News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:06PM (#35222984)
What I find ironic is that as businesses leave China, they move into the exact same type of culture in Vietnam and India. Vietnam is basically a mini China and India is trending towards the same authoritarian regime that most people find distasteful.

The entire western world is so addicted to cheap labor I don't know what would happen when there is no more cheap labor to be found. There will be a huge social disruption when everyone everywhere in the world demands 100k salary a year with social benefits. That or AGIs come out and we get a disruption on the same scale.

Fun fact, Vietnam is moving from 5 days work week to 6 days work week while the rest of us are demanding 4 days work week here in the US.

Re:Leaving China by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:08PM (#35223007)
The world will adapt when labor becomes scarce, it will have no other choice. The more scarce labor is, the more pricing power it has.

Arguing over “what if AGI” is like arguing about nuclear war and winter. It might happen, but no plans you form for it will survive contact with reality, so there is very little value in spending cycles on optimizing for it.

Re:Leaving China by foobiekr on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:14PM (#35223059)
Labor isn't really going to become scarce this century. Nigeria, etc.
Re:Leaving China by vidarh on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:48PM (#35224536)
Fertility rates are dropping across Africa too, and while the growth will continue for a few more decades, maybe until the end of the century, labour will increasingly be scarce where we need it. There'll be significant political and social upheaval while countries deal with figuring out how to compete for immigrants.
Re:Leaving China by politelemon on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:10PM (#35223035)
I have a cynical view (sorry) that labor will always be cheap somewhere. It's part of the globalization machine, there will always be a decline somewhere, and if there isn't, one will be created.
Re:Leaving China by abstractbeliefs on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:19PM (#35223123)
China's Belt and Road Initiative suggests that they view the under-developed Middle East and African nations to be the next in line, the same as the US viewed China as a source of cheap labour.

The party has been making deep investments into the regions and is developing significant political and social capital at the same time that the West is retreating from them, cutting foreign aid, etc.

Re:Leaving China by nonethewiser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:55PM (#35223505)
> China's Belt and Road Initiative suggests that they view the under-developed Middle East and African nations to be the next in line, the same as the US viewed China as a

I think it’s more “want” than “see.” They might see Vietnam as next in line but outsourcing to ME and Africa suit their interests better.

Re:Leaving China by flextheruler on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:17PM (#35223101)
I’m not sure it’s globalization. There will always be rich countries and poorer countries. Like there will always be poor people and rich people. The gap may and should shrink between the two but not vanish.
Re:Leaving China by nonethewiser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:57PM (#35223530)
And if there is not, we either have global poverty or a tremendous amount of force applied to the distribution of wealth.
Re:Leaving China by akira2501 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:14PM (#35223064)
This view seems inconsistent. Artificial manipulation is not sustainable in the long term. The ability to continually create conditions that lead to cheap labor is limited and will eventually fail.
Re:Leaving China by auggierose on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:20PM (#35223143)
With AI+capital on the manipulating side I am not sure there are any limits.
Re:Leaving China by akira2501 on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:03AM (#35227836)
AI is not magic, neither is capital for that matter. To perform any function in the world, it needs some type of physical form or device to do so. These devices take capital to manufacture and maintain. They're also vulnerable to intentional damage. There are obvious limits.
Re:Leaving China by auggierose on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:21AM (#35247499)
Capital = physical

AI = control of how to wield the Capital and defend against intentional damage

What are the obvious limits?

Re:Leaving China by layer8 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:53PM (#35223487)
On the contrary, it seems that increase of income inequality is a natural trend.
Re:Leaving China by akira2501 on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:01AM (#35227820)
Since when? 40 years ago? Yes.

400 years ago? Hardly.

Re:Leaving China by nonethewiser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:58PM (#35223543)
What artificial manipulation?
Re:Leaving China by akira2501 on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:05AM (#35227847)
Are you saying that you presume the inequality is the natural state of things? What are you basing that on? A world with governments and corporations that are capable of squashing the populace? Do you ever wonder what influence this has?
Re:Leaving China by cute_boi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:06PM (#35223627)
There will always be poor and they will be exploited. I guess nature is brutal to keep everyone happy.
Re:Leaving China by web3-is-a-scam on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:39PM (#35223322)
And many of the Vietnamese factories are owned by China.
Re:Leaving China by inconceivable on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:25PM (#35223184)
indeed. vietnam is run by the communist party of vietnam. remember, they won the war. that's why there is no south vietnam and north vietnam anymore (unlike korea).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_Vietnam

i wonder how long it will take before we start hearing "i hate the VCP but i love vietnamese people/culture". probably when they get powerful enough to challenge the regional US interest in anything significant.

