News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by Animats on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:51PM (#35318028)
Pay attention to this. A war between China and Taiwan is quite possible. There are Chinese generals who claim the war will be over in a few days. That's what Putin thought when invading Russia and trying to take Kyiv.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by imwithstoopid on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:17PM (#35318390)
Russia won the Eastern Front despite suffering dramatically higher casualties than the Germans

China smashed the US at Chosin Resevoir despite dramatically higher casualties

Ho Chi Minh once said something like "ten Vietnamese will die for every US soldier that dies...we will win"

and he was right

keep that in mind

every American should learn about Chosin Reservoir...a forgotten battle that may very well be the worst US military defeat since WW2, maybe the only time in recent history where US soldiers broke unit cohesion and were running for their lives

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by poxrud on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:31PM (#35319249)
USSR won because of American lend lease and Germany having to fight on two fronts. Modern wars are won with equipment and technology, not human wave attacks (see Russia Ukraine war)
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by dogma1138 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:35PM (#35320415)
Lend lease wasn’t a major contributor to the eastern front, however the North African campaign was.

It pushed German logistics off the edge, forcing them to allocate most of their heavy lift aircraft and fuel to try to keep North Africa.

That said Ukraine isn’t binary case either. Russian problems in Ukraine seem to go well beyond just logistics and are plagued by lack of strategy and even a remotely competent military leadership.

The technological advantage Ukraine has isn’t what led them to prevail.

If Russia could employ even basic combined arms warfare and conduct organized advances that serve a singular strategic objective the result would likely be very different.

The question is right now is where the people element of the Chinese military sits.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by dragonwriter on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:34PM (#35319266)
> Russia won the Eastern Front

No, that was the Soviet Union. And, by modern Russia’s standards as used to describe the situation in Ukraine, you can’t really credit the USSR either, as it was really a proxy war by the USA against Nazi Germany.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by jandrewrogers on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:06PM (#35319626)
Current US weaponry and doctrine were informed by their 20th century experiences with massed human attacks, which are still considered to be realistic scenarios in some theaters. They have many tools for effectively solving that problem at scale now.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by tyh on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:27PM (#35318526)
> There are Chinese generals who claim the war will be over in a few days. That's what Putin thought when invading Russia and trying to take Kyiv.

Geographically Taiwan is easier to isolate. It is also a much smaller and denser country. Ukraine has a direct border with a NATO country that has been very useful as a safe staging area. Taiwan would be completely reliant on sea and air for resupply.

As a Taiwanese American, I do believe my cousins would put up a valiant fight. However it is hard to imagine it lasting very long without foreign boots on the ground. A conflict of any length in Taiwan would result in a huge loss of life.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by Manuel_D on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:39PM (#35318675)
Taiwan is also an island separated by hundreds of miles of ocean from the mainland. Russia shared thousands of miles of land border with Ukraine, much of it flat steppe. China's ability to make meaningful changes in Taiwan would be difficult with it's own boots on the ground, and it would be far harder to to that in Taiwan than Russia doing it in Ukraine.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by Animatronio on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:24PM (#35319171)
You seem to forget that Ukraine has hundreds of km of borders with NATO countries (Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania). Refugees go out, military supplies go in. How would that happen in Taiwan.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by tim333 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:28PM (#35320333)
Boats, aircraft.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by molotovh on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:17PM (#35320776)
Yes, there's no direct land route for Taiwan's allies to use, but the same is true of Chinese forces trying to get onto the island. Their supply routes may be shorter than Taiwan's, but they are just as vulnerable. Both sides are likely to suffer a majority of their losses just trying to supply their troops, and the effectiveness of submarine warfare against enemy shipping and air superiority against enemy airlifts will determine victory in the long run. So long as the West maintains superior submarine and carrier fleets, they offset the longer supply lines. If China catches up in either or both of those areas, the advantage of shorter supply routes starts to tilt in their favor.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by anon84873628 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:28PM (#35320332)
Invasion of Taiwan would require the largest amphibious assault in history. And it's easy to point defensive artillery at the water.

