News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:00AM (#35342169)
I'm clearly no expert in labor law, but isn't the entire point of unionization that the company has to negotiate significant changes in contract and benefits terms with the union? As a lay person, that seems like the first principles of what unionization means. The company can act directly with the workers in non-union locations and must work with the union in union locations; that seems to be what Starbucks is doing. (Now, are they being strategic and jerks about it? Yeah, probably, but they couldn't unilaterally impose these changes, even if seemingly beneficial to workers, without negotiations with the union.)
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by hvs on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:09AM (#35342316)
Starbucks is allowed to give benefits to union members without negotiation (why would unions want to fight free benefits?). But most companies don't just give benefits to unions when they can use them in contract negotiations.

Now, I'm not a lawyer, labor or otherwise, so I'm not sure how the law works when you provide benefits to non-union shops but not to union shops, but that's what the NLRB is for.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @04:56PM (#35347707)
Unions have tried to block unilateral pay raises in the past. It's a contract change; the union feels empowered to be a party to that change (which seems "fair and reasonable enough" to me).

https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/...

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by hiddencost on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:29AM (#35342652)
First, for the record, any claims that unions make this process harder is a lie designed by a union busting consulting firm.

Second:

(1) any change to the contract has to be approved by the union. That includes raises and the like, yes. (2) that can literally be an email from Starbucks to the union's lawyer saying "we're making these changes" and an email back from the union lawyer saying "cool, sounds good". (3) union lawyers work for the union members. They almost never have a reason to reject a purely positive change, and turn-around for simple positive changes can be 24 hours easily (4) if the union wants more, they'll still accept the positive change and then separately negotiate an even larger change.

If there's an active strike negotiation going on, the company may not want to give an intermediate positive change because it weakens their bargaining power.

If the change is a mix of positive and negative, things may go differently.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by vuln on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:45AM (#35342917)
> First, for the record, any claims that unions make this process harder is a lie designed by a union busting consulting firm.

Do you have anything to back this up? It appears to just be your opinion presented as fact. While I’d love to take your word on your opinion presented as a fact; I would prefer to see some data or documentation to back it up. Thanks!

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by equalsione on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:39PM (#35343866)
All described here but there's lots more: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/may/04/starbucks-a...
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by ahepp on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:57AM (#35343129)
I dunno. Where does the burden of proof lie on this? Starbucks seems to be the one claiming they can’t give arbitrary raises to union workers. The union seems to be saying “you can!”

It seems to me that Starbucks is pulling a “we’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas!” here.

On one hand I can see why they’d do that, on the other hand they still need to operate within federal employment law and it sounds like the NLRB says they aren’t. Presumably they can challenge that in court if they disagree?

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by fallingknife on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:58PM (#35344188)
The burden of proof lies on the person who claims that literally any statement that contradicts his argument is malicious propaganda.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by alasarmas on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:05PM (#35343262)
You’re right, it is an opinion. There is probably no easy way to substantiate the statement “any claims that unions make this process harder is a lie designed by a union busting consulting firm”.

On the other hand, the entire job of a union busting consulting firm is to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about unions. The claim that unions would take actions, or fail to take actions, to make it less likely for their members to receive a pay raise, is the kind of claim that a union busting consulting firm would likely make. This is Public Relations 101.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by edgyquant on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:58PM (#35344197)
And the whole point of a union bureaucracy is to justify its existence and paint all employers as great villains. Your biased here. It’s not this black and white.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by xracy on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @07:05PM (#35349342)
coming off of close to 50 years of anti-union sentiment as well as fewer unions and more union busting. We're as close to black and white as we can get in any discussion about current events.

Is the claim defendable, probably not, but the NLRB just found that Starbucks is trying to discourage stores from unionizing (which sounds like something they would do...) So I'm much more inclined to believe they're being unhelpful in union negotiations than a newly minted union is.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by vuln on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @10:29AM (#35357823)
> newly minted union

The union does not appear to be new at least to me. It seems like the StarBucks union is apart of a larger organization of unions.