Re:Leaving China by DiscourseFan on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:38PM (#35223320)
The US and Vietnam are very strong allies now, its unlikely that will ever happen.
Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:01PM (#35224144)
I don't think we have an alliance with Vietnam. AFAIK, there is no US base or military agreement or anything indicating a higher relationship than trade partner.

In fact, a few times DC sent some diplomats to Vietnam, the govt over there responded by sending their diplomats to China. Basically saying they prefer China over the US. It makes sense to them since China is closer and have higher trade value than the US. But because of that I don't see how Vietnam can be a "strong ally" to the US.

Can you explain more or cite your sources?

Re:Leaving China by DiscourseFan on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:35PM (#35225536)
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/04/30/vietnamese-...

I read this a few years ago, not sure how much it reflects reality. Anecdotally, immigration from Vietnam is still strong, except the more recent immigrants I've met are pro-communist (as opposed to the first and second generations of Vietnamese immediately following the war).

I'd imagine that the US and Vietnam are allies in the same way that Israel and Egypt are allies. Publicly, they have to show opposition, but privately they work together economically, militarily, and everyone knows that they aren't actually at odds with each other.

Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:47PM (#35225674)
It is just an old poll. I don't think it is relevant. Public opinion doesn't mean much in authoritarian countries. It is what the Vietnamese government is doing that would reflect what they really think.

It is more likely that Vietnam is playing both sides and try to appease both China and the US. But no way they are an ally or even a potential one.

Re:Leaving China by realusername on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:50PM (#35223445)
Unlike China it's not like they can operate in a closed environment independently though, they need the outside world
Re:Leaving China by inconceivable on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:05PM (#35223618)
i'm pretty sure you just made that up on the spot.

china imports huge amounts of everything critical to manufacturing and food.

https://wits.worldbank.org/CountryProfile/en/Country/CHN/Yea...

Re:Leaving China by xtian on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:54PM (#35223494)
Re:Leaving China by nonethewiser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:00PM (#35223566)
Do you see people endorsing the VCP now? Observing that they’re better than the CCP doesn’t count.
Re:Leaving China by inconceivable on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:02PM (#35223588)
yes, i do. every serious discussion i've heard or article i've read about near-shoring and friend-shoring includes vietnam.

chinese companies also operate factories in vietnam, that's another aspect people just kind of gloss over.

Re:Leaving China by nonethewiser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:18PM (#35223749)
Again, that sounds like “better than China” and not a direct endorsement of the Vietnamese communist party. We are talking about global trade here - the proponents aren’t rooting for communism.
Re:Leaving China by arroz on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:06PM (#35223634)
Only china and India will ever really be able to challenge the US

Big countries with big population

Maybe Nigeria and Indonesia too, but it wouldn’t happen this century

Re:Leaving China by mr90210 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:10PM (#35223032)
One could argue that there is great value on being able to operate in different countries rather than centralize operations or manufacture in a single country.
Re:Leaving China by Krasnol on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:10PM (#35223031)
It's not as much about "cheap work" but about "cheaper work" and there will always be cheaper work somewhere.
Re:Leaving China by muyuu on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:45PM (#35223388)
India perhaps, in the long term, could challenge the US directly - but the idea that Vietnam or Thailand would openly challenge the USA in a hot conflict is laughable

culture is not the reason these people are leaving China, but an open hostility towards foreigners during recent years that is creating a very difficult position for expats living there

Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:55PM (#35224088)
Let say China and the US come into open conflict and everyone is forced to choose a side, which side do you think Vietnam will pick?

China and Vietnam share a long history and culture. They are also right next to each other and have the same government type. Vietnam has openly showed their desire to work with China at the cost of the US. They sent some top diplomats to China right after the US diplomats came to visit them. That is pretty clear to me which country they prefer more.

Investing in Vietnam is basically the same thing as investing in China in the past. It will end the same way, with a strengthened opponent in Asia.

Re:Leaving China by partiallypro on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:26PM (#35224341)
A vast majority of Vietnamese view China in a worse light than the US, and China and Vietnam have recently had quarrels over the South China Sea. They share a lot of history...and some of that history includes China invading Vietnam several times. I wouldn't count on Vietnam siding with China in a global conflict.
Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:31PM (#35225500)
>I wouldn't count on Vietnam siding with China in a global conflict.

