News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by elcomet on Sunday April 23, 2023 @11:41AM (#35677190)
This article actually never answers the question, why does this steam network releases steam in the streets?
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by randyrand on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:01PM (#35677366)
bad pipes
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by wongarsu on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:35PM (#35677748)
So what's up with maintenance? The leaks seem trivial to locate and visibly waste both heat and water.

How is it more economical to have enough leaks that people start talking about it instead of doing proper maintenance? Especially since this situation seems fairly unique, I've never seen this outside the US, and could only name San Francisco and New York as places where this happens. So what discourages maintenance in those places compared to everywhere else?

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by sidewndr46 on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:48PM (#35677882)
As long as a service provider can pass those costs onto customers and there is no alternative service, it can't be economical to make repairs. You'd be expending capital to decrease revenue.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by wongarsu on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:55PM (#35677980)
But everyone is facing roughly the same forces here. You either spend money on maintenance, or you lose money in leaks. It's a tradeoff, but any place outside SF and NYC seems to determine that the best place in that tradeoff produces barely any leaks that a pedestrian would notice.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by Scoundreller on Sunday April 23, 2023 @06:09PM (#35681176)
Water distribution works the same way. Large systems lose like 10% of their supply through leaks in the system but just pump more through the system to make up for the losses. Just like drug smugglers.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by kevincox on Sunday April 23, 2023 @01:20PM (#35678276)
This doesn't make sense. Price isn't set by the cost of service. You could fix the leaks and still raise the price to increase your profit margin.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by zamnos on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:06PM (#35678809)
The energy market in California is highly regulated and the prices consumers pay are fixed by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), and are designed to cover the utility's costs, plus a "reasonable" profit.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by sidewndr46 on Monday April 24, 2023 @10:15AM (#35687946)
If it was an absolute free market with no barriers to entry sure. I've never lived anywhere that energy, water, or sewer was a free market.

My natural gas supplier for example (which is used primarily for heating where I live) routinely raises prices and always flouts state law. My only option would be to discontinue use of natural gas, which would cost me even more money.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by toast0 on Sunday April 23, 2023 @01:35PM (#35678449)
Steam leaks is a big indication that you've made it as the downtown of a metropolis. I've witnessed it in Seattle, pretty sure in Chicago and not sure about Milwaukee.

Doing proper maintenance requires opening the streets, which is expensive and causes confusion and delay, so there's some amount of acceptable leak before it's a good idea to fix it. There's always a chance of finding unmapped critical infrastructure when you dig, which adds more risk. Plus, when you fix it, you lose the street cred.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by wirrbel on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:08PM (#35678833)
I live in a town with teleheating, frankly I never saw it steem. I would say the upkeep in the US of the infrastructure is just bad.

This reminds me that in Paris you can pretty often see water flowing on the street, it seems that the Paris water supply has a tendency to leak that I just don't see in other towns (but then, i am really walking for kilometers through the city when visiting paris so maybe I just have more opportunities to spot leaks).

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by Scoundreller on Sunday April 23, 2023 @06:07PM (#35681153)
Paris regularly cleans its streets with the non-potable water supply of its two-stream h2o distribution system. Probably an antiquated practice back from when not everyone had sewer connections and would dump their waste pots on the road, but they still do it.

https://parisianfields.com/2012/03/11/a-most-unusual-water-s...

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by wirrbel on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:22AM (#35683959)
Interesting!
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by pests on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:17PM (#35682948)
Witnessed in downtown Detroit too.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by mikeryan on Sunday April 23, 2023 @01:18PM (#35678251)
Is this a guess?

I’d think there would be some sort of safety system for venting pressure. Or even condensation around the hot pipes (which seems to be why the same thing happens in New York which also has a steam network)

All of the above could work too.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by greysteil on Sunday April 23, 2023 @01:33PM (#35678427)
If it’s the same as NYC then the steam you see is generally from water evaporating off the outside of the pipes (not steam escaping from the pipes). The pipes are very hot, so any outside water that touches them quickly turns to steam.

https://web.archive.org/web/20160811170408/http://www.coned....

