I don't currently have one, but I want to buy an efficient pickup truck or unibody pickup truck when I do buy one.
In the rare occasions that I do want a car, a truck is really helpful. I don't really see another solution other than cheap and convenient pickup truck rentals.
In my city, you can rent a truck for the day for about $50 (including a decent amount of miles). I know because I do this regularly. I'd be surprised if such an option isn't available in your city as well.
The cheap rentals in my city are at the airport and that makes it a pain to use them. They're not really cheap if I ascribe a sufficiently high value to my time. They also often have limited inventory and don't have a pickup truck right now.
Even at the airport, it looks like a pickup truck is $200 for the weekend. And honestly going to the airport is enough of a pain that I'm less likely to do things that require a truck as a result.
If I owned a pickup truck and kept it in a garage by my place then I would be far more likely to make last minute decisions to go camping or yard sale shopping or whatever.
You don't need a pickup truck to go camping (they're actually not terribly useful for that) or yard sale shopping. Like seriously it's https://van.life not truck life.
That's a good call on vans though. A cargo van might be a good idea for legitimate well maintained campgrounds.
In my area, renting any vehicle at the airport is more expensive than the same vehicle at other locations.
You and every other SUV driver share this dream. We all know that last minute outdoorsy fantasy is not gonna happen. And are you buying the entire yard at the yard sale?
As someone on HN, I would think you would be familiar with the saying "optimize for the common case". If most of the time you simply need personal transport, paying for the gas to operate a truck the occasional use seems sub-optimal.
I say this as someone who owns a VW Golf and who borrows or rents larger vehicles once or twice a year.
A car is a luxury good for someone in my situation and a pickup truck is the common case for that luxury good.
I’ve owned two minivans and three trucks, and I’d go minivan any day.
I have an occasional driver 2003 Silverado for materials pickup and dump runs. It is a fullsize pickup for its year. 2022 Silverados and F250s completely dwarf it. Yet they have the same seating capacity and bed length. It's totally bizarre. And IMO, they're uglier to boot with their Big Mac looking hamburger ass grills.
That's not just trucks. My parents have a recent Hyundai Ioniq. The car is fat and can have trouble fitting into parking spaces.
But there's no benefit; the extra width seems to have gone into providing empty space between the interior seats and the doors. So the usable part of the interior is just as narrow as ever, but it's harder to maneuver and you have to unbuckle and lean way the hell out of your window to interact with toll booths / parking garage machines / etc. Who wants this?
I'm a Gen-Xer who used to borrow my parents' Chrysler Voyager minivan to regularly haul around 5-7 friends on weekends. Most of the monstrosities on the road today are as big (or bigger) and don't seat as many people.
Which he just said he did...
You made the argument that you believed people should rent a truck or use a smaller SUV to tow most loads. And only get a truck if they needed higher towing capacity.
Your point appears to be "I agree with his vehicle choice".
It's also very common for people to argue they need these large vehicles for activities they aspire to do more often, but in practise only do once or twice a year.
I think I agree. For example:
A simple assertion of the form "It would be more useful if he'd said what he was towing." by itself is boring.
It'd much more be interested why you need to know why someone who said "hey I was driving a Tacoma and needed more towing capacity so I got a bigger truck" needs to explain in more detail what he was towing to you.
Is it so we could have a discussion of how his boat or RV or whatever is or is not acceptable and rational to you? That would be a more interesting subject.
Perhaps you'd like to check the math or google the towing limits or have a discussion about suspension upgrades?
It would make a much more enlightening, dare I say entertaining, discussion to have included on what basis, morality, etc. you presume to have questions about his truck buying decisions and whether they were warranted or ethical. You must have an interesting job to be an expert on this.
I wouldn't want to inadvertently do something immoral like improper daily use of an inappropriate tool.
I grew up in one of the more remote parts of Australia and now live in sparsely populated rural part of W.Australia - we get by pretty well in a six cylinder family car both on and off road .. and we tow regularly mid sized caravans and a thirty year old double axle trailer (built from the chassis beams of an old nine tonne truck) loaded up with whatever (tonnes of fire wood, tonnes of sheep shit for the garden, white goods from the city, fallen trees, hay bales, etc).
Oversize Toorak Tractor US Trucks are mostly overkill, but I do recommend a good set of Hayman Reese anti sway bars for more positive control.
https://www.caravanparts.com.au/hayman-reese-weight-distribu...
On the plus side I probably won't see the end of another four decades of rampant consumption for no fit purpose.
Fingers crossed habits changed (don't hold yor breath!).
And anecdotally I see most (90%) large vehicles without a trailer tow hitch at all.
Perhaps visit the "flyover" parts of the land sometime.
* https://hedgescompany.com/blog/2018/10/pickup-truck-owner-de...
Or perhaps you may wish to look at the demographics of who buys pick-up trucks:
> Despite any TV ads you see with F-150s in a rural or country setting, the vast majority of these new trucks are in large and medium-sized cities.
* https://hedgescompany.com/blog/2018/10/pickup-truck-owner-de...
>80% of the US population lives in urban areas:
* https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/urba...
Only 1.3% (2.6M) of the US population are farmers:
* https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/farming-indu...
Yet 2.8M pickups trucks were sold in 2022:
* https://www.goodcarbadcar.net/2022-us-pickup-truck-sales-fig...
Yes, if you're on a farm a pick-up truck could be useful. But the majority of buyers are not farmers (or even construction workers, though even a full-size van may be of more practicality). Pick-up trucks are far and away lifestyle vehicles for the vast, vast majority of owners.
> But during those 40 years, pickups have changed significantly. They’ve become bigger, heavier and more tricked out, and they’ve transformed from workhorse vehicles to family cruisers.
* https://www.axios.com/ford-pickup-trucks-history
* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35046151
The top-selling vehicle in 2022 was the Ford F-150; top selling vehicle in 1982 was Ford Escort: I'm having a hard time believing that people's hauling needs have changed in the intervening decades to rationally justify the sales figures.