder what would happen if you'd spent an extra 30 minutes/day for a few weeks just on this — e.g., focus on remembering 10 minutes out the first week, then 12-15 minutes the next week, etc...

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @04:33PM (#35756877)
We didn't - the ear training portion was all devoted to developing better relative pitch and being able to name intervals and chords. It was more just the TA noting "Oh hey, you can remember that pitch I played earlier in the session, do you have perfect pitch?" and then a quick aside. As other comments mentioned, it's usually not worth it as a musician to develop really good absolute pitch, because you'll almost always have a reference note available.

It would've been a neat psych or neuroscience study, if the psych and music departments got together though. If I were still in college I'd suggest it. :-)

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:21PM (#35758259)
I wish I was in this class?? LINK????
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by nostrademons on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:37PM (#35759252)
It was Tonal Harmony and Counterpoint. Unless you're at the specific college I went to, it wouldn't do you any good (and I think the professor I had died recently, I took it almost 20 years ago), but an equivalent course is offered at most universities and liberal arts colleges.

FWIW I found it well worth it. My mom had been encouraging me to take something far outside my major (physics at the time, then I switched to CS), and was suggesting Art History. I couldn't make Art History work with my schedule, but I took this music theory class and it was great.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by samstave on Saturday April 29, 2023 @07:28PM (#35758317)
Wow, but YES, but NO at the same time ::

there are the certain skills which can be "forgot" but can be picked up {"like riding a bike"}

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by echelon on Saturday April 29, 2023 @08:38PM (#35758675)
> It wouldn't surprise me that training this ability when you're young leads to much longer-term memory than training it as an adult, the same way that training gymnastics when young leads to the ability to do a back handspring from muscle memory, or training a foreign language gives you a much better ability to speak it without an accent.

This is a function of time, not age.

Adults can (though seldom) learn languages to perfect fluency with zero accent. It's all a matter of how much time and immersion you put into it.

Adults are mostly too busy and have too many responsibilities. Children have all the time in the world.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:01AM (#35760841)
The brain’s ability to learn does change by age, as an extreme example people who didn’t learn to speak until like 8, will never be able to.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by alfiedotwtf on Saturday April 29, 2023 @09:51PM (#35759027)
I've never heard of pitch memory before, but this makes total sense. When things make noise around me, I sometimes remember songs that have that note. My favourite one was my motorised stand-up desk which when going up would sound the same as Beyonce's Crazy in Love - and when I think about it right now, I hear the pitch, the song, and that motor in my head.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by wyager on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:16PM (#35759404)
(Neuro-)Physiologically, it's not clear to me why the sense of pitch should decohere. It's not like the cochlea is physically unstable, and the hartley-ish-transformed data the brain is pulling out of the cochlea should be quite repeatable. I wonder if the brain converts the cochlear data into some other representation that is not (inherently) stable, and those with perfect pitch have or develop a more stable version than most other people.
Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by kaba0 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:06AM (#35760869)
Absolute data points rarely make sense, they are rigid and inflexible, which is not good against an always changing environment.

You should be able to recognize the same scene both with a clear sky and a partly cloudy one, and it’s hardly important that this tiger had a deeper voice, the important part to recognize is the fact that there is a tiger. But even something as trivial as movement coordination is constantly updated by feedback mechanisms, like training with weights and dropping them in the end will temporarily make the movements “weird”.

Re:Children aged 2-6 successfully trained to acquire absolut... by AbsoluteCabbage on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:17PM (#35765145)
That’s not what perfect pitch is. Perfect pitch is “color hearing”- recognizing the unique sound properties of each not along the scale, much in the same way colors of the rainbow can be distinguished. It can also be trained for.