News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by mvdwoord on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:47AM (#35664862)
Plenty to improve in food production, sure, but the current move towards hyper processed foods is dumb.

They can take the animal meat (and eggs, and dairy products) from my cold dead hands..

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by nasmorn on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:56AM (#35664908)
If you don’t buy them from very traditional read very expensive producers it is also very unnatural. Animals are simply used as self replacing bio reactors that are fed the cheapest inputs like grain and animal remains. Even the vitamin d in milk is mostly there because you just supplement the animals. I visit a small farm on vacation a few times a year and they have a bunch of chicken running around. I have no qualms eating their eggs, they are not even slaughtered in most cases as the fox eats them first. They also have a dozen cows on their meadow. But let’s not pretend that is where most animal products come from.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by nibbleshifter on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:39AM (#35665131)
In many parts of Europe buying from the traditional local style of producer is the cheaper way to buy animal products.

Supermarket meats often contain a fair bit of water weight IME.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by Eduard on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:16AM (#35665358)
> In many parts of Europe buying from the traditional local style of producer is the cheaper way to buy animal products.

Burden of proof here

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by nibbleshifter on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:06AM (#35667297)
So in Ireland, supermarket meat is cheap, but usually higher in fat and "wetter". Still decent meat, but you are paying for water IME.

At the butcher I pay only slightly more, I know exactly which farm it came from, I know where it was slaughtered and processed, and I can ask for specific cuts/amounts, so less wastage.

Its also much higher quality and not as "wet", so its much nicer to cook with (and I'm not paying for water weight).

I've saved a metric shitload on my monthly food shopping by using the butchers and greengrocers in my area instead of the supermarkets.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by deepsun on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:52AM (#35664882)
Relax, no one is really considering meat foods to go away in the next 100 years or so.

It's all about the access to the vegetarian and vegan foods to those who want it, and it happens to become more popular, so market adapts.

But you present it like someone tries to take your food.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jiggywiggy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:55AM (#35664897)
Maybe not with you. But in most modern cities they are actively campaigning against meat, they are mostly using the moral card: you are destroying the planet. How fun.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by bwb on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:00AM (#35664927)
It isn't a 0 or 1, prob good for you health wise and for the planet to eat a little less meat and a bit more veg. Just look at the data out there.

This last year I am really decreasing how much meat I eat (ill never give it up although I am excited about ground cricket meat and trying that). I am doing it for my health, costs, and because its good for the planet long term.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jiggywiggy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:04AM (#35664949)
Data is sort of wildcard argument. Doesn't has any value if you don't point to specific.

Cashew cheese really is not better for the planet the local organic milk cheese.

In north of Holland there huge patches of land only cow can grace the land and nothing else grows, and there is an abundance of the water. Yet everyone complains about milk and meat taking too much wayer, and that growing plants would be more efficient.

It all depends, you cant just say "data".

Same with health. You really can't claim fried soya or pea protein is healthier then ground beef from a cow that spends his summers outside.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by bwb on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:29AM (#35665073)
Sure, but buying a locally raised cow that is fed on local farmland is a lot better for the environment than steak from Argentina most of the time. The data around that is pretty solid.

I don't think cashew cheese grows in nature, i would never consider it vegetables and I am not advocating for processed foods. Merely stating that cutting down on how much meat you eat and eating more veg is better for your health and the planet. Well backed by data.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jiggywiggy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:25AM (#35665413)
Well backed by data? What does that mean.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by bwb on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:56AM (#35667179)
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jiggywiggy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:35AM (#35667598)
You missed the conclusion step
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by bwb on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:08PM (#35669937)
Sorry bit confused, you asked what data was and I sent you a big explanation? Sorry I am a bit literal at times, what are you requesting that you can't find on Google?
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by kelipso on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:25PM (#35670594)
Lol, at any rate you are saying a bunch of statements that seem pretty shaky, saying they are backed by data, and not linking any sources. I guess the data is in another dimension or something.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by bwb on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:34PM (#35671524)
For sure :)
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by Vespasian on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:16AM (#35665006)
I live in a quite progressive modern city (in central Europe though) and at least here it can't be very widespread as I've never noticed anything like that.

