News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by StillBored on Monday April 17, 2023 @09:59PM (#35609091)
Nah, few enterprises have asked for any of this trash either. I'm pretty sure that most of them would be perfectly happy with a windows 98 style GUI, that supported modern hardware. They don't want all this churn either, they want something that is stable, doesn't change very fast and doesn't require them to constantly retrain their staff or waste their IT admins time fighting with whatever new options require a new set of group policies.

AKA, the new control panel that has been evolving.. most users are likely locked out of it for anything more advanced than changing the sound volume, its the IT nerds that need to figure out the optimal set of setting and push it out. Which is work that the C*'s would be more than happy to not have to pay IT staff to perform.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by iJohnDoe on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:38PM (#35609323)
I think the point was that the big enterprises pay for licenses that don’t display this garbage. The rest, Microsoft is trying to monetize.

I agree big time. We pay for licenses so none of this crap is shown. However, most businesses get the Windows license that is included with their hardware purchase and this crap is shown to them.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by linguae on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:44PM (#35609359)
The sad thing is that you'd think the revenue coming from license sales to OEMs would be enough for Microsoft to not resort to these blatant attempts to make Windows an advertising platform, but I guess it's not.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by iJohnDoe on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:08PM (#35609505)
Much agreed.

It would take a bit more class within Microsoft these days to realize that and maybe they just aren’t ready to take the step in the right direction yet.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by nobody9999 on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:33PM (#35609664)
>The sad thing is that you'd think the revenue coming from license sales to OEMs would be enough for Microsoft to not resort to these blatant attempts to make Windows an advertising platform, but I guess it's not.

I'm not defending Microsoft here, but just about everyone else is doing that same thing (and not just tech companies, auto, appliance, consumer electronics manufacturers and many others are doing this), so why wouldn't Microsoft do so as well?

Microsoft isn't the problem per se. Rather it's the lack of effective privacy regulations. GDPR (sadly, I'm not in the EU) is a start, but is still far too weak to reverse the perverse incentives that lead to your coffee maker[0][1] spying on you.

Yes, that example is (I think) an outlier, but I used it to point up just how widespread this sort of thing is.

But we shouldn't let Microsoft off the hook for that reason. We should bash them (and everyone else who does this kind of thing) and do our best to vote with our wallets/feet.

Failing that (for whatever reasons), as others have pointed out, Pro/Enterprise versions of Windows allow you to turn this garbage off.

[0] https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2022/jun/14/chinese-sma...

[1] I'd note that the article linked in [0] has some pretty blatant jingoistic undertones^W^W China bashing. That said, concern over this sort of thing out of China is definitely a concern, but less so (at least to me) than the US/Western corporations that are doing at least as much of this disgusting stuff.

Edit: Clarified prose.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by ezconnect on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:44PM (#35609731)
They in it for the profit. They would not shy away from a revenue stream. Users can still clean it up.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by TheRealDunkirk on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:31AM (#35613103)
As they say, "That's what you get for thinkin'." My Fortune 250 leaves all this crap on by default. Launching Edge takes THIRTY SECONDS from a cold start on a brand new, nicely spec'd Dell laptop. I'm not clear if that's some sort of crazy "security" BS they've layered in (they're always making things worse), or the thing just phoning home to Microsoft. I keep thinking they must have gotten a big discount for NOT doing the sane thing, and turning this garbage off.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by Rimintil on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:18PM (#35609576)
Windows has always had this churn. Upgrading from NT4 > 2000 > XP > Vista, etc all required a time investment to figure out new features, group policies, creating an image (Autopilot removed this requirement), etc.

Win 11 changing the Settings CPL doesn’t change the overall body of work required.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by smaudet on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:24AM (#35609937)
It is somewhat strange then that enterprise linux is not more common, you get stability and configurability.

I mostly put this down to bad salesmanship/C*s tending to be effectively technological cavemen...perhaps there are backroom deals we are not privy to, though.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by einherjae on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:34AM (#35610324)
Except you dont, not in termos of unchanging UX. Gnome reinvents itself too often…

I’m surprised XFCE isn’t pushed more as an option.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by justinclift on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:33AM (#35610658)
Wouldn't enterprise desktop folk go with the longer lived commercial distro's or LTS releases?

Doing a quick check, Red Hat still has a "Workstations" product for RHEL:

https://www.redhat.com/en/technologies/linux-platforms/enter...

Hmmm, I thought they used to have a non-"workstation" desktop oriented flavour too, but maybe that's been discontinued or rolled into the Workstation thing above.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by gyulai on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:44AM (#35610378)
> It is somewhat strange then that enterprise linux is not more common, you get stability and configurability.

Subjectively, I am under the impression that, in the enterprise desktop space, Linux is a more serious competitor to Windows than mac OS is.

For example in public administration: At one point the city government of Munich had replaced over 12000 desktops from Windows to Linux [1], and you keep seeing ideas to do similar things pop up in political party manifestoes and position papers like [2].

It is also not uncommon for large universities and research facilities to run on Linux.

Meanwhile, an enterprise running hundreds or even thousands of mac OS devices is something I've never heard of.

I think, in the past, enterprises were a bit more locked-in than they were now because they ran Windows software that they custom-developed, or off the rack but very niche and available for Windows only. But with the trend over the last two decades having gone towards writing that kind of software as web-based software, I think that element of lock-in is gradually but steadily decreasing as well.

The problem is that, once this competitive threat against Microsoft reaches critical mass, it's a bit too easy for Microsoft to counter the threat by simply backpaddling on the trash. In the meantime they just want to milk the cash cow as much as they can possibly get away with.