So this isn’t a _new_ union or a union _moving fast and breaking things_ it’s a conglomerate of other much veteran unions.

> Starbucks Workers United is a national collective of Starbucks Partners who help organize workplaces alongside Workers United Upstate, a union with members across many industries, including the coffee industry.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/qai/2022/12/19/starbucks-union-...

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by xracy on Thursday March 30, 2023 @12:43AM (#35368087)
> The current Starbucks unionization movement began in Buffalo, New York when a store voted to unionize in late 2021.

Less than 2 years from your own article.

That counts as newly minted. Also how many of those locations have a contract at this point? That's the bigger and more relevant piece of this. The fact that other unions are helping them out, doesn't mean that those other unions have negotiated with Starbucks. That's it's own thing that makes every union negotiation different.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by edgyquant on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:57PM (#35361621)
> We're as close to black and white as we can get in any discussion about current events.

Nope, you’re just pro union so you don’t see it as anything but black and white.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by xracy on Thursday March 30, 2023 @12:54AM (#35368174)
I wrote out a really thoughtful response to this, but I will instead just say the opposite of you since that's as much consideration as you seem to have put into your response.

Nope, you're just anti union so you don't see nuance against your worldview, you just trust what corporations tell you.

Wow, you're sooo edgy.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by xracy on Thursday March 30, 2023 @03:22PM (#35377667)
Oh, wait, sorry, CEO of starbucks says he's not anti-union[1]. I guess he isn't anti-union.

In other news wolf says he doesn't prey on sheep.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2023/03/29/1166277326/starbucks-bernie-s...

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:54AM (#35343084)
> They almost never have a reason to reject a purely positive change, and turn-around for simple positive changes can be 24 hours easily

This isn't obviously a purely positive change. Maybe some employees would prefer a current cash-only tip policy (maybe they think the tips are larger in cash; maybe less than 100% of those cash tips find their way onto income tax forms; maybe their paychecks are garnished or subject to a income sharing/alimony/child support arrangement while folding cash isn't; maybe they like getting the tip immediately and using it to buy lunch or gas that day rather than getting it later via payroll).

These are things that a union representing the employees must be consulted on and the story paints this as a purely positive change, but there are times in my life where I'd rather have gotten $10 in cash before lunch than $12 two weeks later in my paycheck.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by WeylandYutani on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:40PM (#35343878)
A lot of people, including myself, are cashless. The service industry will have to change with the times.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by cwmma on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:22PM (#35343550)
Naw none of those things really apply, previously people who paid with credit card would be unable to tip unless they have cash, by turning this on your capturing tips that might not have been able to have been received earlier.

Also you didn't take tips home directly after the shift you'd get it later as they usually shared tips across shifts so closing the store or working any other slow shift wouldn't hurt financially.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:24PM (#35343593)
"none of those things really apply"? Meaning you believe that 100% of cash tips are reported as income? (I don't.)
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by cwmma on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:45PM (#35343958)
Probably not at every store but I guarantee you that at the union stores it was because not reporting the tips would be an immediately fire-able offense and corporate would have been looking for any excuse to fire people at those stores.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by HardlyCurious on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:09PM (#35343314)
That union lawyer isn't going to unilaterally say ok. It has to get socialized and a consensus opinion needs to be found. That takes time. And like you pointed out, the union might not want to accept a modest increase because it can weaken their bargaining position. So, despite your claim the union doesn't make this more difficult, it absolutely objectively does make it more difficult than he company being able to make a decision without these restrictions. That doesn't mean unions are bad or that this process isn't worth it, but don't poison the well with unneeded dishonesty.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by n8cpdx on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:09PM (#35343318)
The Union sets the employees and the business up as adversaries and guarantees that there will be a contract negotiation. If you know that you will be in a knock-down drag-out fight every time the contact is renegotiated, why would you ever give a single solitary inch that you’re not forced to? The business is always n days away from another strike negotiation because that is the entire reason the union exists (to threaten strikes).