So the PRC would need air superiority to disable those defensive positions, which would immediately pull the US and allies into the fight.

There's no Blitzkrieg option. By the time the PRC reaches the semiconductor facilities they will be scuttled. And consider the straight of Malacca instantly closed too. To win the invasion of Taiwan, the PRC would essentially need to defeat the military of the US and every Pacific ally.

I wouldn't move to Taiwan any time soon, but (despite the rhetoric) invasion still seems unlikely... Unless starting a war is the end goal itself.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by dragonwriter on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:09PM (#35318284)
> A war between China and Taiwan is quite possible.

That’s why China is using Russia to try to tie down, wear down, and/or split the Western alliance, not because of either national or ideological affinity. It creates a temporary, or if really successful more durable, opening.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by seventytwo on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:04PM (#35318223)
That would be 100% dependent on what the Taiwanese decide to do. If they decide to give in and absorb into the mainland, it could be over in a few days. If they decide to fight, it would be a second Ukraine.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by cmrdporcupine on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:12PM (#35318328)
It doesn't matter if the Taiwanese were to fold and surrender military suddenly. It would still be a huge a catastrophe. The west would be forced to respond in ways that would be catastrophic for the world economy in a way that the Ukraine crisis doesn't even approach. There's no way normal trade relations could continue as they have.

And the trading relationship between the west and China is the most important in the world.

There'd be famine, hyperinflation, riots, and chaos all over the place.

Even if an immediate war ended quickly, the following instability would merely pave the way for new ones.

The best thing that can happen for the world situation is for the Chinese domestic political tone to step away from the brink with all the imperialist sabre rattling, and for the US to do the same.

The second best thing is that elites in the west plan now to disentangle economic dependencies enough that if such a thing were to happen it would have less impact. There seem to be some moves on that front, but doesn't seem realistic overall.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by spaceman_2020 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:21PM (#35319134)
Are there any pro-China factions in Taiwan? If yes, how much influence do they have?
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by inawarminister on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:53PM (#35320567)
KMT is broadly poised to win multiple cities this year and they're pro One China, though not communism necessarily.

Also Taiwanese military has some pro-One China elements in it last I've heard.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by spaceman_2020 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:19PM (#35319114)
I'm more worried about Pakistan collapsing into chaos and some nutjob getting his hands on some advanced military technology.

Pakistan collapsing has always been a meme but I've never seen things be this bad in all those years. For the first time in my living memory, the Pakistani Army is losing legitimacy. As corrupt as it might be, as an Indian, you could at least go to sleep knowing that there was some order and hierarchy on the other side.

But if the army goes, then I don't know what chaos fills that vaccum.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by dogma1138 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:28PM (#35320339)
I’m pretty sure the US has multiple plans to go in and secure the nuclear weapons and I’m pretty sure in that contingency even China is onboard it really doesn’t want India and Pakistan lobbing nukes at each other.

Beyond that Pakistan doesn’t really have advanced military technology sure it has some US jets but those aren’t particularly useful to anyone outside of maybe Iran.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by inawarminister on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:51PM (#35320540)
US intervening with Imran Khan led to this mess.
Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by spaceman_2020 on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:34AM (#35324289)
By "advanced military technology", I mean anything that's not an AK-47 and a bunch of grenades.

The danger isn't that someone will use Pakistani military equipment to cause mass destruction. The danger is that someone will use that equipment to bait India into a war.

Re:An Anxious Asia Arms for a War It Hopes to Prevent by credit_guy on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:12PM (#35320180)
> There are Chinese generals who claim the war will be over in a few days.

Just like with Putin's generals, Xi's generals may tell him what he wants to hear. If the wants to hear they will be ready to invade Taiwan in 2027, and they say it's not possible, then they'll be replaced with some who say it's possible. If 2027 comes and the invasion is about as successful as Russia's invasion, then they may or may not be replaced. Replaced for sure today versus replaced maybe in 4 years, which one to choose?