The last global conflict had the current Vietnamese government sided with China and the USSR against the US. I think you already lost that bet.

I would like to ask you for sources on Vietnamese sentiment regarding China and the US. But that is probably irrelevant. What the majority of Vietnamese think ultimately doesn't mean anything, because it isn't a democracy. What the communist party think is more important. And I would bet two communist parties are probably chummier with each other than with the US.

Re:Leaving China by selimthegrim on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:37PM (#35226173)
I think you skipped right over 1979 and Cambodia.
Re:Leaving China by partiallypro on Sunday March 19, 2023 @10:45PM (#35226654)
> The last global conflict had the current Vietnamese government sided with China and the USSR against the US. I think you already lost that bet.

I didn't claim a bet, but anyhow I don't know how to tell you this, but that was 40+ years ago. Even then you're not quite right, they went to war with each other in the 70s. The world is much different now and China at that time was not considered a global power. Now it is, and a lot of its neighbors don't like it. That includes countries like India and Vietnam.

> I would like to ask you for sources on Vietnamese sentiment regarding China and the US.

Ok, here is one of many.

"Based on the latest ABS data, only 25 percent of Vietnamese respondents believe that China has exerted a positive impact on their country, but for United States, the number goes up to 85 percent. "

https://thediplomat.com/2021/05/china-and-the-us-who-has-mor...

Re:Leaving China by danrocks on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:48PM (#35225677)
If history shows anything is that Vietnam will defeat any other country. US, China, France, etc. they are simply invincible.
Re:Leaving China by coupdejarnac on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:48PM (#35237560)
This is the kind of comment on HN that really, really annoys me. It's the kind of superficial analysis that seems reasonable only if you haven't studied any history or had any in-depth interactions with the people you're talking about. How many Vietnamese people have you spoken with, and what are their opinions of China?
Re:Leaving China by croutonwagon on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:45PM (#35223392)
Having traveled to Vietnam AND being a bit of a history buff, especially on US war history (and theres a “bit” of an intersection there).

Can you explain how? They are a communist government sure and to get fairly large as a private company you do have to cut the government in (ie: Vin company, Viettel, Sunworld etc) but they do appear to be much less repressive and much more open than say a china. Especially socially.

Re:Leaving China by arroz on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:03PM (#35223596)
China was also much more open and less repressive 10-20 years ago
Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:47PM (#35224020)
I think for Vietnam, it is more that they couldn't afford to be repressive, not that they don't want to.

They are still relatively underdeveloped. Cracking down too hard on dissidents would hurt their FDI from places like the US. Not to mention they probably don't have the money and manpower to spare on that. China was the same when they were at the stage Vietnam is in now. And it is very likely Vietnam will do what China is doing now soon enough.

I have been to Vietnam too and I think for the time I stayed there, I got to experience a pretty authentic feel for their political and cultural systems. And all it reminds me of is China, a decade or two ago.

Re:Leaving China by croutonwagon on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:44PM (#35224497)
Thats fair. I have never been to China but have worked witb folks that have. They have to take some….extra precautions traveling there.

Vietnam seems much more open. Their internet is largely open and accessible. Even easy to register sims. They have no quarantine or vaccine requirements for entry or visa etc.

All in all much more open and light. Similarly in good company they would be fairly open about the government and problems etc.

It definately isnt on the same level of freedom as America but definitely didnt seem as repressive as china and i didnt see the will there to move that way. In fact they seem like they wanted to remain open for the financial benefits of doing business in the west.

Re:Leaving China by tomohelix on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:40PM (#35225598)
>Vietnam seems much more open. Their internet is largely open and accessible. Even easy to register sims. They have no quarantine or vaccine requirements for entry or visa etc.

This is patently false. I do not know what time period you went to Vietnam but recently their country literally went into lockdown and did not open until much later. They still require proof of vaccination to enter the country and I was told to present my ID and visa before I was allowed to get a sim card. They also blocked many social media and news sites like BBC. Any content remotely critical of the party over there is blocked and their authors arrested. It is very reminiscent of early China.

They definitely can ramp it up once they get their hands on more surveillance tech.

Re:Leaving China by croutonwagon on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:20PM (#35381144)
I was in Vietnam last month. I also work in IT and had both my personal and work laptop with me. I waited to reply because i still had friends in country at the time.

There is no proof of vaccination required and hasnt been since at least the beginning of this year.

I did not notice any blocks of internet on Viettel (and BBC is in my news feeds).