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by jwr on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:04PM (#35678775)
That means the whole thing is incredibly wasteful. I always wondered why nobody seems to care about the huge amounts of energy being wasted in NYC in this way.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by tommoor on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:29PM (#35679111)
In NYC the steam is from co-generation facilities which produce electricity first, so the steam is essentially waste product to begin with – in most coal plants for example you'd just have giant steam stacks to condense the water again. But yes, it's all very normalized waste.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by lukeschlather on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:43PM (#35679240)
There's an invisible component which is the efficiency of the furnace used to create the heat. Suppose every building uses a small furnace which is 30% efficient, then there's no visible waste heat in the streets. On the other hand, suppose a bunch of buildings use a single furnace which is 50% efficient and pipe the heat with 10% waste from piping. You're still substantially less wasteful to use the central furnace. There's no such thing as a system that doesn't generate waste, and the visibility or invisibility of the waste doesn't tell you how wasteful the system is.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 23, 2023 @04:20PM (#35680134)
What does it mean for a heating furnace to be less than 100% efficient? Efficiency is normally measured in terms of how much waste heat you generate. If your goal is to produce heat, it isn't possible to produce any waste heat.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by quesera on Sunday April 23, 2023 @04:25PM (#35680187)
A lot heat is lost as exhaust into the air.

This can be a large portion, e.g. in older systems from the days when fuel was cheap, and pollution wasn't a topic.

Modern systems attempt to recover exhaust heat, and can be 90-ish% efficient.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:00PM (#35680579)
Releasing heat into the air is the entire point of the building furnace. For the heat to get lost, it would have to leave the building.

There's a more obvious argument that leaking steam into the streets is a waste of heat, but that still depends on your goals. You might like having warmer streets.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by quesera on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:59PM (#35681092)
> Releasing heat into the air is the entire point of the building furnace

You're thinking of forced hot air systems, but these do not vent combustion exhaust into living space. There are fuel remnants and combustion byproducts in the exhaust which would smell bad, and kill people.

Combustion exhaust, and all of the heat it contains, goes up the chimney and is lost. The living space air is heated by proximity to the combustion chamber, but circulates in a separate closed loop.

Also, in a forced hot water system, there is no air circulation at all. 100% of the air involved is heated and goes straight up the chimney.

Aside: Some people call FHW systems "boilers" instead of "furnaces", but this seems to vary by region. Where I'm from, "boilers" are steam systems only -- which seems reasonable, since water is not boiled in a FHW system.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 23, 2023 @07:22PM (#35681763)
> You're thinking of forced hot air systems

> Also, in a forced hot water system, there is no air circulation at all. 100% of the air involved is heated and goes straight up the chimney.

Without disputing your other points, this isn't right. I'm not thinking of any particular style of system. The point of every heating system is to release heat into the air. The problem people experience is that the air they occupy is too cold, and the solution is to heat that air. The point of a system that circulates hot water through your building, or your apartment, or anywhere, is that the hot water will release heat into the air there. Heating the air is the only goal regardless of whether the system involves circulating any air.

The point that you can lose heat by venting hot combustion waste to the external atmosphere is well taken.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by quesera on Sunday April 23, 2023 @07:43PM (#35681924)
I think we were talking about furnace efficiency. This is measured without respect to the heating distribution elements. You don't need to have a distribution system connected to measure furnace efficiency.

So when I said that 100% of the air involved in a forced hot water system is used for combustion and exhausted, I mean the air at the furnace, not the air that is indirectly heated in the living space.

Agreed that the goal is to heat the living space though, including the air. A forced hot air system does that directly (pushing heated air into living space), and forced hot water does so indirectly (pushing hot water into radiators in living space, which heat the air by convection).

Radiant floor heat is another example where there's no air at the heat source.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by pests on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:14PM (#35682932)
If the goal is to heat a certain building and the heat is being lost in the building the furnace is in or in the streets that is definitely a waste.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by elcomet on Monday April 24, 2023 @04:34AM (#35685046)
And it is leaving the building. Think of a chimney, most of the hot air leaves the building.
Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by MagicMoonlight on Sunday April 23, 2023 @08:19PM (#35682177)
Furnaces are almost 100% efficient because you're literally producing heat. There's very few ways to burn fuel and not get that fuel to produce heat.

This kind of argument works for power stations, but it doesn't work for heat because it's obviously not more efficient to heat 13 miles of piping in addition to your building rather than just burning stuff in your building.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by quesera on Sunday April 23, 2023 @08:37PM (#35682314)
An old but common oil-fired furnace for a forced-air system will be about 70% efficient at heating air which will be delivered to the living space[0].

The rest (almost 30%) goes up the chimney, or radiates out from the furnace itself[1].

It's heat, thermodynamically speaking, but it is not useful heat.

0: This is measured at the egress point of the heating chamber, which is distinct from the combustion chamber. It is not measured at the living space, because there are other losses in distribution (uninsulated and/or leaking ductwork, etc).

1: Some is also lost to light energy, and some fuel is not fully-combusted. These account for a couple percentage points.

Re:Why steam rises from San Francisco streets by the_mitsuhiko on Sunday April 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#35679603)
That however is not a natural “feature” of district heating. Vienna uses it too and I have never seen steam leaks.