This is very well said. Thank you!
“Draw a Disney logo but for adults”
That image now lives on Adobe.com
No, you don’t want Disney to sue Adobe.
Giants battling it out can result in a clearer environment for everyone else that couldn’t afford legal risk in an environment of doubt.
I want to see Disney sue Faber-Castell for making great pencils I used for my deviant art
Also IANAL but even then there's probably fair use rights in parodying their logo
It's not clear that the quality will be exactly the same (in fact it will very likely be worse), but working generators are essentially ways to quickly generate training data. And I can't think of a legal argument for why generated output from a model would be less legal to use as training data than an unlicensed photo off of DeviantArt.
Nobody has really called out OpenAI on this, but OpenAI has a clause in it's TOS that you won't use output to build a competing model. But that's... just in it's TOS. If you don't have an OpenAI account, it's not immediately clear to me (IANAL) why you can't use any of the leaked training sets that other people have generated with ChatGPT to help align a commercial model.
Certainly if someone makes the argument that generators like Copilot/Midjourney aren't violating copyright by learning from their sources, it's very hard to make the argument that Midjourney/Copilot output is somehow different than that and their output can't be used to help generate training datasets.
Let's say you take your hello kitty dot art, and make a poster promoting a commercial event. You then take it to FedEx Kinkos and use a self-service copy machine to make 1000 copies. You could reasonable argue that you are violation of copyright infringement, and the photocopier / FedEx kinkos isn't.
Now instead, you have AI generate a poster, and it generates a very similar image to hello-kitty. It's arguably so similar than a reasonable person would say it's a copy. You take that poster and again make 1000 copies. Is there copyright infringement? If so, who if anyone, is liable for damages?
They use Firefly to generate a poster, and unbeknownst to them, the image it generated is a reasonable facsimile of a copyrighted/trademark character.
The person has inadvertently committed copyright infringement.
So does Firefly need to come with a warning?
The safer solution, to the chagrin of another commenter, is for Adobe to neuter the tool by only training on data in which Adobe has express permission to use.
We do not need creative technology to regulate observance of copyright law.
(By the way I think the chagrined other commenter was yours truly ;-))
Leave the decision to the user instead of baking it into the technology.
The counter is always, “Well, we can see our way forward to doing it, which means someone else can also do it. So… we better beat them to the punch.”
It's not a good look for the tech industry and the ESG corporate culture. It is destroying the very hacker culture that made them.
Thanks airstrike, for dropping this truth bomb.
And just like that, Adobe expands its ministry of creativity powers. In the beginning, it was dollar bills on the no-can-do list. Now it's pictures of Darth Vader and hello kitty.
You just have to, you know, draw it.
“How dare you not let me copy your stuff for free woth zero effort!”
… entitled much?
are you saying it won't work? if that's the case, that seems really silly. what's stopping me from drawing hello kitty myself?
it's not the tool's job to regulate my creativity. the law exists to regulate the use of my art, not the act of creating the art. I can draw hello kitty all I want and leave it in my drawer, if it floats my boat