It's the most incredible form of mental gymnastics in order to grab power
- Activities staying inside state lines should not be subject to federal regulation so that people don’t get sent to prison when, on the balance, it harms both them and the society as a whole more than the alternative.
Seems fairly value-neutral to me, as in usable for both good and evil in equal measure. The tricky part is deciding which is which, of course.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Procedures_Reform_Bil...
> It is not otherwise to be supposed, that the Constitution could intend to enable the representatives of the people to substitute their will to that of their constituents. It is far more rational to suppose, that the courts were designed to be an intermediate body between the people and the legislature, in order, among other things, to keep the latter within the limits assigned to their authority. [0]
It is absurd to say that the Supreme Court “magicked out of thin air” the notion of judicial review in Marbury v. Madison. That was simply the Court's first assertion of the power the constitution gave it to wield, the wielding of which is the primary purpose of the judiciary as a separate but equal branch of American government.
0. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_No._78#Judicial_r...
> The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution …
Let’s not continue this conversation. The view I’m presenting is long established and can be found better and much more extensively made in a great many sources which no one should have any trouble finding, should he wish. You, I infer, do not wish.
The odd thing, really, is that it took a decade and a half, until 1803, for the Supreme Court first to find it necessary to tell another of the other branches of government that it had broken the rules.
Good thing we’ve learned so much since then. You would never have anyone so short sighted as to jump up and down for that in these more civilized times.
Some countries even have several dozen supreme justices, with a new one every year or two. That would rid us of this obscene phenomenon that turns one elderly person's health issues into a disgraceful politically polarized evening news issue. It also increases the RoI of extortion and assassination.
I have always thought Wickard v Fillburn was wrong decided, though.
Meanwhile, Wickard v Filburn sits there claiming that growing food on your own land to feed to your own animals is "interstate commerce". Like, do words have meaning or not? What does interstate mean? Is it possible for a thing to not be interstate? If I wipe my nose, is there an interstate element to it? If we're allowing Wickard v Filburn to stand, why not Roe v Wade as well? It's all politics, even the courts. <insert "always has been" meme>
In Wickard v. Filburn, a farmer grew grain on his farm. He did not sell this grain, whether across state lines or otherwise; he merely fed it to his own livestock on the same farm. SCOTUS ruled that this could be regulated via the Commerce Clause because, if he grew his own grain, he could be expected to buy less grain on the open market, which could indirectly affect interstate commerce. By that logic, virtually anything can affect interstate commerce, and be regulated as such.