I don’t understand why people expect labor to be able to play hardball while also trying to benefit from a cooperative relationship with the adversarial partner.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by whitemary on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:41PM (#35343889)
To put my cards on the table, I am a Marxist. I also agree with every part of your comment. This is why (disciplined) Marxists oppose the NLRB and other aspects of Americanized union arrangements, and it's why we support right-to-work. The NLRB and the slew of anti-labor laws enacted in the US in the late forties have effectively weakened unions to the point that they cannot fight for anything without navigating the NLRB's bureaucratic maze of anti-labor regulations. Realize these laws were enacted in direct response to soldiers returning from WW2 and not taking shit from anybody. They made demands, fought for them, and won, and capital passed these laws in response.

So...the question now becomes: How do you feel about illegal wildcat strikes? Would you support abolishment of the NLRB? Would you support reversal of the Taft Hartley act? Which side are you actually on?

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by fallingknife on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @05:52PM (#35348479)
I'm pretty much the opposite of a marxist, but I absolutely support the abolishment of the NLRB and the legalization of all otherwise legal labor negotiation tactics as freedom of association. If there are critical professions that we don't want to strike, then their employer can negotiate that as part of their contract in exchange for higher pay.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by wahnfrieden on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:19PM (#35350147)
All the more reason to encourage wildcat strikes
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by WeylandYutani on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:35PM (#35343784)
It would be so much easier if those damn peasants would just shut up and follow orders.

Look we know why unions got started and the human condition hasn't changed. There are people out there who would reintroduce child labour if they could get away with it. Guess who makes sure that they can't?

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by sokoloff on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:37PM (#35343818)
Legislators.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:41PM (#35343895)
Clearly not based on Iowa and Arkansas legislators.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by iso1631 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:34PM (#35343767)
employees and the business are adversaries without a union. The business is always n days away from an employee leaving for better terms elsewhere

A union meanwhile has a strong incentive to keep the company viable, otherwise they have a lot of out of work members

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by wolrah on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:06PM (#35344337)
> The Union sets the employees and the business up as adversaries and guarantees that there will be a contract negotiation.

> I don’t understand why people expect labor to be able to play hardball while also trying to benefit from a cooperative relationship with the adversarial partner.

I don't understand why people think it's not an adversarial relationship without a union. The workers are trying to get the most value for their labor, the company wants to get the most labor for its money. The difference is without a union the company has more power than you do.

Outside of the smallest businesses, most individual workers are disposable as far as the company is concerned. Their duties will be picked up by other employees and there's no rush to replace them. The company won't be substantially harmed by losing one worker, for the most part. There are of course exceptions, generally in small organizations or specialized skillsets, where individuals can be extremely hard to replace, but those cases are not the norm.

On the flip side most workers who lose their job have an immediate problem. Almost 2/3 of Americans live paycheck to paycheck. If they lose their job they have at most a few weeks before they're missing payments. No longer having a job with no immediate prospect to replace it poses an imminent threat to the stability of their life.

This gives employers a massive amount of leverage to push for the absolute minimum they can get away with before employees start saying "I'd rather starve", while employees have little to push back with.

A union attempts to balance the scales by turning the workforce in to a combined threat. No longer is the company negotiating against an individual, it's one or more entire classes of workers that they stand to lose and have to replace if they don't come to an agreement.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:10PM (#35343341)
> that can literally be an email from Starbucks to the union’s lawyer saying “we’re making these changes” and an email back from the union lawyer saying “cool, sounds good”.

No, it can’t. If it requires a contract amendment, it has to be ratified by the membership, not “union lawyers” (who probably wouldn’t be in the direct chain of contact; contract changes would usually go through the unions bargaining staff, who might consult with lawyers, as the main contact.)

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by edgyquant on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:57PM (#35344170)
> First, for the record, any claims that unions make this process harder is a lie designed by a union busting consulting firm.

This is a lie and is peddled by pro union lawyers and activists. It goes both ways. Anyone who’s worked for a union or with one knows that they most certainly make negotiating directly harder. This is one of the main points of a union.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by pavon on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:34AM (#35342746)
Yeah, at my employer changes in benefits have always rolled out to non-represented and union employees at different times depending on the negotiation period for each union. I'm curious as to where the line is drawn here.