De-trashing an OS is easy. Meanwhile, they are working hard to make sure that Windows is the OS that runs the widest array of software on the widest array of hardware, which is not so easy (anything Windows from ancient to modern, Windows subsystems for Linux and Android). Windows emulation on Linux is also making massive progress, thanks in part to Steam, but I guess that structurally, it will always be easier for Windows to emulate Linux than for Linux to emulate Windows.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LiMux [2] https://www.transformation.gouv.fr/files/presse/Declaration_...

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by Nursie on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:46AM (#35611876)
I no longer work there, but back in the early 10s IBM were allowing a lot of management and a few engineers to move to macs.

Their thinkpad business had been spun off, the thinkpad exclusivity contract had run out, and IBM were in a "we already give too much money to MS" mood at the time. No idea how far that went.

They also had a RHEL workstation-based distro you could put on your thinkpad (with a few tens of thousands of users on that IIRC), or if you were particularly adventurous, a 'layer' that could be installed on Ubuntu (that had a few thousand users) or Debian(I was one of 22 people doing that at the time!))

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by red-iron-pine on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:33AM (#35613781)
Now that they own RH entirely, would we see a push to RHEL on the laptop at IBM (or Fedora, maybe)?
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by Nursie on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:48AM (#35625055)
Entirely possible they already have gone in that direction, but you'd have to ask someone on the e-client team, or whatever they call it now!
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by deafpolygon on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:22AM (#35613018)
> Meanwhile, an enterprise running hundreds or even thousands of mac OS devices is something I've never heard of.

as a former sysadmin in these places, it's not easy to lock down macOS down - and less so to ensure that compliance is being enforced. compliance is huge, far more important than what platform you run on. MS makes this easy, and Linux support is mainly for labs, etc, who get put on a separate network most of the time and locked down.

account management on linux and mac is a nightmare, and just simple to relegate to AD. for all its problem, GPO makes this cakewalk.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by zerkten on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @10:22AM (#35614415)
>> Meanwhile, an enterprise running hundreds or even thousands of mac OS devices is something I've never heard of.

Your experience doesn't match with reality. There are multiple sources available describing the growth in macOS usage. One that's quoted in news reports, but hidden behind a paywall, is an IDC report from 2021[1].

It describes macOS penetration at ~23% in 2020 up 6% from 2019. The is supported by descriptions of the impact on enterprise end-user computing management teams that historically have only supported Windows. You can even look at the growth of Intune, and the breadth of acquisitions by Microsoft, to see that Microsoft is very likely supporting 1000s of mac devices.

An important element of how we got here is mobile. Windows had made huge investments in configuration management while OS X was an oddball. Managing it required a different set of tools. iOS and Android adoption in many enterprises caused an end run around the end-user computing gatekeepers from 2007-2012 with a proliferation in MDM solutions.

This eventually led to standardization of so-called "modern" configuration management API/interfaces/tools. The door was opened to more Mac adoption through Apple Business Manager while admins had already adopted modern management tools that covered Windows and mobile.

This doesn't discount the challenge with some users needing to use legacy Windows software. Once upon a time this was a strong moat. For years, IT have been under pressure to make this work on mobile (where feasible) which has cut down the blockers on macOS or Linux usage.

[1] https://www.idc.com/research/viewtoc.jsp?containerId=US46965...

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by jwagenet on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:19AM (#35610556)
And, you know, a ton of critical software that doesn’t run on Linux.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by orwin on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:06AM (#35611634)
It's good enough for French military.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:27AM (#35611734)
Ah yes, the consumers are rushing to buy SW designed for the military. That's how Apple became so successful, copying UX built by the military for military users. /s
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by bdavbdav on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:12AM (#35612917)
That population is shrinking. Having worked in very large (investment) Banks, other parts of the finance sector, the move is generally to divest from thick clients to web. The whole COVID situation pushed this along even faster with the reliance on diverse VDI solutions, which don't necessarily play very well with crummy in house thick client apps.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by jwagenet on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:50AM (#35615645)
This might be true for business apps, but I don’t see any suitable replacements (by a long shot) for mechanical CAD, Adobe Suite, etc.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by smaudet on Friday April 21, 2023 @10:01PM (#35662623)
High performance, low error-tolerance applications previously only available to Windows are a continuing lock-in, yes - that's part of why gpu drivers are such a big deal.

There have been working comparability layers for the various hard-to-run on anything but Windows software appliances, but a major sticking point has been the GPU support (which keeps the software running well).

I don't think this will be true forever though, graphics drivers continue to make strides in being more open, often to the benefit of the various organizations writing or purchasing the gpus/firmware/drivers.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by trelane on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @10:14AM (#35614326)
And security issues. The downside of folks wanting to write software for your platform is that not all of it is good for the user.
Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by varispeed on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:55AM (#35611551)
Most organisations use Excel and it doesn't work on Linux - at least you can't have a seamless experience for a typical office user.

Some companies tried to use free alternatives to Excel, but there were always compatibility issues when customer or partner use Excel.

I think if someone had created 1:1 alternative to MS Office (with all its quirks and bugs), then switching to Linux would likely be a no brainer.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by pauby on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:12PM (#35617639)
That's why there's Office 365. It runs everywhere there is a modern browser.

Even Linux.

Re:The Windows 11 Trash Party by varispeed on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:54AM (#35625933)
It's on someone else's computer, so it's a no no for many organisations.