News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by melling on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:03PM (#35483132)
The aviation sector is about 2%.

Sounds like another premature optimization problem, as applied to climate change.

“Premature optimization is the root of all evil“

https://wiki.c2.com/?PrematureOptimization=

What about coal?

What about coal?

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by TheRealPomax on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:05PM (#35483161)
Why do people keep pretending that we can only focus on one industry at a time? News flash: WE CAN ADDRESS MORE THAN ONE AT A TIME.

What about coal? You tell me, what part of fixing rice production interferes with shutting down coal mining? Because as far as anyone can tell, the answer is not a single part.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by melling on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:13PM (#35483279)
We already are seeing climate issues. We could have been off coal by now.

“A 100 years of coal emissions is 1000 years of rice”

By not addressing the big problems sooner, we have shortened the window to seeing significant problems.

We’d have more time to solve the smaller problems, or they may take of themselves. For example, the population in China will drop significantly in this century.

Unfortunately, it sounds like we are lining up our miracles so by 2050, we’ll be at net zero.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by idopmstuff on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:20PM (#35483385)
Nothing you're saying here responds to the question. Everyone knows we're seeing climate issues.

Why does making agricultural improvements prevent dealing with coal?

> By not addressing the big problems sooner, we have shortened the window to seeing significant problems.

This is true of all problems, not just the big ones.

> We’d have more time to solve the smaller problems, or they may take of themselves.

If we dealt with all of the smaller problems, we'd have more time to solve the larger problems, or they make take care of themselves. For example, the population in China will drop significantly this century, reducing the need for power consumption from coal plants.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by TheRealPomax on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:31PM (#35483549)
You are aware that there are eight billion humans on the planet, right? If everyone helped, we'd already be done: they're not. But conversely, it's not like we have ten people and we can either put them on coal, or on rice. We have millions of people actively involved at all levels, and the folks tackling rice have zero qualifications to solve coal, and vice versa.

It's like complaining that the folks making bicycles aren't making office buildings: stop being part of the problem by pretending these are mutually exclusive problems to solve and that people should stop trying to solve entire percentage values. 2% is not "a drop in the bucket", 2% is a huge number.

We can have different people work on different problems at the same time. By insisting we don't do something in parallel, all you're doing is telling folks to stop solving problems they can solve at an industrial scale. Are you solving coal, right now? No? Why are you wasting time and not solving coal? Oh you're doing something else atm? Why aren't you dropping that on the spot and solving coal? This is not a constructive attitude, it's flat out being part of the problem.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by replygirl on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:41PM (#35483709)
we've been proving since before the kyoto protocol that we really aren't capable of addressing much at once. the first clean air act was 60 years ago, while the paris agreement's net-zero horizon is 27 years out. i don't trust a many-pronged approach because i already live with the consequences of its failure
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by dylan604 on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:54PM (#35485509)
As a devil's advocate (I too believe we can make simultaneous changes), what about the concept of "don't change more than one thing" during testing so you know exactly what change had what effect? What if we stop using coal and change agriculture only to find out that the effect was/is too much? To find out that the changes to agriculture caused side effects elsewhere. Mashing all the buttons at once rarely plays out as the correct method.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by hinkley on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#35487765)
I could fill a book on the rationalizations about sequential prioritization just in the software industry. Our politics are chump change compared to geopolitical issues.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by knodi123 on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:13PM (#35483277)
I litter frequently. Some people criticize me for it, but I rightly point out that my own litter is a tiny fraction of city-wide litter, and if I stopped, no one would even notice the difference.

I'm not even the biggest contributor! Mechanized recycling trucks hoist the bins high in the air and let stuff fall into a hopper on the back, and on a windy day, every single bin they pick up produces a few pieces of litter. I don't know why I should change my lifestyle while trucks like that still exist.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by eulgro on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:23PM (#35483434)
I kill people frequently. Some people criticize me for it, but I rightly point out that my own murders is a tiny fraction of city-wide deaths, and if I stopped, no one would even notice the difference.

I'm not even the biggest contributor! Fast-food restaurants and soft drink companies keep promoting unhealthy diets from which people develop diseases which eventually leads to thousands deaths per year. Plus, most people conciously make awful lifestyle choices which will eventually contribute to their deaths. I don't know why I should change my lifestyle while people like that exist.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by replygirl on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:30PM (#35483534)
littering is not on the same moral plane as murder though
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by eulgro on Saturday April 08, 2023 @10:28AM (#35493471)
"Evil is Evil. Lesser, greater, middling… Makes no difference. The degree is arbitary. The definition’s blurred. If I’m to choose between one evil and another… I’d rather not choose at all."
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by replygirl on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:25AM (#35513453)
the author of the witcher is not a moral authority
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by melling on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:19PM (#35483363)
Nice meaningless analogy.