A google search for "starbucks site:NLRB.gov" gives a ton of results and none of the first 10 were obviously related to this complaint. If anyone can find a link it would be helpful.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by frgtpsswrdlame on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:40AM (#35342849)
You can read about what is and isn't allowed here: https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/di...

You might also be interested in reading about why the NLRB was formed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Labor_Relations_Board

Basically we have a lot of rules about the relationship between unions and companies because when we didn't do that there was a lot of violence.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by tutuca on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:48AM (#35342979)
Like people being hang for climing labor rights or doors being closed leading to fires killing a lot of working women.

That kind of violence...

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by whitemary on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:00PM (#35344233)
...and the NLRB ensures that the violence continues only in one direction; from the ruling class against the working class.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by brightball on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:05AM (#35342247)
I've heard that this is typically how it goes. Union reps will negotiate every detail, so all of the stuff that you have already done for the rest of your staff has to be brought to the table as a negotiating point with the union for it to factor into the conversation.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by wahnfrieden on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:26AM (#35342617)
Withholding tipping from union stores was determined to be illegal wage theft
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by justin66 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:40AM (#35342840)
* * *
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by FireBeyond on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:52PM (#35346021)
Yup. Around here, they removed the foam comfort mats from the work areas (behind the register, at the machines, etc.) that were designed to reduce fatigue, foot stress / pain from extended standing.

They said it was a safety issue.

Then it was pointed out that they'd only removed them at the stores where they were unionized or were in the process of doing it, and they had very little explanation for why the mats were safe in non-union stores.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by chrisbolt on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:33AM (#35342720)
> In May 2022, then-CEO Howard Schultz announced that the company would begin rolling out credit card tipping in the fall at all of its locations — save for the 200+ stores that were unionized or in the process of unionizing.

They didn’t keep tips, they withheld the convenience from customers. Shitty, but not exactly theft.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by Arrath on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:16PM (#35343444)
That seems like exactly the kind of hair-splitting shenanigans that management would undertake to attempt to strike back at the union stores.

Sure, they're only withholding the convenience from the customers, but how much real impact does this have on the tips given? I know I've personally had to forego giving tips before due to lack of cash.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by uoaei on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:06AM (#35342266)
None of your assumptions matter. Only the union contract and its contents matter. Do you have the text of the contract?
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by justin66 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:49AM (#35343013)
> Only the union contract and its contents matter.

Strictly speaking, a century's worth of American labor law also matter. Since we're listing things that the average hn user is unfamiliar with.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by nemo44x on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:08AM (#35342296)
If the employees keeping tips wasn't part of the contract then the employees don't get to keep tips. For all we know the tips are supposed to be pooled and divided among all workers based on seniority. Or if there's nothing in the contract then management can probably keep them for themselves or donate them.

the same for raises, etc. The contract should have all of that spelled out. If not then the union failed at the their job.

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by klyrs on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:24AM (#35342584)
> Or if there's nothing in the contract then management can probably keep them for themselves or donate them.

That's a violation of federal labor law.

https://www.7shifts.com/blog/restaurant-tip-pooling-laws/

Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by rcme on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:25AM (#35342601)
Employers cannot keep tips, directly or indirectly. Using tips as a bargaining chip for unions is indirectly keeping the tip.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by mc32 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:48AM (#35342980)
But I think they can bar tips from their business.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by rcme on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @02:06PM (#35345302)
Employers can’t discriminate based on union activity either.
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by jayd16 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:13PM (#35343393)
Is there any evidence of any attempt to get this approved and the union pushed back? Why speculate that its the union's doing?
Re:Starbucks Illegally Withheld Raises and Tips from Union W... by mrgoldenbrown on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:47PM (#35345014)
The piece you're missing is that Starbucks didn't say "we offered this deal to the union and they rejected it." Instead they make vague statements about how things would work, if Starbucks was acting in good faith, which it's been clear they haven't. The NLRB has sanctioned them multiple times for acting in bad faith, including not negotiating. They can't blame the negotiation process for delays when they are the ones delaying the negotiation process.