I've got a few friends who are vegan but it's mostly me doing the questioning as I'm curious about developments in that field (and agtech)

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by nunodonato on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:04AM (#35664953)
what destroys the planet is not meat or non-meat. Its mass production of [insert food here]. I have fun listening the vegan arguments until they are shown how their over-consumption of avocados or soy-based foods has devastating or exploiting effects on ecosystems and people.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by matsemann on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:34AM (#35665098)
But people (including you it seems) don't really understand the scale at which meat production harm the environment compared to vegetables. Yes, every mass production have problems, but with meat you need multiple times the amount of everything, because you first need to produce the food the cow or whatever eats, and then the meat production.

For instance, it's multiple times less co2 impact for me eating an avocado here in Norway that's been shipped half the globe around from south america, compared to eating meat from the local farm. The scales are just so incredibly different in production (vs transportation) that it's not to "gotcha" many believe to claim that something imported is automatically bad.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jiggywiggy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:26AM (#35665905)
You can't honestly claim buying avacado's is better for the planet, it's wreaked social & ecological havoc in multiple south American countries with dried up rivers, gangs and lack of diversification of the income of a country.

Next to that it's not always Plants vs meats. In many places only cattle can graze but not much of value can grow.

The CO2 issue is really a terrible comparison. Everything cows put out has been put in from the air. The airplanes are excreting new/old CO2 taken from fossil fuels. Some claim cows are still worse because of methane, but they forget to mention methane only had 12 years lifespan in the atmosphere.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by myaccountonhn on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:26AM (#35666405)
> it's wreaked social & ecological havoc in multiple south American countries with dried up rivers, gangs and lack of diversification of the income of a country.

The produce to feed the cattle is often detrimental to the environment too. They're not cutting down rain forests in Brazil to produce soy for meat substitutes but rather for produce to feed animals.

But it's absolutely important to eat local and if you're gonna eat meat ensure that the animal was fed local produce too.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by selimthegrim on Sunday April 23, 2023 @11:27AM (#35677056)
You’d really rather have them making drugs than avocados?
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by deepsun on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:42PM (#35680957)
The question is about scales (or proportions) -- yes, most mass produced foods, (e.g. avocados) wreaked havoc, but the scope meat production does that might be way larger.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jna_sh on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:09AM (#35665314)
> or soy-based foods

The vast majority of soy production, particularly the environmentally destructive production that’s converting rainforests in South America into farmland, is for animal feed, not human consumption: https://ourworldindata.org/soy

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by hammyhavoc on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:14AM (#35666292)
Bold of you to assume I'm not growing my own food.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by deepsun on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:38PM (#35680908)
Campaigning (for anything) is good, I see nothing wrong about it.

Active people will (and should) win, that's the law of nature.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by ben_w on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:31AM (#35665081)
100 years is a long time, if they're not seriously considering it, they should.

That timeline is long enough to also include the serious possibility of basically any weird currently-just-Sci-Fi option: https://youtu.be/Z_ZGq8Tah0k

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by profeaturo on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:07AM (#35664962)
We’re only a few disasters away from the government deciding that the climate crisis requires drastic measures, including a severe rationing of meat and other products considered harmful to the environment. It’s clear from the rhetoric that this is the direction we are moving in, and it’s also clear that the great percentage of the population will comply and even celebrate such restrictions.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by rebuilder on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:23AM (#35665040)
Maybe it’s time we take action to reduce the severity of the crisis before we end up in the scenario you describe.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by profeaturo on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:36AM (#35665112)
Institutional science is now politics. At this point there’s no way to systemically create the kind of feedback loop necessary to take any kind of intelligent action, nor is there political will. It’s far more politically expedient in the near term for the powers that be to say that whatever measures they’ve implemented are working and then let the networked tribe punish anyone who dissents.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by jna_sh on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:11AM (#35665335)
I can’t walk about in public wearing a mask for any length of time without getting harassed, despite the continued prevalence of COVID and the worsening picture regarding long term consequences. I have trouble believing “it’s clear” that a great percentage of the population will comply, I think the handling of the early lockdowns has done for that. It seems more clear to me that governments will struggle to get compliance for any such measures at scale, based on attitudes since.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by hammyhavoc on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:12AM (#35666278)
Where do you live? I walk around with a mask in the UK with zero issues, same with my partner and family.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by deepsun on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:36PM (#35680897)
Well, if we're talking about climate change action items, then it actually makes sense to me, although I cannot find any numbers on how effective it is (comparing, to, say, better insulation of house windows).