Let me fix it for you.

“You litter frequently in your neighborhood, while 200 people litter in the park across town. What problem should the town address sooner?”

We are at the brink of too late.

Where did you go wrong?

https://amp.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/20/ipcc-cli...

Times up.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by baxtr on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:19PM (#35483366)
I don’t know where you live, but listen: “Don’t mess with Texas!”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2qIF3PL7lQ

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by mcdonje on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:07PM (#35485691)
I have mixed feelings about this comment. It's good satire. But that's something I expect on reddit. Over here, it seems like we're running afoul of the forum norms, and Poe's Law.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by knodi123 on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:21PM (#35485882)
That's fair. I meant it to be taken as an invitation to explain why (or why not) personal responsibility should matter in a world where the problems are complex and have a thousand sources. But I didn't do a good enough job of couching it that way, and it certainly pissed off the person I was replying to. I guess the responsible thing to do at this point is bail.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by lars_francke on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:07PM (#35483184)
This is not an either/or thing.

Germany emits 2% of all CO2, not worth us doing anything then?

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by quonn on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:21PM (#35483389)
Depends on the action. Gluing oneself to the street in order to prevent 5% of 2% of an industry that is rapidly shifting to EVs is questionable, for example.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by lucb1e on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:39PM (#35483668)
Heard about someone who glued themselves to rails before a coal plant. Allegedly that prevented the equivalent of 800 years of average western european lifestyle emissions. Here I'm trying to get my own climate warming impact to be at least close to zero (and failing), and this dude has a 10x impact by doing nothing but sitting on rail for a bit. The cost is losing 9 months of their life on jail time. (Definitely an interesting proposition were it not for (1) the likely reality that some other coal/gas plant just spun harder during that time, and (2) that I'd likely get more jail time because I did it knowingly and found it worth it and as such it's not a sufficient deterrent.)
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by explaininjs on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:02PM (#35483994)
Is the idea that downstream consumers had an easier time retooling their processes to an entirely different power source than buying from a different coal plant? Questionable, at best.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by hinkley on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:35PM (#35487942)
I'm trying to rehab a 10th of an acre of prairie that used to be temperate rainforest.

That won't even offset my own impact on the rest of the world. But I'm showing up to meetings with other people, giving advice, hopefully some inspiration, as well as plants to make the process a little more accessible to other people.

Best case at the end of this, I've helped dozens of people reduce their carbon footprint, and they've helped hundreds do the same, and so on. All of us will still have a positive carbon footprint, but we've called into question what the average footprint should look like. Us and a hundred other people who think about things like transportation or building standards or entertainment.

The end goal is that becoming a giver instead of a taker represents sacrificing 10% of your lifestyle instead of 75%. It's very hard to peer pressure people into giving up 75% of what makes life worth living.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by insane_dreamer on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:04PM (#35483147)
The need to eliminate coal emissions does not preclude the need to eliminate emissions from other sources.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by melling on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:07PM (#35483192)
I suppose if we didn’t wait decades to eliminate the big problems, we’d have more time to worry about the smaller problems.

A 100 years of coal emissions is 1000 years of rice.

Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by lkbm on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:49PM (#35483845)
Did the people working on rice hamper the work on coal? Or is the issue that they're wasting their time by doing anything but trying to get rid of coal? As best I can tell, neither you nor I are working on coal either.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by throwaway2190 on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#35487767)
+ while there are still people starving, this is helping to solve a big problem, it wasn't done for climate change, it's just nice that it might help there too.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by insane_dreamer on Friday April 07, 2023 @01:27PM (#35484288)
So ... all agriculture scientists should stop what they're doing and become clean energy scientists?
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by mikeytown2 on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:05PM (#35483162)
Emissions reduction isn't the goal, it's a nice side effect of this. Not needing to replant every year is the reason for using this rice.
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by pfdietz on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:30PM (#35483531)
Are you enjoying your whataboutism?
Re:Perennial rice: Plant once, harvest again and again by hinkley on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:26PM (#35487852)
I'll tell you the same thing I tell the average knob who spews "premature optimization is the root of all evil" at me as a way to get out of having to think about anything uncomfortable, or ever accept culpability for any problems:

You don't balance a budget by only looking at the tallest tent pole.

You have to ask yourself what proportion of the overall budget a particular concern is 'worth' and figure out how to get there. Until that total is reduced to < 100% you will always be in debt. Starbucks or no Starbucks.

From there you chip away at each element as the opportunity arises, balancing opportunity against cost (both of action and inaction). If something proves to be too hard to change, you have to compromise elsewhere. And in the long run, order only matters if you go bankrupt in the middle of the process.