I would periodically hop on a VPN i own and use Firefox Focus if i was googling something that the government may have viewed as controversial. But I wasnt given a reason to, I am just a bit of a privacy freak and assume they are logging traffic.

And the sim card did not require any ID. When we arrived one of our friends handed them out, about 10 of them to all of us. I even went as far as to call and upgrade it to a higher plan as 1GB/day wasnt sufficient.

Re:Leaving China by onos on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:28PM (#35223842)
I don’t believe the average western person would care at all if they could afford fewer cheap products. Corporate profits would certainly go down.
Re:Leaving China by _-david-_ on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:47PM (#35224019)
>I don’t believe the average western person would care at all if they could afford fewer cheap products

I don't think this is the case. The average person wants a lot of things for cheap. Also, more expensive items like computers and phones would increase in price. People like having the newest phones, but might be priced out of it if it increased.

Re:Leaving China by mikrotikker on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:06PM (#35225269)
I am mocked for seeking non-china made goods, and paying extra for it. Predictably from my (boomer) parents who see no problem with funding china and getting low quality goods that break... its so cheap they have no problem simply buying another one. If we were importing cheap gold jewellery from nazi germany they'd be all about it.
Re:Leaving China by ren_engineer on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:41PM (#35223966)
>What I find ironic is that as businesses leave China, they move into the exact same type of culture in Vietnam and India

most of those are just Chinese shell companies or doing final assembly on parts made in China to get around sanctions and as a PR stunt by big companies to appease DC by claiming they are moving out of China

Re:Leaving China by FpUser on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:59PM (#35224122)
>"The entire western world is so addicted to cheap labor "

This is the only thing that allows rich to get richer while still keeping peasants under the boiling point. Without cheap labor living standard in developed countries would drop like a rock. What comes after nobody knows.

Re:Leaving China by A_D_E_P_T on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:10PM (#35225316)
> Fun fact, Vietnam is moving from 5 days work week to 6 days work week

This is literally because they need to increase manufacturing output and efficacy if they're to have a hope of competing with China's economies of scale. (It's probably not going to work out, on the whole, and a large amount of Vietnamese "manufacturing" is tightening the screws on products that were 90% assembled in China.)

> while the rest of us are demanding 4 days work week here in the US.

This is because a huge chunk of American jobs are bullshit make-work. If the US had a better legal/regulatory system, you could move to a three-day work week and nobody would notice a thing.

Re:Leaving China by catothedev on Thursday March 23, 2023 @09:50AM (#35274777)
I've spent years in both China and Vietnam.

I also used to believe the common phrase that Vietnam was a "mini China". Reality is different. It's no where near as repressive.

Real Christianity & Buddhism is all over the place.

Everyday people don't speak with the self-censorship I've seen in China (and I don't certainly don't censor myself the way I felt forced to in China).

The internet is no where near as censored (or softly censored) as in China! This is a night-and-day level of difference.

Ironically, in some regards, VN is more capitalist than the USA. Just go down any average street in Saigon and see how many entrepreneurs you find. And never saw 'chengguan' bossing people around in VN. Part of the reality is that communist policies failed so hard in VN after the communist takeover, many people had no choice but to stand-up-against-policy and be entrepreneurs regardless of official laws and that is baked into the culture now.

Part of the reason VN's communist party isn't as powerful as China's communist party is because it does not have as much resources. But I would argue that part of the reason is the government really doesn't have the desire to be anywhere near as heavy-handed as the CCP. At some level, Vietnam seems to me like 'one big family' with a certain level of warmth to it, whereas China is just too big with too many intra-China conflicts for Chinese people to extend trust to other Chinese people. In my experience, there is a much further sense of distance in relations with PRC Chinese people (not e.g. Taiwan Chinese) that is difficult to overcome.

People in the US/Europe forget that Vietnam had a border conflict with China following the France/VN US/VN conflicts -- the difference about the China conflict is that China truly does want to take over some of Vietnam's land for keeps -- this is understandably ingrained in everyday Vietnamese people's minds.

Everyday VN people are commonly quite welcoming to visually-obvious-foreigners, whereas everyday PRC Chinese people are often times quite wary.

Vietnam also operates within ASEAN. Singapore/Malaysia/Thailand/Indonesia/Philippines political opinions and security concerns impact Vietnam.

I would say things in VN have changed a bit since Nguyen Phu Trong's leadership and Covid (globally democracy on average has taken a step back during this timeframe), but I've come to realize that calling Vietnam a "mini China" misses many important points.