By the way, "the government deciding" sounds like it's totally detached from public wish. But in democratic countries public has a lot of influence on the government, way more than popular meme says (speaking as an emigrant from autocratic regime), it just public is not exercising their right (or really trust the government). So it's actually "people are going to decide".

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by whywhywhywhy on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:37AM (#35665497)
If you could remove meat from the supply chain and be the main supplier for the alternative, why wouldn’t you choose to profit from that?

The upside for the politicians and suppliers seems too astronomical not to be at least thinking about it.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by waihtis on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:16AM (#35665002)
Same. No-one has yet been able to explain why I should exchange a well-functioning animal-based diet into a vegan one where I need to supplement by default to fulfill human needs. I have respect for those who do it on the basis of animal compassion, but claiming healthiness is obviously a false statement.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by Not-the-One on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:35AM (#35665103)
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by ben_w on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:24AM (#35665044)
Can't speak for you personally, but the average human today has an unhealthy diet since well before the recent popularity surge of vegan-by-choice in the west, so I don't accept "well-functioning animal-based diet" as a general premise even if you personally can make it work.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by waihtis on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:10AM (#35676370)
If you have a bad diet and you remove a significant source of protein and other nutrients from it, how is it a better diet?
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by ben_w on Sunday April 23, 2023 @10:56AM (#35676766)
I believe the name for what you're doing there is "begging the question".

Vegan diets generally have protein and other nutrients.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by waihtis on Sunday April 23, 2023 @01:16PM (#35678232)
to my original point:

> why I should exchange a well-functioning animal-based diet into a vegan one where I need to supplement by default to fulfill human needs

applies also in the protein domain, seeing how vegan protein sources lack or have minimal concentrations of some essential amino acids, for instance

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by ben_w on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:54PM (#35681060)
That issue basically only happens if you eat exactly one plant, not if you eat at least two, because different plants miss different amino acids and most protein rich plants have most amino acids and the differences overlap nicely.

This is so easy you're probably doing it already even as a meat eater: Mexican chilli with rice? Beans and rice compensate for each other's weaknesses. Peanut butter on bread? Peanuts and wheat cover each other.

There are some things that are technically complete by themselves, but mycoprotein (Quorn) which I think is complete, isn't available for purchase everywhere.

Conversely if you do single-foodsource-diet with meat, you can also get problems, most famously protein poisoning and scurvy.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by roebk on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:43AM (#35665157)
Hang on, I think you’re muddying the waters here. A vegan diet is purely done for animal compassion. A vegan diet, a plant-based diet and even whole food plant-based diet are different diets.

Veganism is a lifestyle based around the notion of reducing as much harm to animals a feasibly possible. No one claims that a vegan diet is centred around health. After all, you could be vegan and eat nothing but Oreo’s and Dorito’s.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by archon1410 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:46AM (#35666086)
> They can take the animal meat (and eggs, and dairy products) from my cold dead hands

Hopefully, they will. The HN community is rather hostile towards ethics (i.e. doing the right thing); but I have say it again—evil things are evil, and they must end.

Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by ihatepython on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#35666465)
If we run out of plant food sources, the omnivores can simply eat the vegans. In nature, there is a food chain.
Re:Animal Meat and Milk Sales Drop in Europe as Vegan Versio... by archon1410 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:55AM (#35666633)
It seems you don't understand how this "foodchain" works—there will be nothing, no non-human or human animal, to eat if "we" run of out plant food sources. Everything consumed ultimately comes from plants.